Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

A Debate Worth Watching

avatar

Hillary Clinton asks Barack Obama, "why won't you debate me?" She wants a debate, and to get one she's even proposing to shake up the format quite a bit. No moderators, just timed statements and rebuttals.

To be honest, I'm sick of these debates. Points aren't scored on substance. They're about faltering, waffling, gotcha moments, and crowbaring in zingers written by comittees of humorless assholes.

I propose a completely new debate format that might actually be interesting to watch. Let's have a debate without the nominees. Let's do this like debate club. Invite two figures skilled in debate to stand in for the candidates and argue for or against. To be fair, halfway through the debate, the debaters can be made to switch which candidate they are arguing for. I suggest Al Franken and Christopher Hitchens. That match up will be fun and entertaining. Al Franken would jump at a chance to get his face on national television to promote his bid for the senate, and Christopher Hitchens would leap at the chance to highlight his personal opposition to the policies of both candidates. Hitchens may be an asshat, but he's a very skilled debater, as is Franken. Franken can be witty and sharp without being a prick.  Hitchens is a walking encyclopedia of facts and historical context, capable of making compelling arguments that cut to the bone.

What do you say? Should we make this happen?


Comments (6)

avatar

"Let's have a debate without the nominees." I meant without the candidates. Clinton/Obama not Democrat/McCain.

I nominate Gotalife vs. Potus Obama 2008. The best part would be watching them attempt to switch sides and betting on whose head would explode first.

I like where your heads at. Let's have a TPM face-off with the most 'ardent' of supporters on each side. It could be brilliant.

avatar

He won't debate her L/D cause he is a chicken shit. Come on now. If your challenged to an L/D you gotta show. Geek rules are in play here. Nobody but nobody that has ever debated would chicken out of a L/D if they weren't scared to be whipped.

avatar

I want to commend your boldness. The bulk of the post was about the tiredness of the debates and whether it would be more interesting to see figures like Franken and Hitchens stand in for the candidates, free to say what they want because their quotes can't be attributed to the candidates themselves. You chose to stick to a tangential subject briefly mentioned in the first paragraph. Kudos.

avatar

hey, thanks. I always appreciate people that agree with me. Peace

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


July 21-25

Bill Bishop The Big Sort

July 28-August 1

Book Cover

August 4-9

Book Cover

August 11-15

James Galbraith The Predator State

August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address