Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Jeremiah Wright's sermon

avatar

Josh posted this afternoon about a video of a sermon given by Jeremiah Wright, the pastor of Barack Obama's church in Chicago. I agree with the crux of Josh's post, but I had a very different reaction to watching the video itself.

Is it just me? Jesus, but we white people seem to have thin skins! I just cannot for the life of me understand what anyone would find offensive in Rev. Wright's sermon.  Maybe the supposition that Hillary Clinton, as a white female person, has never suffered discrimination of any kind? That's about the only thing I can find in his sermon that I disagree with.

Was it his use of the "n-word"? But that was a form of reported speech, or rather the opposite, a report of speech that never happened: "Hillary ain't never been called a n*****."

That's a fact. And it is so highly probable as to be a virtual certainty that Barack Obama *has* been called the n-word in his lifetime.

So what is it that's so offensive in his sermon?  Why is the MSM getting away with labeling Rev. Wright's church "a black radical church"? Is it radical to say that there is racism in America?  If that causes offense, then let me say that I am offended to hear someone deny that there is racism in America. The United Church of Christ is considered to be a mainstream denomination by almost any measure.  The words that Rev. Wright used are used in black society all the time.  And by many whites as well.

In his TPM post, Josh called the sermon "racially charged." Sure, OK. But so what? How can truths about race be told in a non-"racially charged" manner?

And Josh wrote "we wouldn't be seeing this stuff now if it weren't for the fact that
this is the kind of campaign Hillary Clinton's campaign has decided to
wage -- often directly and at other times indirectly by not reining it
in in her supporters when it crops up on its own".  Leaving aside the question about whether it is any candidate's obligation to rein in his or her supporters in the first place (I think it is not), it is truly a shame that "we" wouldn't be seeing this stuff if she didn't conduct her campaign the way she does.  "We" *NEED* to see and hear this stuff.


Comments (4)

Ned: On the one hand, I am inclined to agree with you. It is rather funny to sense the stunned confusion of white people when they discover that black anger continues in the United States, and rather sad to realize that whites have little idea why this anger continues.
On the other hand, I think Obama needs to be really careful with this. It's not the exact content of the sermon that is a problem. Rather, it is the ongoing storyline with Rev. Wright; namely, that he is anti-American. This sermon would do nothing to dispell that belief. I believe that McCain and his surrogates will both deftly and bluntly use this issue in the general election. Obama needs to do everything he can at this point to reduce their opportunities to do so.

avatar

Joe,

Yes, I also agree with your second point (on the other hand). It is a political reality.

I only hope that Obama can successfully thread the needle of putting out a positive message of hope and reconciliation, while not "whitewashing" the painful moral realities of black anger, an anger we all should share.

avatar

No offense, or critique, I obviously agree with you. But I'm pretty sure I posted this a while ago: http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/03/jeremiah-wright-what-exactly-i.php

avatar

Sara,

I am sorry I missed your excellent post; if I had noticed it I would have joined in instead of starting a new thread. Thanks for posting a link -- I would never have found it otherwise since it is (gasp) almost 3 hours old! I did look for an existing thread before I made my own, but I find it pretty hard to find threads in this new TPMCafe.

-- Ned

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address