Reader Posts
« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
Bill Clinton: "The people who need a president know she'd be the best."
Dear President Bill Clinton,
I voted for Barack Obama and millions of others have to. Your quote seems to say we don't need a president, or worse, faults our judgment. As an American who has exercised his right to vote since I turned 18, I find this incredibly offensive, especially coming from a former president. Of course, I guess I should not be surprised considering previous comments from you and Hillary's other consultants. By your measure, only those who support your wife matter or need a president. Shame on you Bill Clinton.
Advertisement











Comments (4)
And you just can't imagine what he meant?
February 24, 2008 7:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
I'm sure I can imagine what Bill Clinton means here, but the problem is that it comes off as presumptuous at best and terribly arrogant and dismissive at worst.
Unless I'm totally off, Bill Clinton is really saying something like, "There are a lot of hard working people in America that are struggling to make ends meet. They are the ones who most desperately need leadership right now." I think this is a pretty fair paraphrase (I could definitely write some snarkier versions if you like!)
The problem is that this implies that he doesn't think that any of these people are voting for Obama. Unfortunately, Wisconsin showed that Hillary's stock is on the decline with the white working class. Whether Bill does or doesn't have a point, how far do you think insulting these people goes toward winning back their support.
February 24, 2008 8:49 PM | Reply | Permalink
Matt, this line of Bill's has upset me, too, from the first time I heard it. It's quite obvious he is trying adapt an old conservative line of attack, by pushing the idea that Obama voters are nothing more than a coalition of the (Volvo-driving, latte-sipping) elite and young political neophytes (students) who can afford to dabble in the Obama campaign as a hobby.
Funny how quickly Bill forgets what an important part African-Americans and young voters played in his campaigns. I suppose neither group no longer needs a President?
But the Clinton Administration wasn't consistently wonderful news for working people of any age or background. As DF wrote above, blue collar voters in Wisconsin and elsewhere have been gradually trending toward Obama as they get to know him better. I'm a lower income voter and lifetime loyal Democrat who has plenty of concrete, policy-related needs (from consumer and academic debt to healthcare) -- and I'm an Obama supporter. I think it's terrible that Bill Clinton has stooped to the point of trying to write people like me out of existence in their desperate grasp for the nomination. That's not the Bill Clinton I volunteered and voted for in '92 and '96 That Bill Clinton was hopeful and inclusive; he promised "to stand up for the forgotten middle class". Now we don't exist --unless we support his wife.
February 25, 2008 2:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
The Americans whe need a president... Like the pharmaceutical corporations, and the insurance companies, and the health care industry. Oh- and the defense contractors and international agribusiness. They know Hillary is best. After all she knows how Washington works from day one.
February 25, 2008 3:19 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment