Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

The Truth VS. Barack Obama

avatar

©2008 Jonathan Cifre, J.D., of SAVAGEPOLITICS.com. All Rights Reserved.



by ShallowHal
SavagePolitics.com Contributor
(ShallowHal is the ORIGINAL AUTHOR of the now famous “Barack Obama’s LAUNDRY LIST OF LIES”)


INTRODUCTION


A warning should be issued, right here, and right now. What I am about to tell you could hurt you. It could set you free. It could be told in a way you might not like or respect. It could be all of these things and a few you never wanted to know.


In your Divided House there exists a paper thin weakness, a figure behind a curtain, with feet of clay, living only for the hour because tomorrow may never come. The soft underbelly your Champion harbors in hopeful oblivion exists, I and many others, together, have seen it. There are just too few of us. We know what it fears, for we are ‘The Sword’. It has it’s Achilles Heel, this Body Politic, if one only knows where to look. But to look requires the opening of one’s eyes. And yes, it could be awful. That is why I’ve warned you.


Nothing ever worth knowing is easy and this is no different. I need you to see. I need you to think. I need you to understand where I am coming from. But first you must understand who I am because if you cannot recognize me, there is no point in us going any further. So allow me to introduce myself - my name is Truth.


By definition I am simple. TRUTH: 1. the true or actual state of a matter; 2. conformity with fact or reality; verity: the truth of a statement; 3. a verified or indisputable fact, proposition, principle; 4. the state or character of being true; 5. an obvious or accepted fact; truism; 6. honesty; integrity; truthfulness; 7. (capitalized first letter) ideal or fundamental reality apart from and transcending perceived experience.


So as you can see, I can be many things but I cannot be controverted. I can weather opinions but am never changed by them. No matter the twisting of the wind or the shade of the glass, the sky is still blue and the grass is still green, and a version of the truth is only true if unchanged.


So this brings me to my portrait, the one I am about to paint. It is mine, and yet others have drawn the same conclusion. It has taken years for this picture to ‘expose’ itself, but just a month and a day, for me to paint the image, that I have discovered was not in my mind alone. But this is not a reproduction; this is not an opinion. After all, I am Truth, am I not? So I must tell you the image is real; it is set. This portrait is more Dorian Gray, knife in canvas, then Dorian Gray, young illusionist, misleading his audience, while hiding from the world his sins behind a curtain. Indeed, this is the Dorian Gray found on the floor, horrible to look upon, but undeniably him.


THE TRUTH VS. BARACK OBAMA


* * *
CHARGE 1 – “The March on Selma got me born.”


EVIDENCE - Senator Obama was born August 4th, 1961. The march on Selma began March 7th, 1965. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2


COUNTER CLAIM – Senator Obama was talking about the general movement, not specifically about Selma.


REBUTTTAL – Senator Obama was in Selma, Alabama, before a mostly AA crowd at the Brown Chapel AME Church on March 4th, 2007. He clearly stated “because some folks were willing to march across a bridge . . . they (his parents) got together, and Barack Obama, Jr. was born. So don’t tell me I don’t have a claim on Selma, Alabama!” Barack Hussein Obama was born on August 4, 1961. The first march on Selma, Alabama occurred on March 7, 1965.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 2 – “My father was just a simple, impoverished goat herder.”


EVIDENCE – Barack Hussein Obama, Sr. was a privileged, well educated youth, who’s tribal family owned and controlled all tribal land. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2, SOURCE 3


COUNTER CLAIM – He was poor to start off with, he only became an educated and successful man later in life.


REBUTTAL – Barack Hussein Obama, Sr. was privileged from the moment of his birth. Being born into the powerful tribe of the Luo, he was graced with an ‘upper class’ lifestyle. He later would go on to be ‘Big Man’ of the tribe and work as a Senior Economist in the Kenyan Government.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 3 “My father believed in the ‘power of the people’. I believe in the ‘power of the people’.”


EVIDENCE – Senator Obama has often stated that his ‘father’s attributes’ are ones that he has sought in his own life. Barack Hussein Obama, Sr. was part of a corrupt Kenyan government in the 1960s. He believed in taking land from it’s owners and taxation up to 100%, ‘if benefits’ were ‘commensurate to their income’. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2


COUNTER CLAIM – What does it matter what Senator Obama’s father believed in?


REBUTTAL– Senator Obama portrays himself as a ‘new politician’ with a ‘new way’ of getting things done. Senator Obama has stated, “I did feel that there was something to prove . . . to my father.” Senator Obama also stated further, in his book Dreams Of My Father, “It was into my father’s image . . . that I’d packed all the attributes I sought in myself.” His father’s ‘attributes’ included ‘100% taxation’ and repossession of land and property against the will of the rightful owner. Thus seeking the ‘favor’ of his father, and using his father’s ‘attributes’ as a model, Senator Obama therefore must maintain similar ideals and respect for ‘the people’. How these ‘policies’ are an example of ‘belief in power of the people’ is obviously highly questionable.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 4 - “My family has strong ties to ‘African freedom’.”


EVIDENCE - Raila Odinga committed genocide while attempting to overturn the 2007 Kenyan elections. Senator Obama and Raila Odinga are first cousins. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2 , SOURCE 3


COUNTER CLAIM – What does it matter what Senator Obama’s African relatives do in Africa?


REBUTTAL – Senator Obama campaigned for his cousin while on a visit to said country. Senator Obama claims a distinct debt to his familial ties, painting them in a light that is downright revisionist.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 5 - “President Kennedy rescued my father from Kenyan obscurity and airlifted him to the American Dream.”


EVIDENCE – Senator Obama’s father came in September 1960, while EISENHOWER was President. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2


COUNTER CLAIM – But his father did come to the U.S. so what is the big deal?


REBUTTAL – Senator Obama misrepresents historical events. No speech by President John F. Kennedy brought Senator Obama’s father to the U.S. in 1960. John F. Kennedy was not President in 1960, Dwight D. Eisenhower was President. The Senator is attempting to subtly equate himself with J.F.K., subconsciously implying he would be a similar President. Senator Obama, you are no Jack Kennedy.


VERDICT - SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 6 - “My Kenyan Grandmother has always been a Christian.”


EVIDENCE - Senator Obama’s Grandmother’s own interviews contradict this statement. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2


COUNTER CLAIM – What does it matter what Senator Obama’s African relatives do?


REBUTTAL –It goes to a person’s character and willingness to evade, distort, or rewrite history. Senator Obama’s Grandmother does her daily Salat prayers at 5am according to her own interviews (per Islamic law). Not to mention, Christianity does not allow for a woman to be one of 14 wives to 1 man. Senator Obama’s use of his Grandmother as an example of how ‘Christian’ his family is, in order to counter accusations of secretly being a Muslim, sustains the idea that the Senator is deliberately distorting the truth to cover-up associations and ‘fatherly attributes’ that he knows are problematic to his election, should he be forthcoming about them. His decision to make statements patently false in order to propagate a more ‘electable’ image speaks not only to his character but to his judgment. Distortions or edits to evidence that wholly misrepresent the truth is dishonest.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 7 - “My first name (Barack) is not Arabic - it is Swahili.”


EVIDENCE – Senator Obama’s name is Arabic in origin, not Swahili. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2, SOURCE 3, Columnist Says Barack Obama ‘Lied To The American People;’ Asks Publisher to Withdraw Obama’s Book, NEW YORK, Aug. 10 /PRNewswire/


COUNTER CLAIM - What does it matter where Senator Obama’s name originates?


REBUTTAL - If the origin of his name doesn’t matter, then why publicly lie about it? There is no transliteration between the alphabets of Arabic and Swahili. The Africanized derivative of the Arabic ‘Baraka’ is Barack, but the origin and source is entirely Arabic. Senator Obama again distorts the facts in an attempt to distance himself from associations he deems politically inexpedient. Senator Obama’s middle name, Hussein, is also Arabic. Naturally, so is the Senator’s last name, Obama.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 8 - “I never practiced Islam.”


EVIDENCE – Senator Obama practiced Islam daily at Meteng Primary school, where he was registered as a Muslim. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2, SOURCE 3


COUNTER CLAIM - What does it matter whether Senator Obama practiced Islam as a child?


REBUTTAL – If there is no importance to the fact that Senator Obama practiced Islam as a child, then what is the motivation for lying about it publicly? Indonesia requires students to study religion. Barry Soetoro was registered as a Muslim at the Meteng Primary School. One cannot participate in any studies within a Madrassa without practicing Islam.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 9 - “My school in Indonesia was Christian.”


EVIDENCE – Senator Obama was registered as a Muslim at Meteng Primary School. The school offered Christian classes as well. Barry Soetoro did not attend them. He later spent 2 years in a Catholic school SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2


COUNTER CLAIM - What does it matter that Senator Obama’s school was Islamic or Catholic?


REBUTTAL - Again, If there is no importance to the fact that Senator Obama practiced Islam as a child, then what is the motivation for lying about it publicly? Indonesia requires all students to study religion. Barry Soetoro was enrolled as a Muslim at the Menteng Primary School where he studied among other subjects, Islam. In 1969 Barry attended a Catholic School. This is the only schooling Senator Obama discusses, thus Meteng has been somewhat covered up. Why one would ask? The only conclusion that can be drawn from this scenario is that Senator Obama lied about this school and its subject matter for political expediency. In later comments the Senator stated he did not attend an Islamic school, but in his book “Dreams Of My Father” he states that he ‘got in trouble for making faces in Koranic studies’ and was disciplined by his mother. One would ask how many Catholic students remember being taught the Koran by their nuns.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 10 - “I am fluent in Indonesian.”


EVIDENCE - Not one teacher says that Senator Obama could speak the language at the time. SOURCE 1, (Kirsten Scharnberg and Kim Barker, “The Not-So-Simple Story Of Barack Obama’s Youth,” Chicago Tribune)


COUNTER CLAIM - What does it matter that Senator Obama can’t speak fluent Indonesian?


REBUTTAL - YET AGAIN, if it does not matter, what is the motivation for lying about it publicly? Apparently we are to infer, by Senator Obama’s supposed “fluency” in Indonesian, that he is very sophisticated and experienced in “foreign affairs”. Perhaps Senator Obama feels that grade school French and Spanish qualifies most U.S. students as UN diplomats.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR


* * *


* * *


CHARGE 11 - “I lived in Indonesia. I have more foreign experience than Senator Clinton or Senator McCain.”


EVIDENCE - Senator Obama lived in Indonesia from the ages of 6 to 10. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2, SOURCE 3


COUNTER CLAIM - Living in a foreign country is a much more in-depth experience than just visiting one.


REBUTTAL - To imply that living in a foreign country, for 4 years as a child, is equitable to official trips representing the U.S. Government is completely without merit. Also, implying that it also equates to receiving classified information and studying these subjects with personal political experience is quite ludicrous to say the least.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 12 - “My foreign travels and life experience better qualify me to address our nation’s closest Allies.”


EVIDENCE - Except for Africa and Middle Eastern Muslim countries, Senator Obama has never been anywhere else in the world. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2


COUNTER CLAIM - The Middle East is an important area and so is Africa.


REBUTTAL - Indeed it is, but that is not what Senator Obama was arguing in this statement. He categorically stated he would be better qualified to meet with our nation’s ‘closest’ allies. Pakistan, Indonesia, India, Kenya, and Iraq can hardly be considered America’s ‘closest’ allies. Implying visits to 7 countries in nearly 47 years (4 of which were in his youth) is somehow equitable to visiting 80 countries in 18 years, (as has his opponent, Senator Clinton, in various official governmental capacities) is completely dishonest.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 13 - “I was ethnically confused, that is why I used drugs.”


EVIDENCE – Fellow classmates describe racial tensions and meetings discussing such issues. Barry Obama was not in attendance. SOURCE 1, (Kirsten Scharnberg and Kim Barker, “The Not-So-Simple Story Of Barack Obama’s Youth,” Chicago Tribune, 3/25/07), Dreams From My Father, pages 93-94.


COUNTER CLAIM - He admitted to using drugs in his youth. So what?


REBUTTAL - Either Senator Obama’s family was to be idealized and their ‘attributes’ incorporated into his life to assist with his success, or his family’s ambiguity, and latent racism drove him to drug use. Either the first is a false reality, or the second, but they cannot both be correct.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 14 - “I understand what it is to be an African American.”


EVIDENCE – Senator Obama is not African American according to U.S. Law. Senator Obama is an Arab-American according to U.S. Law. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2, SOURCE 3


COUNTER CLAIM - Senator Obama’s father is from Kenya (Black African) and he (Obama) was born in America. How can you say he is not African American?


REBUTTAL – Senator Obama’s racial background consists of the following: 50% white (mother, both sides), 43.25% Arabic (father, both sides), and 6.25% African Negro (father, one side, 1 generation removed). 12.5% is the legal threshold one must prove to claim racial status under the law. In addition, Senator Obama cannot make a sociological claim as an African American either. He was not raised as an African American, was not raised by African Americans, and was not raised in an African American neighborhood.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


* * *
CHARGE 15 - “I was an underprivileged youth.”


EVIDENCE – Senator Obama attended prep schools and later on went to Harvard Law. His Grandparents were wealthy bankers and his Step-father was an Oil Executive. His mother was also a P.H.D.. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2, SOURCE 3


COUNTER CLAIM - He went to school on a scholarship and had to use food stamps to survive.


REBUTTAL - From the ages of 2 – 6, Senator Obama was raised by his wealthy, grandparents. From the ages of 6 – 10, Senator Obama was raised by his mother and his step-father who was an Oil Executive in Indonesia; from the age of 10 until his early adulthood, Senator Obama was living again with his wealthy grandparents, one of which was the Vice President of the Bank of Hawaii. Senator Obama has attended prep schools like Occidental College, paid for by HIS FAMILY. He then went on to Harvard, the State Senate of Illinois, and the U.S. Senate.


VERDICT – SENATOR OBAMA, YOU ARE A LIAR
* * *


This is merely the framework of the portrait; there is more to the image on the canvas then first meets the eye. It’s details await examination. ‘Inside’ you will find magazine articles that never existed, Not-So-Universal healthcare, bill-jacked legislation, the promise not to run for office in 2008, ‘Present’ votes, ‘Oops’ votes, Ayers, Rezko, Wright, Meeks, Farrakhan, Khalidi, Auchi, Palmer, Michigan, Florida, Guns, Exelon, Lobbyists, PAC Bundlers, Big Oil, SubPrime, Passports, NAFTA, FARC, Altgeld, Caucuses and Classmates, Trinity and Terrorism, Bitter, Typical White People, Flag Pins and Anthems, Investment Conflicts and Un-proud, Overpaid Wives. For starters.


Follow the link - and down the rabbit hole you go . . .


http://savagepolitics.com/?page_id=326


 


Comments (34)

This is the same level of garbage as those bullshit Peter F. Paul posts about Hillary. Well, I reject and denounce those and I reject and denounce this.

If I feel like visiting tabloid slander sites like peterfpaul.com and this idiot's site, I'll go there. No need to infect this site with that type of disease.

Great photo Hilary!

Thanks! I'm still not 100% decided on its permanency.

avatar

What a load of crap.

avatar

Out of interest, which of the 15 charges are wrong, and why?

For starters, how about every one that uses freerepublic.com as a "source". That dispenses with 6 from the get-go.

And the "Counter Claims" are ridiculous.

Example:

CHARGE 7 - “My first name (Barack) is not Arabic - it is Swahili.”
EVIDENCE – Senator Obama’s name is Arabic in origin, not Swahili. SOURCE 1, SOURCE 2, SOURCE 3, Columnist Says Barack Obama ‘Lied To The American People;’ Asks Publisher to Withdraw Obama’s Book, NEW YORK, Aug. 10 /PRNewswire/
COUNTER CLAIM - What does it matter where Senator Obama’s name originates?

Well, actually the counter claim was that his name is Swahili. And Arabic. And also that it doesn't matter.

Let's look at the "Sources." Source 3 - a link that doesn't work. Excellent. Source 2 - a message board at Free Republic. That's reliable. And my personal favorite, Source 1, which if you actually click on it and read it, says quite clearly:

The Senator's first name, Barack, is a Swahili name that has its origins in the Arabic language. [Emphasis mine]

And it's kind of like this. My son's name is Jackson. Just about every baby name book says that it means, "Son of Jack." That's no fun, right? Well, one time I stumbled across a baby name book that said it meant, "Full of personality." So I'm going with that. And that's what I'm going to tell him.

I suppose, if he ever decides to run for President, I'll have to tell him that in most baby name books it has no meaning other than "Son of Jack" so he doesn't get accused of lying about what his name means.

avatar

I'm not suggesting it's an important issue, but if a furore erupted over the derivation of his name when he was running for president, and he relied on what his mother had told him rather than doing a few minutes of research, and then went on record saying everyone else was wrong, he'd be a bit silly.

avatar

Especially if his father was called Jack! (Barack's middle name should have made him pause to think maybe his parents had Arabic names on the mind!)

avatar

I hope that isn't the most incorrect thing in the list! Just from what you've posted, I'd say that it is untrue to say "My first name (Barack) is not Arabic - it is Swahili"
but it would also be untrue to say that it isn't Swahili.

It's both - a Swahili derivation of an Arabic name, and thus definitely not a traditional Swahili name.

So, I'd have to agree that Barack mislead there, for whatever it's worth - going from Baraka (Arabic) to Barack isn't exactly a big evolution.

Problem is, that quote is unsourced. That's not what he said.

Where this all got started is with Mike Allen over at Politico. He wrote:
"Why has he sometimes said his first name is Arabic, and other times Swahili?" in February of last year.

What Barack actually said:
According to a January 12, 2004, Copley News Service article: "In an interview last week, Obama said he decided to call himself Barack -- a Swahili derivative of Arabic that means 'blessed,' as 'baruch' does in Hebrew -- after his father died."

I also might add that the article cited in that particular item, "Columnist Says..." includes this line:
"My point: if he will lie about his mother and father, what else is he lying about? Can we expect 'bimbo eruptions?"
The author clearly has a high view of Democrats. This is GOP talking points at its worst and how it ended up in mainstream liberal sites is beyond me.

avatar

If he didn't even give that quote, then that answers that question, Charge 7 is struck from the list!

On another note:
He decided to call himself Barack? What was his name before that?

He went by Barry.

Hate Spam Sucks! What is this, the 33rd time we've seen this pile of garbage posted here?

TPM - Please ban this clown's IP address ASAP

As much as this is a load of crap, it's not bannable crap, IMNSHO. I think having an incredibly loose leash, like TPM does, is a very good policy.

I definitely prefer no moderation to aggressive moderation... but a teensy weensy bit of moderation might be better than none. Can't let the trolls run all over you.

Why are all those "charges" unsourced?

Gotta love the internal consistency, too. We'll dismiss Obama's years in Indonesia because he was a little kid and probably forgot all about it. But if at the same time he was a "registered Muslim" (whatever that means, and if it's even true), that clearly must have left a serious mark on him!

Score!

"Registered Muslim"? What, like he and Michelle registered at Bed Bath & Beyond when their daughters were born? Or maybe they were registered at Target, since they were still paying off their student loans and were living economically. I wonder if they got the KitchenAid Stand Mixer? I've always coveted that one. I hope I can be registered some day, too!

avatar

No, it doesn't claim practising Islam "left a serious mark", it claims he's lying about it.
Score deducted.

A warning should be issued, right here, and right now. What I am about to tell you could hurt you. It could set you free. It could be told in a way you might not like or respect. It could be all of these things and a few you never wanted to know.

I'm freeeeeeee! Free at last!

What. Ever.

Y....A...W...N

Is it possible to quote me yawning?
Apperantly yes!
"Y...A...W...N"

Look at that, it is possible to quote you yawning. ;P

The intro to that is one of the most over-inflated, self-important bits of lexical diarrhea I've ever laid eyes on.

Great post for those who have not drank the kool aid.

But we already know his is just another rookie, lying,politician.

A sure loser if the dems are dumb enough to run.

avatar

Mmmmm, forbidden Kool-Aid...

Just have to add my two cents to the growing chorus of voices denouncing this as a pile of horrifically odorous proportions. The author must be commended for his intestinal fortitude, which simultaneously accommodates this fecal and his head.

This is just plain stupid. It reveals more about you than Obama. You're no better than the Obamaniacs tossing out their paranoid accusations right and left.

And the hypocrisy of discounting his childhood in Indonesia while arguing against his experience and then clutching it to argue that he practices Islam -- You know if you want to be a successful hypocrite, you at least need to put such big contradictions in separate posts.

elsylee,

I can't believe someone actually wasted time writing this shit down, formatting it, and posting it God knows where.

Each point is either trivial, stupid, or just plain false.

Your "savagepolitics" outfit must be a garbage-mill if this is the kind of stuff you propagate. You're wasting your time posting this stupid shit here at TPM. Well, "Foreigner" is one commenter on this thread who is credulous enough (or spitefully anti-Obama enough) to take it seriously.

(Foreigner, are you a dumbass or an asshole? I'm frankly surprised you would find serious questions to ask after reading this piece. I kind of thought you were more intelligent and/or less malicious than that.)

elsylee,

I can't believe someone actually wasted time writing this shit down, formatting it, and posting it God knows where.

Each point is either trivial, stupid, or just plain false.

Your "savagepolitics" outfit must be a garbage-mill if this is the kind of stuff you propagate. You're wasting your time posting this stupid shit here at TPM. Well, "Foreigner" is one commenter on this thread who is credulous enough (or spitefully anti-Obama enough) to take it seriously.

(Foreigner, are you a dumbass or an asshole? I'm frankly surprised you would find serious questions to ask after reading this piece. I kind of thought you were more intelligent and/or less malicious than that.)

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address