Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

It Only Gets Worse!

Statistics are already being released showing a MAJORITY of our troops are suffering from PTSD.  But, like a lot of us who served in Vietnam, they hold it inside because of the stigma attached with seeking treatment.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20080430/ts_afp/ushealthmilitary

My work on the subject of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder is in its second year now.  I've interviewed, exchanged email and had communication with hundreds of fellow vets.  A common response has been:  "I held it inside because I didn't want to be branded "insane."  So many suffered for so long.  Some for over 30 years. 

I finally sought treatment at a veterans center a couple of years ago.  It's still difficult to admit the problem.  I've always known deep inside that I had issues with what I saw and did in Vietnam.  I have learned through my conversations with other vets that Corpsmen and Medics tend to have "special" conflicts and damage because of the unique perspective of a "non-combatant."

We are, as a rule, "healers."  The violence and bloodiness of combat goes against the very nature of people who want to stop just those two things.  So, there is the trauma of combat multiplied by the stress of trying to overcome its consequences multiplied by the psychological pressure of wondering if you did enough or if you could have done more or if your training was sufficient for the job you were trying to accomplish.

I talked to another Vietnam Corpsman who participated in a "Corpsman Only" group at his vet center.  He said it helped him more than anything he'd ever done.

I haven't been in such a group but I can understand how it would be good therapy because the key to coming out of the dark cave in which PTSD sufferers dwell, is to finally find someone to talk to about what's in there with us.

But how can you talk to anyone about such things?  In the mind of every victim of PTSD is the thought that he or she is somehow alone in the world.  Nobody "understands."

In a way that's valid because each case is unique.  But I have found that there are common threads and those can be the "twigs" to which the falling victim clings to avoid plunging into the precipice.

There will be decades of consequences to pay for the acts of this arrogant and incompetent leadership.  The PTSD "monster" will leave other victims in its path of devastation for generations.

Nobody can turn back the clock.  Nobody can retroactively grant wisdom or competence to Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld and the rest.  Nobody can give peace back to the minds of these brave Americans who will suffer for years.  Nobody can give back the lives to over 4,000 who have sacrificed all.

There are those, and one in particular who will probably respond to this blog, who call those of us with PTSD cowards.  Cowardice is what kept Cheney from serving.  Cowardice is what kept "Georgie" out of Vietnam.  Cowardice is what has kept our representatives in Congress from standing up to these monsters for all these years.  But cowardice is NOT something which should EVER be attributed to a PTSD victim who served honorably and bravely.  PTSD is REALITY for too many because of policies which were made by cowards.

My advice to returning vets:  Seek help.  Take advantage of the VA's treatment centers.  Don't be afraid to admit you're suffering.  Don't do what I did and let your best years fester away when they could have been so productive. 

I assure you this:  YOU ARE NOT CRAZY.  You DO need help.  Listen to that voice deep in your soul that wants help not the one telling you that if you go for help, you're just admitting you're weak.

Weakness and PTSD are linked ONLY by those who suffer PTSD.  Those who treat and understand it best know that it takes more strength to reach out and try to regain that grip on reality lost during combat.

I may not be able to help personally but ANYONE who is suffering and reading this can feel free to contact me.  I don't hide behind funny screen names or phony "patriotic" tags.  If conversation will help, I'm here.  If more is needed, I can put you in touch with experts who know enough to help. 

Whatever you do.  Don't hide in the cave for 40 years like I did.  It's a giant waste of your talent and intelligence.  Semper Fi and good luck!


Comments (25)

Highly recommended.

Bad enough to have to either remember or try to forget, but when the war in question is dubious (or obviously stupid) it can only make it harder.

My father, a preacher, is a Vietnam vet. All of a sudden in the past year, he's been having...problems. At first they thought it stemmed from his stroke from 5 years ago. He's finally been diagnosed with PTSD. All these years of people telling him that he mostly likely has PTSD. He pushed it aside but his paranoia, among other things, was getting really, really bad. Now that he's getting help, his a much different person. All the battles everyone has had with him, are gone for the most part. From what I hear, everyone's pretty much relieved at this point.

The events of this administration's actions and this horrible war have brought back a lot of PTSD to Vietnam vets. Your Dad is not alone. I'm glad he's found some help. Tell him I said "Thanks for his service!"

Great post, Chuck. Both LBJ & Bush should have been impeached, convicted, removed from office and jailed as war criminals.

Tom

For the record, LBJ inherited Vietnam from JFK. And while his handling of it was poor, he had the best and brightest of that previous administration pushing it to the blundering tragedy that it was... only to have Nixon continue it.

By all indications, LBJ couldn't care about foreign policy at all - he wanted to take the New Deal to the next level. And as soon as he had the chance in the White House, that is exactly what he did.

If not for the guns, he would today be lauded as one of the greatest presidents for the butter.

... but LBJ is the one who conned the country about the Gulf of Tonkin incident the same way that W conned the country about Saddam's nonexistent WMD.

LBJ was human - as Senator Clinton famously noted, he was instrumental in getting the Civil Rights act of 1964 passed, and he can rightly take credit for the Great Society programs. He also inherited and then vastly escalated our military presence in Vietnam, and also rightly deserves much of the blame for that.

Some of this is linked to "big boys don't cry".

Also, it should be obvious that in the US, except if you are in the arts, the idea of going to a therapist is essentially career suicide (if it gets out).

But why should mental health be any different in this country than bodily health? We aren't into taking care of ourselves in most ways.

Thank you for this post on an important aspect of a brutal war that is increasingly ignored by the media.

I suspect non-military personnel and contractors are also returning a bit traumatized, and that the problem is a bit more widespread than believed.

I find that a very astute observation, AdAbsurdhum. From my own experience in VN (US Army Real Estate, Ist Log) I would say quite a few contractors, who were on the graft and corruption ground floor associated with many contracts, are likely to suffer some kind of psychological blowback. I used to call it the "Milo Minderbinder syndrome" - but now it's the "Haliburton complex." Oh, the stories I could tell...

Chuck,

Thanks for sharing your story and the TRUTH behind the statistics. I applaud your courage! It touched me deeply. I can relate to EACH AND EVERY WORD.

I implore anyone suffering from PTSD and to their loved ones to follow your advice and seek treatment. Don't give up, don't sweep it under the carpet. There is help available. There is no shame!!!

Thank you for your service Chuck and welcome home!
Semper Fi

avatar

Thank you for this post. Excellent.

Hey Chuck, thanks for taking time out of your work to remind folks about this.

My mom was an RN in the PTSD Clinic in Menlo Park. The program does help many, but as you say it really needs to be expanded. One thing they are trying to do now that they didn't do in Vietnam, is keeping the units together when they come back. Having that time together apparently helps a lot. Another thing that is good is that they are recognizing PTSD as a problem NOW, rather than denying it for 15 years, so some small progress has been made.

Not enough though, not by a long shot.

Thanks for all you do.

Arrrgh.

To clarify, she worked in the PTSD Program. "Clinic" implies that vets can just walk in off the street and enter, not so. At least when she was there, you have to sign up for the program and it lasts several weeks. Maybe if there were "Clinics" and vets could just walk in, it would be an improvement.

:(

One thing the VA really needs to work on is the glut of paperwork required for these folks to get the help they need.

avatar

Thank you for your service, Chuck, and thank you for your post. You're brave and wise to bring up this topic, and it serves to help a lot of soldiers in need.

Semper Fi and keep up the good, hard work...

Chuck,

Thank you from the bottom of my heart - I think I love you. Your quote:

"I held it inside because I didn't want to be branded "insane." So many suffered for so long. Some for over 30 years.

My significant other's favorite phrase is "I'm sure a shrink would love to get into my head." After two volunteer tours in Vietnam as a Marine we are still dealing with the fact that there is ZERO discussion. Every time I see the statistics of the men and women serving us now I just cry. This will be years of pain for them and all the people who love them. And, as you know, no matter how strange it may seem you do not give up on people you love when you see the influence in their mind being so clearly no "from" them. PTSD is the gift that just keeps giving. Maybe someday I can get him to read your post. I keep searching for ways to make therapy sound attractive.

He's lucky to have you. Thank you for your comment. If he was wounded near Danang in '67/'68, I may have worked on him. I was at the hospital there in the Receiving Unit.

Tell him I said thanks for his service and I hope he does let someone inside his head. I know from experience it only gets worse if he doesn't.

Not to mention female personell coming back with not only PTSD but trauma from sexual abuse, rape, etc... This may turn out even worse than Vietnam did in terms of mental health.

I predict it will be MUCH worse than Vietnam in the suffering of these vets. The military and VA are doing better jobs of admitting the problem and a little better job of treatment, but so many are swept under the national carpet when they return. It WILL haunt this country for decades unless the powers in D.C. open their eyes and ears.

My sister is a Psychiatric Social Worker who works at a State run Mental Health Facility.
They have been told to be aware of the clients who have come back from the war and the fact that MANY of the returning female troops have been raped!
What can you say to that?

PTSD is not unique to combat. Rape victims suffer one of the most brutal and life-altering crimes known to man.

Hey Chuck,
Keep your voice out there. It is voices like yours that tell the story of the war the administration does not want us to hear.
You are quite clearly a great man. I thank you for all you've done and are doing for our country.


As an aside, these stories, and the suicide numbers that the VA has been hiding, and stories about lack of supplies or health care or education make me sick with our government. Any suggestions on what we can do personally?

I wish I knew what to do. I've been screaming against this "hurricane of EVIL" since it began. All we can do is keep screaming. It's too late to impeach but Bush/Cheney, et. al. belong in prison for war crimes.

The future PTSD tragedy in this country is inevitable because of what this administration has done. Nothing can stop that.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address