Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

What's in a name when the name is Hussein?

I understand this tactic of bringing up Obama's middle name is childish, but calling it "slimy" or "underhanded" or "insulting" seems awfully close to whining about the mean Republicans using the man's actual name. I'm an Obama supporter and I volunteer for the campaign as often as I can, but I'm not happy about the responses to the use of "Hussein".

Of course they should refute charges of anti-semiticism and other nonsense, but please, let's not make the Senator a victim. Do we really want our candidate to be asking, implicitly or explicitly, that people not say his middle name? Isn't that pathetic and absurd?

I'd like to hear some language about being a nation of immigrants, that we are not so easily frightened by a person with an unusual name.


Comments (36)

The problem isn't that they're saying it. It's the reason they're saying it, and it doesn't require mind reading usually to figure this out.

That said, I agree with you that he (and his campaign and supporters) should definitely refrain from playing the victim. I think it's acceptable to call it out when it's clearly being used to incite (one poster on TPM frequently refers to him as B. Hussein Osama), but that ignoring it will usually be the best course of action.

Spot on.

And in case you needed more evidence of the fact that this is a sleazy tactic meant to play on fear and ignorance, the trend of calling him B. Hussein Obama (which clearly shows an effort to emphasize the middle name over his first name) was started by none other than Ann Coulter.

Juan Cole has an EXCELLENT piece on this topic:

http://www.juancole.com/2008/02/barack-hussein-obama-omar-bradley.html

avatar

I tend to agree with this. Obama has a confident style of campaigning and speaking that completely eschews playing the victim. Whether or not a victim has justice on his side, a victim is weak. Obama seeks to project strength and control over his own destiny, and his supporters should support him in that approach.

But so many Democrats have kneejerk habits of responding to opposition criticisms with complaints of various kinds about the criticism - No fair! Stop that! Low blow! Smear! Race card! Red baiting! Dog Whistle! - rather than simply addressing the criticism with strength, calmness and humor and turning it back against the critic. Consider the following illustrative example:

Typical Republican Charge:

Obama and the Democrats want to surrender in the fight against terrorism, and will make us vulnerable to attack.

Typical Democratic Whining Response:

How dare you attack our patriotism! I'm insulted! I'm offended! My feelings are hurt! Shame on you!

Improved Obama-style Response:

If Republicans hadn't failed to take care of business in Afghanistan and hadn't marched the country into a dumb war in Iraq that has exposed Americans to new terrorist threats that didn't exist before, then Democrats wouldn't have to pull the country out of this mess. But that's just what we're going to do.

Here is another hypothetical exchange that would make the same point:

Republican Taunt

Barack Obama, Barack Hussein Obama, Barack Hussein Obama, Barack Hussein Obama. Get it? Barack crypto-Muslim Manchurian candidate Hussein Obama.

Typical Democratic Whining Republican Bitch Response:

Bad Republicans! Smear campaign! Guilt by association! Anti-Muslim dog whistle! Do not mention our candidate’s middle name!

Likely Obama-style Response

My middle name, as you may have heard by now, is "Hussein". It was given to me my father, Barack Hussein Obama, Sr., and it means “good” or “handsome”. He and my mother were divorced when I was two years old, and I saw him only once since then. Since I am a Christian, I will refrain from the temptation to mock the unusual names of some of my Republican opponents. Of course there are some real doozies out there.

For those people who really want to help Obama, I suggest they please take their lead from the campaign and the candidate himself, who has much experience in dealing with all of these tactics, and clearly knows how to handle them. The constant complaining to the refs is weak, and it doesn’t work. Even if people think your complaint is just, they lose respect for you from your making it. The president is the most powerful individual in the US, and does not really have a ref to complain to. Americans expect a president to play with pain, fight back and best his enemies, not to complain about unfair treatment.

recomend

Nice analysis.

Yeah, this is spot on.

It should be every Democrat's personal goal this election season to educate himself or herself in what trustfundbaby cleverly referred to as "Obama Jujitsu": Repelling attacks not by playing the victim but by turning the attack around on the scumbags what leveled it in the first place.

Maybe Hillary's campaign would be going better if she learned a little Obama Jujitsu herself.

Very nicely done.

It would be reasonable to use all three names if media would also say John Sidney McCain III, Willard "Mitt" Romney, and Hillary Rodham Clinton, etc.

There is no good reason to emphasize middle names. They exist as further identifiers---no one is confused about which Obama is being discussed. They are used in stern-parent mode, as in when the judge asks the defendant to rise, and the sentence is pronounced.

It is transparent as to purpose, and intentionally misleading in this use.

avatar

Rodham is her maiden name: Hillary Diane Rodham Clinton.

OTOH, when it comes to sitting presidents, the middle name is sometimes common, sometimes not. William Jefferson Clinton and George Herbert Walker Bush seem common, but Ronald Wilson Reagan and James Earl Carter don't.

I suspect if Obama does make it the White House, no one will have a problem with the middle name, especially when he overseas in places like Indonesia, etc.

James Earl Carter; William Jefferson Clinton; George W. Bush; George Herbert Walker Bush; Ronald Wilson Reagan; Gerald R. Ford; Richard Milhous Nixon; Lyndon Baines Johnson; John Fitzgerald Kennedy; Harry S. Truman; Franklin Delano Roosevelt; etc., etc.

Yes. My point is those full names were always used for emphasis, as in when the actual winner is announced, when the winner is inaugurated, etc. They were not used in typical conversation or news coverage.

Best response for us is to ignore. Obama can handle it.

I've made the same point on another thread; I'm sure Obama isn't ashamed of his name and if he was, then he's had the capacity to change it.

Thank you, Dan.

Think of the Republicans as Nelson of "The Simpsons" playing the "quit hittin' yourself!" game. We know the response of the target should be much more than, "Ow! Stop it! I'm tellin'!" You've got to strongly, accurately, with all fairness, knock the bully on his ass. And deliver a bit of turned-the-tides mockery.

I don't think Rodham qualifies as a middle name.

avatar

Obama has nothing to be ashamed of, but those who insist on using his middle name all the time are trying to form an association in the public's mind between Barack Hussein Obama and the late, not so lamented, Saddam Hussein of Iraq.
But of course, Hussein is a common name just not familiar to the majority of Americans.
The slime has as much substance as trying to suggest all persons with the name "Joseph" are potential murderous tyrants because that was Stalin's first name.
Obama has a cool style and doesn't seem to get rattled by nonsense. On the other hand, just to ignore the slime suggested by using his middle name is probably not smart either. I suppose the best for Obama to do is himself to make a point of responding, when necessary, by making a point of using others' middle names until the air leaks out of that tire.

oh please, they say Hillary Rodham Clinton all the time to emphasize that she's not womanly enough...to remind people that she kept her maiden name after marriage. Yes, it's used to denigrate but that's a fact of life.

Look at the times those of us on the left have use Goerge HERBERT WALKER Bush to emphasize how elitist, privileged and out of touch George HERBERT WALKER Bush was.

When Obama complains about the use of his actual name, I cringe. First, it's a concession that there's something "wrong" with being named Hussein. Two: it's a concession that there's something "wrong" with being named Hussein. That's 3-10 as well, by the way.

Don't give an inch on this one, Obama. It's your name and it's unAmerican to judge someone by their name. America is bigger and better than that, but not if you are going to whine about it.

Actually, I never heard anyone refer to George HW Bush as anything other than George Bush until there was a reason to distinguish him from Jr.

I don't think Obama has complained about people using his middle name. I think his supporters have and McCain, the national GOP, and even Karl Rove have said the use of such Muslim baiting could backfire and should be avoided. I do think it's important for Obama's supporters to deconstruct distortions and smear by subtle innuendo when they hear them a la Media Matters, but I don't think there is anything subtle about the HUSSEIN HUSSEIN HUSSEIN business.

I've been trying to think what a better response would be for Obama supporters than outrage, because I agree that it implies there is something wrong with the name itself and there isn't. One thought was a day when everyone incorporated HUSSEIN in their own online names, e.g. "Oregon Hussein Activist" to show that we are not afraid to be associated with something with Muslim origins. But I'm sure someone else could come up with a better tactic. Ideas?

avatar

Actually, I did that once yesterday on Matt Yglesias's blog, signing myself "Dan Hussein Kervick" in a comment on one post. Rather than go into a defensive crouch over Obama's middle name, better to just get it out there everywhere and laugh it off.

Oregon Activist:

Obama doesn't complain about the use of his middle name. That's the thing. I don't think Obama cares much about this. I think he expected it and thinks Americans are above it. He mentioned his name in the 2004 Democratic Convention. He has always been aware of its effects.

I think the greater complaints are coming from the exaggerated wink-wink use of it by those discussing it in the context of "you can't trust this guy because of his secret Muslim identity". And I think there are more screams about this by well-meaning Obama supporters than the campaign itself. It will try to score points where it will, but it is the media and supporters who are more ruffled by this.

I think Obama was more annoyed by the photo (he did look pretty silly - hardly threatening), than the repetition of his middle name.

The way to deal with this sort of nonsense is for Obama and his supporters to embrace his middle name. "I was given this name by my parents, and I'm proud of it! It's a good, strong, proud name." Should an American named Joe have been ashamed because Stalin shared that name? Should an American named George be ashamed because you-know-who has the same name? Seize back your name, Barack Hussein Obama, seize it back and don't let them steal it from you. Make us proud of your name.

avatar

Juan Cole, over at "Informed Comment" has a good write up on names, focusing on the meanings and sources for Barack and Hussein.

When Obama becomes president, we can just call him "H".

avatar

When people emphasize the "Hussein", all they are really doing is throwing a gang sign to their fellow lizard-brained travelers. It's the rhetorical equivalent of a fart joke.

As such, IMO the proper response is to treat the offender the same way that you'd treat an eight year old who rips off a good one - it's not worth any more reaction then an indulgent pat on the head and a confident dismissal. If they keep it up, remind them that the kiddie table is off yonder, and that they best scoot off - the grownups have some important work to do.

LOL @ "throwing a gang sign to their fellow lizard-brained travelers"

avatar

My Jewish step-father (born in 1914) was given the middle name "Adolph" and used it without apology.

Many of us at the Obama website (and as noted above)have adopted Hussein as our middle name in a show of unity. Some scoff, but I find it a valid form of peaceful protest.

No one says George Walker Bush, they just call him George W. Bush, or just George Bush.

No one says Bill Jefferson Clinton, they just say Bill Clinton.

What's in the name Hussein is irony. Irony that America killed 3 Husseins, Saddam and his two sons because they refused to surrender and leave Iraq before we invaded it on the premise of the harboring weapons of mass destruction and causing the terror attacks on 9/11/2001.

avatar

Perhaps my post can shed light on this topic.

http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/02/defense-from-outerspace-aliens.php

avatar

Glad someone's blogging on this.

My own take on the "correct Barack reponse", posted here, goes something like:

"Yes, my middle name is Hussein. It's a wonderful name. It's a diminutive of 'Hassan' and means 'good' or 'handsome.' The name has been carried by some staunch allies of the U.S., such as King Hussein of Jordan, who also concluded a peace treaty with Israel. I am not only proud of my name, I am proud of the thousands of patriotic American Muslims who carry it, even if they do not share my Christian faith. We must always remember that the strength of America is in the diversity of the people who come together to form this unique and amazing society."

Kind of surprised Team Obama isn't more out in front on this.

avatar

Just a thought, but if I was an Islamic terrorist,
hell-bent on the destruction of the USA by "attacking from within", why in the name of all that is sacred would I use someone with the name Barack Hussein Obama as my tool to accomplish this? Seems to make more sense that I would use a nicer name, like John Brown, or George Bush....even John McCain.

I hope this fear-mongering won't work again. But history has shown that, for all their strengths, the American people can also be quite gullible.

avatar

Yes, I was going to make the comment about the late King Hussein of Jordan and his peacemaking role. There are many many good people in the world with the name Hussein. Just because Saddam Hussein wasn't a good guy shouldn't tarnish the name. And every time I hear someone disparage the name Hussein, it reminds me that so many people in America don't have passports, haven't traveled and are sometimes xenophobic about what they don't know or understand. It's really ridiculous making so much of a name when there are important issues to be addressed.

avatar

I keep wanting to Obama campaign to point out that John McCain has the same first name as John Gotti, the Mafia kingpin. "You don't want a president who's part of the Mafia, do you? Well, umm, actually, (cough) McCain isn't (cough), BUT HE HAS THE SAME FIRST NAME, WHAT'S UP WITH THAT?" I think that really makes the point. Of course, I'm not the candidate, and bright ideas like that are why it's probably a good thing. But still, I'd like to hear someone say it.

avatar

the second coming of Christ had better be white, be a USA citizen, speak perfect English and have a name that isn't unusual or sound like an evil doer. LOL! If he/she doesn't fit in this mold then the republican party will surely have him/her hanging on the cross without a trial. Looks like it's the silly season for the republican party again. They must be very scared of Obama to try to make a big deal about his middle name. If a persons name is Jeffery does that mean he is like Jeffery Daumer(sp)? How silly and ignorant is this?

avatar

The self-serving and shameless hypocrisy of the Obamanauts is laugh-out-loud funny.

"How dare these hateful Clintonistas and Republitards refer to our Savior by his ... real name?!? By exploiting the fact of his middle name these haters wish to portrary him as foreign, exotic, the OTHER... when we all know that being conceived out of wedlock to an 18 year old mother named Stanley and a globe trotting inseminator named Obama (who himself was the product of the second of his Muslim father's three polygamous marriages) who abandoned the two when Obama Jr., was just two leaving Stanley to remarry an Indonesian Muslim named Lelo and taking baby Obama off to live in Indonesia to attend Catholic and Muslim schools and God knows what else and then sending little Obama off to Hawaii to be raised by his white Kansan grandparents, there to attend an exclusive elite prep school where he bided his time playing hoops, smoking blunts, and snorting coke and then to attend Occidental College and then to invoke his affirmative action privileges available to him only by virtue of the seminal contribution of the absentee father he never knew to be admitted to two Ivy League schools so that after little adult accomplishment he can be elected to the US Senate and run for President two years later ...

Why, our guy's life arc is as normal and typical and as American as apple pie. How dare these haters portray him as an OTHER by daring to use his middle name?

avatar


One wishes that one could find some report of Obama being as ready to condemn his supporters' constant, snide references to John McCain's age as McCain was quick to condemn the use of Obama's middle name.

Oh, right, nothwithstanding all the laws against age discrimination, McCain's age is a legitimate election issue where Obama's foreignness is not.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address