Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

PTSD And The VA Claim Process

For those who suffer from PTSD, the following will probably sound familiar.  For their spouses and families, I hope it brings a little understanding for some of the self-destructive and before now unexplained acts they may have seen from their veteran loved one.
         The "claim" process to receive treatment and compensation from the VA for PTSD involves many months and MANY pages of documentation.  Like most dealings with bureaucracy, it is demeaning and complex.  A cynic might think it was put in place to prevent anyone from following through on a claim.
         Suicide rates among Vietnam veterans, veterans of Afghanistan and Iraq and others who suffer from PTSD are at all time highs.  It's time for the government to find some compassion and understanding for the horror of this affliction.  It's time for the VA to honor those who have served with diagnosis and treatment instead of endless red tape.
         What follows is a brief excerpt from my "Statement In Support Of Claim" which will accompany many "Stressful Incidents" documents which must be dated and validated with names of witnesses, names of those killed or wounded in the incident, location and other details.

(The
“stressful” incidents noted on the enclosed documents are only part of
the reason I now realize that PTSD changed my life and caused me to be
the person I became.  Events of the past few years brought memories flooding back and the dreams returned.  As I watched our troops in Afghanistan and Iraq
going through another pointless, political bloodbath for the enrichment
of arrogant, incompetent leadership, I became more and more angry.
Finally, I sought help and began to understand that there were others who were going through the same thing.  The more I
learned about PTSD and its horrible consequences, the more angry I became.  The
isolation I’d felt all my adult life, the detachment from humanity, the
“escape” of alcohol, the “death wish” which has haunted me; all
suddenly had a basis in reality.  I was not alone! 
Sirens
in the night have always awakened me with that knot in my belly like
the ones which screamed at the hospital firehouse every time mortars or
rockets rained on MAG 16.  Loud, sudden noises cause me to instantly tense up and go into my “fight or flight” mode.  Only a few months ago I was walking through a Walmart store and one of the stock people dropped a pallet behind me.  I crouched and jerked around ready to defend myself.  The feeling in my belly is something only another veteran can understand.  But it has been there every time a loud, crashing noise has surprised me since I returned from Vietnam.
Trying
to get past the feelings of helplessness and weakness have been my
motivation for seeking help from the veteran centers in Indiana and Illinois.  I want to get help.  But nothing seems to help.  I’m tired of being alone even when I’m with people who love me.  I have hurt my family and everyone who has loved me because, in some strange way, it is my defense mechanism which
tells me: “don’t become attached.” 
Unless
the person who is reading this KNOWS PTSD and what it does to a person,
they can’t possibly understand the helplessness and desperation I feel.  I hope there is HOPE because I’ve run out of strength and endurance to keep hiding behind these walls I’ve built in my mind.  I hope our government’s representatives and the people of the VA realize what’s in our country’s future.  Most of us did one tour in Vietnam.  These vets today suffer three, four and five tours in Iraq.  Not only that but we had days or weeks of relative safety with nights of terror.  These vets
have CONSTANT fear.  There
is never a minute of their tour that they don’t have to worry about the
guy walking next to them detonating a bomb or the car on the street
blowing up.  The horror of PTSD is going to haunt this country for decades…  generations.
I was a corpsman because I wanted to help others.  Most corpsmen I knew were compassionate and non-violent people.  The few I have talked to who I knew during Corps School are changed as I am.  (name deleted from blog), who was in my company there is a completely different person than the gentle, fun-loving human being I knew. We are all changed forever.  My life is gone.  It’s too late to change what I’ve been and done.  This is my cry for help.)

If you are a Vietnam veteran or a veteran of the current conflicts and you are holding back on seeking help, PLEASE listen to one who knows...
Don't build the walls in your mind that keep love, emotion and trust from entering.

Get to a Vet Center.  There are people who CARE in every urban area of this country and many small towns.  I promise there is someone who will listen and help you find the counseling and treatment you need.  Don't let the feelings of helplessness, isolation or the unfounded belief that there is some kind of "weakness" which causes these feelings and thoughts to haunt you.  You are NOT alone!


Comments (4)

Thanks for writing this Chuck. My girlfriend works at the local V.A. in Homeless Affairs. I hope that over time the stigma of seeking help evaporates.

For further reading, I wanted to point out BOB HERBERT in today's NYT's - http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/20/opinion/20herbert.html?hp

... And all writing by Capt. Nathaniel Fick, USMC. In particular, he wrote an Op-Ed in the Boston Globe called "Coming Home - But to What" (which I can't find online for some reason...) Anyway, here he is speaking before Congress: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_J9stsmPFo

Fick (:30): "... The most shocking part was coming home and finding that half of the nation hardly knew we were gone."

Thank you for taking the time to read and comment.

Thanks for bringing attention to the tragic plight of our veterans suffering from PTSD. I am one of them. I served in Desert Shield/Storm and I was lucky enough to get the proper diagnosis from VA doctors. That was the end of my good fortune in dealing with the VA.

I was granted 40% disability for Gulf War Illness but I was denied compensation for PTSD as the VA ruled that it was not service connected. I was a stinger missile gunner with the 3rd AD, whose mission was to cut off the retreating Republican Guard as they fled north from Kuwait back to Iraq. Though there were no aircraft to shoot down, I was right up front with A-1 tanks firing on both sides of me and AH-64's and A-10's pummeling targets 3k away from me from above. The VA ruled that it was not the combat that caused my PTSD, (my guess is because I was honest and said that I never fired my weapon) but they made no attempt to postulate another cause. There isn't one.

Here's the worst part, imagine having your claim denied, (given the info above) and then reading the VA's own guidelines for establishing service-connection:

"It is the defined and consistently applied policy of the
Department of Veterans Affairs to administer the law under
a broad interpretation, consistent, however, with the facts
shown in every case. When, after careful consideration of
all procurable and assembled data, a reasonable doubt
arises regarding service origin, the degree of disability, or
any other point, such doubt will be resolved in favor of the
claimant.
By reasonable doubt is meant one which exists
because of an approximate balance of positive and negative
evidence which does not satisfactorily prove or disprove
the claim. . . . The reasonable doubt doctrine is also
applicable even in the absence of official records,
particularly if the basic incident allegedly arose under
combat, or similarly strenuous conditions, and is consistent with the probable results of such known hardships."

So how do they acknowledge that I was there and was harmed (awarded 40% for Gulf War Illness), make no attempts to find an alternative cause for my VA diagnosed PTSD, then deny my compensation based on service-connection?

Frankly, I'm not surprised about the veteran suicide cover-ups and memos about under-diagnosing veterans with mental health issues. I'm quite convinced that the VA would rather see veterans take their own lives than have to sign off on their disability compensation.

Mr. Keller, good luck to you. I hope that your story will turn out better.

And I thank you both for your service and for your comment. It sounds like you might have grounds for an appeal. Have you thought of that?

I agree the VA, the administration and the civilian leadership in Congress would rather see us commit suicide than to deal with the treatment of so many. Hopefully some in Congress will stand up to the "Chicken Hawks" who sent us to fight and die and find the compassion to help those who need it.

In the end, unfortunately, it always winds up being about MONEY to them. Millions for a bridge to nowhere, billions to Halliburton but NOTHING for those who were sent into harm's way.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address