Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Hilary and Barnburning

avatar

It appears that Hilary has adopted the fine old tradition of "barnburning" in the Democratic Party.  During its first period, under Jackson and Van Buren, a split develop in the New York party, and one faction became known as "Barnburners" because if they could not  win the intra-party fight, then they would "burn the barn down" and destroy the party's chances in the upcoming election.  Hilary  and her supporters, having gotten themselves into this predicament by not being ready to contest the nomination  contest after "Super Tuesday," now appear intent on destroying Barack  Obama to win the nomination.  Which will be then  be worth then a rapidly declining $1.00 note. She will have zero support in the Black community and among net-roots liberals, she will have made great arguments about why John McCain would be a better Commander-in-Chief then she would be, she would have establish that she is a flip-flopper on Iraq (she was for the war before she was against it), where McCain is not, and finally she has never shown that with her pre-existing negatives she could get more than 48% percent of the vote even before she pissed the African-American Community.   The Republicans are so desperate to win, and prevent a real examination of the crimes of the last eight years, that they have picked McCain, a man most of them despise.  If they win despite this war and this economy, it will be true achievement of the Clintons (who have never been very good for the rest of the party anyway).

On policy matters, she is convincing me every day that she would run a center-right, Wall Street friendly, free-trading economic policy and an equally center-right, lets bomb some brown people on occasion, but not as much as the Republicans would like, foreign policy.  It is not coincidence that the union buster, Mark Penn, and corporate lobbyist Howard Wolfson are her biggest fans.


Comments (3)

avatar

Nice historical analysis.

avatar

"Hilary and her supporters, having gotten themselves into this predicament by not being ready to contest the nomination contest after "Super Tuesday," now appear intent on destroying Barack Obama to win the nomination."

I'm a HRC supporter and I don't feel like I'm in a "predicament" of any kind. There is no lreason to throw in the towel on Clinton, because Obama is not over the delegate count yet, and several states have yet to vote. Give Democracy a chance! This is akin to announcing who has won the presidency before the people in California get a chance to vote. Cool it. I find most of these TPM posts annoying, anti-democratic, ranting, and very accusatory in a nasty, vitrious way against Hillary Clinton. She's a candidate, she has 49% of the popular vote. We care about her. If you continue to push this disenfranchisement agenda, of crying for her to throw in the towel, you are only going to cause further erosion of solidarity within the Democratic party. Really. You want to push me and others toward a sit out? Keep calling for her to resign, forcing her hand, instead of letting the Democratic process play itself out. I don't happen to agree with that little Republican writer, David Brooks, that her chance is 5% or with his sanctimoniously clever expressions like "audacity of hopelessness". I think it behooves us all to let the people and the process decide who will be the nominee through vote, not through advocating the premature withdrawal of a popular (yes, she is popular although not at TPM) candidate.
Why are you all Democrats, anyway, if not to respect the Democratic nomination process?

avatar

Don't ask me, I'm from a state that doesn't count, and I wear Birkenstocks.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address