Reader Posts
« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
In defense of Wright and Obama's patriotism
A story I was told in history class:
During the Kennedy
administration, when the civil rights marches were just getting
started, Bobby Kennedy went south to meet with black civil rights
leaders. He was to convey to them that the Kennedy administration
wanted to help but ask if they tone down their rhetoric and marches
because they were making the US look bad and there was a cold war on.
Black
leaders responded angrily and made a lot of anti-American statements,
saying why should they care about America's image in the world. It
wasn't their country anyway.
Bobby Kennedy -- a true blue patriot -- left the meeting and went back to Washington, mad as hell.
But
reportedly, a couple weeks later, he called one of his senior aides
into his office and said something to the effect of, you know, if I'd
been treated the way they have, I might feel the same way about this
country.
From then on, the Kennedy administration fully supported the civil rights movement.
In
regards to Jeremiah Wright and Michelle Obama's comments, I think we
should trust the American people to be just as fair minded.
The
truth is that most of them haven't thought about this from the other
side. Like Bobby at that time, they've just not put themselves in the
other person's shoes.
We need to remind the American people
that America first enslaved blacks and then forced them to live under a
descriminitory set of laws and the unbridled rule of lynch mobs.
Even
President George Bush recently said, in regard to whites in the south
hanging nooses out of their trucks, people need to remember what blacks
have been through.
And we need to ask all those people, given
that history, how would they feel about a country that had treated them
that way or their relatives -- many still alive to remember it -- that
way?
Would the fact that the country had finally stopped
treating your people badly but only after being repeatedly pushed to do
so, assuage you? Would you look upon 30 years of affirmative action as
enough to make up for 400 years of oppression -- oppression witnessed
by a generation of people still alive today?
I personally am
not surprised by the notion that there's a fair amount of anti-American
feeling in some quarters of the black community, but I sense that most
Americans of African descent WANT to believe in this country. There's a
desire to love America and be proud of it, but there's the fear that
America maybe won't return the favor.
If Obama is elected
doesn't it say, more powerfully than anything else could, that those
fears are unwarrented and that Americans of African descent can rest
assured that they are full members of this country. Does it not offer
the potential to change once and for all how Americans of African
descent feel about America? It has already apparently changed how
Michelle Obama feels. What is the impact for our country if that change
in feeling becomes universal? If you're concerned about the lack of
patriotism of people like Jeremiah Wright and other cynics who say
America is a racist nation, isn't the best response to show him he's
wrong about the country?
You don't have to do that by
necessarily electing Obama president, but you do have to do it by
giving Obama a fair shake and by being understanding of the history
that blacks have faced and the necessary attitudinal consequences of
that which make it impossible for a black politician not to know and
even be friends with someone of Wright's views regarding America.
The
trouble is that this may not be an argument that a black person can
make to whites as successfully as another white could make it to
whites. Maybe someone like Senator Byrd or someone a little more
conservative, who has credibility with more conservative elements of
the white population?







Comments (11)
exactly.
March 14, 2008 1:15 AM | Reply | Permalink
I always want to hope for the best, but you have to recognize that regardless of how impatient many of us are for America to move to the next level, there are those that fear thinking outside the box. Running for President against the Clintons and John McCain is like trying to compete against Walmart and there is little room for mistake. At this point, the super delegates are paying alot of attention to how well Obama is doing with voting groups besides the African American community. They want to assess who would have the longest coattails in a general election.
Obama is very adept at diffusing fears and someone with the anger that Wright showed in those sermons is scary to alot of folks. They're still trying to figure out who Obama is and they will judge him by the company he keeps. Obama needs to do more regarding Wright than just have a campaign spokesman talk about him. If Obama is the candidate in the general election, you can already count on some of Wright's footage showing up in 527 ads. Obama needs to deal now or he may not see the general election.
March 14, 2008 2:31 AM | Reply | Permalink
Word.
March 14, 2008 2:35 AM | Reply | Permalink
"And we need to ask all those people, given that history, how would they feel about a country that had treated them that way or their relatives -- many still alive to remember it -- that way?"
The bad treatment of black Americans did not stop in the sixties. We have made great gains, but still all black Americans today are victims of discrimination and abuse. And as Barack said in his first book, any black person who stands up and speaks out against that abuse will be called a n----r. Pardon me for not providing an exact quote, but I lent the book to a friend.
Many people right now are calling Wright a madman, maniac, racist, etc, without even listening to the words he speaks.
Why can't white Americans think about what it's like to be black in this country?
March 14, 2008 5:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
Now Obama comes forth to "condemn" the statements made by his spiritual advisor.....now that we have become aware of them. He isn't fooling anyone. He attended the church for twenty years, sat there with his wife and children, contributed a lot of money to this church, asked Pastor Wright to marry him and Michelle, and asked him to baptize his children. Now he denounces him. Now he denounces him... because he was advised to. Because it's hurting him politically.
Otherwise, he would be there every sunday drinking the Kool-Aid. Now I understand why Michelle wasn't proud of America .........until she and Barack are stones throw from grabbing the White House. Now I understand why Obama didn't place his hand over his heart. It wasn't an oversight....it was a conscious decision. I'm not fooled by his verbal "rejections" of his spiritual mentor. On the inside nothing has changed, he's just pulling it back into the shadows where we, the voters, can't see it.
March 14, 2008 5:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
I am a devout Catholic and we believe that Jesus is a man of peace not hatred. Anyone who speaks of Jesus but spews hatred is not a follower of Jesus.
My wife used to go to one church every Sunday morning until we had a bad experience with the priest who criticized one of the churchgoers for singing the wrong song. That is enough for us to be biased against that priest. My wife and I never attended the services at that particular time since then. The priest didn't spew hatred, racism or even unpatriotic words. The mere fact that he didn't have finesse to criticize one of churchgoers was enough for us to be turned off.
I am not running for the highest office in this beloved land of ours but if my priest spews hatred against the same people that our God died for (Catholics believe that Jesus sacrificed his life for all mankind, not only whites or blacks), I have enough conviction and good judgment to determine that it is wrong and that the priest should be outright condemned even after his first sermon of hate and racism.
March 14, 2008 7:53 PM | Reply | Permalink
You've got the wrong Jesus I'm afraid.
You must have missed the part where he kicks the money changer's stalls over, and says rich people can't get into heaven, or how the Roman Empire may take your taxes but could never have your soul.
If Jesus were alive today he would be vilified as an unpatriotic fruitcake who demolished ATM machines, denounced the American government, and said everyone in the Fortune 500 was going straight to hell.
In fact, I think Jesus and Wright would have got along just fine.
March 14, 2008 8:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
Great point. Righteous anger is not the same thing as hate and racism. I agree with Wright, but I understand why Obama does not.
March 14, 2008 9:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
BULL!
You DARE call others "racist " but defend the most incindiary speech I've heard in my whole 29 years!
No! This is not acceptable from ANYONE!
You want to say it's okay to have a double standard?
No!
You know what?
A LOT of ethnic groups were treated like shit when they first arrived on these shores.
Life is rough.
Nobody has a free pass to hate speech.
"Righteous Anger", huh?
Dare I name the hateful causes fueled by "Righteous Anger"?
IRA bombings? Terrorism? Suicide Bombers? Lynch Mobs?
No! Wright is not right and Obama needs to cut him loose!
March 14, 2008 10:13 PM | Reply | Permalink
Where is the racism in Wright's speech? Wright is angry about injustice. Saint Augustine said: Hope has two beautiful daughters. Their names are anger and courage; anger at the way things are, and courage to see that they do not remain the way they are.
You make a leap from Wright's anger to bombing and terrrorism without any justification.
March 14, 2008 11:44 PM | Reply | Permalink
Stravu9,
"'Dare I name the hateful causes fueled by 'Righteous Anger'? IRA bombings? Terrorism? Suicide Bombers? Lynch Mobs?'"
I believe you forgot to mention another group...the KKK, many of which are inside the system presently. More contemporary instances of Co-Intellpro are still reaping the benefits of their statues. The African American community is well aware of ethnic injustice from first hand accounting. Can you say the same and to what extent?
Most of this attention on Rev. Wright and the Renko affiliation is mostly good ole' boy politics. But the average citizen does not recognize it as such and the people who playing hard ball politics know this...and are counting on it. This is not the end of dirty politics.
Do I detect a little "Righteous Anger" coming from you?
You are 29 and have not experienced American outside the bell jar.
March 14, 2008 11:37 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment