TPMCafe
« Terror Trials and the Loss of Faith in American Strength | Home | Jobs and Change, Communications and Energy »

Bail out our schools

user-pic

Any day now, the Obama administration will announce $4.35 billion in extra federal funds for under-performing public schools. That's fine, but relative to the financial squeeze all the nation's public schools now face it's a cruel joke.

The recession has ravaged state and local budgets, most of which aren't allowed to run deficits. That's meant major cuts in public schools and universities, and a giant future deficit in the education of our people.

Across America, schools are laying off thousands of teachers. Classrooms that had contained 20 to 25 students are now crammed with 30 or more. School years have been shortened. Some school districts are moving to four-day school weeks. After-school programs have been cancelled; music and art classes, terminated. Even history is being chucked.

Pre-K programs have been shut down. Community colleges are reducing their course offerings and admitting fewer students. Public universities, like the one I teach at, have raised tuitions and fees. That means many qualified students won't be attending.

Last year the nation committed $700 billion to bail out Wall Street banks, the engines of America's financial capital, because we were told we'd face economic Armegeddon if we didn't.

We've got our priorities backwards. Our schools are the engines of our human capital, and if we don't bail out public education we face a bigger economic Armegeddon years from now.

Financial capital moves instantly around the globe to wherever it can earn the best return. Human capital - the skills and insights of our people - is the one resource that's uniquely American, on which our future living standards uniquely depend.

Starting immediately, the federal government should give states and local governments interest-free loans to make up for all school and university budget shortfalls. The loans can be repaid when the recession is over and local and state tax revenues revive.

Over the longer term we must shift incentives away from financial capital toward human capital. A tiny one half of one percent tax on all financial transactions would generate about $200 billion a year, according to the Economic Policy Institute. That might put a crimp on Wall Street bonuses but it's enough to fund early childhood education, smaller K-12 classes, and lower tuitons and fees for public higher education.

The Street's financial capital is important to the American economy, but over the long term the classroom's human capital is absolutely crucial.


39 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I believe we are all keenly aware that President Obama and his fine Secretary of Education have studied the problem of underperforming schools and have identified the problems, not as a lack of funds to attract the brightest and best educators, nor funds to see that children do not come to school hungry, nor funds for decaying physical plant, nor bloated and overpaid administrative staffs. The problem of course is the teachers, so much so that they applaud the firing of the entire faculty
http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2010/03/02/obama_seeks_accountability_in_underachieving_schools/

Said the VERY liberal and VERY fair-minded, hell, VERY decent man Obama :
"In his speech, Obama said the firing of the entire faculty at a Rhode Island school is an example of how there has to be accountability. Officials in Central Falls decided last week to fire 93 high school teachers, administrators, and other support staff by the end of the year."

No. Nothing about the administrators who presided over the school's decline and then scapegoated and fired the workers. Accountability does not begin with the misdeeds of the Bush-Cheney regime, nor of the bankers who brought down the economic system. Our VERY smart president knows exactly who is to blame for this problem. It is the entire faculty of an underperforming school. Nevermind a serious infusion of funds to repair our failing human infrastructure. We have "Race to the Top" the newest gimmick replacing "No Child Left Behind" and "Vouchers". With demographic moves that make only suburban and private schooling of import, the goal is no longer genral excellence in public education. We can replace it by failing schools and rhetoric that indicates phony concern and scapegoating workers.
At least in Education policy our VERY bipartisan president has achieved his VERY bipartisan goals with Gingrich endorsing the policy with full-throated approval:
http://www.correntewire.com/bipartisanshit_obamas_education_policy_endorsed_newt_gingrich_al_sharpton

"The Black Agenda Report has been documenting the atrocities of the Obama education policy, including the traveling sales trio of Gingrich, Sharpton and Education Secretary Duncan. Now, why, you may ask, would Newt Gingrich endorse Obama's education policies? And shouldn't such an endorsement be a huge red flag to anyone who thinks government - and public schools - should and can work since, you know, Gingrich has spent his entire career working to destroy government.

There are at least two reasons that I can see why Gingrich - and any corporatist - would love Obama's education policies. First, Obama is giving away 4.35 billion dollars as part of the stimulus to try to improve schools. Good, right? But here's the catch, to be eligible for the giveaway, the state has to embrace charter schools. Now you might think that a big fancy study by Stanford University that found charter schools less successful overall than public schools would at least raise a question about whether pouring even more tax dollars into these private-run schools is a good idea, but you'd be wrong. Because, quite simply, there is no amount of empirical evidence that can stop bipartisan doubling down on bad policy (see, e.g., TARP). So even though there is no evidence charter schools do better than public schools (in fact, there's evidence of the opposite), you cannot get any of this additional money unless your state embraces charter schools. To be followed, of course, by studies which show charters, having gotten an extra $5 billion pumped into them, perform better than public education. At least, I'm sure that's what they're hoping will happen. It will make replacing your school board with a corporation so much easier."

user-pic

Firing all the teachers was only one more way of cutting the budget. It got rid of all those experienced teachers who had enough years and experience that they were being paid above the minimum and allows them to be replaced with first year teachers who will start at the minimum wage for teachers.

What this completely ignores is the role parents play in the educational process. When parents downplay the benefits of education, and promote ignorance, their children do not get educated, no matter what the teachers do or do not do.

When parents emphasize the role education plays in prosperity, and encourage their children to get an education, those children prosper.

Place the blame where it belongs, not with the children, or with their teachers, but with the parents.

Firing experienced teachers en-masse was just plain stupid.
.

user-pic

I strongly agree with the thrust of your comment namely that broader social issues play a compelling role in the level of achievement in schools (I would greatly broaden the responsibility from parents to the society at large). It is little known but I remember reading of a study that documented an incredibly high level of achievement in schools that were educating former slaves after the civil war. The scholarly achievements were striking and enormous, but of course reconstruction, jim crow, bigotry, poverty, lack of jobs has had an incredibly dispiriting and discouraging effect on the children of these same individuals. It is not the teachers alone that have gotten worse it is the whole view of education and the value we put on it as a society (or the lack thereof).
I think firing teachers en masse, and then Obama and Duncan applauding it, is a rotten, rotten, immoral act.

user-pic

We seem to 'value' education - $160 billion to the states - far less than we 'value' AIG - $180 billion - and as to the $4 billion? Apparently that's what fell on the floor after Wall Street's feast - and the dogs didn't get.

Facebook

What youre saying is completely true. children health

Facebook

I do agree with all the ideas you have presented in your post. They’re very convincing and will definitely work. Still, the posts are very short for starters. Could you please extend them a bit from next time? Thanks for the post.by healthy families and child health plus

user-pic

If American policy is going to be dictated by the intellectual heirs of the Hessian redcoats, whose latter-day counterparts, woefully ignorant of basic American history, employ the name of the opposition to the redcoats, the tea party, then there is little need for education in the USA. If President Palin doesn't know if Africa is a country or a continent, why should anyone else bother to do more than learn a little Chinese?

user-pic

What's $4B about what we spend in Iraq in 2 weeks?

We know where the money is.

And are still we kidding ourselves that our national security lies in competing against Iraqis and Afghanis while we ignore competition from China India?

user-pic

The "coalition" governments in Iraq and Afghanistan have been designed to be the most corrupt administrations in the world.

They are just great for funneling money from the US taxpayer into the pockets of the military contractors like KBR and Halliburton who then "donate" a small portion of it to the political campaigns of Senators and Representatives to continue the "War on Terra" so more US taxpayer money can be funneled to military contractors.
.

user-pic

Money spent on schools goes largely to low paid teachers, and other school workers. It does not go to "investors", the wealthy class, who want more, more, more $$ in their accounts. I think that explains why there is unlimited money available for ravaging Iraq and Afghanistan, but none for schools. It explains why it was so easy to find $700 billion for Wall Street banks, but so hard to find less than 10% of that for schools.

Our government exists primarily to help transfer our money to the wealthy. Until that changes, nothing else will.

user-pic

In my state the teachers union sent teachers to Nevada (2500 miles) to work with ACORN to commit voter fraud. Now the schools are on furlow one Friday a month due to lack of funds.

user-pic

Be sure to post that confirmed data about the voter fraud. If that were not substantiated, I know you wouldn't make these allegations. So we're waiting.

user-pic

You can see it right there - the education cuts have rendered inokeah unable to spell "furlough" correctly. :)

But seriously, even Faux News has dropped the "ACORN voter fraud" meme for lack of evidence. That's a pretty strong statement...

user-pic

It is a strong statement.

They probably heard from ACORN's lawyers about knowingly making false and defamatory statements. Doubt that inokeah has yet, though.

Still waiting for his data.

user-pic

Rather than the federal government loaning money to the states, why not implement permanent changes to the tax code so that state governments are allowed to keep more of their money?

The public education system has been going down the proverbial toilet in this country for 30 years. Bush's No Child Left Behind should prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that any federal "one size fits all" education policy is simply not going to work. The reason, obviously, is that all 50 states have specific nooks and crannies that need remedying. Problem is, the broad strokes of a federal education program usually leave these specified problem areas neglected.

If states were allowed to keep more of their citizen's tax dollars, then the various legislatures could allocate money to these nooks and crannies.

Trying to find ways to make federal programs work (when they've been failing for decades) is like trying to stick a square peg in a round hole.

The health care dilemma, also, would be easier solved at the state level.

Facebook

thanks for useful information!


Best regards, Mary, CEO of youtube to mp3

user-pic

Someone has to say it:

1.) There is no stomach, *to put it mildly indeed,* in U.S. politics for additional spending until we get things under control.

2.) But what if this is really, really important?
Then see no. 1, above.

I might even go out on a limb for all of you blame-Obama-firsters, and suggest this is not entirely Obama's fault.

user-pic

"1.) There is no stomach, *to put it mildly indeed,* in U.S. politics for additional spending until we get things under control."

Bullshit.

What is lacking in US politics is the stomach for paying (by raising taxes) for the spending that is being authorized and mandated by Congress.

Congress has also spent all the money that was set aside for Social Security and now they want to declare that fund bankrupt when the Federal Government ows it over $4 Trillion dollars.

user-pic

This is politics. What am I to take from your comment?

There *is* political will for such things? Or what?

user-pic

Take it that there IS a will in Congress to spend more and more money that they don't have.
.

user-pic
Now you might think that a big fancy study by Stanford University that found charter schools less successful overall than public schools...

Since public schools overall have a much lower percentage of at risk kids, that is not much of an indicator of anything other than how to cherry pick data.

OTOH, a Democrat proposing full funding for the teacher's union that in turn funds Democrats is no surprise.

user-pic

I saw a story of a school in Califonia where one History class had had 12 teachers is 6 months, now considering the importance of teacher-student relationships, that is a confusing situation for even the brightest students.

user-pic

A look back at recent history provides a glaring example of how a country fares run by an under-educated, and in our case a more and more illiterate populace.

Russia following WWI and the Revolution, which killed off a vast number of the educated, was run by former (uneducated) peasants - and we know how well that went.

user-pic

Everybody thinks they know how to fix schools. There are educational fads, theories, demands, quick fixes. No one ever asks teachers or students what will work for them. It's always some overpaid consultant, or one of the ghouls who make a living going from district to district hiring on as superintendent for a few years, implementing their pet theories and moving on to greener pastures.

Simple steps to better schools: free early childhood education, all day kindergarten, smaller classes, better teacher education, administration geared to what is best for students, social services for kids who come to school hungry, sick, beaten, abused, from a shelter or sleeping in the car. Programs that involve parents, even those parents who don't have the time or the inclination to show up, mentors for teachers and for students, current materials, texts, and supplemental books, electronic literacy and computers that aren't 10 years old.

Even half of the list above would improve schools enormously. But this country only gives lip service to caring about children. Like so many other things in 21st century America, if you want a good education for your children, you are on your own.

user-pic

Is there any reason now that children should not attend schools all year?

The original reason for having the summer off was that children were considered an asset working on the family farm. The USA is long past that stage.

So, why aren't children at school all year long?
.

user-pic

Great stuff for writing my project in college. Good topic for my essay writing.

Jim

user-pic

I like this essay writing materials!

Facebook

Reading this makes me sad
Thanks
Repair Pst File

Facebook

Why? can you tell me.. SBOBET | Gadget News

Facebook

I agree with you that starting immediately, the federal government should give states and local governments interest-free loans to make up for all school and university budget shortfalls. ReallyThe loans can be repaid when the recession is over and local and state tax revenues revive.

Facebook

I agree with you that starting immediately, the federal government should give states and local governments interest-free loans to make up for all school and university budget shortfalls. Really, the loans can be repaid when the recession is over and local and state tax revenues revive.

Sofia by iscsi Software

Facebook

A tiny one half of one percent tax on all financial transactions would generate about $200 billion a year, according to the Economic Policy Institute.Trinity Arcade St Georges Terrace Perth Albedo Photography Perth Wedding Photographer.. That might put a crimp on Wall Street bonuses but it's enough to fund early childhood education, smaller K-12 classes, and lower tuitons and fees for public higher education.

Facebook

The post is pretty interesting. I really never thought I could have a good read by this time until I found out this site. I am grateful for the information given. Your writing is also very excellent. Thanks by plc | landlord insurance

Facebook

I will be your frequent visitor... swiffer wet jet | Vicks Cool Mist Humidifier

Facebook

I choose my friends for their good looks, my acquaintances for their good characters, and my enemies for their intellects. A man cannot be too careful in the choice of his enemies. auto insurance quotes online

Facebook

A principle is the expression of perfection, and as imperfect beings like us cannot practice perfection, we devise every moment limits of its compromise in practice. buy insurance| submit articles

Facebook

A nation which has forgotten the quality of courage which in the past has been brought to public life is not as likely to insist upon or regard that quality in its chosen leaders today - and in fact we have forgotten. online games to play for free | imobiliare

Facebook

I have nothing against protests. As long as they don’t turn into riots, protests are constructive. People should have the chance to prove their point and if that’s the only way they can make themselves clear, let it be! 19.000 teachers! That is cool! I’m amazed they had the courage to do this. They must have had a good leader. Probably some of them got a criminal justice degree online. It surely helped them organize such an event.

Facebook

It's interesting concept, i wonder if it will really increase sales tho, hopefully it does work. I appreciated all the usefull information keep up the good work. oem software downloads

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address