Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

The Chess Match is Over; A Graceful Resignation = A Positive Legacy for HRC and All Women

avatar

In world-class chess matches between International Grand Masters, when one of the opponents recognizes that he (not many "she's" in this arena of competition) is in an unwinnable position, he resigns. No dishonor attached to it...it's expected. In fact, it's an implicit complement to his opponent's skill. (If I can see I'm done, he also can.)

Hillary Clinton has established herself as an International--or perhaps more difficult in the USA-- as a National Grandmaster of Politics. She knows she is in an unwinnable position. Yet, unlike the Grandmasters of Chess, she refuses to concede.

She, unlike chess players, clings almost obsessively to a hopeless cause...a terrible trait for a chess player and an even more terrible one for a President of the United States.

Her (failed) campaign has opened the door for qualified women to run as serious candidates for the office in the future. Despite her inexplicable, bold-faced lying during the campaign, she has managed to go where no (US) woman has gone before: A female candidate that was taken seriously by the electorate, regardless of party affiliation---something no other woman in the history of the country has ever done.

She was able to accomplish this on the sparsest of resumes; she displayed both the emotional and physical fortitude that voters expect in a potential president; she certainly outdid her distinguished husband on the "grace under fire" front, never appearing peevish or overly sensitive to criticism, never getting red-faced pissed-off at questioners...just a few tears welling up in New Hampshire. Overall, a fantastic performance.

She had the bad fortune to run against a phenomenon: an African-American, good-looking, younger, JFKesque orator who could only be criticized--ironically enough--as "elitist." Who the hell would ever have thought the first serious African-American prez candidate would have to refute charges of his elitism?

She did the best she could; and in doing so elevated all women.

She failed on the combination of her own flaws and Obama's extraordinary talents.

She should resign with honor, like an International Grandmaster in Chess.


Comments (4)

I agree with the analogy, but at this point would rather have the remaining contests play out. The 50 State prep for the general election has a few states to go.

avatar

She should resign with honor, like an International Grandmaster in Chess.

Fred...could I ask if you asked Jesse Jackson to do the same back in 1988? I'm just curious. And I'm sure that you well remember that Dukakis did in fact have the nomination sealed that year. TIA

avatar

Thanks for commenting.

I do not equate the candidacy of Jesse Jackson with that of Hillary Clinton.

Jackson was not a serious contender, as Bill Clinton implied during this campaign; Hillary was.
Jackson did nothing to advance the prospects of African-Americans in Presidential politics, quite the contrary; Hillary has done so for women; Barack, to put it mildly, has done so for for all people of color in the USA.

I would no more have called for Jesse to pull out of the race in '88 than would I have called for Kucinich(?) to do so in '08. They are, at best, mere political footnotes.

avatar

JJ wasn't a serious contender? He led in delegates after the MI caucus in 1988. He was close in our primary that year but the Duke win in WI took him out.

Yeah he was a serious contender in 1988 and I'd like to know why you and Barry are ashamed of his achievements. Can you help me understand that?

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


July 21-25

Bill Bishop The Big Sort

July 28-August 1

Book Cover

August 4-9

Book Cover

August 11-15

James Galbraith The Predator State

August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address