TPMCafe
« Is Charlie Crist Anti-Business? | Home | Realists »

Sympathy for the Devil? Oprah and the Palin Blitz.

user-pic

I like Oprah Winfrey. She gets people to buy--if not actually read--books like Carson McCuller's The Heart is a Lonely Hunter and Tolstoy's Anna Karenina. She oozes the right amount of sympathy for people who have been mauled by chimpanzees and incest survivors and recovering drug addicts like Mackenzie Phillips. She's perfected the technique of humanizing celebrities and wringing heart-wrenching stories out of victims - it's good TV.

But that's exactly why Oprah did a terrible disservice to the public in today's interview with Sarah Palin, who is no victim and no ordinary celebrity. She's a politician who has carefully crafted a bogus narrative of victimization at the hands of McCain aides, the Washington elite and the mainstream media. And now with Going Rogue, she's trying to cement that story, neutralizing McCain staffers who say otherwise (see Sam Stein and Geoffrey Dunn's reporting at the Huffington Post), and stay relevant enough to make a bid for president in 2012, while continuing to flex her Facebook-Twitter muscles to torpedo Obama's agenda.

For most of the show, Oprah pitched Palin softballs and missed opportunity after opportunity to inject some reality into the conversation. Oprah asked Palin to talk at length about how the McCain campaign dealt with the news of Bristol's pregnancy. According to Palin, the McCain team painted a picture of happy grandparents instead of the more complicated mixture of disappointment and surprise that Palin and her husband actually felt. That might be true but somewhere along the line of questioning, shouldn't Oprah have mentioned Palin's support for abstinence-only sex education? What about when Palin claimed that Bristol - who was in the audience and is a Teen Abstinence Ambassador for the Candie's Foundation--was on a mission to educate American youth about the consequences of "unprotected sex"? Just what kind of "protected sex" does abstinence-only education teach?

Then there's the segment when Palin discussed at length the empathy she felt for women who have unintended or unwanted pregnancies. The "easy" way out is how Palin characterized abortion, casting her choice as heroic and making it seem as if she regarded abortion, personally, as the wrong option. But what Oprah failed to point out is that Palin wants women to have no choice at all - not even in cases of rape or incest.

When Oprah finally asked Palin about why she left the governor's office so abruptly, Palin suggested it was because journalists and opposition researchers from the Obama campaign had come up to Alaska, filed FOIAs (oh snap!) and started ethics investigations - making her an ineffective governor. But the ethics investigation into Troopergate began before Palin was nominated and not by Obama opposition researchers but by the Alaska state legislature. Palin made herself an ineffective governor by abusing her office - as the Branchflower report found--before she was even on the national radar. Notice also the conflation of journalists with political operatives. That's what Palin is now calling fact-checking of her book by AP reporters--"opposition research."

The entire effect of the show was to cast Sarah Palin as an ordinary American woman who has been thrust unwillingly into the political and media machine. Poor Palin--in her universe Katie "the Perky One" Couric badgers her incessantly with questions like--what's your policy on abortion or what magazines or newspapers do you read? And then there's McCain strategist Steve Schmidt who bullied and manipulated her into doing things she didn't want to do--like run for vice-president. In Palin's eyes - Schmidt's a marauding chimp. But just who does Oprah take us for - chumps?

Over the next few days, my co-editor Betsy Reed and I will be reading and responding to Going Rogue, as will contributors from our book Going Rouge: Sarah Palin, An American Nightmare, which is available only at www.orbooks.com.


100 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

My copy of GOING ROUGE is supposed to arrive tomorrow!

Don't blame Oprah -- she never asks hard questions. Has anyone ever challenged Sarah? If "What do you read" is a tough question, then I hate to think of what would be a real challenge. But to be fair; none of them get asked truly challenging questions.

Silly things, like "Are you still smoking cigarettes?" and crap like that are considered major big deals in this pathetic press corps.

user-pic

Here, here... 'Going Rouge' is much preferred to providing financial support to Palin & Co.

user-pic

That's right! it's only about the money!

Facebook

I recently came across your article and have been reading along. I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make readers read from the beginning to the end. I would like to read newer posts and to share my thoughts with you.
Austin web design.

Facebook

One of my favorite rules is to not talk much about powerful women (men are not so danger but women - they are), and the subject of this post are exactly that. You never know where you can meet one of them. And than what? urinary tract infection remedies

Facebook

You guys were talking about in view of politics? online degree

Facebook

You guys were talking about in view of politics? online degree

Facebook

thanks for useful information!


Best regards, Mary, CEO of youtube converter

Facebook

Whoa! who's really the devil between the two of them? marks and spencer money |
loans tesco

user-pic

It was the constant barrage of unfounded ethics complaints from liberal activists that made her decide to leave so the ben 10 izle state could conduct real business. Republicans türkçe tom ve jerry izle should tom ve jerry izle show a similar disregard for the law and swamp every elected democrat ben 10 izle with the same types of charges. I'm sick and tired çizgi film seyret of playing nice while democrats tom ve jerry izle play hardball. What ever happened to the çizgi film izle 'serious' charges against Tom Delay? Nothing, because they still can't make a case, and they knew they never could. It was simply democrat political dirty tricks to misuse the law as a political weapon. ben 10 izle

user-pic

Oprah is doing penance for having gotten too political in 2008. Is she going to do The Daily Show?

user-pic

Oh please! too political? yeah, right.

user-pic

I agree. I felt uncomfortable about that Oprah did not as her more questions as she talked about abortion and 'unprotected sex'. I didn't feel that Oprah was really interviewing her so much as providing her a venue to talk and I didn't care for it much.

And I see a complete irony in the 'oh poor me victim' story and her quitting her job as governor after having tried to convince us that 'hockey mom's are pitbulls with lipstick' and she shoots wolves from helicopters and other such hooey.

We should know how incapable she is of handling the presidency. She couldn't even handle her experience as governor or running for VP well.

user-pic

Ratings trump facts.

user-pic

I am hard pressed to recall a topic on TPM more worthless than this garbage book.

user-pic

There's entirely too much attention being paid Sarah Palin by our side. Just in case you haven't figured it out she's in it for the money not the governmental power. For her, her fame is power enough. She has no business in politics and she is smart enough to have figured that out and she also realized that in order to cash in on her fame she needed to do exactly what she has been doing since she resigned and it's working out very well for her. What she needs more than anything else is to remain in the limelight. She gets more attention and publicity from the left than she does from the right. Her appearance on Oprah would have been just another episode if people on the left weren't kicking up all this dust about her appearance and her book, etc... It's time to focus on what's important instead of this nitwit.

user-pic

Well said! This is a golden egg laying goose that's she's going to milk for every egg possible before the lights go out. McCain selecting her as his running mate was the golden opportunity to make her filthy rich at the expense of the downtrodden in the republican ranks.

user-pic

You expect a little much out of Oprah. She's not a journalist. She doesn't ask people hardball questions. It's just a personality program. Nothing to see.

user-pic

Give 'em enough rope ...

"The perky one" (Katie Couric)
"Ricky Hollywood" (Levi Johnston)

Oh yeah, she's presidential material.

user-pic

"Hitch you wagon to a star"
This is the cliche' that fits all commentary on this page.
The only time I can remember this much hate as during the JFK adminisrtation. So just rememeber that hate is what it is.

user-pic

JFK wasn't stupid.

user-pic

I remember hate, iamatroll.

Palin calling Obama a baby killer, a guy who pals around with terrorists, not a Real American, people shouting to kill him at rallies, others carrying guns in the streets, Palin saying he comes from a Party that would kill her baby and have death panels.

I remember John Lewis saying to John McCain to stop the hate.

Lewis, who knew hate, had not seen anything as bad as the Republican campaign fear and hate stoking rhetoric since churches were burned with kids inside in Alabama, Blacks were beaten in the streets of Selma and the bodies of college kids were fished out of ditches in Mississippi.

user-pic

Oprah is not a news show. Her job is to show that everyone has a story, no matter what they've done in the past.

user-pic

Good Lord, why do people keep talking about Sarah Palin?

This situation reminds me of the debate about whether college football should have a playoff system.

A vast majority of college football fans would like to see a playoff versus the current bowl format, but these same people continue to support bowls by buying tickets and merchandise. If you really want a playoff, stop attending or watching Bowl games.

If you want Sarah Palin to go away (at least as far away as Fox News), stop obsessing over her! Her continued presence in the MSM's spotlight is due primarily to the Democrats, who, since her big speech at the RNC in St. Paul, have developed and maintained some sort of weird psychological Palin-complex.

She will never be president. If she runs, she won't even get the GOP nomination.

She'll end up hosting her own 60 minute show on Fox News. And that's not so bad.

user-pic

I know, and normally I'd totally agree with you, cheering you on (rating your comment high if we still had those,) but then I was just over at The Guardian (UK) newspaper website and at the top of the home page is a big picture of Oprah, Sarah and kids, with the title
Sarah Palin on Oprah--
She's not retreating, she's reloading
.

Methinks this is not just the usual dumb work of the liberal blogosphere giving conservatives the buzz they need going on here....I'm not wondering whether she's going to be the next prez or even whether she will run, I'm more wondering whether she's going to trying to be the next Oprah, or more like the next Rush Limbaugh. After all, his shtick must be growing quite tiresome even for the diehard fans, and he's not getting any prettier to look at, either. :-)

user-pic
and he's not getting any prettier to look at, either

Understatement of the year!

Facebook

and he does not become more beautiful in appearance, or Link Building Services SEO Services

user-pic

She's milking the public for every penny they have.

user-pic

Interesting factoid:

Hezbollah's Ammar Mousawi to Sharmine Narwani, in a recent interview">:

Q: Mr. Mousawi, do you watch any American television shows? Any particular programs you admire?

A.: My wife likes the Oprah show, and I watch it with her sometimes -- Oprah seems to cover some interesting topics of social value.

The key word there is "social," not "political." Sometimes people just like to know some of the feelings of the people behind political celebrities, that's human nature. They want to know that whether they like the person(s) or despise them. That's what Oprah tries to do with virtually all her guests, and it's also a big reason why she's a very successful and wealthy woman with an international audience. Her show is mostly about personality, personal interaction, personal history, and dealing with personal problems. If she went serious political like you want her to, she'd never have gotten where she is, she'd be retired in nowhere land along with Phil Donahue. She also wouldn't have inspired a lot of people who don't normally bother to vote to go out and vote for Obama in a similar fashion; she didn't sell her fans on him on policy arguments, that's for sure.

user-pic

This also maybe strikes me as that typical TPM "why doesn't everyone get that my issue is most important" style.

It's like when that guy who posts on VA issues leads every essay with something like, "While the nation distracts itself with the Carrie Prejean sex tape, Virginia Senator and military veteran..."

And this is one of the reasons that we look so detached from people's real lives sometimes. Oprah's fans don't want her to skewer Sarah Palin. That's not why they watch the show. If Bill Maher had been caught lobbing softball questions at the Roguette, it'd be different.

user-pic

You are a typical uninformed, lying liberal. It was the constant barrage of unfounded ethics complaints from liberal activists that made her decide to leave so the state could conduct real business. Republicans should show a similar disregard for the law and swamp every elected democrat with the same types of charges. I'm sick and tired of playing nice while democrats play hardball. What ever happened to the 'serious' charges against Tom Delay? Nothing, because they still can't make a case, and they knew they never could. It was simply democrat political dirty tricks to misuse the law as a political weapon.

This line was just a classic "Notice also the conflation of journalists with political operatives. That's what Palin is now calling fact-checking of her book by AP reporters" -- When did the AP launch an army of investigators to "fact check" Obama's books? or Bidens? Or any democrat? This conflation of journalist/political operative has been in the making since the 70's. The MSM is simply now the propaganda wing of the DNC.

user-pic



Aw ... TFB . . .

Wallowing in your hot pile of dog crap again, are you?

hahahahahaha . . .

~OGD~

user-pic

Sarah Palin is perfectly representative of conservative thought. She articulates conservative policy ideas flawlessly, without making those ideas sound any smarter or dumber than they really are.

Palin was as good a governor as the GOP is ever likely to field. As VP candidate, she was as close to truth in advertising as Republicans get.

user-pic

The new 'American Dream' is having a publicist and image consultant in every household. Who needs an education and experience anymore? We're all either going to "sing and dance" or "pray" our way out of the world's global capitalist crisis.

user-pic

I agree with everything you wrote, evaluating the strength of the Oprah-Palin interview, except for one thing -- Bristol Palin was not in the Oprah audience, not in the audience glimpse I saw. However, her middle daughter Willow was, as well as the ubiquitous youngest daughter Piper.

user-pic

Sarah Palin is perfectly representative of conservative thought. She articulates conservative policy ideas flawlessly, without making those ideas sound any smarter or dumber than they really are.web design

user-pic

This also maybe strikes me as that typical TPM "why doesn't everyone get that my issue is most important" style.online website design

Facebook

ezel izle
indir

thanks for this good post

Facebook

ı like this really

ezel son bölüm izle
film izle

Facebook

thanks admın ı like this topic

oyun indir
rüya tabirleri

user-pic

I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! Hulu Downloader | iPad Converter

user-pic

. m2ts files converter from m2ts converter

user-pic

if you are a fashion man,you must heart the abercrombie and fitch or the pandora

Facebook

You guys were talking about in view of politics? online degree

user-pic

This site has lots of information, I really enjoy reading this.
generic viagra
viagra generic

user-pic

This site has lots of information, I really enjoy reading this.
generic viagra
viagra generic

user-pic

Good article and post. I really thanks to the author!
pain pills
pain pills online

user-pic

You expect a little much out of Oprah. She's not a journalist. She doesn't ask people hardball questions. It's just a personality program. Nothing to see.

laptop computers

user-pic

Oprah turned her into a hero! OMG
Detox your body and Master cleanse

user-pic

Oprah is not the devil, I like her to
Name Badges
London Hair Extensions

user-pic

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share lots of great information and inspiration
Affordable Logo Design

user-pic

Nice post to hang on..I really loved it the way of the stuff provided in this article..This has given very useful information. Leicester Bank l Loans Unsecured Bad Credit

Facebook

film izle
Thankss adminsss

Facebook

Site is very nice and fun and I always recommend this site.
We'll wonderful people Paslanmaz Çelik I wish to take advantage of service..

Paslanmaz

Paslanmaz tee

Paslanmaz Metal

Facebook

Very very much post comment . Fırsatlı Alış Veriş

cabal Cash

Facebook

The entire effect of the show was to cast Sarah Palin as an ordinary American woman who has been thrust unwillingly into the political car shipping and media machine.

Facebook

then there's McCain strategist Steve Schmidt who bullied and manipulated her into doing car transport things she didn't want to do.

Facebook

The entire effect of the show was to cast Sarah Palin as an ordinary American woman who has been thrust unwillingly into the political tech house and media machine.

Facebook

She's perfected the technique of humanizing celebrities and wringing heart-wrenching stories out of victims - it's good car transport TV.

Facebook

I like Oprah Winfrey too. Thank you for the post, it is very interesting!

Best regards,
Sofia by Iscsi Linux Software

Facebook

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share lots of great information and car transport inspiration.

Facebook

My copy of GOING ROUGE is supposed to arrive tomorrow!

Don't blame Oprah -- she never asks hard questions. Has anyone ever challenged Sarah? If "What do you read" is a tough question, then I hate to think of what would be a real challenge. But to be fair; none of them get asked truly challenging questions.

Silly things, like "Are you still smoking cigarettes?" and crap like that are considered major big deals in this pathetic Search Engine Marketing press corps.

Facebook

I like Oprah Winfrey too. Thank you for the post, it is very interesting!izmir escort

Facebook

Sarah Palin is perfectly representative of conservative thought. She articulates conservative policy ideas flawlessly, without making those ideas sound any smarter or dumber than they really are.izmir escort

Facebook

Smpathy for devil I don't think so. Online Muslim Matrimonials

Facebook

Nice written about the devil.Access Healthcare

Facebook

Bingo Sites
This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.

Facebook

Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. This was actually what I was looking for, and I am glad to came here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us.

Deal or no Deal

Facebook

advokat oslo
Standards at Guantánamo rival or exceed those at similar institutions in the United States and abroad. After an inspection by the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe in March 2006, a Belgian police official said, “At the level of detention facilities, it is a model prison, where people are better treated than in Belgian prisons.

Facebook

I absolutely adore your site! You aggressive me as able-bodied as all the others actuality and your broiled PS is absolutely nice. Thank you for afflatus and accumulate up the acceptable work thanks!
Deal or no Deal

Facebook

I high appreciate this post. It’s hard to find the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it! would you mind updating your blog with more information?
Scratch Cards

Facebook

Thanks for sharing your great comments. I agree with you. I found your post very useful and interesting in reading. Keep sharing more useful articles.
Short term loans | Personal loans

Facebook

executive jet, private jet, charter flight, air charter, jet charter, business jet, executive jet leads, private jet.

Facebook

movers, moving companies, mover companies, moving quotes, mover packer, moving company, moving services, local mover, moving leads, movers.

Facebook

Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. This was actually what I was looking for, and I am glad to came here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us.
dsl providers

Facebook

search engine optimization, seo, search engine marketing, sem, seo services, local seo, link building, search engine optimization.

Facebook

san francisco movers, moving companies, mover companies, moving quotes, mover packer, moving company, moving services, local mover, moving leads, san francisco movers.

Facebook

This is a golden egg laying goose that's she's going to milk for every egg possible before the lights go out. McCain selecting her as his running mate was the golden opportunity to make her filthy rich at the expense of the downtrodden in the republican ranks. I agree with your comments.
Online marketing companies Delhi

Facebook

It’s really helpful for me which I have ever seen.Its presented well and nicely written which easy to understand.Thank you very much for the information.
Backlink Booster

Facebook

Would you please provide way more information on this issue?? By the way your blog is amazing. Best regards..
airstream

Facebook

I am glad to came here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us.Essay

Facebook

Only Dictators DEMAND respect...I will however, tell you what I DO have for Mr. Obama..a little...'SYMPATHY FOR THE DEVIL'...,So I thought I would do something a little different,and have some interactive fun in my property investment.

Facebook

I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains wonderful and helpful posts. I have read most of them and got a lot from them. To me, you are doing the great work.
calfeutrage

Facebook

I simply want to say I’m beginner to blogging and site-building and honestly liked you’re web blog. Very likely I’m likely to bookmark your blog . You absolutely come with amazing well written articles. Thanks a lot for sharing with us your blog site.
Bilbao hotels

Facebook

In this awesome scheme of things you actually secure an A for effort. The writing is highly powerful and this is most likely why I am taking the effort to opine. I do not make it a regular habit of doing that. 2nd, while I can easily notice the jumps in reasoning you come up with, I am not necessarily sure of how you seem to connect the details which in turn make the actual conclusion. For right now I will, no doubt yield to your issue but trust in the future you actually link your facts better. Hamburg hotels

Facebook

I have been searching for some information about it almost three hours. You helped me a lot indeed and reading this your article I have found many new and useful information about this subject. the diet solution program

Facebook

I absolutely adore your site! You aggressive me as able-bodied as all the others actuality and your broiled PS is absolutely nice. Thank you for afflatus and accumulate up the acceptable work thanks!
pagerank 3 backlinks

Facebook

Great post! I'm just starting out in community management/marketing media and trying to learn how to do it well - resources like this article are incredibly helpful. As our company is based in the US, it's all a bit new to us.
Lieferantenmanagement

Facebook

Sarah Palin is a representative of conservative thought. She articulates conservative policy ideas flawlessly, without making those ideas sound any smarter or dumber than they really are.
Payday loans 300 | Instant cash

Facebook

This was really helpful. Thank you for posting this! I am wondering why they made the program so hard to use if it requires that much work?
SEM

Facebook

shipping a car, auto transport, automobile transporters, auto shippers, auto transporters, shipping a car.

Facebook

automobile transporters, auto transport, automobile transporter, auto shippers, auto transporters, automobile transporters.

Facebook

Thank you so much for your work on keeping the site together and keeping these flowing.
USA Poker Sites

Facebook

You have provided a nice blogging example for blog writer as well as article writers and also this is helpful information for industrialization, knowledge processing, planning as well as monitoring the data and resources........thanks a lot.
Backlinkbooster

Facebook

This is a very great post. I will print out the post and read it carefully again. Thanks
medical aid quotes | car insurance quotes

Facebook
Facebook

Really like your blog content the way you put up the things…I’ve read the topic with great interest and definitely will stick your blog routinely for other great posts.
PR6 Backlinks

Facebook

Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. Thank you for sharing great information to us.
mothers day flowers Delhi|send mothers day flowers Tokyo

Facebook

Still there is room for greater development and I would recommend more emphasis on research and of course it will bring a better situation. Thanks for sharing a nice read. Cheers
Worldwide Health Insurance

Facebook

This is the first time I am visiting this post.I have gathered much of it.Really a interesting firm things.
hemorrhoids cure

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address