Reader Posts
« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
What's the Matter with America?
Thomas Frank's great book "What's the Matter with Kansas" basically asked why people in many states of our great country, and particularly small town America, continually vote against their own self interests when electing representation.
This is essentially what Barack Obama was saying - and he was right.
Why do people continually vote for elected officials who do not help them? Who add to their bitterness and frustration?
And one very believable answer is that their is a block of the electorate who allow social issues and religious belief to trump good common sense on occasion.
Believing in God is not mutally exclusive to voting for someone who can improve our lives.
Last time we looked; this country did have a separation of church and state. The blurring of this started long ago but after 9/11 we were all looking for reasons "why" and church and synagogie attendence rose to record levels.
It is fact that in hard times people turn to their spiritual lives to help understand/explain why/how life is as it is.
The fact that sometimes there just is no reason for unfortunate events, is just not good enough for some people.
What Sen Obama did was tell the truth. And after all the lies we have been told by our elected officials; we can only hope that people voting in Pennsylvania and the other nine remaining primary states look in the mirror and truly understand they should vote in the best interest of their lives, the lives of their children and the lives of their fellow citizens.
While Sen Clinton's campaign left a litany of much more disturbing issues this week that truly cast doubt on her ability to run a campaign much less a country, than Sen Obama's words could ever infer, the Obama campaign chose the high road. No one in the Obama campaign is talking about Bill Clinton's truly insane speeches this week (if my husband ever said I was old and should be excused for forgeting things - that would be it!), Bill Clinton's being paid over $800,000 by an orgaization supporting the Columbian Free Trade Agreement, Mark Penn and so much more --
The Obama campaign lets voters make up their own minds.
Bill and Hillary Clinton think they can tell YOU what to think.
So now, under the tutelage of Sen. Clinton and McCain, the MSM is trying their best to portray Sen Barack Obama - a man raised by a single white woman in the early 60's, an absentee black father, without means who rose through his own sheer brillance to where he is today - as an elitist.
The contrast to this "elitism"?
On the left we have: "the "middle class" champion who went to Wellesley and Yale Law, lived in a Governor's Mansion since the early 80's and then the White House in the 90's and has been in a Georgetown townhouse and a manison in Chappaqua NY since becoming a US Senator and filed income tax for $109 million dollars for the past seven years.
On the right we have: the "my friends" champion who is the son and grandson of Admirals. Who is married to one of the wealthiest women in the Southwest United States, who supports making the Bush tax cuts for the rich permanent and who has yet to make public either his tax returns for the past few years, or his health records.
If this is the prism on the left and right - who frame Sen Obama as an "elitist" - we run the risk of getting what we deserve next November.




Comments (20)
Sen Barack Obama - a man raised by a single white woman in the early 60's, an absentee black father, without means who rose through his own sheer brillance to where he is today - as an elitist.
This is not a jab, but I have wondered about this and you would seem to know. If Obama was as you have portrayed here how did he mange to attend prep schools and Columbia University and Harvard and all? Even with Scholarships, you are talking boatloads of money.
April 12, 2008 5:29 PM | Reply | Permalink
Umm, loans? That he finally managed to pay back two years ago after getting paid for writing two best-selling books?
But seriously, you are trying really hard to find fault.
April 12, 2008 5:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
Touchy, touchy! Those would be some big ass loans my friend. And he clearly did not get loans to attend prep school he would have been too young! Umm!
I had heard his grandparents were loaded. Is this the case or not?
April 12, 2008 6:14 PM | Reply | Permalink
Read his books if you want to know. His mother's parents were not dirt poor, but his mom raise him modestly.
He certainly lived very modestly while he was a community organizer in Chicago, getting paid net-to-nothing.
Believe it or not, many people fund their entire college education through loans. I did.
If your case against him is that he went to a prep school and that his grandparents might have paid for that, I have NO idea who you COULD vote for.
April 12, 2008 6:22 PM | Reply | Permalink
How rude! Is this how civil discourse is held where you are from?
April 12, 2008 6:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
I apologize if I came off as rude, God knows this is not the best medium.
But it's ridiculous to fault somebody for managing to find opportunity and get education. Your reaction was that he must be lying and he must have been born into riches. I thought this was supposed to be the country of opportunity, where you can make it on your own. But instead, it's become the country of suspicion and blame.
It's extremely frustrating to see how close minded people are in this country, how prejudiced and how much of it spills into the political process.
April 12, 2008 6:44 PM | Reply | Permalink
No offense taken I really was just wanting to know. A good education is expensive!
April 12, 2008 7:14 PM | Reply | Permalink
But everybody should be able to get one, and I think Obama will do the most to make education more accessible. He understands what a blessing it is.
Please, check out his very concrete plans on his website, under "Issues". I particularly like his tuition credit in exchange for community service. It's not coincidence that he mentions it so often.
And thanks for replying.
April 12, 2008 7:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
If your idea of rudeness is someone taking exception to astonishingly ill-informed comments, then count me as rude, and glad to be so considered.
Who did your homework for you when you went to school?
April 13, 2008 12:48 PM | Reply | Permalink
You consider someone who hasn't read O,bama's books to be "astonishingly ill-informed"?
Wow you have pretty high standards!
Perhaps you could provide a synopsis of the books for those of us who work 10 hour days.
Give us the Cliffs note version so our ignorance will not so offend you Old Grouch.
April 13, 2008 3:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
OK, so you think I'm going to do your homework for you? In what alternate universe was that idea born?
April 13, 2008 6:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
Just trying to help you feel happy about your contributions to the campaign. Like I said, I hate for my ignorance to so offend your delicate sensibilities!So enlighten me , do!
April 13, 2008 8:48 PM | Reply | Permalink
in a similar vein there's a bloody wonderful post over at Daily Kos. Check it out:
http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/4/12/03854/5216/164/494100
April 12, 2008 5:49 PM | Reply | Permalink
this reply may show up twice - because I wrote it and sent it and it never appeared so here goes again --
strav9:
All the info is availble between Obama's two books and GOOGLE -- I have been a big fan since the 2004 convention and read both books -
To answer your questions:
(a) his grandparents were not rich - he grew up with them in a two bedroom house in Hawaii after coming back to the USA -
(b) his mother was a big advocate of getting a good education - Barack got a scholarship in Hawaii to the Punahou Prep School (this was revealed during the Hawaii Caucus when Sen Daniel Inouye - a Clinton surrogate - tried once again to portray Obama as an elitist and the school came out with a statement that he was on scholarship)
(c) He went from Punahou to Occidental College in CA on a partial scholarship. The rest was paid with loans that were paid off by the money from his first book "Dreams from my Father".
(d) He transferred to Columbia University from Occidental College - again part scholarship and part loans. Also paid off after the publication of "Dreams". (this info is in the book)
(e) He worked as a community organizer and did not go to Law School until he was 28.
In the "Audacity of Hope", Obama writes that he and Michelle did not pay off their Law School loans until they got the advance to this book.
He was in Harvard Law as part scholarship and part loans.
--
As a mother of an 18 year old I can tell you that any good school would give money for s student as bright as Barack but also the schools all give money for diversity and a black guy named Barack Obama who grew up in Hawaii is about as diverse as one human can get!
April 12, 2008 6:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thank you for the information.
My niece just got accepted at Cornell and even though my brother in law is a Nuclear Engineer and she has some scholarships it is going to cost a fortune to send her out of state tuition to Ithica , but hey, she'll be attending the same school as Keith Olberman and Bill Maher. I just went to Wash U in St. Louis and it was very high!And Sub Ivy!I really just wanted to know how he did it!
April 12, 2008 6:38 PM | Reply | Permalink
Harvard tries hard to get qualified blacks, with generous tuition assistance. It recently announced a major restructuring of tuition schedules to allow more middle-class students, too.
April 13, 2008 3:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
Wash U is an excellent school
Congratulations
April 12, 2008 6:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
Just curious... what about that was rude?
April 13, 2008 1:04 PM | Reply | Permalink
I also remember a story that Obama told on the campaign, about his VISA being declined at a restaurant, or at a hotel. He was working as a civil rights lawyer, but paying off some substantial student loans, and paying the day today bills. He talked about the embarrassment of being declined, and the anxiety every time he used it to purchase something.
Everyone who is well educated isn't an elitist. There are student loans and scholarships for those who are motivated and willing to take on a huge debt commitment. Those that do so clearly believe in the value of education. When faced with the same alternative, I chose to work rather than go to college on loans. There isn't a day that goes by that I don't regret it.
Obama was raised in a middle class, working family. He has done extraordinarily well for himself, given where he started. Anyone who refuses to admit that fact, isn't being honest.
I commend your relatives for taking a risk and sending their children to good schools. I have no doubt they are making the right decision.
April 13, 2008 3:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
Please clarify. Are you saying that Obama was too young to take out a loan personally, or that there are no financial aid programs for prep schools?
April 13, 2008 3:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment