Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Rethinking the "cult" of Obama

avatar

You've heard it, I'm sure, from your friends who support Hillary Clinton, and even from some of the most prominent figures of the mainstream media -- Joe Klein, Jake Tapper, David Brooks, etc. Supporters of Sen. Barack Obama are like a "cult" in their exuberant zeal for this "messianic" figure who promises little more than "hope" and "change." They're "creepy," they stage episodes of fainting, and they're getting ready to name their firstborn "Barack," regardless of gender.

As an Obama supporter, I took offense at these comments when they were first made, as I do now. I tend to view it as a reactionary response by old-media types who view politics through the lens of the campaigns they've covered in the past -- establishment candidates, and supporters who tend to be closer to 50 than 30. Now they see this new political figure with hoards of enthusiastic supporters who are wholly new to the process and they say to themselves: "This isn't how it's supposed to be."

But I've begun thinking about the word "cult" and its application to the 2008 Democratic primary, and it seems to me that if this silly slur is going to be bandied about, it should be directed at the campaign whose supporters act in the more cult-like manner – those of Sen. Clinton.

 

When I think “cult,” I think of an assemblage of people unified in their in slavish devotion to a single authority figure. Their devotion to this figure is such that it refuses to diminish or even waver, even when this figure acts in such a way that benefits themselves at the expense of their following, or is glaringly inconsistent in their rhetoric.

 

How then, can one not start to view some of Hillary’s die-hard supporters in a “cult”-like fashion, given that the Clinton campaign has adopted a strategy of securing the nomination by irreparably damaging the likely nominee, and thereby decreasing the chances that a Democrat will win the White House?

 

How can they not be viewed as cultish after regurgitating the Clinton campaign’s increasingly absurd exercises in Orwellian doublethink? “Obama is not ready to be commander-in-chief, but he’d be a fine VP!”; “We completely disagree with Ms. Ferraro’s unfortunate comments, but how dare Sen. Obama play the race card!”; “Momentum doesn’t matter, it’s all about delegates, which don’t matter because we’ve got the momentum, which is irrelevant because nobody can win without superdelegates, who should follow the will of the voters in their states but feel free to overturn the will of the people as express in elected delegates, which don’t matter.”

 

That’s not to say that the supporters of Sen. Clinton are a “cult” right and proper. But if you’re going to use the word, just be sure to use it in the way that’s the least wrong.


Comments (4)

they're getting ready to name their firstborn "Barack," regardless of gender


My wife and I joke that we are going to screw up our kids one way or another, might as well consciously pick a few and start a theraP fund.
I'd considered naming our next boy Barack (I probably won't because there are too many other koolaid drinkers that it may end up being a common name in the yet born generation) but hadn't as yet considered it for a girl's name.
hmmm ...

avatar

"cult" is just a smear word because the GOP and perhaps Clinton were jealous of all the enthusiastic volunteers in the Obama movement.

McCain sure wishes he had any sort of "cult" giving him lots of money, too.

Hillary does actually have a "cult" of hardcore followers who seem very fanatical.

But in democracy, I think , on the whole, enthusiastic participation is a good thing.

avatar

The Jones Cult...
I also see the Radical Islamists as a Cult.

Shoot when Clinton sent Janet Reno down to that little town to take care of David Koresh (he got in his pickup and drove to town almost every day and they had had him on surveillance for two years), all the men at the compound went to town to work as this place was way out in the country and not in Waco as the reporters report. But you have to remember, just two weeks into the Clinton Administration we had the first World Trade Center Bombing. Clinton's answer to getting tough was to send troops out there and put stadium lights on all those men and more women and children and play rock music night and day for three months they were there terrorising all these little children and their mothers. They could have picked up David Koresh in his car going to town and all the other men. That was just a big show to show how tough on Terrorists Bill Clinton and Janet Reno could be. They ended that after three months of terrorizing them by barbecuing them all.

Yet we worry about how we treat the real Terrorists that are sawing off our citizens heads with dull blades.

I'd say the Muslim Extremists are Cults. They certainly can't be following anything heavenly or God like.

And like I said. Mrs. Barak Obama was ashamed to be an American until she came into Reverend Jeremiah Wrights Godly ways. Then she began to love it under his guidance.

During Clinton and Gore's Administration a Resolution was passed in Congress to Oust Saddam Hussein from Iraq.

George W. Bush was sitting down in Texas just starting to play Governor when Congress passed that. That was their intent... it's nice now that they get to blame it on G.W.

Keep on listening to the facts....

You can't throw any of them out that are true, that's how intelligent decisions are made. They are not made by feelings.

avatar

Re your comment

When I think “cult,” I think of an assemblage of people unified in their in slavish devotion to a single authority figure. Their devotion to this figure is such that it refuses to diminish or even waver, even when this figure acts in such a way that benefits themselves at the expense of their following, or is glaringly inconsistent in their rhetoric.

That would be exactly what the followers of Allah are doing right now in Iraq, Afghanistan and oh yes, they have done it twice in New York City and once at the Pentagon and had aim on our White House all in the name of Allah.
They aer a Cult

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address