Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

"Your Corps is Still in the Fight and Your Fellow Marines Need Your Help"

avatar

The letter came to the house while my son was actually here on a lovely surprise visit.  He'd had a couple days free and had decided to make the 400-mile drive to enjoy his boyhood home--exploring the pastures again with the dogs, hanging out with us, watching movies.  We marveled at the freedom--that he could just up and come visit--after four years of combat deployments, combat training, and infrequent leaves home punctuated by either pre-or post-deployment tensions.

I drove up to the mailbox (a mile and a half from the house), and in amongst the magazines and bills and political pleas for money was a simple cream-colored envelope with no return address, postmarked Connecticut, addressed to our son Dustin.

He didn't know anyone in Connecticut, but it obviously wasn't a credit card come-on or a bill or anything else familiar, so he carelessly ripped into it, then stood stunned at the simple red flag insignia at the top.

For those of you unschooled in military matters, when an officer makes general, his stationary is uniform across the services--a simple red flag at the top-center of the page, containing however many stars the general has, and the service insignia in the middle.

This flag had four stars and a Marine Corps insignia.

It said:

"Dear Fellow Marine
    
Once a Marine, always a Marine is more than just a slogan--it is deeply ingrained in the fiber of all who have earned the title.  Our Nation is at war--our Corps is at war--fighting a determined enemy bent on terror and domination.  Your Corps is still in the fight and your fellow Marines need your help..."

It went on to tell my son that he was an "elite warrior" and that the job he had started "is not yet finished." 

Acknowledging that he has transitioned into the Individual Ready Reserve, "I ask you to consider returning to our Corps to help us defeat this enemy and see us through this crises."

Mentioning the sacrifices he and his family had made, the letter referred to "a new Broken Service Selective Reenlistment Bonus."

No mention was made as to how much this bonus might be, or how it might be paid out.  My son was urged to call an 800 number or speak to his recruiter to find out.

The letter went on to highlight the young "new generation of Marines" that were going to need experienced Marines such as Dustin to help them in this fight.

It was signed, "Semper Fi Marine!" with what appeared to be the personal signature (but was probably machine-done) of James T. Conway, the Commandant of the Marine Corps.

My son read the letter, then said quietly, "And so the guilt-tripping begins."

He was disgusted by the sly 800-number.  "If I even call that number just to find out how much the bonus is, my name and information will be entered into a data base that indicates to the Marine Corps that I am considering returning to the service, and I will be marked, most likely, for recall to a combat deployment."

For my son and my nephew and thousands like them who stepped up, volunteered to serve their country in time of war, fought bravely through numerous combat deployments, and managed to survive and move on to civilian life at long last--their greatest fear is that they might be recalled and sent back to war yet again.

I repeat:  They do not want to go back.

Every time I see someone like John McCain bragging about how many soldiers have reenlisted even while already in Iraq, I want to vomit.

Most people have no CLUE the high--pressue tactics put on these young men and women to stay in.  The bribes, for one thing, have skyrocketed.  My twin nephews, both active-duty army captains, were offered tens of thousands of dollars to reenlist but were given a strict deadline to sign or lose the bonuses.  One nephew was already deployed when the deadline loomed.  Fearful that if they didn't sign, they'd get recalled anyway and sent back to combat without the bonus, they both reenlisted.  But they were pretty much career army anyway.

But thousands of captains and other junior officers are not, and the military is bleeding out of young talent because of this godforsaken war, the multiple deployments, the unbelievable stresses on families.

Being offered huge chunks of money is only part of it.  For enlisted men and women, especially, the pressure to reenlist is intense and often dirty.  For my son and nephew both, each of whom had done multiple combat deployments--when they made it clear they were not reenlisting, their last few months of service were spent in enlisted-man hell. 

My nephew, who was at the time completing his third Marine Corps combat deployment to Iraq as a  lance corporal, was yanked out of his unit and sent to a large army base near Baghdad where one of his duties included picking up trash on the grounds.

Let me repeat that.  A decorated combat Marine, on his third deployment to Iraq, had to spend his last couple months picking up trash on an army base because he refused to sign up for four more years and more combat deployments.

Once a service man or woman makes it clear they want out, then even the simplest requests get ignored, often to great personal detriment.  One of my son's buddies was due to muster out in a month.  The Marine Corps requires that a Marine needs 30 days to complete the process, getting paperwork straightened out, turning in equipment, getting physicals, and the like.

This young man's CO scoffed at that, and only gave him FOUR DAYS to complete the process, something almost guaranteed to cause him to make a costly mistake.

Other service members sign up for another hitch because they are PROMISED that if they do, they will not be redeployed.

PROMISED.  They even get it in writing.

Time and time again, those promises are broken, and the first thing that happens to them is that they get redeployed.

Pressure tactics such as this letter--harmless enough, considering--may not work on my 30-year old, college-graduate son, who's been around long enough to recognize what's going on.  But take a kid who went into the service right out of high school; he's maybe 21 or22 years old, and he or she becomes ten times more vulnerable to bribes and "guilt-tripping."

On this visit home, my son and I sat outside one cool evening and watched one of those spectacular West Texas sunsets we sometimes take for granted.  As the sky purpled and the stars twinkled forth, Dustin shared with me some more details of his harrowing last deployment, how every single day a vehicle in his unit got blown up, how during one three-day period, five men had to be medivacced out and two privates sent back to the States from the sheer stress.

"We were so scared," he said.  "Every day you think...who's it gonna be?  The rig in front of me?  The one behind?  My own?"

And of course, his vehicle did get blown up, as they say, but he was one of the lucky ones, able to stagger away under his own legs before his knees crumpled and the chopper arrived. 

In a soft voice, he told me about how, with each deployment, some of his buddies suffered worse and worse post-traumatic stress back in the States--something that has been borne out by the military's own studies.

Daily, I read reports of the toll this war is taking on military families in every aspect measurable.  Divorce, child abuse, spousal abuse, homicides, suicides, nervous breakdowns, hidden brain injuries from IEDs, alcoholism, prescription drug abuse, brawling, depression, and long-term health issues.

I hear talk about building up the military with more troops--the money's in the budget--but most civilians are getting wise to the fact that signing up means going to war over and over again, and more and more are turning away.  The army's had to let in recruits with criminal records and high school drop-outs, and they're just flat running out of DEPLOYABLE troops. 

What that means is that, when a unit deploys, they're running short of bodies to send to war, so they're dragging guys out of rehab from war-related injuries and redeploying them.  They're deploying troops who have committed violent crimes but have not yet been prosecuted.  They're deploying trooops who've attempted suicide.  They're sending troops with non-combat designations into combat roles, minus the intense training needed.

I have to make it clear that there ARE soldiers and Marines and airmen who WANT to reenlist.  They are intending to make the military a career, or maybe they really are gung-ho on the war (a greatly diminishing bunch), or they have desk jobs that don't expose them to a great deal of danger on their deployments.  And there are a very rare few who are adrenalin junkies and get off on war--a very small number, but a few.

There are some who ARE drifting after having gotten out, and sort of float back into the service because they find they need that discipline and like the security.

But a great many of those reenlisting are not doing it for patriotic reasons.  They're being bullied, manipulated, threatened, bribed and cajoled back into the service so we can keep fighting two wars after five straight years with a military made up of less than one percent of the population.

"Support the troops" is a platitude that REALLY means, "Support Bush's War."

We'll be seeing a lot of it in the run-up to November, especially since John McCain has staked his entire campaign--and Bush his entire legacy--on that premise.

But the truth is that the United States military cannot go on like this much longer. 

Remember that memorable scene in Gone With the Wind, after the fall of Atlanta, when Scarlett loaded up Melanie and her new baby and Prissy into a rickety old wagon drawn by an aging and worn-out horse, and headed home to Tara?

Remember how, when they were almost there, the horse simply stopped moving.  No matter how hard Scarlett whipped that horse, it would not move.

And then, it collapsed.

Dead in its traces from sheer exhaustion.

Our military won't die in its traces, but the enforced extensions pushed on it and whipped into a frenzy by politicians on both sides of the Atlantic have exhausted it almost to the point of no return.  Some 40 percent of its equipment is now ruined by war and in urgent need of repair.  Traumatic Brain Injuries and post traumatic stress combined with serious marital and personal problems have ground down the collective consciousness of our fighting men and women to the breaking point.

And yet, the war in Iraq, they say, has moved on down the list of voter concerns.

No matter what "commanders on the ground" may say (they have their own legacies to protect)--we ignore the stresses this war has brought on our troops at our own peril.


Comments (19)

Your son was raised by you. And therefore has the fortitude to resist.

God help those others who didn't start out with the same inner strength.

God help us all!

Thank you, Deanie. That was painful to read. But I'm glad you wrote it.

Hard to believe our government is doing this to us and our kids. Hard to believe.

What an outrage!

You know where I stand on this, Deanie. "Support Our Troops" has become an obscene platitude when spoken by the monsters in this administration.

I support the troops, I just don't want to be one.

Thank you Deanie.

I'm reminded of the neighboring houses I sometimes see here in Maryland, one with a sign that simply says "Support Our Troops," the next with a sign that says "Bring Them Home."

You can't have one without the other.

avatar

Billy Glad, semper fidelis to you too, sir. I encourage all to click on his link. One picture, as they say, tells more than a thousand words.

Deanie, I can't even begin to count the number of people Bush has betrayed and ruined. My son was in Saudi Arabia and Kuwait with the 2nd Marine Division in Desert Storm. His mother and I hung on to every briefing from Colin Powell for dear life, and came to trust that man. When Bush sent Powell to the UN with phoney evidence of the Iraqi threat, we thought the evidence was flimsy, but we trusted Powell. Of course, now our faith in Powell, our government, and in our own judgement has been destroyed, along with Powell's career. My son has never lost his pride in the Corps, but I've never heard him talk about wishing he could re-up for this one. We need to redeploy those troops now, date certain, and with no wiggle room about "events on the ground."

Thanks for reminding us why we vote, and what the electoral fuss is about.

Deanie, I don't know how you do it. You manage too convey the absurdity and horror of Iraq with a humanity and personal view that avoids vindictiveness. I could never do it.

I am so glad that your son has come home to you. Please, please, please submit your extraordinary posts to some major newspapers. WAPO, New York Times, (hell, try the Richmond Times Dispatch or the Daily Progess in Charlottesville).

What strikes me most about your wonderful posts are two things:

1. The facts are so obvious, but you state them in a way that only really stupid people could refute them

2. Although, thankfully, your son has survived this mess, all those who have not survived, or those who are horribly maimed, have done it for George Bush and his oil and mercenary friends; certainly not for our country.

How sad for our country. Thank you for your many thoughtful posts.

Deanie,

Thank you for writing this and sharing it with us. I am sending a link to this post to all my friends.

Deanie, I am so proud of you. You're like that bunny that keeps pounding her drum and keeps going and going and going.

You're son is right to not respond. And you're so damned right about the impact this war is having on our troops.

My son has been back since September and the effects of PTSD are starting to kick in. He thought he could handle it on his own. But his wife, daughter and I are telling him that he isn't.

Some of his fellow soldiers have turned to alcohol, fighting and worse. But others, like my son, have just "shut down" emotionally, afraid of "losing it" if they allow the feelings to emerge. We're encouraging him to get counseling.

The Army owns him for another two years, because he was pressured to re-enlist right after his Stryker was blown up and told he'd be sent back if he didn't.

Like he said this weekend, "I think about getting out and then I remember -- I can't. So what's the point in thinking about it."

The horse analogy you used is perfect.

My son only sees the road ahead. He doesn't have the option to stop. He believes he can't risk looking back to process his feelings, because the only thing he has left to help him cope is to just keep going forward.

My son, like many of our returning soldiers, are engaged in an emotional death march. Unfit to serve in this war and fearing they're unfit to survive it.

We need to bring all our troops home and allocate all the country's resources to help them heal.

Heal the troops, heal the nation.

Thanks, Deanie for this spine-tingling post.

Sometimes I feel guilty for leaving the military without going to Iraq. Other times I feel it was the smartest thing I've ever done. Especially for my kids.

Morgan, Thank you as well, for so many things, but especially for being a Military Mom.

PLEASE LISTEN:

If you do convince your son to pursue a PTSD claim of any sort, your very first step needs to be consulting a good lawyer at the very beginning of the process. Look for a lawyer that has experience dealing with the VA and the DOD. DOD will stop at nothing to deny your son the treatment he has earned, and they are expertly cheating Vets out of everything every single day.

Pro-bono representation is out there for PTSD claims, so some searching could pay off.

avatar

God bless you Morgan my dear. I have been wondering about your boy--his deployment with an army Stryker Brigade was one of the worst I've heard about from fellow military families. Most people really cannot fathom the horrors some of our fighting men and women have been forced to witness and the terrors they have survived.

They walk about in a world of insanity and are then expected to return to the "real world" sane. It's a true testament to their courage and strength of spirit that so many actually, really, do. They live productive lives and raise families and painstakingly rebuild their shattered souls with hardly a crack showing.

They should not, then, be yanked out of that peaceful life and forced to return to the madness of war.

The righteousness of an American Foreign War is directly related to the willingness of America's elites to sacrifice their won blood and treasure in the war effort.

If general Conway is looking for a way to ease the current military crises, maybe he should step-up recruitment efforts in one of the most under-represented in the military identifiable groups of service aged persons: The College Republicans.

Thank you for writing that, Deanie. Like the others here I wish your writing could get the wider audience it deserves. Please consider collecting your posts into a book, or at least a long magazine article.

Our problem as a nation is that we continue to see war as simply another part of diplomacy. Our leaders fail to understand the enormous cost of war, primarily on those who must fight it, but also on the nation as a whole - it coarsens our national character. And, of course the monetary cost is staggering, when you think of the alternative uses for that money.

avatar

One of my colleagues is an ex-Marine, and he too is sickened by this sort of thing. Over the last three years, I've seen a notable drop-off in his pride at having been a Marine; he's got a good job and a good perspective on the world, but deep down he is hurting.

He, however, like your son, is one of the lucky ones with a wonderful family there to support him. How you all manage to do it, and with such grace, never ceases to amaze me.

Amazing post. Thank you for sharing that.

Thank you for the advice, Slouch (somehow I suspect you're no slouch). My son and his wife (a former soldier herself) are very aware of how to play the system. And I'm relieved to know they are not opposed to going outside the "green wall" to find help. My son was recently subjected to an experience in a military hospital emergency room that can only be described as "degrading." My daughter-in-law, bless her courageous heart, stood up to those in charge to remind them her husband was a decorated combat officer who deserved to be treated with respect, compassion and deference. And she didn't stop there -- she sent her complaints to Congress.

Deanie's son and my son are among the few lucky ones who have strong family support. We can help them fight their battles here at home. It's the other soldiers, the ones who find themselves struggling alone, that need our help -- the nation's help the most.

They've earned it, and this nation owes it to them.

I couldn't agree more, Deanie. Sending soldiers on multiple deployments under duress and stress, fatague both mental and physical, and with full knowledge these soldiers are medically, mentally and physically unfit to return to combat is not only morally wrong, it's abuse from the highest ranking officer in our military -- their Commander-in-Chief.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address