Reader Posts
« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
Anyone following Lebanon? Open discussion invitation...
I was just searching for a spot to chat on TPM about the current situation in Lebanon and it's all AP posts you can't comment on or offsite links, so I thought I'd try a little post here and see who else is interested and takes the discussion bait. Perhaps this post will hit the TPM dustbin in no time, or perhaps it may live another day...
Anywho, I'm no expert on what's happening but I do have a news life outside of the daily political chatter and figured I might throw out some inflamatory stream of consciousness thoughts and see what others have to say.
-------------------
No big fan of Hezbollah (not so progressive on women's or gay issues, rather fundamentalist, to say the least) but I still feel like "good for them" in the sense that they are trying to stand up for themselves as a people in a land hostile to them. People have a right to self-determine, even if you don't like them, and there should be a certain softening of demands made to historically oppressed groups.
Hamas was democratically elected, and yeah, they are hostile to Israel, but Israel has the ovewhelming upper hand, and imprisoning Hamas' elected leaders and cutting off gas and otherwise negatively controlling the Palestinian economy doesn't help. Inevitably it's gonna piss people off. Hamas took Gaza, demonstrating their popular support. Only Abbas really remains on the other side and I'm not sure how long the West Bank will tolerate his ineffectiveness in making strides towards true Palestinian self-determination.
I'm anti-US imperialism. We've completely taken the torch from the British when they dominated the area and I think it's time we stopped trying to force our will. Our motivations over there tend to be rather craven and we usually get it wrong (arming Bin Laden and the pre-Taliban, empowering and later arming Saddam, installing the Shah, cuddling with the House of Saud to this day, unconditional support of Israel, ad nauseum). One of my favorite all-time books on the subject of US foreign meddling since WWII is Rise to Globalism. First read it in high school in the mid-80s. Changed my life -- it, along with other contemporaneous rebellious movements, opened my America-Is-Disneyland eyes. The true patriot works to make the country better, internally and externally, and has little use for flag pins.
Speaking of which, you know Hamas loves Obama, right?
Recently, there was the debacle known as the 2006 Lebanon war. Sure enough, that's boomeranged into some new upheaval.
There's simply current day-to-day news in Lebanon where the Shiites (Hezbollah) take a Sunni TV station and then the Lebanese government declares Shiite media illegal.
I really just hope we don't fuck it up worse. But, then again, I'm not holding my breath.
Damn











Comments (6)
I admit, I'm just a stupid poet who isn't even a poet, and I don't know Hamas from Hezbollah and I don't even know if this has anything to do with the Gaza Strip...but when I saw those people jumping over the fence a few months ago, trying to get to gasoline and food, I said "Right on!" and hoped they would get what they needed and be able to bring it home. To whatever home they have left.
My knowledge of all this is limited, but when I see people trying to eat and get supplies to their own people, my heart goes out to them.
Being dumb in this way of mine, I can only look at some of the pictures in the news this week and say to myself, "Why is it that people can be forced to this?".
For soil? For land? For oil? For real estate? For a belief in a higher power? This is worth letting some people starve and die?
May 10, 2008 2:30 AM | Reply | Permalink
I, like you, have contradictory feelings. Hezbollah is the only source of protection and leadership many South Lebanese, mostly Palestinian, have. On the other hand, Lebanon, in spite of its turmoil, has always been the most progressive country in the Middle East, and it pains me to see radical shi'ite Islam, if that is the case, take over West Beirut, one of the finest places I have ever visited.
May 10, 2008 8:30 AM | Reply | Permalink
I'll add that it is the typical case of the alienated and oppressed clinging to the radicals who will defend them. The good works of the hateful and radical Farrakhan is another example.
May 10, 2008 10:19 AM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for posting. I hope your post stays up,as I think this needs to be discussed. Juan Cole had an excellent post on the situation yesterday -- he's linked through TPM.
I still don't know enough.
However, I have been terribly frightened that while we have been fighting out this nomination battle, a new drumbeat to a new war with Iran has started -- this one could involve the use of "tactical" nuclear missiles.
I haven't been doing a darned thing about this.
I think it is important that we be careful about how we use TPM. I know it is not a political advocacy site. However, I will suggest that it is time to begin working to stop the next war before it starts.
I will email my senators today.
Also, I need to read Juan Cole and actually learn about this mess. Ignorance is no excuse -- not when one knows that one is ignorant and chooses to remain so.
Anyway, I'm lecturing myself more than anyone. I really am feeling like one of the "Good Germans" in the 1930's, and I'm Jewish.
May 10, 2008 9:01 AM | Reply | Permalink
I find a parallel in the destabilizing effect of bombing Cambodian "VietCong sanctuaries", which led to Pol Pot and killing fields.
The neocon dream of stirring things up in the area, (as opposed to the tradition of settling them down), yielded an opening for Hezbollah to gain respect. Israel, feeling that Iraq gave it some cover, tried to act to preserve its own respect after Hezbollah embarrassed it. Failing to seriously degrade Hezbollah, Israel ended up boosting its status. That Lebanon could not prevent Israel from exercising force within its borders gave Hezbollah another relative boost.
Thanks, guys.
May 10, 2008 10:49 AM | Reply | Permalink
I recommend this post from yesterday by Chris Allbritton, with lots of updates from his contacts in Beirut:
http://www.back-to-iraq.com/2008/05/a-hell-breaking-loose-in-beiru.php
May 10, 2008 4:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment