Reader Posts
« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
West Virginia Voters and the Politics of Gold-Toed Roachkillers
Some of us were taken aback by the implications of Hillary Clinton's comments during a recent USA TODAY interview where she cited evidence that ["Sen. Obama's support among working, hard-working Americans, white Americans, is weakening again, and how whites in both states (Indiana and North Carolina) who had not completed college were supporting her."]. Some of us weren't. The scenario that was painted and its application to West Virginia voters serves as fertile ground for the exploitation of a gold-toed roachkiller mentality that historically has been a part of southern politics, but also has root in American society.
The gold-toed roachkiller gets extraordinary pleasure from sticking it to their nemesis. In this instance, the gold-toed roachkillers are the State of West Virginia blue collar and working class white voters and the nemesis is Barack Obama who happens to be their non-white foil. Keeping with the script, Obama doesn't get credit for having a white mother.
Gold-toed roachkiller politics defy logic or common sense. The gold-toed roachkiller doesn't care about sound economic policy, universal health care or social justice. Sound priniciples get trumped by misguided racial motivations. These priniciples are trumped by a mentality which says I should do better than you simply because I'm white and you're not. It's a mentality that says I'm not doing quite as well as I should because you're taken that job from me. It's a mentality that says that because of the color of my skin, I'm better than you are. It's a mentality that says that there is no way in hell that I'm going to vote for a black person.
The gold-toed roachkiller is an exploitation of racial prejudices. It's a mentality that has given us red state/blue state politics. It's a strategy that helped Jesse Helms defeat a challenge from Harvey Gantt in the NC Senate Race with his "black hands" ad and also helped Bob Corker defeat Harold Ford in the Tennessee Senate Race by associating Ford with partying with a white woman. And we all know the role that the Willie Horton ads played in helping George W. Bush defeat Michael Dukakis.
The gold-toed roachkiller has prevented the U.S. from fully actualizing the U.S. Constitution's pronouncement "that all men are created equal." So many of us are not really surprised by the "revelation" that some white people will not vote for a black person regardless of that person's qualifications. We just wonder why this historical truth is being injected into the political equation yet again by the Clinton Campaign at this time and place. Is it the pleasure that can be obtained from getting caught up in the moment and sticking it to your nemesis no matter what the consequences may be?
The gold-toed roachkiller is a strategy that can be defeated. Call it good prevailing over evil. The gold-toed roachkiller appeals to our worst attributes and it's not just racial in nature. It exploits our differences in general. As good as it might feel to do harm to a nemesis, the real pleasure or satisfaction is derived from doing good. It's when enemies break the ice and become friends and discover that their similarities are greater than their differences. Politically speaking, it's when Democrats and Republicans resolve to work together for the common good.
So although some white people have not voted for a black person or say they will not vote for a black person, that is not a universal truth. Just ask Barack Obama. Obama is the front runner because white people have voted for a black person. So this argument that Hillary should be the Democratic nominee because she has greater appeal to white voters, should be put to rest. Just because Obama will have trouble getting some white people to vote for him is not a good enough excuse for not attempting to overcome this obstacle. As Bill Cosby told graduating students last Saturday during his commencement address at NC A&T State University, ["they can succeed if they try"], it gives me a good feeling to know that my country is trying.










Comments (9)
Maybe some people just think Hillary is a better candidate.
May 13, 2008 3:55 AM | Reply | Permalink
Otto F wrote, "Maybe some people just think Hillary is a better candidate."
Your comment is not incorrect, and the votes prove it, but those voters who think like that are.
May 13, 2008 10:11 AM | Reply | Permalink
That's plausible, because I used to think that way also. However, Hillary is much too smart not to understand the implications of her remarks or maybe she was just tired. In some ways the comments are true and we don't discuss race candidly in this country. We are more prone to use racial differences to our advantage. I don't believe that Hillary or Bill are racists, but why inject this language at this time right before the WVA primary where voters have been portrayed in a less than favorable manner by the media as being poorly educated backwoods white people living in the first of second whitest state in America who harbor racist tendencies.
May 13, 2008 6:09 AM | Reply | Permalink
Hillary now needs over 70% of all remaining delegates, pledged or supers. This means that tonight she needs to win 20 of the 28 delegates in W.VA. just to hold steady. Anything less and tomorrow she will need an even greater percentage of the remaining delegates. In order to get 20 delegates she needs to beat Obama by 40 points tonight, 70-30, anything less and she will be even further behind than she is now. In other words, anything less than 70% of the vote is a loss for her.
May 13, 2008 8:36 AM | Reply | Permalink
Great piece Bussta Brown. I'm amazed more haven't read your post. I recommended it, so should help. Oh, BTW, had a pair of Buster Browns when I was a young lad...loved those shoes.
May 13, 2008 10:07 AM | Reply | Permalink
Interesting name for a very common phenomenon!
Barack Obama is the best of the best. If some narrow-minded bigots can't see that then, to use the famous words of their Patron Saint, SCREW 'EM.
May 13, 2008 10:12 AM | Reply | Permalink
Why do you assume that all blue collar, white Americans are racists? Some blue collar white Americans voted for Clinton because they believe according to the polls, that she more closely aligns with their views on the economy and health care. They also believe that she is better able to fix the economy more so than any other candidate. In states such as Ohio, Pennsylvania, Kentucky, West Virginia, Michigan and Indiana, the economy is the number one issue, probably because job loss is so overwhelming in these states. Over and over in polls the voters name the economy as the number one issue affecting them.
May 13, 2008 10:56 AM | Reply | Permalink
"Why do you assume that all blue collar, white Americans are racists?" Actually, I don't assume that all white blue collar workers are racist, but I do know that this is a group that is regularly exploited through the use of racial ads and distortions.
May 13, 2008 12:11 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks udasai for the compliment. Actually Buster is correct, but far too many people have that name already, so thus it's Bussta.
May 13, 2008 12:17 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment