Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Hillary's Minister Supports Rev Wright!

avatar

    During the Clinton years at the White House, they attended Foundry United Methodist Church in Washington, DC. I don't know for sure where she attends now, or even if she does, but in light of her statements that she would have left Wright's church, it is interesting to see that the Minister at Foundry has put out the following statement in support of Rev. Wright.

A STATEMENT CONCERNING THE REV. JEREMIAH WRIGHT
 
 
The Reverend Jeremiah Wright is an outstanding church leader
whom I have heard speak a number of times. He has served for
decades as a profound voice for justice and inclusion in our society.
He has been a vocal critic of the racism, sexism and homophobia
which still tarnish the American dream. To evaluate his dynamic
ministry on the basis of two or three sound bites does a grave
injustice to Dr. Wright, the members of his congregation, and the
African-American church which has been the spiritual refuge of a
people that has suffered from discrimination, disadvantage, and
violence. Dr. Wright, a member of an integrated denomination, has
been an agent of racial reconciliation while proclaiming perceptions
and truths uncomfortable for some white people to hear. Those of us
who are white Americans would do well to listen carefully to Dr.
Wright rather than to use a few of his quotes to polarize. This is a
critical time in America's history as we seek to repent of our racism.
No matter which candidates prevail, let us use this time to listen again
to one another and not to distort one another's truth.
 
 
Dean J. Snyder, Senior Minister
Foundry United Methodist Church
March 19, 2008

So I wonder now if Sen Clinton will bother reject and denounce her own minister?
 


Comments (41)

avatar

Rev. Synder is to be applauded because he didn't stand silently by and watch a crime being committed. He came forward. More people should follow the example of Rev. Synder and exhibit a little backbone.

avatar

Thank you so much for finding this out and posting it. It will help Hillary's minister's strong support for Reverend Wright become more widely known.

avatar

Link? I'd like to use this and disseminate this release. We need to focus the media's attention on this if/when they let the Wright thing really come to a boil again this time.

avatar

I'd be interested in the link, too.

And, it raises another interesting point: where are links to more complete segments of Rev. Wright's sermons? I would definitely be interested to hear Rev. Wright as "vocal critic of the racism, sexism and homophobia
which still tarnish the American dream."

avatar

Where is this on the 24 hour news shows? They couldn't wait to get Hillary's new remarks about Barrack & Wright,in fact it was the lead news story.

The Clinton's entertained Rev. Wright in the White House,after being impressed after attending his service.

avatar

Oh they did not. He was at the annual prayer breakfast for the clergy held at the White House.

avatar

Great post. I took the time to listen to some of Rev. Wrighs Sermons on YOU TUBE. I am a 46 year old Jewish male and can see why Minister Snyder made his supporting statement. None of us would want to be judged on a snippet of our most inflamatory statements , while offensive, taken out of context. Thomas L. Abrams

Thanks for headlining this in a reader blog.

The link to Dean Snyder's (Senior Minister at The Foundry United Methodist Church) PDF document is:

http://www.foundryumc.org/pdfs/Statement%20concerning%20Rev.%20Jeremiah%20Wright.pdf

If that link is invalid try:

www.foundryumc.org

and click the Dean Snyder statment link.

Here

[Thanks, Elusive! That was good to know.]

avatar

To see the full context of Rev Wright's sermon about the chicken coming home to roost, see:
http://tinyurl.com/2um3uo

This clip is well worth watching. In contrast to the 5 second blurb we see on the tv, it shows a much more thoughtful exploration of the tragedies which result when violence begets violence.

avatar

mcconnett:

Wow, I watched the clip and that was illuminating. It seems Jeremiah Wright is a black militant. His "faith footnotes" and "emergency chord religion" comments, in fact his whole arrogant attitude, have left me reeling, and Obama would do himself a favor in the general election to distance himself from this guy, maybe even cut him loose. I don't think most Americans are going to go for this "time for soul searching" and "chickens coming home to roost" stuff, especially if the Republicans start up with it. It's easy for liberal democrats, or Hillary, or for her pastor to write a letter of support. But I come from a Republican family (even though I am a Democrat) and this is snuff stuff.
If you want to do Rev. Wright a favor, don't circulate this clip. Find something milder.

Uh, did you miss the part where he was quoting a white man?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Peck

avatar

" It seems Jeremiah Wright is a black militant.

sassl2j, please provide EVIDENCE for your ludicrous statement.

In his "God damn" sermon, Wright calls upon God to damn America, and for good reason in accordance with the Bible. He does not call upon anyone, black or white, to attack or kill Americans.


"God damn America, that's in the Bible for killing innocent people...God damn America for treating our citizens as less than human. God damn America for as long as she acts like she is God and she is supreme."

Wright was spot on in this clip.

I've been ignoring this faux-scandal because I thought it was a non-issue. But today I finally watched the most notorious clip in its full context on YouTube. Sure, as a rhetorical flourish, "God damn America" is pretty intemperate, but it's clear that he's criticizing the government, not the people. As for the rest of the sermon -- I really enjoyed it. And since when do preachers have an obligation not to criticize the government? And for what it's worth, almost all Rev. Wright's criticisms of the American government, in this clip, were spot-on. And I have no idea where people get the idea that he is "racist" against whites -- that is just not there.

This is the 6.5-minute segment I watched:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=RvMbeVQj6Lw

Since McCain doesn't want to make a big deal of this, Huckabee has defended it, and Obama has already given his extraordinary, inspiring response ... let's hope Clinton will allow the debate to move on to something that actually matters in the lives of the American people. The economy? Anybody?

I think we should convene a committee on the economy - come up with a plan. Maybe put the guys responsible for the mess in charge.

Touche.

avatar

An interesting piece at Truth-Out gives a historical perspective to Rev. Wright's sermons and his own history. The piece is long, but well worth the read.

The authour reminds us that slavery was written into parts of the Constitution:

"What is often overlooked are the parts of the Constitution that laid the foundation for hundreds of years of slavery and oppression for African-Americans; the constitutional framework for human beings to be treated as less than human. It's these sections of the Constitution that America has never truly atoned for and still refuses to make right."

[...]


Many overlook, too, the fact that the Wright issue has been mainly discussed from the white person's perspective. Notably the way the media presented Rev. Wright was unfair and disrespectful of the public, Obama and Wright.

"The reporting and commentary on Dr. Wright's words have been presented from the perspective of people who either have no appreciation for the African-American historical experience or a personal agenda when it comes to presenting these issues."
[...]
"Dr. Wright is not un-American. He embodies what America was founded upon, the free exchange of ideas in the public space, speaking truth to power, challenging America to be the best that it can be. The Rev. Dr. Jeremiah Wright's views might not reconcile with many Americans' perceptions of America, but they must not be discarded as the ranting of an angry man. His statements were founded in the historical truths that African-Americans have and continue to live through."

http://www.truthout.org/docs_2006/032208F.shtml

Even McCain made a statement against linking Obama to his pastor (probably due to Pastor Hagee and televangelist Rod Parsley endorsements). Huckabee went further in his statements to stand up for Obama. What did Clinton do? She sought to do more damage control by bringing up the Wright issue again today.

Hillary and her surrogates' use of race as a device against Obama may be worse than being racist.

For all the good she has done, Hillary's blind insensitivity toward the Black Community may have permanently damaged her standing and reputation.


avatar

Great article. Thank you for posting such an important piece of information. Here is another important link to full length audio versions of Dr. Wright's sermons. The site also includes a couple of interviews with Dr. Wright in which he discusses his views on moral values and democracy.

http://odeo.com/find/rev+wright

Strange to ponder that if Hillary had pounced on the Wright "flap" as an opportunity to disseminate her own defense of those who rail against injustice, that she might've thrown the MSM for a loop and garnered much-needed respect from progressive Dems for her continued bid. There have been moments since this cycle's nomination contest began that I've felt grudging respect for the obvious qualities that Hillary brings to the table. Debates where I had to admit to myself that she is a woman whose competence and fire I would be glad to see my own daughter express. Fight the good fight! Dad's got your back! Didn't I raise you to understand that life ain't fair? It is what you make of it, for better or worse, and we'll always have the holidays for commiserating over the table about how bad it all is, and deciding whether or not your old man and his generation are doing enough to help level the playing field.

But, alas, Hillary is not fighting the good fight. The Democratic electorate that has now set itself against her are, for the most part, neither as sexist nor as stupid as she or her supporters imagine. We're simply paying attention.

avatar

She is not "fighting the good fight" because you are an Obama supporter, thats fine. No one thinks you are either "sexist nor stupid", but you expect Clinton supporters to quit. Not happening, she fights on, we fight on. I couldn't care less what Obama's pastor says or believes, that doesn't have anything to do with my lack of support for him. We can play tit for tat til the cows come home, but this Presidential campaign is not over, lets fight with honor. No more name calling.

Splinter, for what it's worth, I agree entirely with your sentiment. If Hillary were to decide to take the high road and say, you know, this contest is about what I bring vs what my opponent brings, and let the electorate decide where the cards fall, I'd be 100% onboard with letting this thing play out. But that ain't what's happening.

What's happening is that, on the one hand, Hillary is holding Obama accountable for not unifying the party, while at the same time throwing down an ugly gauntlet (me or your Democratic principles, you partisan sap).

At least that's how I read the latest on her website. Thank you, Mr. Daou, for crystallizing why I won't be voting for your aunt's preferred candidate in the GE. Both these gals have gone off the rails and I'll be damned if I'm gonna be made to feel guilty for pointing that out.


"this Presidential campaign is not over, lets fight with honor. No more name calling."


If only Sen Clinton would do so. She has time and again proved herself incapable. Even McCain and Huckabee said that Obama should not be judged based on this. Hillary is the only one low enough to try to make hay with this. There is no where she will not go. That is the reason she is losing. If she took the high road every once in a while she could take some of Obama's supporters. But she fails to do so time and again making sure that all the movement it from her side to his.

Rember it is not people like you she must win over. You are already on her side. She has the Machiavellian vote locked up. It is just not quite large enough to win a nomination. She has to move outside her base.

I agree, there have been lots of times when Hillary could have acted with class and chose not to; I was struck by her failure to congratulate Obama on a good race after her "decisive wins" in Ohio and Texas(which we know she didn't in fact win). I was raised to thank an opponent after a contest, win or lose, but especially after a win. I don't believe she even thanked her voters in states she lost for supporting her, but simply hurriedly said that those states didn't matter.

And like others have said, she could have taken the high road when asked about the Muslim business, and over Rev. Wright.

Had she behaved this way I would definitely be planning to vote for her if she gets the nomination. However now will be difficult.

avatar

In the interest of fairness, it should be noted that the Reverend Snyder WAS NOT Clinton's pastor. He is the CURRENT pastor of the church the Clinton's attended during their time in Washington. The pastor during Bill Clinton's presidency has retired.

Incidentally, when asked, Clinton's campaign did not respond to the question of where Clinton's CURRENT church home is. It's certainly odd, though not out of character, for Clinton to leap into the "pastor fray" if her own church-going is in question. After all, it's pretty easy to say that you'd walk away from a church if you don't have any long standing ties to one.

I'm just saying...

For whatever its worth, the post is incorrect. Snyder was not Hillary's minister.

Correct, technically it's her former church, since she's now in NY not DC.

Snyder was not her minister when she and Bill attended the church. Period. Not "technically"

avatar

NOTE: Dean Snyder is currently the Senior Minister for the Foundry United Methodist Church, and was not the pastor when the Clintons were in the White House.

http://www.politico.com/blogs/bensmith/0308/Hillarys_former_pastor_defends_Wright.html#comments

Hillary will reject Wright, but she good pals with Mc Cain... the man who spoke some very, very nasty words about her daughter Chelsea !
Oh well, they were just words!

avatar

You are WRONG. Rev.Snyder is not, nor was not Hillary's paster. He became Pastor in 2002...the Clintons were already gone by then.

Change you title...It's not the truth.

***Breaking News***

Hillary's membership in the secretive religious Cult "The Family" is starting to be picked up in the MSM

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/3/26/135640/787/385/484718

Snipers, NAFTA & Cults. Oh my.

Yeah. I read an article about it in The Nation. I have to confess, I'm pretty nervous about getting a whole big tit-for-tat "thing" started over this. I wish the religious stuff would just die down. Just like with race and gender stuff, religion is a "third rail" in campaigns. I hate seeing this stuff stirred up in primary campaigns. Usually left-leaning voters are in complete agreement about such things. It's only in this primary season that hostilities (among Dem voters, for chrissakes) have been stirred up.

It just ain't right.

In wars of religion, everyone loses.

avatar

The problem with this is, the facts are incorrect. Dean Snyder was not Hillarys pastor. But hey don't let the facts get in the way of big story.

avatar

Hillary's minister hasn't been described by her as an important mentor. Hillary hasn't equated her minister to a part of her family. She didn't use her minister's words as the title of any of her books. She didn't make her minister part of her campaign's religious council. Regardless of what her minister thinks of Rev. Jeremiah Wright, she can not remotely be associated with her minister's views in the way that Barack Obama can be associated with his minister's views. While attempting to distance himself from some of his pastors most controversial statements Mr. Obama did not renounce his minister. He did not attempt to distance himself from Wright. There is a reason for that. He can not.

Wow. That was deep.

OMG! When I saw this headline I thought it said, "Hillary's MONSTER supports Reverend Wright." LOL!

HuffPost about Trinity's fight to save their good name which Hillary has made part of her "Tanya Harding Strategy" in yet more race-laced attacks: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/03/26/video-disputes-black-sep_n_93535.html

Also a good NYT story about Obama refreshed, revived and renewed back on the trail answering questions about his church again. I've said this before, and I know I'm not the only one, but this has been a blessing in disguise because it has almost totally dispelled the crazy he's-a-secret-Muslim rumor attacks. It's also giving him an opportunity to speak to Christian conservatives because as this article shows, he knows their language. So, now he's able to put on a little Huckabee if you will.

avatar

It has rightly been pointed out that Minister Snyder was not the Senior Minister during the years Hillary Clinton was attending Foundry. My headline did indicate that he was Hillary's Minister and I stand corrected.

I don't claim to be a journalist, but do believe in honesty in posting. When I saw her comments on Obama and Wright, I thought it fair to go have a look at Foundry Methodist's website and found Minister Snyder's statement prominently posted. I thought it was important that it be seen as (pat on the back to myself) no working Journalist had put this information out.

I would be willing to bet though that we will be hearing soon from Minister Wogaman, who was her Minister. They have been known to have very similar views and have led strong congregations with very liberal and inclusive views. This really begs the question of why the Clintons no longer attend Foundry. Obviously they don't live in Washington full time, but certainly they keep a home here and are in town often enough on a Sunday that they could pop in from time to time.

Perhaps the church is a little too liberal and inclusive for them these days. This is where we get into trouble with this sort of religious litmus test. Do we really want to start with this fight over who's Pastor said what and when and when did the candidate know about it?

Is Wright making statements that might be racist? Does Foundry support gay marriage? What else do these people support???
BE AFRAID...

I really think this should be left alone by all the candidates. Sadly, I don't expect it will.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address