Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

The "Valley Of The Shadow"... PTSD







“I was too scared to be scared!” That's a quote from a Vietnam vet. When a PTSD victim can “admit” that kind of fear or release some of the anger and shame which is held so deeply inside... Well, that's the beginning of acceptance of another truth spoken by another Vietnam vet: “You may think you're OK, but you're not!”


The book, “Achilles In Vietnam” by Jonathan Shay, M.D., PH.D., gives the following five “ruins of character” which are symptoms of PTSD:


<blockquote>

A. a hostile or mistrustful attitude toward the world;

B. social withdrawal;

C. feelings of emptiness or hopelessness;

D. a chronic feeling of being “on the edge,” as if constantly threatened;

E. estrangement. <\blockquote>


Waking suddenly to a sound in the night, feeling that knot in the belly because of a smell or thought, shivering inside as July 4th fireworks explode... These are all things that await our returning Iraqi vets. These are things Vietnam vets and veterans of all wars have lived with since men first battled against other men.


Anyone who hasn't read “Achilles In Vietnam” would be enlightened by taking a look. It compares “feelings” of Vietnam vets to the warriors in Homer's “Iliad.” Startling similarities in not only language but actions and consequences are poignantly compared.


I've written blogs during my research for a book on PTSD which attempt to tell the stories of veterans I've interviewed. Some of the other “common” statements I've heard too many times to discount “mere chance” as their origin in each individual are:


  1. I can't go to the “Wall” yet. Not only because of all the names there who were known to me as REAL human beings but because of the way we were treated when we came back. (I've heard more than once: “We will NEVER forgive you for the way you treated us!)

  2. I drank too much because I thought it made everything go away. But it always came back... Or worse, exploded in a fight.

  3. It's amazing how vicious a human being can be to another when threatened or frightened.

  4. I've felt it, seen it, heard it, smelled it, dreamed about it too many times. It all comes back and I wake up in a cold sweat wondering where my weapon is or, worse yet, with my weapon in my hand.

  5. It NEVER goes away!



3,145,000 served in Vietnam. 776,000 served in combat. There were 321,000 casualties and over 58,000 killed.


3963 American troops have died in Iraq. 3824 of those have died since George W. Bush declared “Mission Accomplished” aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln.


In late January, Illinois became the first state to initiate state-funded, mandatory screening of all returning Illinois National Guardsmen and Reservists for PTSD and traumatic brain injury. The “debriefing” of all returning troops may head off some of the future problems for some of these vets. But a nationwide program and many millions of dollars will be necessary for diagnosis and treatment of PTSD in Iraq/Afghanistan era vets. And that doesn't begin to count the untold millions in future law enforcement costs.


I know how many of them will feel in 40 years. I hope the changes in government policy and the treatment of our current veterans prevents another generation from living the torture many Vietnam vets have suffered.


Watching what this administration has done brought back many feelings, thoughts and nightmares for me and many other Vietnam veterans. I hope history will not be kind to George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld and the rest. I hope history shows the truth about the death and misery directly resulting from their greed, incompetence and arrogance.


I hope we don't wind up with another “Wall” in Washington with over 50,000 names. In the end, it will be up to us: “We The People.”


Please write your representative in Washington. Ask them to find the courage to fight this administration to the end. Let's work together to hold the death toll in Iraq for American troops under 4,000. Let's put an end to the suffering of the Iraqi people and the American people. Let's get to work to make sure those who have already served too many tours in Hell because of George W. Bush get the treatment they need.


“We The People” MUST take our country back from the monsters who have corrupted our constitution, stolen our civil liberties and sent so many into the “valley of the shadow” which is PTSD.


Comments (6)

Thank you, Chuck, for keeping this issue front and center.

A smaller percentage of soldiers may be dying in this war (compared to Vietnam). But that only means a larger percentage having to live with PTSD... which can be like a living hell.

It is my belief that an unjust war, in particular, sends soldiers into moral jeopardy. Wrestling with terrible memories is one thing. Having to live with the moral ambiguity of one's actions is another, sometimes more terrible, legacy.

My heart goes out to anyone suffering from PTSD, whether due to combat or other trauma.

Please seek help if you are experiencing any of the symptoms Chuck outlined above.

avatar

This will only get worse due to the ease of starting wars. Congress has relegated ALL authority to the executive branch, so it is very easy to get into mischief without discord by the other branches.

Notice there was immediate passages of laws exempting our leaders, agencies, and military from ALL war crime and other prosecutions.

Notice there are now paid militias taking the place of draftees, so it is easier (although much more expensive) to have bodies to send off to war.

Notice that the mobsters in Congress don't even bother reading the important information (or have knowledge of our past history) before okaying young folk to be sent to their deaths.

Notice that every congressperson in the United States have companies working for the military or defense department in their district... a sure sign that the defense budget will continue to rise and that these folk will have jobs (and bodies).

Finally, notice that congress no longer cares about prosecuting or holding anyone in Washington accountable for illegal, immoral, or unethical behavior. It has become an anarchy on the inside while still espouting laws and democratic ideals to the public...


Yes, I've noticed... It's a shame what has happened to our government. It is a shame what this administration has done to, and in the name of, our country!

Chuck, take a look at Deanie Mills' post here:

http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/blogs/deanie_mills/

Deanie is always honest and she writes so well. Thanks for the heads-up, TheraP.

My mom ws a VA nurse in Palo Alto. One thing I admire about the West coast as opposed to the East, is that the Vets were there, in our face. On the whole, I think they're treated better.

I befriended as many as I could. I miss them, and cherish every small gift they'd inevitably give me, and every tall tale I was privledged to hear. I adopted a few when I worked in San Francisco and always made time for them. I remember one, in particular, that I'd buy coffee for as we walked the several blocks to my work. We'd chat about politics, his overly worried sister, and other things. Sometimes about his lack of faith in the human race. One day he said he'd really like to have some socks. I gave him some cash ( far more than was needed for socks,) and said, "the next time I see you you'd better be wearing socks!" It was a while until I did again, but he shouted at me from across the street, pulled up his pant leg and pointed at the socks.

Socks.

Good God.

We owe them so much and give so little.

I worry so very much about the tens of thousands of wounded vets coming home from Iraq and Afghanistan.

My mother nearly became an alcoholic listening to their sad stories. It wasn't JUST the war. They had a lot of other problems, too. Just like anyone else, I guess, but theirs became insurmountable.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address