Reader Posts
« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
The Founding Fathers would be ashamed
This might just be the last blog I write about politics in America. I have written about Obama being the American Mandela, the burden of the hope he brings, and the man he is in his own right. But I don’t know anymore. I still believe in Obama, but I just don’t believe in American politics anymore. If this is how they want to play politics in America then I don’t want to play anymore. This is too sick. This is nothing to be proud of. My fleeting experience has made me question this thing they call American politics in an American democracy. Yes, they won - the cynics and morally corrupt. All of them - left, right and centre. This isn’t fun anymore. I don’t mind the comments on my blog. I have a thick skin. But if this election is what politics is all about in the US, then I don’t know if I have the stomach for it. This is just not right guys. This is not what people fought for and died for.
This is not the America I got to know and love over the last 18 months. This is not the people I have met. And I hope to God that this isn’t a reflection of how people outside the US see America. But they do. Because it goes out to everyone out there. You might not care. But I do. And so should you. Because when your President says he wants to bring democracy to people everywhere… this is what they see. And I can assure you. This is not something you want to export.
I just can’t believe that this is what politics has come to. What democracy has come to. I don’t agree with President Clinton and other politicians on the left, right and centre when they say, “That’s just politics“. No. That’s how you made politics. That’s the direction you have taken politics. You are the leaders of this great nation. And you should be ashamed of yourself. You should be ashamed in turning this great democracy into the laughing stock of the world. And you should be ashamed of not inspiring people to participate anymore. You are the reason for democracy failing in the US.
But it is not just the politicians. It’s the media. Slurping up everything that the politicians say. Or trying to spew hatred about every politician they don’t agree with. They don’t question policies. They don’t look into the future these political promises. No. They spew hatred about the mis(character) of potential leaders whether it is true or not. Or whether it is relevant or not. You should be ashamed of yourself. I thought you were here to inform people and be the guardians of this great democracy. But no. You don’t. You spew hatred and take no responsibility. You just sit back and laugh at the people - all the way to the bank.
It is no wonder people don’t want to vote. It is no wonder that young people feel that it is not worth it. They are still young enough to believe that politics should be about leadership, honor and truth. But they look up at “their” political leaders and all they smell is the foul smell of corrupt souls. People with vested interests. A city of sin where lobbyist outnumber politicians. And the lies they tell and the stories they spin. You should be ashamed of yourself for lying to the people of America. And especially for making the young people lose hope even before they truly start off in life. You cynics and liers are making cynics of those with hope in their hearts. You make the young people old before they should. You make them lose their hope and love for America. You kill the American Dream little bit bit little lie. You should be ashamed.
I can’t believe the character assassination taking place. Whether it is an attack on Hillary because she is married to Bill and stuck with him because of his sleeping around. Or McCain because he changes his opinion on issues the way we all do all of the time. Or Obama because a black man spoke from the heart about race and you attack him as racist. Look in the mirror and ask yourself who would be a leader that you can respect and look up to. Can you live with any of these three if you kill their character like this? When you show no respect - can you expect any back? You should be ashamed of yourself.
And to Hillary and Mac and Obama. You should be ashamed of yourselves. I know you try to be honorable. But you are not trying hard enough. You should act like the leader people need and not just the leaders they want. You should be clear and direct with any of your supporters or those who work for you when they attack the character of the other. Whether it is a twitter message (McCain), or racist (Hillary), or monsters (Obama). Be the leader people need. Because it has never been more important than now. People are losing hope. Losing hope in American politics. And you are not helping.
And to the Republicans and Democrats. To the left and the right. Be ashamed of yourself. You talk more about how you are different. Why you hate the other side - because they are gay, pro or anti abortion, because they are for or against immigration, because they are godless or too godly, because they are pro or anti big business, because they are pro or anti war. But you never talk about what makes this country great. You never talk about what makes you American. What makes you one. You just try and carve your little niche of hatred. And you know what? It just gives your enemies more reasons to hate you - because you are telling them everything that is wrong about America. Instead of telling them what is great about America. You should be ashamed of yourself.
I have seen corrupt leaders. Morally corrupt leaders. I come from South Africa and lived under Apartheid. And I have seen the hatred that politicians and their followers can create. And you are walking a fine line here. I see so many PW Botha’s walking around parading as politicians here in America. And I see the Dutch Reformed Church in many places of worship. And Die Burger in so many newspapers and televisions. But I have also seen great leaders. I have seen Mandela who we all know well. But I have seen leaders I don’t agree with who brought greatness to themselves. FW De Klerk. I didn’t like him, but he showed his greatness as a leader by making the difficult choices “his people” didn’t want to take. I don’t like McCain or Hillary - but they can show greatness without my support. It is up to them. They make the choice.
I have been here for 18 months. And I got to love this country called America. It was nothing like I expected. The people are great, great people. Warm, open and friendly. And hardworking. More than you can imagine. I see them behind the tills and at the gas stations. Those are the people who make you great. Those people who will fight your wars not because they believe in the war, but because that is what America does when one is hurt - they all stand up. These people who sweat blood and tears every single day to pay the mortgage and give their kids a chance in life. These are the people you lie to every day. It has not been the America I read about in books or seen in the movies. I have seen why this country is so great. Why you can be proud to be American. And you should be ashamed for not liking them and for lying to them.
But when it comes to politics I am not so sure. There is just too much hatred. This is the worse case of democracy I have seen anywhere. This is not how you convince the world that democracy works. This is the ugly underbelly of America. The moral corruption of democracy but the sick and twisted who wants to win above anything else. And the people I speak to in the streets and the shops don’t like what they see or what they hear. And the lies create so much white noise that they don’t know what to believe in anymore. They thought they saw greatness and then it was taken away from them by hate-speech and lies. You should be ashamed of yourself.
You set the example for all Americans. You want to know why they take drugs in baseball and football? Ask youself what kind of message you send when you tell people that everything goes as long as you win. You can lie and you can steal. As long as you win. What are you telling those who grow up? And those who should entertain us with pride in sport? You should be ashamed of yourself. You are corrupting America every single day.
But most of all, you should hang your head in shame for what you have done to the Founding Fathers of this great nation. They have sacrificed and fought for your freedom. They were not perfect. But they were honest. And they fought an honest fight. They gave you everything. And you spit in their face with your lies and twisted speech. Look in the mirror and ask yourself what they would think of you. What would they say if they saw what you do and what you say? And what you think. You should be ashamed for belittling what they fought for and died for. Thank God that you were never asked to sign the Declaration of Independence. Thank God you were not one of those Founding Fathers. Because America would not be if it was for you. Hang your head in shame. Your founding father and everyone who have died for America and lived for America will be ashamed of you. You do not “hold up”. You should be ashamed for even calling yourself American. You put this country to shame. Shame on you. You don’t deserve greatness because you don’t know what it means.
———————————
I won’t be writing about American politics anymore. I will write about my life and my experiences. And I will write about what bugs me. I will write about anything and everything that comes to mind. But not about American politics anymore. You know I support Obama. But I don’t think America is ready for Obama. And sadly, I don’t think America deserves Obama. Not those Americans who play these games. They will drag him down the way they have dragged me down. And the America I know is greater than that. Should be better than that.
I am busy reading The Audacity of Hope. And sorry. I just don’t have that audacity… or that hope. He is a better and a bigger man than me. I just hope to God I am wrong and he is right. But I don’t know. I just don’t know.
Tomorrow is another day. And I will still be proud of living in this country. When I see those people working behind the counters and in the factories. Those good to honest hard-working Americans who have shown me their love and affection. Those Americans I have come to love. I just don’t want anything to do with American politics anymore. That is just not American anymore.










Comments (5)
Yeah, American politics is looking pretty bad right now.
But hold on, and be of good hope. I think we're going to have a President Obama in 2009. And he might raise the tone a bit.
March 25, 2008 6:05 PM | Reply | Permalink
I can empathize, as I was right there two weeks ago... but, with all due respect, I'd urge you to lift your chin up.
There are all sorts of factors that justify feeling down about the state of politics at the moment, and they don't have to revolve around your feelings about the two candidates on the Democratic side who continue to battle it out.
The 24-hour media is eager for a new headline every four hours, and feasts on weekly controversies to enable its talking heads to blather on about things they remember from their campaigns gone by and to enable campaign surrogates to put their feet in their mouth on a bi-weekly basis, thus restarting the cycle of headlines & controversies and propping up their ratings. I know there are substantial similarities in the candidates' positions on the actual issues that should be the fodder for debate in the country, but that doesn't absolve the media from exploring those differences that do exist, and reporting, instead of bloviating and creating spectacle.
Then there are the Swift Boat Poseurs for Fraud, and the "clean-coal" industry (sponsors of all CNN debates who ensure that no substantive debate about global warming and our need to stop burning coal actually occurs during those debates), and other special interests forming PACs and 527s that we haven't even heard of yet that will denigrate and vilify and attack and dredge up otherwise meaningless quotes and factoids about candidates and distort them and use drudge and fox to inject said distortions into the "debate" on the campaign until everything is just a big, expensive, filthy, muddy, clusterf*&^%k that doesn't resemble at all what we've come to hope would comprise this common enterprise we call 'democracy'.
But, that's just it.
We have to keep our heads up and fight through because not persevering is a declaration of defeat.
Adams and Jefferson and Madison and Hamilton and the like didn't have the same romantic impressions of each other that we have 200+ years hence. There was some truly vitriolic filth spewed between them, and on their behalf by the multitude of partisan and highly political pamphleteers, back in the day, and I would say that it may actually have been more personal and harder to stomach than the stuff we're seeing now.
But, their convictions and ideals carried them through any squeamish moments with courage and purpose, and I would argue that we who hope to carry on their traditions in this great experiment we call America must batten down the hatches, put on a fresh pot of coffee, take a couple of minutes to stretch and then jump right back into the fray.
Based on your tome above, I feel it is safe to assume your disappointment stretches from the sense of a loss of hope, but I am here to remind you that while it may seem that your hope was held just by you, in a singular sense, in fact, it is something that lives and breathes in the collective hearts and minds of all who would consider themselves Democrats.
We may feel down and dispirited at times, but given a good pat on the back and a smile, it should be easy to recognize that we will not be 'defeated' quite so easily.
Make no mistake; it is likely to get worse 'out there', especially as the general election comes around.
But rest assured that the everlasting hope of an America that prides itself on the democratic dreams and ideals of its citizenry will not, indeed, cannot, die a premature death at the hands of the foolish crap that gets thrown about during election season and that may temporarily overcome one's sense of hope. This is, after all, one of the things we are working to change! We cannot assume it will simply go away, and it will take many of us with commitment and a sense of common purpose to doggedly root out falsehoods and baseless attacks and slanted coverage and all the rest until it is revealed for the filth that it is.
So let us not begin with the premature autopsies of hope just yet. How about we roll up our sleeves, knock on some doors, make some phone calls, write some LTEs (hell, pen your own op-ed!), and organize our communities based on the principles we hold dear.
and remember, when you or I feel down, someone will remind us that we can, in fact, accomplish great things, and overcome seemingly insurmountable obstacles, if we stick together, keep our heads held high, and work our asses off...
yes.
we can.
March 25, 2008 6:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
Dont be deterred, Change is hard and the forces of entrenched power are awesome. Dont get discouraged, Obama has a lot of support and can be a uniting force. I am a46 year old white jewish male from Davie , Florida. I supported all of the Dems ( many with little enthusiasm) and have never been more excited than now.
Our time is now. yopu cant retreat , get discouraged or give up. Think about where this thing started and how politics as we know it has been changed by Obama. He has brought new people in and will continue to and raised more money from non lobbyists than anyone in American History.
Stay in the game , stay positive, think of all of the positives the candidacy has brought and will bring and the true colors being exposed of the people many of us may have once admired.
I know how you feal and I have been there during this campaign more than once, but I get stronger each day as the forces opposing change get stronger. ( I also stoped watching cable news shows) Thats why I started blogging and use my real name. Take care, Tom Abrams
March 25, 2008 6:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
This is the way American politics has always been. I'm looking at a page in a book "American Presidency" and they provide examples of candidates accusing each other of fathering illegimate children, selling out to business, questionable ethics, etc, etc, - all going back to the beginning of this country, except for the first three Presidents.
I spent several years in 5 different countries and my impression is that it's not that different anywhere.
I know it's not helpful to you, but this is a political process and most of the time politicians are not so hugely different from each other, especially when the majority of the voters are concerned.
March 25, 2008 6:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
"You know I support Obama. But I don’t think America is ready for Obama. And sadly, I don’t think America deserves Obama."
One of the things I admire in Obama is his hopefulness, his lack of cynicism.
I cringe at the ugliness and menace of US politics. But then I see him trying to make it better.
And I wonder, if he thinks we have a chance to change things, maybe we might?
So why not try? We have little to lose and everything to gain.
It's funny, I supported Obama when I believed he had little chance of winning. But I thought I would support him as a protest of the status quo. Sometimes you have to support a cause, win or lose, just to make the effort.
Anyway, those are my thoughts.
March 25, 2008 7:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment