Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Obama shows trust and respect for voting public: Hillary not so much


Obama has embarked on a profound sociological and political gamble. He
gambles by offering the electorate a deep respect by quietly and firmly
telling truths. His campaign, to a degree unparalleled in normal
campaigning, constantly and repetitively gambles that voters of all
stripes, indeed, can handle the truth. It must be at times agony to
watch the 'gotcha' spin from opponents and the press while waiting to
see if the American citizenry can make intelligent decisions faced with
a cacophony of spin.

So
far the voters have proved Obama's respect for them to be well placed.
They have showed their common sense by ignoring mindless spin battles
and continuing to vote increases in Obama's winning lead primary
numbers.

Hillary has made
herself into the politician's worst nightmare, a caricature of the
pandering politician. This week I am against trade deals says she as
she enters a post-industrial state. This week I am a bird hunter she
advertises. Last week I was a policy wonk and before that Mrs.
Experience and whoops I find myself in rural hinterlands so fetch me a
shot and a beer.

Obama
was thoughtful, honest and a bit perhaps too cerebral last week. He was
thoughtful, honest and trusting of the electorate and a bit perhaps too
cerebral the week before. He said his white Gramma distrusted black
people and that she said bigoted things, which was honest, thoughtful,
respectful of his listener's intelligence and a bit too cerebral the
week before that. Pennsylvania's rural voters in the majority accept
that there is bitterness and a penchant to be angry over race, guns and
religion but Barack's delivery would have been better couched in more
palatable down to earth terms.

It
must be agony for Barack and Michelle to watch and listen to twaddle
gossip cast as news, waiting and waiting to see if common folks respond
with common sense to not particularly revelatory truisms, that
widespread unemployment encourages bitterness and that racism at
varying levels is part of America's culture.

I'd
like to think that the Obama family is actually in a "win-win"
situation. They will continue to rise above pandering political
showmanship and tell truths, although perhaps in a voice a bit too
cerebral. They will ask and tell the electorate that their
understanding is required to define and tackle America's open sore
problems in health care, job creation, a dollar driven Washington
culture and the USA's international posture. If Americans in a majority
can actually "handle the truth" we/they will stand with the Obamas when
they inherit the White House and begin a brutal slog to "change." If,
on the other hand, voters revert to distraction over race, religion,
sexuality and Annie Oakley panderings then Barack's quest for truthful
definitions to guide America will be seen as a bridge too far of an
endeavor; a bit perhaps too cerebral.


Comments (10)

avatar

i have been making a similar point regarding the faith in the electorate implicit in obama's mature and truthful responses to the 'gotcha' attempts emanating from the republican and clinton camps.

...in more pleasantly formatted paragraphs than your otherwise useful post, i hope.

AND he is showing that he can stand up to the muckflinging he's gonna cop in the general. i bet ari fleischer is scrambling trying to dig up something to tar this baby with.

Aha. Thanks for your amiable agreement. Thirty percent of the media absolutely know that 'bittergate' is pundit characters seeking political caricatures and that they are blithely not discussing the issues.
The formatting was not mine. It spontaneously happened when I hit submit and I never read it at that time.

Excellent post, Craig (and downunderland, I kinda like the weird paragraph formatting... it has a free verse kind of flavor to it).

I appreciate your point that Obama has been Obama has been Obama, the whole way through this process. He's not perfect because nobody is. But he's consistent, in an election that tries to push inconsistency at every step. Well said.

I'm looking forward to the debate tomorrow night, to see if (as I suspect) he will continue to be consistent and hard-hitting, both.

Merci. Let's hope for a good debate. I hope his casual humor flumoxes the grasping Hillary a time or two. She was booed the other night when she dissed him. That can't boost her confidence.

avatar

If the polls continue to bare out little harm was done to Obama, it should prove that many people had caught on to the republican tricks & lies or maybe they read Thomas Frank's book, What's The Matter with Kansas? By the time Obama got there they were ready for the real "straight talk." He had faith in them, It was perfect timing, imagine someone telling them they were right to feel so unhappy or bitter, who wouldn't?

This may take awhile, the deceit has been going on for a long time, but if this does happen there could be big color change to red, white & blue.

I've felt for years that our whole governance was like a corporation that did not have a "Mission Statement."
If one listens to the Obama family they are saying that an American family that works (2 persons I guess) 40 hours a week should have all the basics.
They should have food, housing, clothes, reasonable vacations, health care and access to higher education. That I would say to "My Friend" John McCain is a game plan.
By daring to speak uncomfortable truths one can define the mission and define the weaknesses. Only so can one begin chipping away at America's ills.
Good decisions take considerable time to conceive and implement. Barack seems quite unique that he has the patience to see plans slowly unfold, including sticking with consistency and honesty as a political message even in the face of the drivel jawed pundit class.

By daring to speak uncomfortable truths one can define the mission and define the weaknesses. Only so can one begin chipping away at America's ills.
Exactly, Craig. Obama strikes me as one of the first "adult" candidates we've seen in a long time. He's remarkably grounded and consistent, and he's got the surprising ability not to panic (at least, not visibly) about these bits of turbulence. This is the kind of guy who gets things done.

Thanks for your post. I share your opinions about Obama's faith in the capacity for Americans to be fair-minded and intelligent. Your reference to Obama's gamble on the electorate is exactly how I've viewed it too.

I have noticed that many people, even Republicans who have no intention of voting for Obama, are responding to the rare and unexpected respect that Obama's message and tone offers us. I think this is a good sign. I'm hoping and assuming Obama will be as respectful in governing as he is in campaigning. Perhaps his style will inspire other politicians to follow his example.

Imagine what might be possible if this so-called gamble proves to be fruitful.

I've been real busy lately but...

Only a stone cold person would not perceive some degree of bitterness and even more certainly anger in the communities around here.

Hundreds of people lost pensions and health care when a long established - over 120 years old - transitioned through several hands and closed. When the Company was re-opened a few months later, it was considered a whole new entity and not responsible for the defunct company's.

in another case...

Mitt Romney's Bain Capital bought the porcelain business from American Standard and then sold it to another company which promptly moved all the work to Mexico. They were here about 70 years.

There was a time the first company was large enough it had full size baseball and softball leagues for its employees and their kids. A lighted, company owned, immaculately maintained ball field and adjacent park with playgrounds.
bleachers, electric scoreboards, genuine and modern restrooms - not porta.

Between the two of them at one time, there were over 1800 jobs. Those were just two of the companies around here.

A lot of people that are not too happy, and I think a fair number here think Obama is a heck of a lot closer to the truth of things than the MSM wants to stop and credit him for. To just gloss over the concerns like the other two are doing - in a way - is to go minimalist on the real issues.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address