Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Bill Clinton was (wink) talking about race, not patriotism

avatar

Bill Clinton's recent comments to that VFW audience in North Carolina should be understood for what they were: a perfect example of the Clintons' now-polished technique of making veiled-but-legible racist comments and then disingenuously denying them,  even (diabolically disingenuous!) blaming the Obama campaign for the controversy.

Specifically, Clinton's "patriotism" comments were in fact another racist shout-out to White working class voters, and an attempt to lay at Obama's door the rotten fruits of all the Clinton's strenuous race-baiting. "Yes," Bill was saying, "it's distressing and downright unfair to Whites that all this unpleasant race stuff is dominating the headlines. Wouldn't it be great--I mean, NORMAL--if we had two candidates who could talk about the REAL issues--not this unpatriotic race stuff? Y'know, two WHITE candidates, McCain and Hillary--wouldn't that be great?"

So the fact that many White voters don't want to vote for a Black candidate--for exactly the web of historical reasons Obama forthrightly addressed in his speech on race--is fine, Clinton is saying. In fact, it's Obama's uncomfortable-making campaign that's the problem!

But of course it's not Obama who's raised race as an issue in the campaign. It's the Clintons. Obama has mostly run as a candidate who simply happens, in the American social lexicon, to be labeled as "Black." It was both Bill and Hill's race-baiting (Bill on Jesse Jackson in S. Carolina, Hillary's "I have no reason to believe he's a Muslim," etc.) that established the "race meme" as an independent factor in  the campaign.

So the Clintons race-bait, and then turn around and blame Obama for the nastiness, telling Whites it'd be the most natural thing in the world to vote against Obama because he's Black--patriotic, too.

Honestly, did Nixon,  Reagan, or either Bush stoop to any more venomous--if clever--race-mongering than that?


Comments (5)

avatar

Was Bill and Hillary on the grassy knoll as well? Sheesh....get real

avatar

Agreed. The Clintons are worse than the GOP in the sense that their race-baiting is so clever and sublte that it is all that more effective. The GOP does everything ugly and openly. Bill is appealing to the white blue collar crowd that is "tired" of hearing abotu these race issues. Race issues that Obama's opponents have brought up, I might add.

avatar

Check what Ed Rendell said on Meet the Press -- people don't want to talk about this race stuff.

No qestion what Bill was up to to anyone who can listen.

avatar

Take me back to the good old days, to those gay 90s when black Presidents were white...

avatar

Bill was talking about (wink) electability. I doubt he was personally questioning Obama's patriotism, but I think he was implying that "typical" voters will be asking the question. Sure, it's a clever, indirect plug for Hillary, who doesn't carry that particular baggage, but that's it.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address