Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Hypocrisy? Clinton Changes her Tune on Florida and Michigan

I wish I had a dollar for every time I've heard Terry McAuliffe say Barack Obama made a "political decision" not to campaign in the Florida and Michigan primaries in order to satisfy Iowa and New Hampshire, but if Obama made such a decision, so did McAuliffe's candidate, Hillary Clinton. This, from the September 2, 2007 NY Times:

“We believe Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada and South Carolina play a unique and special role in the nominating process,” Patti Solis Doyle, the Clinton campaign manager, said in a statement.
The pledge sought to preserve the status of traditional early-voting states and bring order to an unwieldy series of primaries that threatened to accelerate the selection process. It was devised to keep candidates from campaigning in Florida, where the primary is set for Jan. 29, and Michigan, which is trying to move its contest to Jan. 15.

Today Hillary is sending out an email urging her supporters to tell the DNC to "count every vote." The real political decision is Clinton's appeal for a do-over, something she would never do if the candidates' delegate counts were reversed. 

By the way, the next time McAuliffe makes his "political decision" statement, it would be nice if somebody—anybody—in the media challenged him on it. It took me all of 30 seconds to find the quote above. 



Comments (12)

How about this snippet straight out of McAuliffe's book "What a Party" - When McAuliffe was DNC Chair and Leven was threatening to move up the MI Primary under his watch

"I'm going outside the primary window," [Michigan Sen. Carl Levin] told me definitively.


"If I allow you to do that, the whole system collapses," I said. "We will have chaos. I let you make your case to the DNC, and we voted unanimously and you lost."

He kept insisting that they were going to move up Michigan on their own, even though if they did that, they would lose half their delegates. By that point Carl and I were leaning toward each other over a table in the middle of the room, shouting and dropping the occasional expletive.

"You won't deny us seats at the convention," he said.

"Carl, take it to the bank," I said. "They will not get a credential. The closest they'll get to Boston will be watching it on television. I will not let you break this entire nominating process for one state. The rules are the rules. If you want to call my bluff, Carl, you go ahead and do it."

We glared at each other some more, but there was nothing much left to say. I was holding all the cards and Levin knew it.

Full story available here -
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/04/27/mcauliffe-has-flip-floppe_n_98857.html

Brilliant!!!

Thank you x 2!!!

Now if only we can get this on the national nightly news...

avatar

Between Hillary and Obama I prefer Hillary. Not because I trust her, I don't, but because you know her allegiance is to herself whereas Obama has allegiance to whoever is standing in front of him that he perceives is important. Watch him. Wright, Avery, his wife. He always defers to perceived power. Obama has a great need to be "lead" and no confidence in himself. These are not indicators of someone who can lead.

Bollocks.

Who the heck is Avery?

avatar

Huh? This premise is nuts. How on earth do you not process her triangulation?

avatar

Aha! Got it. Clinton 'triangulates'. Barry 'reaches out'. Is that it? Is that why Reagan had all the good ideas?

avatar

If you weren't an Obama supporter your argument would be so much more compelling. "Butcha AHH, Blancha AHH!!", to quote Baby Jane. I just love hearing from the folks who are outraged at the prospect of a primary where every state counts.

In this protracted campaign that has lasted so many months it's amazing how votes don't count at all if they are cast one week, but would count completely if they had been cast just a few weeks later. Poor Florida and Michigan. All those invalid people!

But then in November everybody's vote will count. Well, except for the spoiled ballots. At least none of us will ever know if our ballot was spoiled or not. They don't send out notices saying, "Sorry. You're invalid."

And then of course there's the electoral college system which gives each state 2 electors, plus a certain number of electors relative to population... which means if you live in a state like Wyoming your vote counts much more than if you live in California. Wyoming's population merits it only 1 elector. But it gets three. Not bad. No wonder Dick Cheney decided to come from there. He gets three times the voting power he deserves.

But I guess none of this really matter because most states are winner-take-all in November. If the Democratic primaries were too, then Hillary would have already won. But they're not. Pity! However it doesn't really matter because come November millions and millions of people will be voting for the candidate they didn't vote for anyway. I mean, look at all those Democrats who voted for Obama in N. Carolina. They pretty much finished Hillary off. But they'll be voting for McCain in November because N. Carolina is a winner-take-all red state. Boy, are those Obama supporters going to be pissed when McCain thanks them for their vote.

At least as a Californian I'll be voting for Obama, even though I may have written in Clinton. There's no chance this state is going Republican. Well, except that in their infinite wisdom the voters of California recalled their Democratic governor and replaced him with Schwarzenegger. You can't blame them. We had a huge budget deficit, and Schwarzenegger was after all a movie star like Ronald Wilson Reagan whose name just happens to add up to 666, but the born againers never seemed to notice.

And now that we have a huge budget deficit again I suppose we might one day see a Democratic governor in "Ka-lee-foah-nya" if the right movie star with the right accent comes along. Although Schwarzenegger is popular again. He became unpopular for a while, but as soon as the economy soured and the same conditions came along that allowed him to kick his predecessor out of office, the Governator's popularity went back up again. Go figure! I mean, everyone knew those were fake potholes he was filling in that photo op on the news. His office had sent a road crew out to that neighborhood to dig those potholes that very morning. He drove over a hundred fifty real potholes on his way to film himself filling in that fake pothole. But he looked good in his expensive shoes and finely pressed pants wielding that shovel. Great smile, too.

Well at least he's against the constitutional amendment measure that's going on the November ballot. It's kind of odd though that the guy twice vetoes gay marriage, but now wants to uphold the ruling from the supreme court. I guess he figured it wouldn't look good if the Governor was against gays, the state legislature AND the state court.

It will be nice to get married again. We've been living in sin for so many decades. We tied the knot four years ago in San Francisco, but the courts turned around and untied it six months later. Then the legislature accomplished the herculean task of passing gay marriage not once, but twice. So we would have married two more times, but those marriages were vetoed by an Austrian weight lifter. I'm so glad he came to America to take advantage of our many freedoms. Just wish he wasn't so determined to take away mine. So now the courts have given us a fourth chance. Maybe we'll run out and get hitched again before the voters get their chance to unhitch us again in November. Banning gay marriage in California would be such a moral victory for all those poor central valley Republican saps whose winner-takes-all votes will be going to Obama.

It will be nice to get married again.

Congratulations and best wishes! And here's to hoping that those poor central valley Republican saps aren't successful in taking it away.

avatar

A lot of polls show that Obama will make North Carolina competitive, and has a good chance of winning it.

And it's quite funny that you claim you want all the votes to count, given that you've endorsed a popular count that leaves out four states.

avatar

Good rant. I have this lingering fear that the FL/MI mess is somehow gonna come back and bite the Democratic party in the ass later. Hoping teh DNC does get-out-the-vote ads in FL and MI in late October saying "come out and vote, we promise it will count this time!"

avatar

stuart......Barack Obama made a "political decision" not to campaign in the Florida and Michigan primaries...

If you have a link to the above, please post it here. No one campaigned in FL or MI unless you count Obama's TV buy that ran in FL and Obama supporter Conyers telling people to vote uncommitted in the MI primary. Obama did make a political decision to take his name off in MI...he didn't want people to see his name with the little number following with Clinton's name with the big number in the headline. It is a pretty punkass move, don't you think?

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


September 15-20

Book Cover

September 22-27

Book Cover

September 29-October 3

Book Cover

October 6-10

Book Cover

October 13-17

Book Cover

October 20-24

Book Cover

December 1-5

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Claire Wilcox



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address