"In Mosul, in 2003, it felt like we were making the city a better place
(but now, on his third deployment), "We killed a man who was setting a roadside bomb. And when we searched the bomber's body, we found identification showing that he was a sergeant in the Iraqi Army.
"I thought, What are we doing here? Why are we still here? We're helping guys that are trying to kill us. We help them in the day. They turn around at night and try to kill us.
"If we stayed here for five, even ten more years, the day we leave here these guys will go crazy. It would go straight into a civil war. That's how it feels, like we're putting a band-aid on this country until we leave here."--Staff Sgt. David Safstrom, Delta Company, 1st Battalion, 325th Airborne Infantry, 82nd Airborne Division.
"In 2003, 2004, 100 percent of the soldiers wanted to be here, to fight this war. Now, 95 percent of my platoon agrees with me." (that we should get out.)--Sgt. First Class David Moore, platoon sergeant., same unit, self-described "conservative Texas Republican"
"The Iraqi Army would not fight with us. Some actually picked up weapons and fought against us
Before that fight, there were a few true believers. After that, I don't think you'll find a true believer in this unit. They're paratroopers. There's no question they'll fulfill their mission. But they're fighting now for pride in their unit, professionalism, loyalty to their fellow soldiers, and chain of command."--Capt. Douglas Rogers, same unit.
"I don't believe we should be here in the middle of a civil war. We've all lost friends over here. Most of us don't know what we're fighting for anymore. We're serving our country and our friends, but the only reason we go out every day is for each other.
"I don't want any more of my guys to get hurt or die. If it was something I felt righteous about, maybe. But for this country and this conflict, no, it's not worth it."--Sgt. Kevin O'Flarity, squad leader, same unit
(source: "As Allies Turn Foe,Disillution Rises in Some G.I.'s," by Michael Kamber, New York Times, May 28, 2007.)
"They feed us (the intelligence) that they want. I guarantee that everyone in the city knows where we're going. Because the Iraqi Army told them. The only thing they don't know is how big a force we're coming with
It's a debacle."--Spec. Josh Lake, 26, of Ventura, Calif., Apache Company, 1st Battalion, 23rd Infantry Regiment, Stryker Brigade
"The general feeling among us is we're not really doing anything here. We clear one neighborhood, then another one fires up. It's an ongoing battle. It never ends. It's just the same old bull."--Spec. Daniel Caldwell, 20, Montesano, Wash., same unit
"We're constantly being told that it's not our fight. It is their fight." (the Iraqi Army) "But that's not the case. Whenever we go and ask them for guys, they almost always say no, and we have to do the job ourselves."--Sgt. Jose Reynoso, 24, Yuma, Ariz., same unit
"You do have corruption problems among the ranks
They have militias inside them. They are pretty much everywhere. We're chasing ghosts."--Sgt. Justin Hill, 24, Abilene, Tex., same unit
(source: "U.S. Unit Patrolling Baghdad Sees Flaws in Bush Strategy," by Sudarsan Raghavan, Washington Post,, January 12, 2007.)
"To be honest, it's going to be like this for a long time to come, no matter what we do. I think some people in America don't want to know about all this violence, about all the killings. The people back home are shielded from it; they get it sugar-coated."--Army 1st Lt. Antonio Hardy, 2nd Brigade, 2nd Infantry Division
"What is victory supposed to look like? Every time we turn around and go in a new area there's somebody new waiting to kill us. Sunnis and Shiites have been fighting for thousands of years, and we're not going to change that overnight.
"Once more raids start happening, they'll (insurgents) melt away. And then two or three months later, when we leave and say it was a success, they'll come back."--Sgt. 1st Class Herbert Gill, 29, Pulaski, Tenn.,1st Infantry Divisiont
"We can go get into a firefight and empty out ammo, but it doesn't accomplish much. This isn't our war--we're just caught in the middle."--Pvt. 1st Class Zach Clouser, 19, York, Penn., 2nd Infantry Division
"They can keep sending more and more troops over here, but until the people here start working with us, its not going to change."--Sgt. Chance Oswalt, 22, Tulsa, Okla., 2nd Infantry Division
(source: "Soldiers in Iraq View Troop Surge as Lost Cause," by Tom Lasseter, McClatchy Newspapers, February 3, 2007.)
"Why are we here when this country still to date does not want us here? Why does our president's personal agenda consume him so much, that he can not pay attention to what is really going on here? I'm still here in this country wondering why, and having to pick up the pieces of what is left of my friend in our room. I would just like to know what is the true reason we are here? This country poses no threat to our own. So why must we waste the lives of good men on a country that does not give a damn about itself? Most of my friends here share my views, but do not have the courage to say anything."--Pvt. Donald C. Hudson, Jr., 1st Brigade Special Troops Battalion, 1st Brigade Combat Team, 82nd Airborne Division
(source: "A Soldier in Iraq Asks in Despair: Why Are We Here?" by Donald C. Hudson, Jr., Clarksville, Tennessee Online, May 29, 2007.)
"When are we going to get out of here? We don't feel like we're making any progress."--Spc. David Williams, 22, Boston, Mass., 82nd Airborne Division, the first of five "surge" brigades to arrive in Iraq. This was a question he hoped to pose to Sen. Joseph Lieberman during a visit, but never did.
"We're not making any progress. It just seems like we drive around all day waiting to get shot at. It's just more troops, more targets. But I'd never really say that to the senator." (Lieberman). "I think I'd be a private if I did."--Spc. Will Heden, 21, Chester, Conn., same unit
"It's like everything else in this war. (referring to Baghdad) It hasn't changed."--Spec. Kevin Adams, 20, Moosup, Conn., same unit
"I think it's important we don't lose our will."--remarks made by Sen. Joseph Lieberman to the troops of the 82nd Airborne
(source: "Lieberman Talks to Troops in Baghdad," by Leila Fedel, McClatchy Newspapers, May 30, 2007.)
"In January, we were doing routine presence patrol through the city of Hawja, and one of our trucks was hit by a roadside bomb, an IED, and it killed four of the soldiers out of the five that were in the truck. And during the recovery of the fallen soldiers all the debris inside the truck--we just had the truck loaded with school supplies and soccer balls and crayons and notebooks and coloring books. We just wanna help. And it was just a really eye-opening and frustrating experience. Because we're still getting killed out there."--Spc. Kevin Torres, who appeared on 60 Minutes, out of uniform, to explain why he was one of several thousand soldiers and Marines to sign the Appeal for Redress petition to Congress to end the war.
(when asked by 60 Minutes correspondent Lara Logan, "What would you say to the people that say, 'All right, it's clear that the war in Iraq is incredibly difficult and life is really tough both for Americans and for Iraqis, but pulling out's not the answer. It's only gonna get worse. There's gonna be all-out civil war.'"):
"How does that become the default? Either someday, we have to leave. We can't stay in Iraq for the next thousand years."
(asked if there's a possibility that Iraq might be better off if American troops stay and finish the job):
"But then our lives are hanging in the balance of a flip of a coin
We volunteered to make a difference, not just to be part of an experiment."--Sgt. Ronn Cantu, answering her on the program
(source: "G.I.'s Petition Congress to End Iraq War," CBS News, Sunday, February 25, 2007.)
"We really don't want to go to Iraq, but we joined the military out of economic necessity. I'm scared. I just want people to know that we didn't want to go over there. We're not looking forward to it. People are over there dying and suffering. Nothing has been accomplished. We've sacrificed a lot of our time, and a lot of people have died for this. And for what?" --female Army soldier, due to deploy soon, who chose not to reveal her name, rank, or unit designation from fear of repercussions
(source: "Opposition to the War Growing Among Troops," by Sarah Olson, truthout.org, March 28, 2007.)
"What do you want us to accomplish over here? We aren't hearing any end state. We aren't hearing it from the president, from the defense secretary
We're working hard and the politicians are arguing. They don't have bullets flying over their heads. They aren't on the front lines, and their buddies aren't dying.
"
We're not complaining. We're tired of being lost. Have you ever been lost and at the same time getting shot at? It's miserable
I want to be here for a reason, not just a show of force."--Sgt. 1st Class Michael Eaglin, 1st Battalion, 5th Cavalry Regiment, 1st Cavalry Division
"It's almost like the Vietnam War. We dont know where we're going."--Spec. Adam Hamilton, same unit
(source: "Troops at Baghdad Outposts Seek Safety in Fortifications," by Ann Scott Tyson, Washington Post, May 8, 2007)
"There is an organized, constructive level of dissent with the ranks on this war
It's not political when people heed the call of their conscience. Not one more of my brothers should die for a lie. This is my generation's call to conscience."--Sgt. Liam Madden, 22, 31st Marine Expeditionary Unit, served in Iraq, 2003--assembling out of uniform to present the Appeal for Redress petition to Congress on Monday, January 15, 2007
(source: "Service Members Rally Against the War in Iraq," by William H. McMichael, The Navy Times, January 15, 2007.)
"One of the key things we all have in common is this frustration with the detachment that we see all around us, this idea that we're at war and everybody else is watching American Idol.
"It's tough to have such a serious sense of commitment, and then come home and see so many people focused on frivolous things. So I think this frustration is serious and growing. And I'll tell you the truth: I blame the president for that. One of the biggest criticisms of the president, and I hear this across the board, is that he hasn't asked the American people to do anything.
"Asking somebody to die for their country might not be the biggest thing you can ask. Asking my guys to kill, on my orders--as an officer, that's difficult. I'm telling that kid to squeeze that round off and take a man's life. And then he's got that baggage for the rest of his life. That's what you have to live with."--Paul Rieckhoff, former Army infantry officer, Iraq vet, co-founder of IAVA--Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America and anti-war activist. He is the author of the book, Chasing Ghosts, about his experiences in Iraq.
(source: "An Invisible War," New York Times op-ed, by Bob Herbert, May 3, 2007. Subscription required.)
"We are not fighting the war on terrorism, we are in the middle of a civil war. Meanwhile, the guy who attacked this country on 9/11 is living in a cave in Afghanistan
(Vice President) "Cheney is a draft-dodger. We've got a president who frankly knows nothing of war and a vice-president who knows even less. Senators on the fence have a choice. They can stand with veterans like us, or they can stand with the draft-dodgers down the road."--Jon Stoltz, 29, Iraq war veteran, co-founder of VoteVets.org, which has 20,000 members, including 1,000 veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan.
(source: "Veteran's Group Speaks Out on War," by Lyndsey Layton and Jonathan Weisman, Washington Post,, February 8, 2007.)
"First and foremost, we should never have gone into Iraq. I felt betrayed by the commanders who said they'd find a way to make this war work, when they knew it wasn't practical. This was a betrayal of the men and women who are fighting in Iraq.
"You can protect the institution of the military through silence. To protect the men and women fighting this war, you have to speak up. There is no courage or honor in silence.
"From the very founding of this nation, patriotism was going against the grain for the greater good of the country. A true patriot is not afraid to look out for the best interests of the nation and its citizens. Today, we are using patriotism to subdue people, to convince them not to exercise their rights. Are we really serving the citizens well by being in Iraq? I think the truth is no, we're not.
"There's story upon story from people who say, 'I can't believe I'm going back for my third or fourth tour. They are all saying they have the same problems, on the streets, as they had when they left.
"I was frustrated that so many people in significant leadership positions remained silent about the war
People are dying. Families have been torn apart. This war is sucking the life out of our military. I cannot stay silent. I need to say that I am concerned enough to put my reputation at risk to point out that this war is wrong."--Chief Master Sgt. Jeff Slocum, 41, United States Air Force. Slocum spent 21 years in the military and planned to retire after 30 years, but has decided to leave the military and speak out.
(source: "War Causes Air Force Chief Master Sergeant to Change Course," by Sarah Olsen, for Truthout.org, April 24, 2007.)
ARMY REGULATION 530-1: OPERATIONS SECURITY (OPSEC): "An OPSEC review is required prior to publishing web log (blog) postings, comments on internet message boards, resumes, letters home
Failure to do so could result in court-martial or administrative, disciplinary, contractual, or criminal action.
"Effective immediately, no information may be placed on websites
unless it has been reviewed
The Army Web Risk Assessment Cell has been formed to scan blogs for information breaches and security violations."--"Army Squeezes Soldier Blogs, Maybe to Death," by Noah Schachtman, Wired.com, May 2, 2007.
The Pentagon has placed unprecedented restrictions on who can testify before Congress, reserving the right to bar lower-ranking officers, enlisted soldiers, and career bureaucrats from appearing before oversight committees or having their remarks transcribed, according to Defense Department documents.
Robert L. Wilkie, a former Bush administration national security official who left the White House to become assistant secretary of Defense for legislative affairs last year, has outlined a half-dozen guidelines that prohibit most officers and civilians appointed by President Bush.
The guidelines, described in an April 19 memo to the staff director of the House Armed Services Committee, adds that all field-level officers and enlisted personnel must be "deemed appropriate" by the Department of Defense before they can participate in personal briefings for members of Congress or their staffs; in addition, according to the memo, the proceedings must not be recorded.
Wilkie's memo also stipulated that any officers who are allowed to testify must be accompanied by an official from the administration, such as Secretary of Defense Robert Gates or his top-level aides.
Both Democrats and Republicans in Congress see the move as a blatant attempt to bog down investigations of the war. But veterans of the legislative process--who say they have never heard of such guidelines before--maintain that the Pentagon has no authority to set such ground rules.--"Pentagon Restricting Testimony in Congress; Blocks Staff of Lower Rank," by Bryan Bender, Boston Globe, May 10, 2007
"When I returned from the war, almost 40 years ago now, I stood up and spoke from my heart and my gut about what I thought was wrong. I asked the question in 1971: How do you ask a man to be the last man to die for a mistake?...I never thought that I would be reliving the need to ask that question again." --Senator John Kerry, in remarks made January 29, 2007, as quoted in, "Soldier's Death Strengthens Senators' Antiwar Resolve," by Jonathan Weisman and Ann Scott Tyson, Washington Post, January 30, 2007