Save Israel From Its Rightwing Destroyers
The far right really is intimidated by J Street.
Check out this limp hit by Lenny Ben David, the West Bank settler who has been tasked with smearing J Street by investigating its donors. Lenny, who was sent packing by AIPAC after 25 years, now sits in his settlement working to bring down the organization (J Street) that hugely irritates the people who let him go. Weird.
But Lenny is like an old Stasi wannabe. At AIPAC, he used to set up spy ops against liberals, doves, and anyone who had the temerity to criticize the settlement enterprise. Then he would compile files against the troublemakers and try to make their lives miserable.
But Lenny left America a long time ago. And his tactics don't work anymore, not on the Israel issue anyway. Most Americans' response to be called out for a lack of loyalty to Israel don't take offense. We don't live there.
But the rightwing nuts think we can be shamed into confession like in the Salem witch trials. "Enough already. We love the settlements. We too are Israel firsters."
In the piece I link to, Lenny does his usual guilt-by-association number. And, like his role models at Fox News, Lenny views the worst associate of all to be Holocaust survivor, financial genius and philanthropist George Soros.
Rightwing Jews and others use Soros the way the Nazis used...the Jews. He is their all-purpose bogey man. Types like Lenny despise Soros because Soros is a racial liberal, supported Obama and does not support right-wing Jewish causes.
To Lenny and his ilk, Soros is a cosmopolitan Jew, someone who refuses to limit his concerns to any one group. No, through his Open Society and a host of other programs, Soros has improved the lives of tens of millions. But the Lennies are furious that he doesn't support the Likud platform or any form of ethnic chauvinism. The Jewish right, like anti-semites, insist that Jews are united by ties of blood and that, wherever we live, our loyalties are to each other. Not true by a long shot and Soros, for sure, doesn't buy it.
Soros is a great man and a great Jew. But no blood nationalist.
Lenny also tries to hit J Street by citing its support for the Saudi peace plan, also known as the Arab Peace Initiative.
The Arab Initiative offers Israel full peace and normalization with the entire Arab world in exchange for an Israeli withdrawal from the '67 territories. It is not automatic. The initiative incorporates a host of agreements and resolutions which are already out there. Israelis and Arabs would negotiate the final terms of an agreement.
Both the United States and the Israeli government have praised the Saudi initiative although neither has acted on their endorsement.
But the settlers are terrified of the Saudi plan because, if it is implemented, their colonies will disappear.
And that is why Lenny is penning screeds. He's scared.
And he knows that J Street's efforts can help achieve the negotiations the Arab Initiative proposes. And that may force him out of the West Bank and back to Israel. And he's scared so that so few Jewish Americans share his world view. If they did, they'd emigrate like he did.
So, sitting on his settlement, Lenny goes to work. One last point. As you'll see from his column, Lenny despises Arabs of any kind, including Arab-Americans. That is why he likes to find connections between Jewish liberals and the oh-so-terrifying two-state-supporting Democratic activist and Christian Arab-American, James Zogby.
In Lenny's world, taking a dime from an Arab, Muslim or Christian, American or non-American, is a crime. It's like the anti-Semites with the Jews. (Lenny could just as easily attack J Street for taking money from HOLLYWOOD or MANHATTAN).
I'll stop here. Lenny is not worth the trouble. His significance is that he typifies a certain type of personality that is not ineffective in thwarting efforts to achieve Israeli-Palestinian peace. Left unchallenged, the Lennies will prevent an Israeli-Palestinian agreement, will engulf America in an Iran-Israel war, and, in general, endanger both America and Israel's chance to survive.
The ugly fact is that rightwingers in Israel are doing far more damage to Israel's chances to survive than irrelevant leftwing Israel haters outside like Norman Finkelstein. Save Israel from the Israeli right which loves the land but hates the state. Israel is too important to be lost, even if those who would bring about its extinction happen to live there (or, actually, in the West Bank).
Lenny is nothing. But a million Lennies is a big threat. Of course, the rest of us constitute many millions more. Don't get mad, organize.

















Nothing? So why does Ben-David get under your skin? And why don't you counter his charges? Your ad hominem say more about you than about Ben-David.
December 23, 2009 11:30 AM | Reply | Permalink
Lenny is someone I love to hate. At AIPAC, Lenny was about the only thing we all had in common. Even the awful Steve Rosen would sidle over to me to say "I have a great Lenny the Weasel story for you."
But even if I didn't know him, I'd go after him for being a lying, racist hater.
Address his points? No way. He makes them up. Lenny learned from his hero, I think it was George Gobel in Germany, that big lies are hard to counter.
Maybe his first name wasn't George.
PS Lenny is great. He is a religious fanatic so he can't watch television on Saturday. So he'd go over to a neighbor's house at game time and position himself so he could see the TV only out of the corner of his eye so GOD (or to Lenny, G-D) would be tricked. Lenny never missed a Saturday game and God never figured out Lenny's trip. God may be a little dim. Lenny is clever. That sideway sitting is smart.
I have to admit it. I love the guy. He is the only religious nut I ever knew and he taught me a lot. Then there is the time he sent out a fax denouncing Bibi Netanyahu as a creep on the very day Bibi hired him. It was so Lenny.
Got it, neighbour (fancyspelling for an American)
December 23, 2009 11:58 AM | Reply | Permalink
Fascinating how far Ben-David will stretch to try to construct a scary alliance between J Street and A-rabs -- really pushing every Islamophobic button in his hardline followers. That coalition of 30, of which J Street and the Arab American Institute were 2 signers, had a majority of Christian signatories -- most of whom were the heads of mainline denominations or organizations. J Street was also not the lone Jewish group represented:
December 23, 2009 3:55 PM | Reply | Permalink
I have nothing good to say for M. de Ben-Davîd, and indeed, I just finished scribbling a small nastygramme over to PJM myself, but . . .
But is it really wise to wash one's dirty communitarian laundry openly out in front of us miserable dhimmís like this?
And, while I'm up: are you ABSOLUTELY sure that there is UTTERLY no chance at all that Team Jabotinsky might prevail at the end of the bloody day?
Healthy days.
December 23, 2009 5:58 PM | Reply | Permalink
RE: "Team Jabotinsky" - John McCloskey
MY COMMENT: Good one! (lol)
Ze'ev Jabotinsky - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ze'ev_Jabotinsky
Revisionist Zionism - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revisionist_Zionism
December 23, 2009 6:27 PM | Reply | Permalink
Soros is a great man and a great Jew. Just like you. I missed your twitter comments this year about the annual Christmas Party you throw.
December 23, 2009 12:29 PM | Reply | Permalink
Exposed! We have a Christmas party and a son named Nicholas.
It's America, babycakes.
December 23, 2009 6:35 PM | Reply | Permalink
Nicholas, smickales, who cares. But is he Jewish?
December 25, 2009 6:21 AM | Reply | Permalink
Who cares?
December 25, 2009 8:51 AM | Reply | Permalink
I agree with you that the Soros I met in the 2000s is a great man. But he did make his fortune on the backs of many innocents. He broke the British pound and cost a lot of middle class British their jobs. He broke the Thai Bhat and inflicted even more pain.
I think he knows this. I think it, and his personal and family history have led him to do great things with the money he's made.
But there are losers in all of Soros' big trades. A lot of innocent losers. This is not an anti-Soros post. I admire the man. But I am anti-tycoon.
December 23, 2009 10:42 PM | Reply | Permalink
At this seasonal marker, M.J. perhaps its not too early to say to you before I forget:
Thanks a hell of a lot for fighting for sanity and justice here at TPM all through 2009 and enlightening those of us who have been prepared to receive the perspective! Much, much, much appreciated!
I hope you and your family have a great holiday season and a great New Year!
Your work here is extraordinarily valuable. I do not at all doubt that you will have wonderful contributions to offer on many levels in 2010.
My Holiday Best,
O.T.
December 24, 2009 12:00 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks,OT Same to you and yours
December 24, 2009 2:05 PM | Reply | Permalink
RE: "irrelevant leftwing Israel haters outside like Norman Finkelstein" - MJ
MY COMMENT: I'm not really that familiar with him, but you seem to judge him rather harshly. Might your opinion of him have (at least, partly) to do with issues other than his animosity towards Israel? I'm nonplussed (to say the least) by certain aspects of his "holocaust industry" notion. But then, (as a lawyer with a science degree) I laughed my way through Joan Peters' patently absurd book, so I tend to value his criticism of "From Time Immemorial".
December 24, 2009 1:46 PM | Reply | Permalink
I dislike Finkelstein because he rabidly hates Israel and supports Hezbollah. I never liked him but when he cheered on the Hezbollah rockets during the 2006 war, I decided that he is not about peace but simply hating Israel and everyone who lives there.
December 24, 2009 2:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
I don't understand the attacks on J Street that come even from some in the liberal Jewish community. I've have said some good things about J Street when shmoozing at my reform congregation and noticed some hostility coming from a few people. I guess the propaganda works in influencing opinion. That's a shame since I would think that most liberal Jews would probably agree more with J Street.
December 24, 2009 2:52 PM | Reply | Permalink
"Old Stasi wannabe"? Is that like MJ wanting to be an old Palmah 'Saison' activist? You know, kidnapping, beating up and handing over to the British CID members of the Irgun? Like that?
December 25, 2009 6:24 AM | Reply | Permalink
I have no Zionist pretensions so, no....
December 25, 2009 8:50 AM | Reply | Permalink
It seems to me that calling for two mutually recognizing states, based on the internationally-recognized 1967 border or a minor modification thereof, is not merely the "Saudi plan," as Settler David pretends, but the plan of America and practically the whole world except for Arab terrorists (who want no Israeli state) and Israeli terrorists (settlers) who want the entire West Bank to themselves (and thus no Palestinian state.)
At any rate, thanks for your many informative and hard-hitting columns this year, and best wishes for 2010 when sanity regarding the Mideast will continue to need outspoken support.
December 27, 2009 3:59 PM | Reply | Permalink
I hope you and your family have a great holiday season and a great New Year!
sikiş
December 8, 2010 11:51 AM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for your patience and sorry for the inconvenience!
Best regards, Mary, CEO of youtube download
December 16, 2010 10:08 AM | Reply | Permalink