Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Laughing Matters

As noted over at TPM Election Central, Hillary is laughing again:

MSNBC: Today, she responded with a hearty laugh -- the kind once criticized and mocked by pundits and the media

CNN: Hillary Clinton used her trademark laugh Thursday to deflect a question

WaPo: Sen. Hillary Clinton turned to a tactic she had used often early in her campaign, though not recently: laughing off the question
I respect Senator Clinton. I've heard that she has an excellent sense of humor and finds many things funny. I, myself, have also been known to chuckle politely in appropriate contexts and even to type LOL on occasion. (Though never ROFL and certainly not ROFLMAO, which I find inappropriate. Have you ever seen anyone roll on the floor laughing? Have you ever seen someone laugh so hard that their ass fell off? Of course not. It's a silly notion.)

But there is a right way to laugh and a wrong way. Hillary has chosen the wrong way. It's one thing to tee-hee at the dinner table in response to funny jokes about Senator McCain's advanced age and clever puns concerning Reverend Wright's last name. It's quite another to cackle on the record at a press conference. Not only does she laugh, she laughs heartily, shamelessly, dare I say, spectacularly. Now I know that Hillary's supporters will argue that a laugh is just a laugh, but not in Hillary's esophagus it's not. Hillary is a smart, experienced politician. That laugh has been polled-tested, focused-grouped, and strategized. She knows exactly what she's doing. I hate to invoke racial stereotypes, but we all know that black people and white people laugh differently. It has something to to with divergent evolution of the diaphragm. Hillary laughs like a white person. Have you ever heard Obama laugh like that? Or Louis Farrakhan? By laughing in this manner, Hillary is obviously once again exploiting racial divisions for her benefit. I'm not saying that she's a racist. She's just a typical white laugher. In the interest of party unity and all that is still holy in the world, I call on her to reject and denounce her laugh and to demand its resignation for her campaign.


Comments (62)

avatar

Would you settle for her just demoting her laugh?

When will we put a stop to this divisiveness? Things are either funny or they aren't and Ms. Clinton is clearly trying to triangulate once again. She appeals to our basest instinct each time she laughs, and it's unconscionable to defend such laughter.

Did you know Rush Limbaugh is urging his listeners to laugh? Sean Hannity even laughed today on his show.

Ms. Clinton, stop the laughs!

TPM mocks the mainstream press, but forgets its own Rudy Giggliani clip.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35s17704Qsw

avatar

Well, there you have it. The answer to that old quandry: "I don't know whether to laugh or cry."

Crying, as we all know, amounts to gender-based manipulation. And laughter, as Genghis points out, is plainly racially divisive. So the answer, of course, is to do neither.

The safest course for Hillary is to display no emotion whatsoever. After all, what can her critics possibly say to that - accuse her of being cold, aloof, and unfeeling?

Some rare but incisive snark from fotw. I like it.

avatar

As laughter is the best medicine, Hillary is only practicing preventative care by doling out her chuckles across the nation. It may seem like excess at times but someone has to cover the millions of uninsured Americans.

Hillary 08--Health Insurance Is A Laughing Matter

She may be laughing on the outside, but she's crying on the inside. Crying over health care. Over the war. And over the environment. Just like that Italian guy who pretended to be a Native American. Except that he was crying on the outside.

Can't her laughter just "step down" from her campaign? Maybe serve as a Girlish Giggle from now on but not really leave for good? The giggle would not have a key role, of course, but it could still have an important role, no?

She must denounce, renounce, reject, and repudiate her sense of humor.

Serious social scientists suggest (hey, accidental alliteration {and again, all right!}) that laughter began as an attack, hooting derisively at the top male in primate troops.

Nyuk, nyuk.

I would type ROFLMAO, but then you must denounce, renounce, reject and repudiate me.

Unfortunately, some of the accusations made against Clinton are so bizarre that I had to wonder - is it satire or is it not? There are Obamaniacs here that would write this in all seriousness.

Still, thanks for the painfully funny post.

Oregon, I apologize if my post caused you any pain. It is permissible to write LOL, but only if you have actually laughed out loud. Similarly, it is also permissible to write ROFLMAO, but only if you are actually rolling on the floor and your ass is falling off.

ROFL

ooowwww ouch! Oh crrrap.

Now what. Anyone have any super glue?

er, I meant, ROFLMAO, it's painful, if yoou must know....

Much safer, tastes like chocolate jammed with peanuts and covered in caramel.


Intrigued by your suggestion that Hillary's laughter is White, I tried to get an interview with Reverend Wright, to determine whether he felt you were wrong or right.

The Reverend could not be reached, so I took it to the streets, and found a Right Reverend Write (he's a part-time poet) in Greenwich Village who told me that he felt not only was Hillary's laughter racist but that ALL laughter is evil and should be denounced. His exact words: "God DAMN laughter!".

So then I tried to get an interview with Obama, but was told he was on the phone with his next endorsing (soon to be announced) Super Delegate and could he take my number. While waiting for his callback, I took the question back to the streets and found a number of people who couldn't tell me what Obama might be thinking but maybe I should go and ask someone named Yo Mama.

I went back home and wiki'd Yo Mama and was directed to the website of Yo-Yo Ma. So I tried to reach Yo-Yo Ma but was told that he was performing on stage and I could try him later.

I then tried to reach Bill Clinton but was told he could not be reached because he had taken it to the streets and was currently standing outside a liquor store in Philadelphia, asking for 5 dollar donations to his wife's campaign. I hear he'll even except quarters.

Tomorrow, I will continue my efforts and, once I get a real interview with a real politician, I will come back and report.

Meantime, I think out of respect to Hillary, Josh should ban laughter here at TPM by deleting the username and profile of anyone who LOL's.

L

O

L

(spaced to deceive Josh's ban-bots)

Hillary doesn't ROFL, let alone ROFLMAO. She does, however, very ocassionally GFBFMDHB.

She refuses to reveal, however, what that means.

er, that was {snicker}

Oh hell.

I'll try beer instead.

I'm no supporter of Hillary, but this laugh thing doesn't seem funny at all. It would be if you added "up-tight" white woman.

Thank you, Maria. It's impossible to edit posts, but I will take your suggestion under consideration the next time I post this. I'm sure the addition will push the post over the edge into funniness.

(For the record, I'm no supporter of Hillary either, but she is not the target of this particular snark.)

You should hear my imitation of her laugh in Spanish. Gets a big chuckle among us Latinobamites.

¡Pues anda que no tiene que ser gracioso eso! Ya me gustaría oírlo, ya...

Imagagite una gallina que fué a una escuela privada, y entonces se casó con un puerco....

LOL = RR (Reír Ruidosamente)

Imagínate una gallina....

RR:)

I reject and denounce the aggressive takeover of this thread by illegal Spanish-speaking trolls and call on Josh Marshall to erect a firewall to prevent illegals from infiltrating our sacred realm.

Use the right word in Spanish or pay the price !


TROLL= GNOMO

I am not afraid of your threats, gnomo. As soon as we finish off Iraq, we'll take over all the Spanish speaking countries and make them speak proper English (which will certainly solve the problem of Spanish-speaking illegals).

Last I looked, gringo (how do you do that italics thing?) out here in California and Oregon, we've already circled your puny wagon trains and are already stealing the horses.

I knew it!!!!! Alert the Feds. Alert the Rush Limbaugh. Run for your lives. The Spanish gnomos are invading.

I would tell you how to do italics, but then I would be guilty of exporting sensitive technology to the enemy.

You white people are always trying to keep us from using your capitalist tools. But my boy Chavez is going bring all your cars to a stop, and then you will have to use those wagons.

No, not Chavez. Anyone but Chavez. Here's the secret to italics:

<strike>use these brackets</strike>

Thanks. I was just about to burn my driver's license and social security card, but then I'd just have to buy them again. We not know webstuff, but Kinkos in Spanish is Kinkos.

Donner ! I know we meet at the Eugene Obama Center. But you are not Hispanic. Let's not fool with the real white people, OK. We need votes for Obama.

You mean it's back to the pass? I know I'm just an old white guy trying to fit in. I saw your Ask A Mexican post. Sorry about that. Nothing worse than trust fund babies.

Did you get your check from Obama for posting?

No, did you get yours? Should not we be doing something really helpful like canvassing today? This is fun, but not really getting any votes. The people on this site don't have a life. Not helping Obama, anyway.

Out the door. Don't make the gringos angry.

avatar

Dude, you need a vacation. If its come down to laughs good or bad....Wow.

Dude, you need a clue. Please sleep tight, and read it again in the morning.

avatar

Re-read. You still need a vacation if you thought that was 1. clever or 2. funny.

You say the sweetest things. I'll send you a postcard from Aruba.

avatar

You need to relax. Maybe it's just a nervous laugh.

If she was as poll tested as you think, don't you think they would have figured out that the softer more human side gets her big points? As in the tearing up and the one time she was positive with Obama near the end of a debate?

Or is it just that hard for her to conjure . . . . even if they know it helps her she can only rarely pull it off . . . .

Swing and a miss! Strike two. Anyone else?

avatar

When did humor die in America?


8-)

There's much debate about that in academic circles. Personally, I blame Family Circus.

Just like Hitler! (I'm testing this one out).

I don't get it. (So much for that trial balloon.)

avatar

"Why is the media always focusing on how I laugh. Why do they never point out when Senator Obama chuckles. For far too long woman have struggled to break through The Laugh Ceiling. It is time for women to laugh off their male chauvinist shackles. Laugh Women, Laught. A rising chuckle lifts all Vaginas!"

I am Hillary Feigned Giggles Clinton,

and I titteringly approve of this message.

The difference in this laugh (as opposed to the other times she laughed inappropriately) is that this time it was completely psychotic. Watch her as she seriously listens to the question, brow furrowed until the question is completed. You can tell from the facial expression she is in no laughing mood. Then, like a schizophrenic, she breaks into this deranged laughter, complete with a nonsensical statement "angels on the head of a pin"?

Hillary dear, there are wonderful medications and therapists out there. Please, for your own good, step away from the podium. These nice gentlemen in the white coats would like to escort you somewhere where you can get some rest.

mageduley, you are a bold soul. I had considered suggesting that she be institutionalized for laughing, but I was concerned that people would consider the proposal too radical. But if one considers the range of emotion that she has shown on the campaign trail--laughing, tearing, and occasionally neither laughing nor tearing--you make a strong case.

Thanks Genghis,

I heartily believe that purposefully displaying a multiple personality disorder as an asset when running for president, represents a serious disconnect from reality. Unless of course, she was just listening to Mark Penn, who is always chock full of "scathingly brilliant ideas".

Here is the link (I didn't see it posted)
http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/04/11/clinton-laughs-off-colombia-questions/

Back in the day, I think people were a tad more sophisticated about how anything could be made to sound insane if looped correctly.

I'm thinking Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd. The maniacal laughter in the soundtrack eventually sounds normal, and that was the point.

It's fun to make fun of people, but really, I'd much rather make fun of their looks.

Say, Obama's ears, or Hillary's pants suits.

True workerbee. But in this instance, there is no looping involved. You can watch it straight through, from the question to the answer. You are not the least bit unsettled by this? It makes me queasy to think this person might have the the chance to be poised over the red button in the oval office at 3 am.

What's wrong with Obama's ears? Too African-American? Don't think that I'm missing the racist subtext. And speaking of pantsuits. That's another example of calculated race exploitation. Have you ever seen Obama or Farrakhan in a pantsuit? I call on Clinton to reject and denounce her pantsuits and demand their resignation from her campaign.

avatar

Well yes actually, I have seen Farrakhan in a pantsuit. However, since his entourage all laughed their arses off at the sight of an old white man dressed in a pantsuit, I have never worn it since.

Senator Obama's ears are very retro. Should appeal to Bing Crosby fans.

avatar

Perhaps Hillary meant Angels on the head of her Mark Penn!. She sure seems to think that he is divinely inspired.

Maria-

Don't disrespect my wagon trains. And have you ever heard about
my friends the "donner party" up there in the pass?

Get it Ghengis? Go out and canvass for real. You can't "work" for Obama on TPM. Seriously.

Next weekend. Philly or bust.

You are a very smart and talented guy. You know all kinds of things important to political work on the web. Whatever you do for a living, you should be on a real political payroll working with ideas and connecting to people. Too bad the folks that really give out the money don't find you and hire you. Perhaps they do. And are looking for the chance.

second that idea....

if we only could find him....

Wow. Thank you. I would love to be able to do this for a living, but I don't think it's easy. I'm considering starting a blog with some friends. We'll see. (But if anyone's hiring ;) you can reach me at http://my.barackobama.com/page/dashboard/public/gGnyqX Screen name Genghis of course.)

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address