« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
A Week of Lessons About Politics
For many, this past week was likely just like any other during the 2008 campaign, full of useless political stories, media bias, lack of attention to actual news events in our country and around the world, campaigns pandering, and horse race stories backed up by misleading polls. Yet, beneath all of this, I have found a number of personal lessons that I believe will help me in better understanding politics, discussing this election and becoming a more informed voter. Often, it's hard to step outside of the day to day back and forth of this campaign and reflect on one's over all feelings about politics, the media, politicians and our fellow voters. Yet, in order to craft a successful campaign, this is a necessary perspective.
Below, I run through a number of lessons I've learned this week.
Lesson One: My view of a political speech or position is too often blurred by my personal feelings towards a particular candidate.
Watching Hillary Clinton give her speech in Unity on Friday I found my views of her and even of her campaign completely transformed. I've read many comments and posts from people who had similar reactions. Now that she is no longer a threat to my candidate, she seems like a great political role model in many ways, with strong positions on issues I care about, and an engaging political demeanor. Now, I'm not saying she didn't do things that were unacceptable and reprehensible during her campaign, but I have a better understanding of what led her in that direction, a genuine desire to win because she believes(believed) she would be the most effective president. I found that I hate this winning at all cost mentality...unless it's my candidate, when, of course, it's OK, because we need to win. This is something I must be aware of and try to keep in check.
In the same vein, I've long believed that energy policy should be the top issue in this country's political debate. Yet, when John McCain -- the candidate I will do virtually anything to stop -- started agreeing with some of my views on energy, I found myself hating him for it, rather than celebrating the fact that some of my views are now accepted wisdom by both candidates. Yes, he's "flip flopped," or changed positions, on some of these issues. But what's wrong with that? If he was wrong before and is right now, isn't that a good thing? Note: I find numerous flaws in his energy policy, but fewer flaws than virtually any energy policy I've seen from a Republican in my lifetime. I think Obama's energy policy is much stronger, but also filled with a number of flaws.
Lesson Two: In my desire to elect the president I want, I too often hold Senator Obama to a much higher standard than any other candidate or politician I support
I found myself genuinely surprised, and initially hurt, by the idea that Senator Obama is actually a politician trying to get elected and not one who speaks the truth at all times. I'm not being facetious here. His positions on FISA, gun control and the death penalty left me, for a moment, questioning whether this was the person I really wanted to support. This despite the fact that I've been personally inspired to take a more active part in government by him; read both his books and found his life story compelling and views on politics exactly in line with mine; agree with him on probably 80 percent of his policy positions; and think he's our only hope to start rebuilding our politics, foreign policy, infrastructure and economy.
I need to get over the fact that Senator Obama will genuinely disagree with me on a number of issues and will likely take positions entirely for political gain when necessary. This isn't to say I shouldn't attempt to push policy in the direction I want, or that I should just keep my mouth shut when I disagree with his statements or policies. But I do need to keep a better perspective of what's at stake here, and why I can't let all of the issues that matter to me be drowned out by one position where I find him wanting.
Lesson Three: While I say I want an informed debate, too often I get happy and excited by the mindless political stories I rail against, as long as they're aimed at the opponent.
When I read the diary last night about John McCain owing taxes on his house in California, I was pumped. Nice, a story against McCain that is easy to fit into a one sentence sound bite and use to demonize him. Yes, it's ridiculous that he has seven houses and that the media calls Obama the elitist. But I don't want any stories out there that take us down the road of debating which candidate is the elitist and which candidate is the "regular guy." Just because it's against McCain, doesn't mean it's a legitimate story within the campaign that I have been trying to pressure the media to cover. By hounding McCain on small stories like this, I think it only gives cover for the media to continue their baseless generalizations about Obama.
Lesson Four: I have let this election stop me from following, talking about and trying to solve the problems that in a non-election cycle would be most important to me
The Mississippi River is still breaking levees and destroying homes, crops, and the hopes and dreams of thousands of Americans. While the media doesn't follow this closely, I find it to be a personal scandal that I have not stayed on top of this story and done more to organize my friends, family and others to help out. Instead, I have allowed the media to dictate to me when this story was "over," even as the levees continued to break. This is personally unacceptable and something I hope to change about myself. Red Cross Disaster Relief Fund
Lesson Five: Too often I think I'm an "expert" on things I don't know enough about.
There are really only two topics that I could call myself something of an expert on, the media, owing to my job, and the Middle East, owing to seven years of concerted study on the region. Otherwise, I'm a novice trying to learn. Yet, when a discussion of economic policy starts, I find myself acting like I know it all and disagreeing, without much though on my part, with people who have a much better understanding of our economic system. Or, when a discussion of religion occurs, I find myself plowing in and often times judging other people's views that I really don't understand at all, owing to my lack of a religious background. One thing I took away from Senator Obama's book "The Audacity of Hope" is the need to empathize with those who disagree with you and try to learn from their perspective. Too often, I find myself miserably failing at this.
Just to note, I'm not saying that I'm going to defer to people who know more facts than me about issues, but I am going to try to listen to them more and learn from their perspectives, in order to better inform my own opinions. I should already be able to do this from my own experience anyways. My political views have changed dramatically during my lifetime, which have proven to me that often times I am not right and that I do need to learn more. Yet, in the moment, I too often find myself thinking, of course I'm right; this is what I believe. That's a weak argument, even if I only use it with myself.
Lesson Six: I need to understand the perspective of the vast majority of voters who don't follow the news and politics as closely as I do.
Many of my friends are not very political at all. Almost all of
them are Democrats, but they don't really care much about day to day
politics. For example, a friend of mine is very much an Obama
supporter, so I asked her to come to a small picnic fund raiser for
Obama yard signs that was literally three blocks from her house (and
we're in the middle of upstate New York, so that's a pretty incredible
coincidence). She says to me, hell no, I'd rather do just about
anything than talk politics for a couple hours on a Sunday afternoon.
At first this surprised the hell out of me. How could you support
Obama and not want to meet others who do and talk about how we can help
him win. But of course, that's how most people feel and there's
nothing wrong with it. She's a smart woman, who has specific issues
that matter to her, but she has her own problems to worry about and
deal with. She's still going to make an educated choice with her vote
in this election, it's just not going to consume the next 4 months of
her life. If I can't easily empathize with her perspective, it's going
to be hard to convince people to support my candidate.












Comments (14)
Well, I'm back.
Thank you, fitz2, for giving us some profound introspection. I'd elaborate, but I'm weary from moving today. Suffice it to say you have shown the courage to do what so many of us don't: you challenged yourself to look truth in the eye and did not flinch or blink. I find all of your lessons valuable. Keep blogging. You have the gift.
June 29, 2008 11:53 PM | Reply | Permalink
Wow. Just wow. Can we give "double recommends"? Since things disappear on TPM so fast, maybe we should just print it out and tack it up to the wall. I think I will. Thank you.
June 30, 2008 12:50 AM | Reply | Permalink
I've learned many of the same things, fitz, and am still in the process of learning them. Last week my mom mentioned that the year is half over, and when I cheered that it would see Bush leave office, she said, "You're too focused on him."
I clarified that I meant the Bush ADMINISTRATION more than Bush himself--but also pointed out that as long as people are dying for his policies, under our name as Americans, how could I *not* focus on it? I still think that. And yet, I've got to find a better way to accept the views of people who don't.
June 30, 2008 2:31 AM | Reply | Permalink
Andrew Golis, is that you?
June 30, 2008 2:39 AM | Reply | Permalink
Great points, wonderful post and pretty much the same things I learned these last few weeks.
PS: If you told me a month ago that I would come to better understand and accept (if not condone) just about everything I know about Hillary, I would have said you were crazy. Just goes to show how quickly an act of courage to support an unpopular opinion by someone you respect can change previous beliefs, no matter how strongly held.
June 30, 2008 4:27 AM | Reply | Permalink
Introspection. How refreshing. And well-written too. A great post.
June 30, 2008 9:15 AM | Reply | Permalink
Great post. Thanks for sharing some good thoughts. Rec'd.
June 30, 2008 9:28 AM | Reply | Permalink
I wish more posters could examine their tendencies in such an honest way. Highly recommended. We all need to look at ourselves critically and productively like this. It will help us focus and bring some much needed perspective back into our discourse.
June 30, 2008 9:46 AM | Reply | Permalink
Another hearty recommendation. So much of politics is subjective - tribal, really - that it is important to take a step back and examine your own thoughts and feelings. Particularly in insulated forums like this one where the tribal mentality can provoke heated reactions. Fitz2 does a nice job. On a related note, I posted a blog on Friday drawing a parallel between Obama's centrism as a candidate and the political tactic of triangulation, for which the Clintons have been so soundly criticized, sort of a challenge for Obama's more passionate supporters to distinguish between the two. By the end of the thread, I found myself agreeing with many of the commenters and disagreeing with (or at least questioning) my original post. Now, can everyone please applaud me for my open-mindedness?
June 30, 2008 11:31 AM | Reply | Permalink
Bonus points for introspection. If only more people could do that, and more often.
June 30, 2008 12:40 PM | Reply | Permalink
Excellent post, in many different ways. Every point made here needs to be reiterated about 100 times before Election Day.
It's is only through a general recognition of these points that political discourse can really improve.
June 30, 2008 2:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
Wow. You're brutally honest with yourself. I admire that more than most other human virtues and talents.
This is the path to true wisdom.
Thanks for sharing.
June 30, 2008 3:59 PM | Reply | Permalink
Each one of these lessons is absolutely true. I commend you on your honestly, absolutely and completely. I don't think you're the only one that has thought many of these things, or even tried to articulate them, which is why I think this post is so important. It speaks for everyone, absolutely everyone. Thank you so much for this.
June 30, 2008 4:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
Dear Ben:
This is a truly excellent post, bursting with candor and passion and truth. I am so very impressed and so grateful that you interjected with this. Please continue to post here.
Bruce
June 30, 2008 6:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment