Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

HRC's 5% chance, Bosnia sniper-fantasy and McCain's reality

avatar

Today David Brooks knocked it out of the park.  His article in today's NYTimes reveals how hopeless the Clinton fight is and accurately predicts the negative impact it will have on whomever is the Democratic nominee in November, most likely Obama.  
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/25/opinion/25brooks.html?pagewanted=printp

But one bit Brooks leftout was the added fodder that HRC's Bosnian misspeak will give to the Republican canon this fall if she manages to wrest the nomination from Obama.  Sure, the misspeak reveals HRC's tendency to exaggerate her achievements as though she's holding court at a cocktail party surrounded by a captive audiece of tipsy people eager to hang on to an intimate story (albeit false) told by a former First Lady.  But more than that, her fake story is a story that will pale in comparision to any "war tale" that McCain cares to share in the fall. 

In January I visited the famous Hanoi Hilton. I walked away with a tremendous amount of respect for John McCain, even though I would never vote for him for the same reasons I would never vote for HRC: the Iraq War Resolution.

Their votes were the same yet there is a difference between their motives.  As I was standing in the Hanoi Hilton looking into windowless cells that were smaller than the average American walk-in closet, a concrete bed on either side with irons at the foot to keep a prisoner in place, I couldn't help but wonder about John McCain's funny looking jaw that was perhaps broken during interrogation and poorly mended, or the limited mobility of his shoulders as a result of the beatings he withstood.  I admired his survival even though I strongly disagree with his war views, war vote, and practically every other political view he has.  But unlike HRC's vote I can understand where McCain forged his politics and why he cast his vote that way.   He's a cold warrior.

For HRC the war vote was just another version of the Bosnia sniper fantasy.  She took a calculated political risk that the Iraq war would go well enough that she would end up looking "tough enough"' to be president, just like she took a calculated risk that the Wright story last week would provide adequate media cover with the press while she slipped in this Bosnia falsehood into the minds of voters.  Hers is a life of political calculation, not principle.

While Obama will face the same man who many will respect for his service to our country, there are a majority of Americans who do not agree with the Iraq adventure and his support of it.  Obama has the best chance of winning the war argument, and even if McCain tries to portray him as inexperienced Obama will not have to explain away a falehood.  For HRC she will be left to defend a calculated vote, not unlike the calculated statement on Bosnia. 

As Brooks describes, HRC's politics were forged through a lifetime of self-serving political maneuvering first for her husband and then for herself.  The recent revelation that her opposition to NAFTA was rooted in the 'timing' of its passage ahead of her healthcare initiative rather than the 'substance' of the treaty itself once more spotlights her habit of revising history to suit her motives.  Again the facts reveal the same unflattering truth; no cause is as important as her cause, and her personal quest is rooted in nothing more substantive than her own ambition.  The nomination is now her "cause du jour" and is a must win even if it means the real "cause du jour", e.g. bringing an end to Republican mismanagement of our country, fails.

It's all about her.


Comments (1)

avatar

Re: the Bosnia landing story. Was Togo West lying when he said they told Hillary and Chelsea to go as fast as possible to their vehicles? Heads down, etc.?

I watched the 3/17 video, and he definitely said she was being carefully guarded.

I read a comment by a soldier who was in Bosnia at the time and this person said no filming was allowed of the actual landing and exiting...but I don't know if this commenter could address all landings, especially of VIPs and entertainers.

Is there any footage of the actual landing and exiting the plane?

Post a Comment

Cafe Features



Cafe Features


June 30-July 4

Steven Greenhouse The Big Squeeze

July 7-11

David Sirota The Uprising

July 14-18

Ross Douthat and Reihan Salam Grand New Party

July 21-25

Bill Bishop The Big Sort

August 4-9

Book Cover

August 11-15

James Galbraith The Predator State

August 25-29

Book Cover







Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address