Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

My Last Word on Wright

Wright is such a non-issue. It really does baffle me that in a time when we face two wars, torture, a recession, a pending world-wide climate disaster, and a global food shortage, that people really think someone's former pastor should be a decisive issue. I really don't get it.

Can someone explain to me how Jeremiah Wright is relevent in any way to the kind of president Barack Obama will be, to the type of policies he will implement? I doubt anyone can because Wright is irrelevent. He really is.

So it's incredibly disheartening to me that voters seem to think he is somehow relevant. I'd like to blame the media's non-stop coverage; in fact, i've been telling myself that the only reason people care about wright is because the media covers the story non-stop in a sensantionalistic way that would make Hearst envious. And he got  us into a war pretty much single-handedly!

It's just depressing. Even more so for me, because a belief in god is about as ridiculous as believing the american govt caused AIDS. So when I heard Wright say "God Damn America! Thats in the bible." I laughed because i thought it was hysterically funny (first of all the bible predates america by roughly 2000 years, so i doubt "God Damn America" is really in there) but i never take any religious figures seriously anyway. Whether they be the now dead Falwell or his kooky sidekick Robertson, or the anti-semite Billy Graham or Rod Parsley who thinks America's purpose is to kill muslims, or that guy with the mega church with horse teeth whose on cnbc on weekends( i dont know his name), or even the friggin' Pope. But i'm in the minority on that.

I mean, this really is such a trivial issue when compared to the real problems we face. I actually get a pang in my stomach when i see the number of people who are persuaded by this bullshit manufactured issue. Are the American people really that stupid?! We're on the edge of oblivion and instead of worrying about how to walk us back from the edge, we're talking about someone's former pastor...ugh...

I just can't help but think how much better off we'd all be if we kept god and politics seperate as the founders intended.
Obama's church and his former pastor are pretty much irrelevant to the type of president he'll be and the type of policies he'll implement. I'll ask again for anyone to demonstrate otherwise. Besides, doesn't the constitution prohibit any religious test to hold office? And isn't scrutinizing Obama's pastor a violation of the spirit of that provision, if not the literal purpose? Any time i hear Sean Hannity criticizng "black liberation" theology, I want to punch him. First of all, this is America and any religion is welcome here. Second of all,  the Catholic church has raped tens of thousands of boys over the last few decades, so who the hell is Hanntiy to criticize what someone else wants to believe?! And i can't help but notice, that despite the rape revelation, Hannity did not leave the church. So if we're being fair and applying the same standards to everyone, perhaps Sean Hanntiy should have to answer why he condones raping children.

I know i'll probably take heat for this, but i really believe that if Obama was white, this wouldn't be an issue. John Hagee, who is white, has said some pretty inflamible, disgusting, divisive things and no one's holding John McCain accountable for him. And speaking of disgusting, divisive things, Falwell and Robertson both claimed that 9/11 was cause by gays, feminists, abortionists, and secularists. Yet they still are able to maintain some ties to what is considered the mainstream. (well, not falwell cause he's roasting in hell).

So you have to ask yourself: How is Wright any different? The obvious answer is, he's black. I'm not saying thats the only factor, but you cannot pretend that it isn't a factor at all.

But think about it some more. There is nothing else on Obama. They've got no dirt, no affairs, no shady practices, all they have is a wack job former preacher, so the corporate media in the hopes to drive up ratings with controversial, sensationalist "reporting" is running with it nonstop.

I just wish for once we could have a political debate about the serious issues we face. Not the process, or political stories that have dominated the last few decades. But actual substantive issues. The challenges we face are too grave for anything less. And i really thought that Barack Obama would give us that campaign. And much to his credit, he's tried.

But his political opponents and the corporate media have decided that an actual civil, substantive debate would interfere with their goals of attaining and retaining power.

In the end, America will get what it deserves. If we chose to rise above this nonesense, we might actual be able to save ourselves from the downward spiral in which we find ourselves. If, however, we choose that a former wackjob preacher who has no relevance at all to the issues we face in America today is a more decisive factor than say a sound energy policy, or a sound and sane foreign policy...well. Ultimately, we'll make our own collective bed. We'll have to sleep in it. 

This is a democracy, after all. Sill, if barely. The choice is ours.

This is just too important. I hope we choose wisely.


Comments (10)

Character, Judgment. Both sorely lacking from Barack Obama.

Character, Judgment. Both sorely lacking from Marginal Player most of the time.

then you'd have to ask about the character and judgment of all those catholics who stayed in their church after those decades of rape came to light, no? i mean, whats worse: staying in a church who's pastor is a bit of his rocker, or staying in a church that not only raped and abused children for decades, but went out of its way to protect and cover for the rapists?

And if its fair to say obama showed bad judgment by joining his church, then is it fair to say John McCain showed bad judgment by joining whatever church he belongs to? This is America, you know. You're allowed to join whatever church you want without fear of retribution or condemnation.


i could also say you showed bad charachter and bad judgment by joining whatever church you joined.

the point is, i don't think you can fairly criticize someone's judgment over whatever religion they've chosen. it's a personal choice and what may be right for you and your family may not be right for me and my family. does that mean because we believe different things that my judgment is better than yours, or that yours is better than mine?

In America, there is no "right answer" when it comes to picking a religion or belief system. That's what makes america so great.

And the fact that you and the sean hannity's of the world think otherwise, well...i won't call you anti-american, but that thought process certainly is.

You wrote the Bible predates America by roughly 2000 years, so you doubt "God Damn America" is really in there. But the Bible is filled with stories of God damning countries (or cities) that behaved badly. Look what He did to Sodom, for example. He pretty well damned the place and its people. There wasn't much left when he finished with the place and its people. You're right that America wasn't mentioned in the Bible, but Wright was right that God did plenty of damning of places that deserved damning. That was in the Bible. And Wright provided a pretty good case for why God would damn America rather than bless it. Listen up before you condemn Wright, America. Comments by Wright don't have to add up to a wrong.

You don't get it. This is exactly the time to concentrate on bullshit non-issues like Wright. Because what else is there to talk about? War? Useless president? Tanking economy? Subprime crisis? Continuing loss of jobs to China and India?

No one wants to hear about that. Of course it's stupid, of course it's totally counterproductive. But such is human nature.

avatar

You know the old saying, "everyone is crazy if you know them well enough?"

Well, stands to reason the same would hold true for Obama's preacher (or anyone else's, for that matter).

The reason Wright is being flogged as an "issue" is because so many people in this country are scared of brown people. And more particularly, brown people who are either not afraid to speak their minds or angry, or both.

That's all this is about. Obama is BLACK!!!!

OOOGA BOOOGA!!!!

I suggest you read "The Fire Next Time" by James Baldwin. The title comes from a prophecy in the Bible "God gave Noah the rainbow sign,No more water, The fire next time." So God could be a pretty mean bastard in the Bible and very well might have said "God damn America," if you believe in such stuff. If you read Baldwin, you will also see where Wright gets his prose. Is any of this relevant to this presidential election? Yes, but not in the way it is being twisted. It is relevant because it highlights how serious the racial tensions are in this country and how far we from fixing the problem as long as we have people like the Clintons, who will exploit racism for political gain.

avatar

I'm a Clinton supporter but will say clearly that I've had enough of the Wright issue. More than enough actually. I sat in the pews and listened to a preacher that said a bunch of crazy ass things till I was 18 and went off to school. True enough, I was doing it when I was growing up to please my family and Obama did it for political cred. That's ok. Politicians seek political cred all the time in many ways. I understand that.

But Wright really doesn't come up on my list of issues that are important to the country in the current environment. I do understand why it's been important to the Clinton campaign to keep the issue active. With the Obama campaign using every other minute to tout Obama's superior 'judgement' for his no risk/no information speech prior to the Iraq invasion, the Wright debacle is karma. And karma is a bitch. Sow. Reap.

I personally think that the Wright issue hurts any dem candidate. Sadly, my morning daily had an editorial on the issue today focusing on the 'under the bus' cliche...shoulda ditched him in the beginning...just political expediency etc... It helps only McCain here in CO which will be close in the fall election in spite of Obama's 'big win' in our caucus.

The dems have a problem right now.

obama does have better judgment than hillary. and just because he joined a church you wouldnt have joined doesnt mean that somehow his judgment is impaired.

can you imagine if we did that in this country? held peoples religious affiliations against them to prevent them from attaining public office?

Seems like it goes against that whole "there shall be no religious test" provision in the constitution, doesn't it?

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address