Reader Posts
« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
Obama Should Go to Memphis
Barack Obama obviously has an African-American heritage. He may be a candidate for all people and he may be positioning himself as a post-racial figure, but he has certain characteristics which associate him with the African-American community and no matter how much distance he (or his supporters) may want to put between himself and that fact, those to whom it might matter have certainly taken note.
He's also benefitted from the Civil Rights movement. The fact that he's a viable candidate for the White House speaks volumes on the issue, but he's also heavily aligned himself with the fight for equality through the subtext of what he says and he has borrowed heavily from Dr. King's style of speech. As an older person, I can't help but to hear the similarity in cadence between "yes we can" and "free at last", plus whenever he launches into one of those "from the fields of Iowa to the shores of..." portions of his acceptance speech, I recognize it as something which I mentally associate with some of the speeches from Dr. King.
This week marks the 40th Anniversary of the assassination of Martin Luther King. There's a full slate of commemorative events planned for Memphis and some of the topics covered will naturally include mention of Sen. Obama's candidacy.
On Friday, the actual anniversary of his death, Al Sharpton is going to lead a march from the Memphis City Hall to the National Civil Rights Center, which includes the Lorraine Motel. After the march there will be a memorial service, then a candlelight vigil and we've been told that several dignitaries will be on the balcony at exactly 6:01pm.
Barack Obama should also be on that balcony. It would mean that he'll be photographed alongside the Rev. Sharpton and perhaps Jesse Jackson, who was also on that balcony forty years ago and he'll be with other leaders from that era, but I think that it'd be a good gesture and would properly memorialize one of our most influential historical figure for him to be there. After all, if it weren't for the efforts of Dr. King, Sen. Obama would not find himself in the position that he finds himself today.
And, because so much of the world's media will be focused on Memphis this week and the events of that sad day, so many years ago: I feel that the entire event, with or without his presence could be a continuation of the conversation that he tried to start in Philadelphia.
Though Barack Obama really should go to Memphis -- It'd be the right thing to do.












Comments (19)
This from an MSNBC commenter about Hillary's third tonight show appearance on Thursday:
"Does she have a big announcement? I heard she might announce she's resigning from the race...
Ron, TX (Sent Monday, March 31, 2008 5:44 PM)
More think she's broke and just after more free advertising, but you never know.
April 1, 2008 6:29 AM | Reply | Permalink
I'm really not sure what this has to do with the subject of my post, but I'm glad "April Fools" is creating amusement for some.
Of course, my post wasn't a joke because I think it'd be a nice recognition of the past and way for Obama to help establish himself as a reconciling and presidential figure, but hey -- thanks for the word.
April 1, 2008 7:00 AM | Reply | Permalink
Obama can honor Dr. King in a number of ways. There is no added symbolism by having him stand on the same balcony. As a matter of fact Memphis shouldn't be honored for doing such a lousy job in protecting Dr. King!
April 1, 2008 6:58 AM | Reply | Permalink
I think he should avoid politicising the commeration of Dr Kings Assination. If he came to Memphis then Hillary would to and it would devolve into competing rallys.
April 1, 2008 7:52 AM | Reply | Permalink
I believe both candidates were in Atlanta on Dr. King's birthday and both were at the commemoration of Selma. As far as I'm concerned, any additional attention that could be brought to his work is a good thing and if that attention were to come from both of the Democratic candidates, then it'd illustrate that we're unwavering in our committment to his dream.
April 1, 2008 10:32 AM | Reply | Permalink
We've all benefited from the Civil Rights Movement. Not to get all post-racial or anything, but I think Obama's "blackness" has nothing to do with whether he should attend this rally. There are some good arguments for why he should, and Larry and Bussta have given arguments for why he shouldn't. I personally think he and Hillary both should, but would understand if either one didn't.
April 1, 2008 8:13 AM | Reply | Permalink
Ben --- You hit it when you said that we have ALL benefitted from the civil rights movement. Having grown up in the pre-civil rights South, I can fully attest to that. The changes also lifted a heavy, soul-killing burden from the whites as well.
(And I don't think either candidate should be in Memphis today, or in Dallas on Nov. 22, etc. There are other times/places to give respect. We don't need the echoes.)
April 1, 2008 9:08 AM | Reply | Permalink
I've noted in other comments and on other forums that I started school the year after desegregation, so I also remember and realize how far we've come.
Obviously, I also agree with you and Ben that we've all benefitted, but I believe that the events scheduled for Memphis this week and all the attention that will be focused on Friday's will help those who are younger to not take the accomplishments for granted and I think the symbolism of what Dr. King saw from that mountaintop would be a good thing.
April 1, 2008 10:43 AM | Reply | Permalink
It scares me for him to be there. That would be some crazy KKK loving idiots wet dream. I agree with Elizabeth2.
April 1, 2008 9:53 AM | Reply | Permalink
I had not even thought of that. But you are right. he should definitly avoid standing anywhere near the Loraine.
April 1, 2008 10:30 AM | Reply | Permalink
I think the Secret Service and the huge crowds would be able to protect him. Of course there's always some kind of risk, but he's already asking for a job that's much bigger than just himself.
April 1, 2008 11:00 AM | Reply | Permalink
True, but some symbolic places/dates just attract extra "crazy". It would be just to good a get for those psychos to resist.
He is applying for president but he doesnt have to paint a target on his back.
April 1, 2008 11:19 AM | Reply | Permalink
If Barack Obama wants to further the work of Martin Luther King, the way to do it is by furthering the work of getting elected President. Let him do that in Pennsylvania, Indiana and North Carolina. I'm a much bigger fan of commemorating life than commemorating death. An honest assessment of Dr. King's life and legacy should show any honest student that the man wasn't about lifting up blacks, but lifting up everyone who was put at a disadvantage by the society he saw all around him. That's why he was in Memphis. Why you think Barack Obama needs to stand on the balcony where Dr. King was murdered is a mystery to me. I don't think it would serve any real purpose other than to give hatemongers a new image to masturbate to...
April 1, 2008 9:55 AM | Reply | Permalink
I know that I personally have been moved by some of the exhibits in the National Civil Rights Center and perhaps none greater than when I've stood on that balcony with my family.
I also believe that though many events scheduled for Memphis this week are focused on the future, there's a lot focused on the past and maybe none more so than what's going to happen on Friday.
Barack Obama, whether he'll be the Democratic nominee or not is a strong symbol for the future and by honoring those who came before, listening to the roll call of Civil Rights leaders and lighting candles on their behalf, I just think that the imagery of a bridge connecting the past to the future would be a hard symbol for anyone to pass up and it should help advance the "conversation".
April 1, 2008 10:52 AM | Reply | Permalink
I live in Memphis. I agree with ondionline. He has work to do in Pennsylvania, Indiana and North Carolina. He shouldnt be here. Trust me we got his back here. We are doing community service projects here in Memphis per Memphis for Obama.
April 1, 2008 10:29 AM | Reply | Permalink
The candidacy of Barack Obama might better be served in PA, NC or IN, but he is where he is today. He might be the most likely Democratic nominee and he may even win the Presidency in the fall, but there's no question about where he's at today and I think that if he can leverage it to bring extra attention to the events and serve as a symbolic bridge to the future, the country would benefit, no matter what tomorrow might bring.
April 1, 2008 10:57 AM | Reply | Permalink
Martin Luther King is Martin Luther King! Is there some MLK attention deficit that I'm missing? Does the country not know who he is? Is he some shadowy, obscure figure that the nation needs more education about so that they can realize his contribution? There are a lot of African Americans whose contributions to the betterment of our nation have gone largely unnoticed, and to our collective detriment, but starting with Dr. King is not furthering the conversation.
I don't think it is hyperbolic to say this: Martin Luther King is one of the most well-known figures in modern history. Show a photo, most people will recognize him. Play an audio clip, most people will know his voice. Does Barack Obama really need to go stand in the place where Dr. King was murdered in order to represent a "symbolic bridge to the future"? What about that act makes him a bridge? Do we as a nation really need Barack Obama's leverage on that?
Let's compromise: What if Barack sets his alarm clock to U2's Pride (In the Name of Love) on Thursday night, will that work? What if he plays it on his tour bus PA system and reminds the reporters who the song is about, would that help?!?! How 'bout he reminds everyone that Bono took some poetic liberties, and that Dr. King was actually assassinated in the evening... Don't get me wrong, I love and honor Martin Luther King. I have a framed print commemorating the March on Washington in my bedroom. I just don't get what you're getting at with this post...
April 1, 2008 11:25 AM | Reply | Permalink
On Friday evening, Obama is going to be in North Dakota, giving the keynote speech at the state Democratic convention. This, I believe, is fulfillment of a promise he made to Kent Conrad or some other ND eminence.
But the curious thing about it is that Hillary reportedly just announced that she will speak there too on Friday, after Obama (never a good idea) in a state in which (1) she's very unpopular (ND superdelegates are 6-0 for Obama, with one undecided); and (2) the primary was already held (with Obama winning handily).
Curious indeed. But would seem to preclude a Memphis trip, at least in the afternoon.
April 1, 2008 11:31 AM | Reply | Permalink
I guess that in theory, the timezones might allow him to be in Memphis at 6:01, but that might be a taxing schedule and maybe he could just do something earlier in the day or at a Thursday event commemorating the speech.
I don't know. It was just an idea and if I were helping with his image management and campaign strategy, I'd have made the suggestion and since the TPM calendar showed nothing for that day, I figured that I'd toss it into the air.
Thanks
April 1, 2008 6:34 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment