Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Time for a nap kiddies

avatar

Very early on children learn cause and effect. Toddlers don't regularly walk into walls do they? However, abstract cause and effect situations are something that little kids don't really grasp.

I've seen much hand-wringing, gnashing of teeth, and rending of clothes over some of what Rev. Wright said about America and 9/11.
 

Clearly this behavior is from people who are mentally immature. What Rev. Wright was describing when he was talking about 9/11 is commonly referred to as "blowback" (and our refusal or inability to understand it).


When mentioned in this context blowback refers to the unintended consequences of our foreign policy aka "messing with other countries".

After 9/11 there were two reactions. The children freaked out and said that we were attacked because of our freedom. The adults examined what happened, who did it, how they got into a position to do such a thing, and why it was done. For years the children, who had been dictating our foreign policy without an understanding of "blowback", won out and we refused to address 9/11 as adults.

If we had we would have come to an understanding that "they" don't hate us for our freedom. They hate our foreign policy because it is harmful to people around the world and it's obstructing their goals (seeking more power). Had we come to that understanding. Had we allowed the adults to take over we would never have invaded Iraq. We would never be playing chicken with Iran, Russia, North Korea, etc..

But we didn't. We let the children run the show. Now we're letting the children run the show again. Instead of talking about blowback, we're talking about someone being Anti-American for talking about blowback.

It's time for the adults to put the children to bed until November (or longer).

So, whenever you see a child freaking out about things that are too adult for their minds to handle (9/11, civil rights, imperialism), put them in bed, read them a story, give them a kiss on the cheek, and turn off the light as you leave the room.


Comments (3)

The title is a sign!

I am going to nap right now!!

avatar

"But we didn't. We let the children run the show. Now we're letting the children run the show again. Instead of talking about blowback, we're talking about someone being Anti-American for talking about blowback."

The thing Democrats never seem to "get" is that the term "anti-American" has a double meaning. And that is simply because the word "American" has a double meaning.

For most people, the word simply refers to people who live in the United States, which is reasonable enough. For the rest, it refers only to White Anglo-Saxon Protestants, and then only to those that vote Republican. Attacking this group is anti-American, while attacking other people who live in the country is not.

This is why it was okay for Falwell and Robertson to blame feminists and gays for the Trade Centre bombing while Bill Maher got fired for suggesting government (Republican) policy had anything to do with it. Maher's statement was anti-American and Falwell's, while it might have been "regrettable", was not.

Let's be clear on this: Wright's heresy is not that he attacked Americans in general, but that he attacked white Americans, and white Republican Americans in particular.

Democrats will never take back the political centre until they deal with this. It is the most important weapon the Republicans have over them. And they are not going to do that - ever - until they learn to defend people like Wright when it is appropriate.

Is Wright correct about the things he's said over the years? Well, sometimes. He's wrong about AIDS being deliberately inflicted on black people, but he isn't exactly wrong to claim that the prison system is a tool to keep black men from excelling financially. The numbers speak for themselves on that issue, and if the situation wasn't deliberately contrived, why don't politicians seem more interested in fixing it?

The Democrats can throw the ball back in the Republicans' court by supporting Wright and saying "WE are willing to fix the problem, you (Republicans) are not." Instead they habitually throw people like Wright under the bus (exactly as they did to Media Matters, over the General Betrayus ad) for daring to criticize "Americans", which is to say "Republicans". The Democrats cannot expect to win anything of importance until they break this habit, regardless of who they choose as their nominee.

The mistake Democrats keep making is to search for the most "electable" candidate under the rules the Republicans have laid out for them, instead of changing the rules to make elections easier to win for Democrats. This is the real basis of the Obama Revolution (really the Dean Revolution), not electing a black man or grabbing a few swing states. Democrats have internalized the eleventh commandment - "Thou shalt not criticize Republicans" - and the Republicans laugh all the way to the bank. They need to stop doing this, pronto, or defeating McCain in November will not ultimately make a bit of a difference.

avatar

"(exactly as they did to Media Matters, over the General Betrayus ad)"

Sorry, folks. I meant Moveon.org, of course. Media Matters got stuck in my head for some reason. :o)

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address