Reader Posts
« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
Let's Get Real About Hillary
When Hillary came in 3rd in Iowa, everyone counted her out immediately. Her speech that night was inspiring to say the least. She went on to win New Hampshire, but then to lose 11 states in a row. She never showed one iota of being tired or beaten. She became the underdog quickly, but came back to win two very important races, and she is now the front-runner nationally according to Gallup, 48% to Obama's 44%.
This is the difference between the two of them. Barack is showing his political immaturity by being knocked off his message and showing his fatigue. Imagine what the senior members of the House and Senate will do to him as president when they want to control him.
This is a good, brilliant man with not enough experience to play in the big leagues yet. It doesn't matter how much he is loved and respected...he has to know how to block the punches and move forward.
I've never been a lunatic over Hillary, and I get frustrated with her when she does or says something really stupid. But I do know one thing about her: She will lead with stamina and power, and make no mistake about it, she is a democrat. Everything she has stood for in her professional career is from the democratic perspective.
I truly believe that if Obama was not black, Hillary would be getting the African American vote, just as she is getting the Hispanic/Latino vote. Why? Because they have watched her work tirelessly on their behalf, and feel a sense of loyalty to her. But Obama is black, and a good man, and I don't blame AA's for backing him for that reason alone. But the fact remains the same. Hillary is good for the less fortunate, the oppressed, minorities, and for all democrats.
I am not a politician and have no way of knowing what works to win. Will she do anything to win? She'll definitely play the politics in the best way she knows how, and will take advice from the pros. People, the whole idea is to win. It's one thing to say "I will not go negative," but let me ask you something? Is it possible that if Gore had done everything he could to beat Bush in 2000 so that there was no chance of Bush stealing the election, that 4000 American soldiers would still be alive today? And who knows how many Iraqi citizens and children would still be alive today? I wish to hell he had gone negative on Bush and won because this country is in worse shape than when GHWB left it.
Despite Willy being slick, and despite the constant ongoing barrage of legal challenges thrown at him throughout the entire 8 years of his presidency, Bill Clinton left the office with the country in better condition than it had been in for decades. Hillary was there through it all, watching, learning, advising, working, and that's experience with the Presidency, even if she did not hold the title. And she has shown amazing stamina throughout all of the crap that was thrown at her. Imagine yourself in her position. Could you have handled it all with the grace and strength that she did? I couldn't. I'd have collapsed emotionally, mentally, and probably physically and spiritually as well.
So, please, people, give the woman a break. You don't have to vote for her in the primary, but if she gets the nomination anyway (and it's more likely she will than not — sorry, it's not about the math, but the Superdelegates, and the rules say they can vote how they want, and they will, and they'll support her because they are politically savvy), vote for her over McCain because she is still a strong democrat who still cares deeply about democratic values, despite what she may seem like during an election contest. And if you can stand to wait for Barack to gain more experience, more knowledge, more stamina, and more power through a few more good years as a senator (where, frankly, he can do great things for us all), then support her in the primary as well.











Comments (15)
Give Hillary a break???? Not a chance! She won't get my vote under any circumstances.
March 8, 2008 12:16 PM | Reply | Permalink
So you'll vote for McCain instead? Or worse, allow him to win because you won't vote at all? Not much of a liberalCEO, eh?
I thought Barack was famous for getting people interested in being politically active...not voting for the democratic nominee because you don't like her is not what Barack would advise...
March 8, 2008 12:30 PM | Reply | Permalink
Then start singing "Hail to the Chief" for President McCain!
March 8, 2008 12:44 PM | Reply | Permalink
"but if she gets the nomination anyway (and it's more likely she will than not — sorry, it's not about the math, but the Superdelegates, and the rules say they can vote how they want, and they will, and they'll support her because they are politically savvy)"
That is simply rampant speculation. Doing that will also NOT be "politically savvy" because it would alienate many independent voters and help push them towards McCain. I voted for Obama in the primary, but I would not vote for Hillary. I wouldn't vote for McCain either.
Hillary v McCain - That would bring back nostalgia for Bush v Dukakis (another lackluster choice for "leader of the free-world").
March 8, 2008 12:23 PM | Reply | Permalink
All of our comments are rampant speculation...including our harsh judgments...
March 8, 2008 12:31 PM | Reply | Permalink
I agree. And all the vitriol spitters who support Barack should really mind their manners!
All the attacks on Mrs. Clinton have made me feel sympathy for her because I'm no huge Clinton fan!
So do what you have too but I'm afraid Democratic history is about to made , not because of a woman or a black man as candidate, but because we will lose AGAIN!
March 8, 2008 12:48 PM | Reply | Permalink
She's a neo-con, not a Democrat. She endorses Republicans over Democrats. There's no reason the party should be loyal to her. It's not about being pro-Obama, it's about being ANTI-Hillary.
March 8, 2008 12:53 PM | Reply | Permalink
All she said was that McCain had more experience than Obama. That's a fact. At least she's honest. It doesn't mean she's supporting him, and you all you other Hillary haters know that. But her comment won't help McCain at all. Whether Hillary or Barack, McCain will remain a senator.
March 8, 2008 1:11 PM | Reply | Permalink
No, she said she and McCain both had more experience than Obama. Aside from her Senatorial experience, which is roughly comparable to Obama's, her experience is equal to that of Laura Bush's.
March 8, 2008 1:32 PM | Reply | Permalink
Oh, that's right! She and McCain both have more experience than Obama. True again. Sorry, her US Senatorial experience greatly exceeds his, and he doesn't have 8 years living and working in the White House. Also, in that 8 years, Hillary had many opportunities to personally experience the Republican war machine.
Listen, I'm working right now for a liberal Democrat, state house leader, who is campaigning to replace a Repbublican US Senator. As much as I love this guy, if he wins and spends 2 years in the US Senate, even with over 20 years in state politics, I'd question his readiness to be US President.
March 8, 2008 2:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
How does having a measly four more years in the US Senate "greatly" exceed Obama's experience? They are both relative newcomers in terms of senatorial experience.
March 8, 2008 2:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
8 years in the Senate, 8 years living in the White House, observing, learning, participating, working with the President, 12 years living in the Arkansas Governor's house, observing, learning, participating, working with the Governor, and having direct influence over many policies, both in Arkansas and the United States. Also to mention her professional law experience before and during all of that. Bill Clinton left the White House with the highest approval rating of any president since WWII, and Hillary left the White House to be immediately elected a US Senator from New York. She must have done something quite right all those years, and she's earned her democratic and republican supporters with hard work, determination and many successes over 35 years.
March 8, 2008 4:04 PM | Reply | Permalink
What has Hillary done for Blacks?
March 8, 2008 2:14 PM | Reply | Permalink
You're kidding, right? Try asking some of her black supporters, like Trenton Mayor Doug Palmer, former Denver mayor Wellington Webb, and congresswomen Sheila Jackson Lee of Texas and Stephanie Tubbs Jones of Ohio, just to name a few. Call them and ask them. They'll give you an earful.
March 8, 2008 2:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
I don't know if any of you were seriously involved in the 2004 contest between Bush and Kerry. If you were, you know that there were 'hallmarks' of the Bush campaign -- the nastiness and the extreme reliance on the gullibility and/or stupidity of the voters -- that are very little different in Clinton's campaign. I can't be part of putting someone else with those views and values into the White House. It isn't a matter of "giving her a break" -- she had my support. Heck, I've voted for her for Senator twice!! But this person who is running for president has *lost* my support and even the benefit of any doubt I could give her.
I'm sorry. It's hard to come to this point and before the primaries started, I could practically have written your post. "Okay, maybe she's not the most inspirational but she's quality - tough, strong, intelligent, etc., etc. So of course she deserves our support." --- But I can't give it, not after I've seen what she is willing to do to a fellow Democrat, not when I see the lack of respect she has for the voters by feeding lies and assuming (perhaps accurately - sigh) that repitition of a lie will make something real, not when I see the secrecy, the "I'm right and I don't want to hear you," and the talking past, simply failing to 'hear' questions she doesn't want to ask. I see underneath someone who cares about winning more than anything and who will govern as GWB has goverened ... and I can't do it. More than anything, we need someone with honesty and integrity as President, and I've lost my ability to believe that she has either.
March 8, 2008 7:34 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment