Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Weirdest, worst, and best moments from the primary campaign

Here's my little list of the weirdest, worst, and best moments of the campaign so far. Please add yours in the comments.

Weirdest: The first things that pop into my head here include Mike Gravel's rock in a pond ad and the story of Mike Huckabee frying a squirrel in college.  Walker Texas Ranger celebrating beside Huckabee in Iowa was sort of surreal.  Every Ron Paul supporter I've met would qualify as kind of weird. Weird stories include actual news stories about Obama's lack of bowling skills or what it means that Hillary downed a shot at a bar. The NAFTA-Canada story was bizarre too in that I'm still not sure what went down and who said what to whom in Canada. 

I'm going to have to go back to Gravel. The man was at emocratic debates and would be largely ignored. He freakin switched to the Libertarian Party recently yet was still on the North Carolina ballot last week. And then there was the rock being thrown into the pond. Shouldn't we all be demanding that HE drop out before we demand that Hillary do so?

Worst: Obviously, there are a lot of possible nominations in this category. I'm not going to list them all for fear that I may throw up in my mouth a little bit.

I'm going to call this one a tie. And the winners are Geraldine Ferraro and Joe Lieberman!  Two former VP nominees who have utterly embarassed themselves this year. First, Ferraro with her ridiculous statement that Obama was lucky to be a black man running for President. But what made it worse was that she went on all the talk shows and the nightly news programs to "make this whole thing go away" and then repeatedly the same claim time and again. It was sad and painful to watfch a person of such historical importance in the Democratic party to be so ignorant and clueless to the offensivenes of her comments.

Lieberman has earned a share of the prize with his endorsement and campaigning for Senator McCain. The man who was painfuly close to being the Democratic Vice President jsut 8 years ago. And then recently he even pulled out the "Hamas likes Obama" smear. Another former nominee for VP and another utter embarassment. 

Best:  This is obviously biased given my candidate of choice, but it would have to be Iowa. I honestly can't remember what the polls predicted would happen leading up to Iowa but I was utterly shocked that a liberal African-American Senator could win the Iowa caucus. South Carolina was not so surprising - but Iowa? 

There aren't many times in politics that I get chills but during his victory speech I was completely slack jawed at what I was seeing. It gave me a certain amount of - dare I say - hope about the possibilities for this country (no matter waht happens from here on out). 

Okay, before you critique mine: what have been the weirdest, worst, and best moments for you?


Comments (120)

Weirdest: Cindy McCains's "You will never, ever see how much money I have. NEVER!"

Bush's dance while waiting for McCain.

Romney's begging for the VP clot.

Best: Gas Tax pander backfires on HRC in IN & NC. Obama stands firm on principal and economic facts. The good people of IN & NC see through the fake giveaway!

Also Fred Thompson. He managed to make Best, Worst, and Weirdest simultaneously.

Ummmm... I meant ""Romney's begging for the VP SLOT."" Not clot. Whoops.....

Weirdest- "Shame on you Barack Obama...Enough with the speeches and the big rallies..." "I am honored, just honored..."

Worst- "No, no no...not God bless America, God d* America"

Best- A More Perfect Union

Sad debate moments:

Clinton: "It's change you can Xerox,"

Clintn: "Maybe we should ask Barack if he's comfortable and needs another pillow."

Obama: "...when you were a corporate lawyer sitting on the board at Wal-Mart."

Clinton: "...when you were practicing law and representing your contributor in his slum landlord business in inner city Chicago."

Clinton: "And there's a difference between denouncing and rejecting."

Nash McCabe: "I want to know if you believe in the American flag. I am not questioning your patriotism, but all our servicemen, policemen and EMS wear the flag."

Stephanopoulos: "Can you explain that relationship [with William Ayers] for the voters and explain to Democrats why it won't be a problem?"

Russert: [everything he said]

Russert: [everything he said]

amen to that

Still think the worst debate question was, "Does Rev. Wright love America as much as you do?"

That was the question that sank the debate. In my opinion, of course.

It's not just your opinion--it's fact!

as usual, the only precision on the board

BO: "You're likable enough, Hillary."

That was kinda weird and kinda bad and to this day, I still don't know what he meant.

"Change you can xerox" had to be one of the worst lines ever.

That was a stupid thing for BO to say. He would have been to say "I like Hillary and I think she and any of the Democratic nominees here would make a much better President for America than the guy we've had the last 8 years."

I flinched when he said that. It was bad. No question. Nobody's perfect.

On symmetric lowpoints, compare that to the Clintons' dog-with-red-meat responses to his fairly innocuous take to the Reno edit board on Reagan changing America's trajectory more than Bill. Somewhere in that January soup is where they lost it. I've always wondered whether the Reno remarks were premeditated bait for Bill's ego. It sure played out that way.

Jon Stewart's "I think he'd be kind of a dicky boyfriend" was a rather apt summary.

avatar

I thought he sounded like a five year old w/ a crush. I was half expecting him to pull a daisy out of his pocket or something!

How about THIS for weirdest and worst moment combined: the Democratic party shooting itself in the head by selecting a nominee who is sure to lose in the general election, who alienates large portions of the democratic base (yes, I'll say it--white working class folks).

It doesn't have to be this way!! There is still time to turn this around!

Hillary '08!!
http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/05/bizarro-day-at-tpmcafe.php

The worst for me was losing my love of Bill Clinton. Having him go from someone I adored to this red-faced caricature, spewing this hateful stuff, having to wonder, "Wait, were they right about the Clintons this whole time?"

Best, Iowa. Watching that speech and realizing, suddenly, the world was a better place. Second best, Tuesday night.

Weirdest: Ack. Hillary's southern accent, "I don't truck with economists." The squirrel. Everything about Mitt Romney. Everything about Cindy McCain. McCain's speech in Virginia with extras from Dawn of the Dead surrounding him. Hillaryis44.

avatar

Poor Rudy, everybody's forgotten all about him. If you're talking weirdest moments of the campaign, doesn't he top the list? His very strange decision to bypass Iowa and New Hampshire and hunker down in Florida for a month. What was he thinking? By the time the media followed him there, everybody, including Floridians, had forgotten who he was. And he spent his entire time down there courting the Jews, most of whom are democrat anyway so couldn't vote in the primary,or registered to vote in NJ and NY. What a contrast to Hillary. He simply gave up so easily, after his staff worked so hard to turn NJ, CT, and Delaware into winner take all primaries, and after he spent 45 million dollars. Very very strange. You gotta think he didn't really want it all that bad. I wonder what made him run in the first place.

Never mind that the Republicans only gave Florida half their delegates, he may have hoped for headlines, but the idiot staked his whole campaign on half a slice.

I did kinda forget about ole Rudy...

excellent thread you begin, master yoda.

weirdest--when i asked my friend in the hrc campaign why there was no hrc organization in several super tuesday states, and he said he didn't know, but he was sure there was a really good answer to that. and he kept telling me there was a good reason, but he never even had a straightfaced explanation.

worst--hillary in the sc debate. you won't take responsibility for any votes, so i can't have a debate with you; you said the republicans had the good ideas; working for your contributor, the slumlord. and getting booed and hissed in a state she had led until very recently, and among blacks as well.

best--the iowa speech was great. and after iowa, i tried yet again to volunteer and finally got connected right so i could do some work for obama.

but my tops would be the night of sc. hosted a fundraiser in a bar, saw the jesse jackson comment on widescreen, saw it get called for obama, expected a 15 point win max, and it. Just. Kept. Climbing. there was a dem there who had gotten into a brawl with pat buchanan at georgetown, and who had had the humphreys and mcgoverns at his wedding forty years ago. wonderful guy, an amazing democrat. he had organizers living at his house this jan. there were kids there that night. all kinds of folks. and when he gave his sc speech, i almost cried, it just really moved me, and things like that just never do. and i didn't give a shit if he won anything, i just wanted to work for this guy. i will always remember that night.

That's a really awesome post, man. I'm serious.

avatar

How about most painful moments? For me that was during the Pennsylvania debate when Hillary opportunistically brought up William Ayers out of left field after he'd taken that horrible grilling by Stephanapoulous and Gibson. That moment is what made it seem like he was being ganged up on rather than simply having an uncomfortable time anwering debate questions.

Another weird: the youtube republican debate. That forum was just so strange to me, plus everybody but Rudy (and maybe McCain, I can't remember) saying they don't believe in evolution. That was cuckoo. Or yet another Rudy moment: The phone call from Judy in the middle of talking to the National Rifle Association. Maybe that's what did him in -- all those weird moments (also think the Rudy-Judy spread on the cover of one of the nyc tabloids.) Or Huckabee's eating squirrel or his rocking out.

Best: The Iowa victory night, not just because of the Obama speech but because of the thrill of realizing that race didn't have to be an issue. That just blew me away when I realized that.

The ABC debate was nearly my choice for worst moment of the primary.

How about the denouce and reject debate scene? Hillary saying "Good" at the end so smugly. Man, that was bad.

avatar

I gotta add to my youtube debate weirdnesses: When that gungho anti-immigrant candidate Tancredo went ballistic about illegal immigrants and he got this really wild, totally insane ("Heeere's Johnny!!!!") look in his eye as he ranted. I really thought the guy was loco after that. Very scary customer. Thank goodness he bowed out early.

(Hey, do you notice anti-immigration has not been an issue since all the Republicans but McCain fell away? That was a big issue when they were all still campaigning. Interesting).

Weirdest:

Huckabee's "I majored in miracles, not math." Ok, I know he was at least partly kidding. But still!

Others already used some of my first choices, but I'll pick some honorable mentions for variety's sake:

Best: Joe Andrew's endorsement letter.

Worst: Hillary's "the sky will open up" mock. (Of all the things she's said, I don't know why this bothered me probably the most. Even too cynical for my taste, I guess.)

Weirdest: "Bomb, bomb, bomb . . . bomb, bomb Iran."

I agree: "there will be celestial choirs singing"
It's the mocking that is both weird and bothersome. SO this is weird and worst. At that point I was embarrassed for Hillary.

Favorite and weird is the Gravel Rock video. Love it!

Oh, the other best. The post from a TPM reader about Huckabee's squirrel comments, ""So it's ok to slather a squirrel in oil and fry it on a popcorn popper, but not to marry and have sex with it? That hardly seems fair."

avatar

Best: Winning Iowa (my home state) was very, very cool, but it was the speech the night of NH results that really made me see this guy's grit, style, and ability to lead when the chips were down. I'd read from someone who knew him personally that he's at his best when challenged and that's what I saw that night; it set a new "metric" for me on how to assess the candidates going forward. How do they handle the hard stuff? By that metric, I think he's won hands down.

Worst, Best and Weirdest all in one: Wright. I still feel terribly sad that this issue arose, that he ultimately had to denounce and reject his former pastor's comments, that there was no good path out of it.

Wright was the Weirdest as well: I'm still trying to get my head around the idea that Catholics like Hannity and O'Reilly bashed him for not leaving the congregation - given the history of the Catholic church, of which they and I are members, and the fact that many of us have stuck it out with that institution despite some very horrific behaviors of church leaders.

But Wright was also a Best for generating the groundbreaking Speech. And for a number of SDs saying his handling of this crisis is what finally made their decision in his favor.

This Best, Worst, Weirdest question reminds me of closing lines from the last episode of the British office -- poorly paraphrased it was: "Life is hills and valleys and you never know until you're done which one you were at." We should ask ourselves the Best, Worst and Weirdest question again a year or two from now.

avatar

I mean the British version of The Office!

Can I add . . .

Funniest:

1. "Appoint Mitt Romney Secretary of Lookin' Good."

2. Every time I see Joe Lieberman now, for some reason remembering Will Forte doing his vein-popping Zell Miller impersonation way back when SNL did those Hardball skits.

That just makes me think of Judge Fudge:

"I don't have time to be President. I'm too busy... being delicious."

Best: Obama's speech on race in Philadelphia. There simply has not been a speech so nuanced and refined in American political landscape vis a vis race relations. It took the wind out of the punditocracy sails.

Worst: Hillary Clinton's comment on the legacy of Martin Luther King, Jr. and LBJ. She managed to condense an entire generational struggle into a context that supported her political philosophy. I won't accuse her of the race card, I will just accuse her of being tone deaf and just plain stupid.

Weirdest: There is a lot to choose from:

1. Ron Paul supporters chasing Hannity into his office building.

2. Bill O'Reilly putting Obama's life in danger to make himself look macho.

3. Pat Buchanan's opinion that African Americans should celebrate slavery because it brought them closer to Jesus.

4. Carville's statement that Hillary has three testicles while Obama has one.

5. Hillary's transformation into the Democratic champion of the Appalachian silent majority.

6. Mitt Romney's speech on religion that threw his Mormon faith under the bus.

7. Hillary Clinton's Christmas present ad. I still have nightmares about her opening up gifts for the American people.

8. Fred Thompson's entire campaign.

Does #2 refer to "Don't Block the Shot! Real low-class, pal! You S.O.B."

Zipper - great work on your list. These are priceless.

Carville's testicle thing, and the related testicle references (on the stump in Indiana with some union leader praising her special kind of fortitude, and her saying, don't go there) both intended and not by the HRC campaign (what MoDo called the emasculation theme) is collectively the weirdest thing ever in politics.

That and the campaign commercial using AC/DC's "Big Balls" with video of the Clinton inaugurals. Oh, wait, that one didn't happen, it just should have.

Oh, good to bring up Carville. Him spitting "Judas" to Richardson on CNN, now that has to be in the running for the ugliest surrugate comment award.

I dunno, it's definitely in the running for weirdest, but Ferraro definitely gave that one some competition.

avatar

(1) The first time I saw Hillary Clinton, a Democratic contender, not a republican opponent, stand there and say `I have the experience to be Commander in chief, John McCain has the experience to be Commander in Chief. Barack Obama has a speech.`
I felt as though I were Alice watching the Madhatter.
We've all become accustomed to that sort of thing now, but the first time was mind-blowing.
(2) Listening to Barack in his post PA speech at Indiana, assuring us all that Hillary had run a `terrific` campaign: this after we'd watched her during the debate actually trying to conflate the Ayers issue when Stephanopoulus seemed to be dropping it and we'd seen her time and again telling white voters `it's all right to vote for people like you.`
(3) Indiana: watching Clinton doing her most extreme, albeit excruciating, imitation of Sarah Bernhardt, whipping herself into some sort of manic frenzy as she `related` to these working people who were being betrayed by Washington and finally, in full operatic crescendo she wailed in extremis - they `don't hear your cries`... So UTTERLY melodramatic and phoney that it hit me clearly: they're all going to see it. This is the Bosnia thing all over again. And I'm pretty sure at least many of them - or at least many sane Indianans watching it later on the news - did see it.

avatar

And you know, many Clinton supporters are still buying that swill.

Of course you misphrase what Ferraro said, but you knew that.

It's been the campaign of the gratuitous spin, with Obama standing there in a white suit trying not to get shit all over him. But you know, you can't mess with it and not get some on you. There's always blowback.

avatar

And Hillary Clinton is certainly learning the hard lesson of blow back.

"mis-phrase"? How would you correctly phrase what Ferraro said?

How about I just let her say it:

"If Obama was a white man, he would not be in this position. And if he was a woman [of any color], he would not be in this position. He happens to be very lucky to be who he is. And the country is caught up in the concept."

And when asked about the comment she said:

"I will not be discriminated against because I’m white." http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/12/us/politics/12campaign.html

But maybe Ferraro was right. People are just caught up in the concept of electing a black man named Barack Obama:
http://www.politico.com/blogs/bensmith/0508/A_big_deal.html

Well quite a few are, yes. Isn't that obvious?
I figured most you would say that's a good thing.
Or was that the message in February and now it's changed? (I'm not on his political memo list).

avatar

Best: Philadelphia speech. This speech will go down in history as one of the best and most influential speeches by any American politician.

And Obama's early assertion that he was willing to sit down and talk with our enemies. Saw that he was the absolute real deal then, because I know his most senior foreign affairs folks were utterly freaked out by his answer, fearing that it wasn't the "right political" answer and a major "gaffe". Obama showed he was a measured, principled man who thinks for himself, and is willing to weather the storm confident of another day. If I had any reservations about his mettle then, they vanished.

Wierdest: Clinton aides running around trying to prove that she didn't lie about Bosnian sniper fire, AFTER, she said she lied about it & so what.

Worst: A 2fer:
Any time Bill Clinton wags his damned finger, we know he's lying.
&
'Hardworking white American people'...ugh. Why Hillary why?

I don't know hy everyone was surprised by Iowa, clearly it was going to either Obama or possibly Edwards, but I had predicted Obama for a variety of reasons.

Still, it was a great speech and combined with the gushing from Chris Matthews, it was the kind of speech which causes you to turn to your wife and say; "He's going to be the nominee".

BTW)
Best: The Iowa acceptance speech.

Worst: All of those stories from the NYTimes, where a few reporters with the agenda of counter-acting their paper's endorsement stirred-up mini-controversies where none should've existed.

Weirdest: The quick burnout of Fred Thompson.

best: Half-heartedly voting for Obama in CA after Edwards suddenly dropped out, and then listening his speech that night and suddenly seeing things in an entirely different light.

worst: Losing all respect for the Clintons

weirdest: The entire slate of Republican candidates - from Rudy 9iu11ani to half-dead Fred, to Huckabee, to Romney to Grampa Simpson and his little sidekick Joey. What a motley crew of comedians.

Weirdest/best/worst of past: Tweety's shiver up his leg.

Weirdest/best/worst of future: McCain dropping out before fall.

Yoda...I like this dude...

Sorry Timba, Im copying you..:)

Best - Obama's speech on race.

Worst - Hillary making Obama expand on relationships he has with other blacks. So after admiring them, losing complete respect for the Clintons.

Weirdest - HRC breaking down and complaining in the middle of a campaign debate! Sorry, that was strange to me. So after admiring them, losing complete respect for the Clintons.
Also weird is Dan Abrams going after Rove so hard, something strange there too.

Also weird...Paul Krugman.

Yeah, Krugman is weird because he seems to have some irrational thing against Obama spliced into a supposedly rational column. I don't think he knows his own heart and mind on this.

Why is it weird that someone disagrees with you and supports another candidate whose positions are nearly identical to those of your preferred candidate? And moreover, that when he indicates his preference, he specifically identifies where he takes issue? I'd have to add that one unfortunate (bad) consequence of this campaign has been the need to vilify nearly half the Democrats who have supported Clinton.

Krugman preferring Hillary isn't weird, but his manic, acontextual persistence in a Tourette's-like eruption about Obama in almost every column is pathetic. What's more pathetic is that Krugman is reacting to the O campaign slighting him, showing it's more than disagreement, it's personalized tinymindedness.

Sure, he's been a little hard, but he's always talked about specific positions Obama's taken. My suspicion is that Krugman was driven a bit batty by some of the over-the-top anti-Clinton hysteria and his feeling that she would make the better candidate. What I find disconcerting is the inability of some to accept any legitimate criticism of their candidate and how quick some are to dismiss prominent progressive voices as Clinton shills.

I don't tune out most Hillary supporters in the media, she has many thoughtful ones, but Marie Cocco and Paul Krugman are to me unreadably kneejerk. Krugman is only important because NYT puts him there. Never understood why, understand less now. MoDo is the only one on that board with star skills. Herbert is fine, but predictable. Brooks is a step down from Safire as a righty voice. WaPo has them beat pants down.

If I could amend my "weirdest", I'd have to say this whole redemption of Maureen Dowd because she's been playing her Obama support to great affect. I mean, it was only a year or two ago that she had moved beyond being irrelevant to "why does the Times keep her around?"

Articleman: We can agree or disagree on some of these (and I agree that WaPo has em beat, hands down) but I find most curious your assertion that Dowd has star skills. Entertaining, yes, but also delusional, vitriolic and twisted. Her irrational loathing of everything Clinton has infected her writing since Whitewater. This season, she's added a near obsession with Obama's (and Hillary's) masculinity, which is one of the things you find weird. She is one twisted puppy. Go to dailyhowler.com and search for Dowd for a highly entertaining critique of her lunatic ramblings.

I'll just agree to disagree with you.

I was a fervent supporter of Bill Clinton until August 17, 1998, the day of his grand jury testimony and angry speech.

For the love of the party, he should have resigned in favor of Al Gore. (Her campaign this year reflects at times the same incorrect sense of the relationship of the leader to the party, but I shouldn't go there.) The evil of the impeachment process, the malignant evil of Ken Starr, doesn't make my view wrong, it confirms it. But that's a point where I differ from a majority of Dems and a large majority here.

So I don't have the least problem with MoDo going after Bill on that. I get that a majority of our base does.

avatar
My suspicion is that Krugman was driven a bit batty by some of the over-the-top anti-Clinton hysteria and his feeling that she would make the better candidate.

There that is again. I'm not taking issue with you, but challenging the assertion. What has been "over-the-top" or "hysterical" about anything coming out of the Obama camp during this campaign? They may have mixed things up a bit, but to put it into perspective, other than the more recent statements from Sen. Clinton, this thing has been pretty genteel.

It's quite an amazing thing to me that Clinton supporters are still harping on the "nastiness" of the campaign when Obama pretty clearly took the worst of it (Clinton gets a free shot at belittling Obama's experience, but she reacts with righteous indignation when others dare question hers, "as far as I know...", "hardworking Americans, white Americans", the Ayers bit, the slams to Obama's patriotism, etc.), and that in any case, it's nothing compared with what she might have had to face against the republicans.

I certainly don't see a need to vilify Hillary supporters, but I also think it was unfortunate that Senator Clinton chose to say that while the presumptive Republican nominee had "certainly" crossed the commander-in-chief threshold, "you'd have to ask Senator Obama" whether he had.

It was unfortunate that Senator Clinton helped amplify racially tinged attacks on Obama, from commenting on his pastor, to qualifying her denial on 60 Minutes that Obama might be a Muslim with "... as far as I know."

That's not to say that many rational, well-intentioned people might not believe Hillary Clinton would be a stronger candidate, or a better president. There's certainly a reasonable argument to be made for either candidate, as they each have differing strengths and weaknesses.

I've been mildly surprised that Krugman has repeatedly touted Clinton over Obama, not because I don't see how he could come to that conclusion, but because he's harped on the point continually, almost with an air of condescension that the Democratic electorate might be making a grave mistake in choosing Obama. As you note, the policy differences between the two simply aren't that large, so it doesn't seem so obvious to me why Krugman would continually harp on that theme. Unless he views himself as a necessary counterweight to Maureen Dowd's psychobabble about the Clintons and their marriage...

Fosberry: Your points are all well taken. And the "... as far as I know" should also go down as one of the weirdest (to some, worst) moments.

I think this is a good thread Yoda!..I will only have one respond that is defense of something you put out for fun. Paul krugman is weird because of his rhetoric....Things like yes, the gas tax holiday is pandering, but yes people that think that are elitist!...That kind of stupid word parsing is weird comming from a Democrat IMO!

Now, back to people's Opinions, at least for me!

avatar

Outstanding thread here. My $.02:

BEST
1) Barack's Iowa speech; still gives me chills

2) Barack's 3/18 speech in Philly; brought me to tears. For way too many reasons to explain here.

3) "I look forward to you advising me, too, Hillary." The ultimate comeback/putdown. Spot-on perfect. And without being mean at all.

WORST
Just about anything that Hillary has said since losing Wisconsin. But the one that still to this day makes me truly despise her is: "I have a lifetime of experience. Certainly Sen. McCain has a lifetime of experience. And Sen. Obama has a speech he gave in 2002." F*ck. You.

WEIRDEST
The sad, ignominious transformation of the 42nd President of the United States from brilliant, distinguished statesman to shrill, embarrassing, psychotic doofus.

avatar

Very good salection. But for weirdest, for me it was the "Who let the dog out, Who, Who" of Romney. The face of the little black kids looking like " Who is this dude..."

Good one. That might win "most awkward moment in the primary."

Maybe I should have had two categories: awards for both the GOP and Dem fields.

avatar

Ah. Yes. That was most righteous. I just love Mitt Romney. So does my politically astute five year old son. Every time The Mittster comes on the TV screen at home -- we are a political junkie family -- my son says, "Awwww. Why do I have to see Mitt ROMNEY?!" I love it!

Nope...that one upset me, kinda like Rove dancing to hip/hop and rapping...

the who let the dogs out that is.

Yes, the who let the dogs out was really distressing to me on so many levels!

Obama telling a conservative African American South Carolina church congregation that they had to move past the homophobia.

The Cantor video pushing was shameful.

Great idea for a thread. Many have already been mentioned but here's a few that have been left out.

Joe Biden's comment on Giuliani was pretty funny: "There's only three things he mentions in a sentence -- a noun, a verb, and 9/11."

Mitt Romney's speech on religion was so bad it qualifies as both bad, weird and funny at the same time. How about this inscrutable line:
"Freedom requires religion just as religion requires freedom."

Weird: Kucinich acknowledges UFO sighting.

Bad: Whether you support Clinton or Obama, pretty much everything written by Maureen Dowd has been really, really, really bad.

Also bad: I'll stir up a little controversy here and say the sturm and drang over Bill Clinton's comments after South Carolina has been bad for everyone. To reash: leading up to South Carolina, every commenter in the country was predicting a big Obama victory because of the state's large African American population. When it happened, as expected, Bill sought to explain away his wife's defeat with his off-handed, unfortunate reference. This is what he said: "Jesse Jackson won South Carolina twice, in ‘84 and ‘88. And he ran a good campaign, and Senator Obama's run a good campaign here. He’s run a good campaign everywhere, he’s got a, he is a good candidate, with a good organization." Somehow, this statement became the "Willie Horton" of this campaign, a "calculated" effort by the Clinton machine to "ghettoize" Obama and "play the race card." Can we please get over this?

Good: It's almost over and now we can channel our vitriol against a candidate whom we really disagree with.

You know, I can't stop thinking about the bad.

Hillary's 3 am phone call was really bad.

I also think the trashing of Bill Clinton's reputation as evidenced by many commenters on this thread is bad. I'm not saying the guy's been edifying out there campaigning for his wife, and as we've seen, he's a crappy loser. But please, the caricature of him as a red-faced finger-wagging hate-spewing race-baiting doofus is just that. A caricature written by the mainstream media that has always hated the Clintons. Numerous times I've heard him described this way and actually looked at the video to find him speaking calmly and cogently.

Which brings me to also bad: The political culture of the gaffe in which a pack of cable tv vultures wait for someone to say something they can sink their teeth into and replay a million times until it takes on a significance it surely does not deserve.

avatar

AG: I agree with you that we can, ahem, no more disown Bill than we could disown our own families. This is true. I love Bill and, like many of us here, defended his lying, horny ass throughout 1998 and 1999. Until his "fairy tale" comment, the mere sound of his voice or glimpse of him on TV truly comforted me. My anger at him, however, has nothing at all to do with alleged media bias against him or Hillary. Not one thing. It has to do with his bitterness toward and jealousy of Obama that is distasteful. And his dog whistle comment about how a McCain/Clinton race would be between two people who truly loved their country. And his whiny "Obama played the race card on me" BS. And his Charlie Rose interview. Juxtapose this Bill Clinton with the man who made the oft-quoted comment four years ago about Clinton Rules, and going with the candidate who makes you think and hope, rather than the one that plays to your fears. Where did that man go? I want him back, dammit! I want him back!

I agree. Bill Clinton is a fighter and it's why people like him - aside form the fact that he can think and speak and we have had so very little of that these last years - and I hate to see him maligned by his own party. I say we reevaluate the situation, folks, because, honestly, who else do we have to take on the Republicans?

Obama?

I mean, for example. Just a thought.

All by himself?

Weird, maybe Worst: It's personal. Arguing in December with a friend who said he'd vote for Giuliani before he'd vote for Clinton. We were so convinced that those would be our choices. Idiots!

Best: Obama's speech on race.

My favorite moment has been ongoing - How many people have you seen criticize Barack for not wearing a flag pin WHILE NOT WEARING ONE THEMSELVES? There have been a few high profile examples, but I am taken aback at the sheer number of (forgive me for this) pots willing to call the kettle black. And it seems to be so common, that no one points it out anymore. I mean friggin Nash McCabe wasn't wearing one in the debate video. Are you kidding me?

Sorry for clogging up the thread, but I can't stop thinking about some of the bad things.

Really, really, really bad has been being finally exposed to the nominating process of the Democratic party. There's gotta be a better way.

And on a related bad bad bad bad bad note: Allowing a silly dispute between the state and national party to get to the point that two critical states will end up being left out of the nominating process. (And no, I don't agree with Hillary that the delegations should be seated; it's bad any way you look at it.)

Worst---Bill Clinton's efforts, all of them. Involving hinself at all undercut Hillary's strengths as an independent person.

Best---winning in November.

I don't count anything on the GOP side, that's shooting fish in a barrel. Those that dropped away were all nuts, and we're left with Grampy Mac Attack.

Best: Barack winning Iowa. Before that I was like. I really like Obama, too bad he won't win. And I was like, HOLY CRAP HE'S VIABLE!

Worst: Clinton "crying" in NH. The pundits saying she made that connection with the voters when I say it for what it really was.."Oh my God, I could lose..." *tears*

Weirdest: Bush dancing waiting for McCain. I remember on "Wait, wait, don't tell me." Maureen Dowd said, "It's so strange. He danced. The econonmy's going down the drain soldiers are dying in Iraq and he just keeps getting happier and happier."

Weirdest: Mike Gravel.

Best: Steffie: "Can Sen. Obama win the election?" Hillary: "Yes, Yes, Yes"

Worst: Tie. "Sen. McCain and I bring a lifetime of experience, Sen. Obama brings a speech he gave in 2002." And, "It's 3AM, who do you want answering the phone in the WH?"

Stupid friggin HTML tags. Sorry.

I also thought one of the better moments was when Sinbad said that the only thing they were concerned about in Bosnia was whether to "eat here or at the next place."

avatar

wierdest-
Early Republican debate -when everybody on stage was asked to raise their hand if they didnt believe in evolution. Remember how they all looked around at each other - all those little little wheels turning in those old heads.

I would classify that as the 2nd Scariest moment. Very disturbing and hint of what will come in the future.

That was an eerie moment...but also good as far as demonstrating how out of touch the GOP is even at a Presidential level.

Scariest moment is from Mike Huckabee:

“I have opponents in this race who do not want to change the Constitution. But I believe it’s a lot easier to change the Constitution than it would be to change the word of the living god. And that’s what we need to do — is to amend the Constitution so it’s in God’s standards rather than try to change God’s standards so it lines up with some contemporary view of how we treat each other and how we treat the family.”

I fear as Americans find out that their lifestyle is dropping (as a result of the end of cheap energy), they will turn to more and more politicians who say exactly this sort of thing. There is historical precedent for populations turning more and more to religion when political institutions fail them.

avatar

One of my favorite moments in all the debates
and, I don't remember which one, but early was a question to BO about his lack of managing financially a large company or a state budget yet Mitt Romney has that experienc. Bo response was based on what he has spent on his campaign and raised and got for his money......I'd take my position anytime!
Bo speeches in Penn. and Iowa were awesome.

Worst has been HRC whining. The Republicans saying they don't believe in science or evolution.

Weird: Cindy McCain always....the stepford wife, she gives me the creeps, she is always standing there at his side in a pastel suit.....ugghhh.

avatar

This is the most surreal campaign.

Operation chaos is like something out of a comic book. Arch villain Rush Limbaugh hatches plan to wreak havoc in Metropolis.

Giant cigar poked in plump face of a round-shaped man. Just add large bold-faced word balloon and you have the makings of a sinister comic book character.

Full disclosure, I'm in the process of creating a comic book version of this election.

Yeah, in hindsight, who out there could have predicted back in December '07 that Rush Limbaugh would be mobilizing his listeners to vote for Hillary Clinton.

Best: Hands down, Obama's speech on race. My son's teachers showed it to his class, a mixed (race/class) group of 12 year old kids in Los Angeles who will remember those words, who will take something from what was said that afternoon.

Worst: I think "you're likable enough, Hillary."
And the sexism.
And the racism.

Weirdest: The Republicans. One after the other, they are all really weird dudes: Paul - Guiliani - Thompson - McCain - Romney - Huckabee - shiver me timbers!

When I saw "you're likeable enough" in real-time, I didn't get the same impressions as others.

Hillary had just made a light-hearted crack about Obama and just how likeable he is... and Obama was returning the favor.

The problem (for Obama) is he didn't flash enough of a smile (though there was one there) and he was looking down writing notes at the moment. As a result, people went off in the wrong direction on it... and it looked worse in print.

That was my take too. I thought it was weird people jumped on that.

Me too (jeez, I'm doing a lot of "me too's" in this thread!). He was saying it in a joking way, but then it got spun as anti-female.

Oh! And I forgot - my absolutely most favorite funniest moment was when a blogger (sorry, I forget who!) wrote about Cindy McCain: Cool! I always wanted a transvestite for first lady. Cracks me up.

my best friend is a die-hard ron paul supporter and i can vouch that not all of supporters are werid. i mean, seriously, whats so "weird" about standing up for the principles of the constitution?

My personal bests are the brushing off the shoulder moment in NC during the PA loss and the moment on 60 Minutes when he categorically declared that his campaign was not going to dig up dirt and use it.

One of my favorites, from a photo I found online somewhere last week, is of Barack doing a chin-up on a steel bar in one of the gym waiting areas somewhere in PA or IN. The bar is at least 8 feet in the air and he's hanging there, terribly thin in his suit and shiny shoes, with his hands on the outside of the bar, not on the inside. I think I found the shot on Time's site...

Lots of my best, worst and weirdest are already on this list, but one of my personal favorites was the failure of the gas-tax pander in Indiana and North Carolina. Seems like American voters actually want a President who believes they have more than a smidgen of intelligence ...

avatar

Weirdest: HRC supporters failing to notice her ever constant personallity changes--what's up with that??

Best: Wacthing Obama's process of growth as a candidate before our eyes--how refreshing is that???

Worst: A tie between the painful awareness that HRC has no shame and the Main Steam Media coverage of the election in the Jerry Springer format of hyping salacious details in exchange for truthful journalism.

Great job PJ!

Most mysterious: the ongoing Women's Voices Women's Vote saga.

avatar

Worst: The MSNBC debate which opened with the moderators giving Hillary no chance for an opening statement, but instead pouncing on her and interrupting her response to argue with her.

Best: Hillary's closing at the MSNBC debate when asked what hardships she had endured in her life. Obama had already responded to the same question by discussing his difficulties as a child in a single-parent family. Hillary joked about everyone knowing about some of her struggles, and then dismissed them, saying that they were nothing compared to what she sees every day happening to average Americans. She spoke of how proud she was to be on the stage with Obama, and offered him her hand. I had chills.

avatar

Weirdest: Turn on my liberal AirAmerica radio talk show, or reading my favorite liberal blogs, and discovering as a Clinton supporter that I was now the enemy.

I agree with just about all of the above - this primary season has been fascinating. I just want to add one to the BEST column:

The comparisons of the venues these two are filling. Barack's over-capacity stadiums and Hillary's barns. Someone did a great piece on it on TV, but for the life of me I can't remember where I saw it. Probably CNN or MSNBC. It was a stark difference!

:)

Ok, and one for the WORST column:

The piece today by Kevin Merida in the Washington Post talking about the racism some of Barack's organizers have run into. I am just thankful it's sporadic. :(

avatar

And vice versa

Best: South Carolina victory

CROWD: YES WE CAN! YES WE CAN! YES WE CAN! YES WE CAN!

Obama: Yes - we CAN heal this nation.

(Shiver)

avatar

Until his "fairy tale" comment, the mere sound of his voice or glimpse of him on TV truly comforted me.


Has anyone who criticizes Bill for the "fairy tale" comment actually send it?> there's nothing racial at all in the remark in any way you interpret it. The comment was about Obama's position on the Iraq War. When did everyone decide that a spouse can't campaign for their spouse to win? this rule seems to have been made up just for Bill C.

Great post idea, Yoda.
Weirdest: Watching those early debates and trying to imagine Ron Paul and Dennis Kucinich duking it out in November (much as both added wit and, yes, wisdom to their parties' discourse).
Worst: Watching the mainstream TV punditocracy bobble its democratic duty so horribly. (Stewart and Colbert, by contrast, shone.)
Best: The realization that we've reached the stage where we can safely sum up the Weirdest, Worst and Best of this primary season. Finally.
Let's do this again in November, shall we?

avatar

Biden on Guilianni: a noun, a verb and 911

avatar

Biden on Guilianni: a noun, a verb and 911

Biggest Letdown: In the debate where Obama was asked about Farrakhan's endorsement and said that he denounced Farrakhan's positions. Then Hillary jumped in and started talking about how she had been endorsed by some extremist group in her race for Senator.

I thought she was going to graciously point out that no one can control what some whackos want to do, but no! Hillary doesn't do gracious. She had to say that she not only denounced the support, but rejected it, and that Obama's denouncing of Farrakhan's positions was inadequate.

To me, that's been the key to Hillary's whole campaign. She simply can't admit the virtues of anyone else running (except McCain, apparently).

Best - Obama's Philadelphia speech. I know I'm hardly the first to mention it, but I wanted to add my vote.

Worst - Lots of competition here, but I'm going to go with what was a turning point for me - Hillary's endorsement of McCain for Commander in Chief over Obama. Up until that moment, I hadn't been thrilled with the Clinton campaign, but I'd been okay with it. But that pushed me right over the edge. I consider it a betrayal of the Democratic Party, and it's the reason I will not trust her.

Weirdest - I can't say. That's like asking which grain of sand on a beach is the sandiest. This whole campaign - both Dem and Rep - has been surreal on too many levels.

ARGH!

BEST MOMENT WAS THE DEEP COVERAGE ON WENCH HILLARY'S CLEAVAGE!

WORST MOMENT WAS REALIZING SHE ALREADY HAD A MAN IN HER LIFE.

WEIRDEST MOMENT WAS FINDING OUT SHE DIDN'T RUN THE WHITE HOUSE IN THE 90S!

BUT...

SHE WILL BRING BACK CORPORATE RAIDING 90S!

ACQUIRE! MERGE! MARAUD! DILUTE! DILUTE!

ARGH!

Under worsts, I would also like to belatedly add this column by Pat Buchanan in which he wrote, among other things:

"[N]o people anywhere has done more to lift up blacks than white Americans."

http://www.theamericancause.org/032108.htm

(General observation: Hunting down Pat Buchanan columns on the Internet can be a disturbing journey.)

Awesome thread.

My vote for weirdest:
The 2/26 debate and right out of the gate Clinton says, quote: “Well, could I just point out that, in the last several debates, I seem to get the first question all the time? And I don’t mind, you know, I’ll be happy to field them, but I do find it curious. And if anybody saw Saturday Night Live, you know, maybe we should ask Barack if he’s comfortable and needs another pillow.”

I don't know if Clinton's "Shame on You, Barack Obama, Meet Me In Ohio" was one of my best, worst or weirdest. I laugh my ass off every time: "enough with the speeches and the big rallies" and corresponding arm levels. If you care to relive the moment start at about 3:11 -- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_X-RoRghAY

So many bests, but another best is when Obama clean clocked Hillary during the Potomac Primaries. That was sweet, sweet victory.

Weirdest: "We're going to go right at OPEC," she said. "They can no longer be a cartel, a monopoly that get to gether once every couple of months" at a hotel in "some plush place in the world" to set prices, she told a crowd a volunteer fire house in Merillville.

Worst? How do I choose?

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address