TPMCafe
« Progressive Taxes Win Big In Oregon | Home | This Just in, on Earmarks and Public Paralysis »

The Sky is Falling -- on John Bolton

user-pic

John Bolton has made a cottage industry out of trying to scare people about nuclear weapons. Contrary to the subtitle of Dr. Strangelove - "how I learned to stop worrying and love the bomb" - Bolton's motto seems to be "why you need to start worrying and embrace the bomb." He reiterates this point at every opportunity, most recently in a piece published in the Washington Examiner. But does he really believe that the Obama administration's modest but essential first steps towards reducing global nuclear arsenals are putting us in grave danger? I seriously doubt it.

Bolton believes in maintaining the status quo, a world in which the United States and Russia possess 95% of the world's arsenal of 20,000-plus nuclear weapons and it's not worth even trying to use diplomacy to reduce those arsenals, much less those of other nuclear powers. In his most recent piece, he even appears to dismiss President Obama's pledge to secure "all vulnerable nuclear materials in four years, so that they never fall into the hands of terrorists." What's Bolton's logic here? Do we need to leave loose nukes and unsecured bomb-making materials lying around to show we're tough? Or is he just so intent on opposing anything that the Obama administration is for that he will oppose even the most effective policies available for reducing the nuclear danger?

What are Bolton's alternatives to diplomacy? Bombing Iran? He has implied as much, even though the effects of such an action would most likely be to undermine the Iranian opposition, accelerate Tehran's efforts to seek a nuclear weapon, and sow further chaos in a region that can ill afford it. Invading North Korea? Even he doesn't seem willing to go that far over the top.

Instead of quaking in our boots at the prospect of nuclear arms cuts, as Bolton would like us to do, we need to look at the real security benefits of a multi-faceted approach to achieving substantial reductions. These steps should include a new nuclear arms reduction agreement (START), followed shortly thereafter by negotiations for even deeper cuts in U.S. and Russian arsenals; a global ban on all nuclear weapons tests (the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty); accelerated investments in securing all nuclear weapons and bomb-making materials; increased investments in the inspection capabilities of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA); a concerted effort to solve the Kashmir problem and improve relations between India and Pakistan to the point that each nation will feel secure in reducing its nuclear arsenal; and a renewed global effort to get Iran and North Korea to curb and then reverse their nuclear weapons programs. Some of these steps are obviously harder - much harder - than others. But each of them is valuable in its own right, and we can't afford not to pursue them.

It's important to remember that there has been considerable success in reducing nuclear weapons over the past two decades. Since the end of the Cold War, more than twice as many countries have abandoned nuclear weapons or bomb-making programs as have initiated them. Total nuclear weapons stockpiles are down by over two-thirds since their peak in the mid-1960s. And programs like the Nunn-Lugar program - which invests in dismantling and securing Russian nuclear bombs and nuclear materials - have made impressive strides. There is no reason why we can't build on these successes to accomplish further reductions in nuclear weapons, making the world a far safer place in the process. We just need to make sure people don't buy into the scare talk of John Bolton and his cohorts.


11 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Re: Your title

It's a pity the sky is not made of bowling balls.

Facebook

Thanks for your patience and sorry for the inconvenience!

Best regards, Mary, CEO of youtube video downloader

user-pic

“Bolton believes in maintaining the status quo, a world in which the United States and Russia possess 95% of the world's arsenal of 20,000-plus nuclear weapons …”

Estimated worldwide nuclear stockpiles, 2009

Country: Total Warheads: Population

1. Russia: 13,000 / 142,000,000
2. United States: 9,400 / 307,000,000
3. Israel (undeclared): max 450 / 7,400,000
4. France: 300 / 65,000,000
5. China: 240 / 1,332,000,000
6. United Kingdom: 185 / 62,000,000
7. India: 60 / 1,167,000,000
8. Pakistan: 60 / 167,000,000
9. North Korea: 10 / 24,000,000


Bolton and Obama both subscribe to policies that are grossly misconceived because there is one state that is an undeclared nuclear power, courtesy of the US that has colluded in the absurdly dangerous and misleading policy of ‘nuclear ambiguity’. This state has been deliberately ignored in the proposed nuclear arms reduction and is, astonishingly, allowed to be hidden from the IAEA inspectorate, with the obvious approval of the White House.

Could it be possible that a state with only one thousandth (1/1000) of the global population should be the third most powerful nuclear entity on the planet? If so, then nuclear arms reduction is merely a myth to gain political points. Just smoke and mirrors.

user-pic

Who pays Bolton ? He is a shill for some group with money. Arms manufacturers, maybe ? Of course the money is laundered through an 'Institute'.

These guys like Bolton stay remarkably on message ... ever wonder why ?

user-pic

Always the right question. WHERE IN THE HELL DOES THE MONEY COME FROM.

And defense contractors have got to be funneling money to this traitorous bastard. They are the only ones who benefit from arms proliferation.

user-pic

I don't wonder why he stays on message, but I do wonder why he keeps getting a forum to spout his beliefs.

user-pic

"a renewed global effort to get Iran and North Korea to curb and then reverse their nuclear weapons programs"

M. Hartung will be interested to learn that while North Korea has already tested nuclear weapons, Iran doesn't even have a nuclear weapon program to reverse.

user-pic

This was a great post and I had no idea he had these beliefs! Well its great we can all have an opinion in America and hopefully it will stay that way.

Thanks Carla Martin
Sport Sandals Designer

Facebook

Hi, i am a student of medical university and i thank you a lot for this information. I found it very interesting and useful. Hubschrauber Rundflug

Facebook

Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. Thanks. gulen charter schools

Facebook

Well, the article is actually the sweetest topic on this related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your forthcoming updates. Saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the tremendous lucidity in your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates. one source talent scam

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address