Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Questions McCain should have been asked on Harball

So John McCain was on Hardball today with everyone's favorite bloviator, Tweety Bird Matthews.

Here are the questions I would have asked:

Why don't you know the difference between the Shia and the Sunnis in Iraq? Once might be a mistake, but twice is a trend and you've mistaken the two groups several times over the last few weeks alone.

You've said you detest war. This seems to be at odds with your eagerness to "bomb bomb bomb Iran"? Explain that please.

How do Bush's tax cuts go from "offending your conscience" to something you enthusiastically support and want to make permanent?

You said you want to run a "respectable" campaign. So why does your campaign seek out the likes of Bill Cunningham and John Hagee?

Do you think its a good policy, in a time of war, to be expelling Arabic translators from the military when those very same translators are vital to our intelligence capabilities, simply because they're gay? Doesn't that policy put our national security at risk?

Why dont you think the assasinations of Martin Luther King and Robert Kennedy were "meaningful" news?

You voted against the 1990 Civil Rights Act. Why do you put the "rights of the unborn" ahead of the rights of actual living, breathing human beings?

Your healthcare "plan" doesn't allow for preconditions. Seeing as how this would disqualify cancer patients (and many many others) why dont you think cancer patients like yourself deserve health care? Not all cancer patients are married to uber-rich heiresses, after all.

Instead, he got tough questions like: "Is Obama an elitist"?  "why are so many young people excited by the words of Barack Obama?" and "Are you a typical white person"? "Do you think you'll be a "great republican president"?

Hardball indeed.

Feel free to add your own questions. Maybe i'll email them to chris matthews for the next time he has on John McCain.


Comments (8)

Questions McCain should have been asked on Harball

I read that as "Hairball". From now on, that's what I'm calling it.

My question for McCain: Hillary has endorsed you, but you haven't returned the favor by endorsing her. Why not?

oops. typo.

and in the headline even.

how embarassing.

here's a question for TPM: Why can't I have an "edit" feature?

They've improved a lot of things recently, so hopefully an edit feature is in the works.

I wasn't picking on you about the typo, BTW. I just think that "Hairball with Chris Matthews" is an excellent name for it. A fortuitous misreading of a typo.

The type is SO much better than the reality.

Still laughing.

It wasn't lost on me that Hardball with Obama was broadcast from West Chester University, a small state school in a group of schools that used to be the PA state teacher's college system. But McCain was at Villanova, an expensive, elite school located on the Philadelphia Main Line, a wealthy area. Who's elitist again? McCain probably had to go there in order to find young Republicans (and a cafeteria that serves arugula). But I also noticed that those fine young rich kids came up with some pretty stupid questions, a bit frat boy, if you will. So of course, McCain got softball instead.

avatar

There is a line journalists won't cross with McCain that they will cross with the other candidates. Maybe it's because he's an American war hero. Maybe it's because they're used to having a good old time with the guy.

It's not helping McCain at all, though, as he's not faced enough real direct challenges and this will be transparent in the GE debates.

I normally don't like to defend Chris Mathews, but his questioning of Obama on the college tour show wasn't any more critical. --and I'm a big Obama supporter. I think the college tour shows are a lot different than if he were grilling them one on one in a studio. Though, with Mathews more or less announcing his own Senate campaign on Colbert last night, I doubt he'll be lobbing many true hard balls.

He should have asked McCain:

What's the difference between how you're proposing we deal with Iran and what Bush did with Iraq? I was really scared by his answers.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address