Won't You Please Come to Chicago?
The elites hate to acknowledge it, but when large numbers of ordinary people are moved to action, it changes the narrow political world where the elites call the shots. Inside accounts reveal the extent to which Johnson and Nixon's conduct of the Vietnam War was constrained by the huge anti-war movement. It was the civil rights movement, not compelling arguments, that convinced members of Congress to end legal racial discrimination. More recently, the townhall meetings, dominated by people opposed to health care reform, have been a serious roadblock for those pushing reform.
Those disgusted by the bank bailouts, and the bankers who brought us this recession, will have a chance to make their views known when the American Bankers Association has its annual meeting in Chicago, October 25-27. A large coalition of labor, community, and consumer organizations are organizing a protest at this "Showdown in Chicago"
A big turnout at this event can make a real difference. Just to review the scorecard, most of the country is still suffering the fallout from the bankers' irrational exuberance of the housing bubble era. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and other forecasters expect the suffering to endure for years to come.
The unemployment rate is about to cross 10 percent, with an additional 9 million workers only able to find part-time work. CBO projects that unemployment will not return to normal levels until 2014. Almost 200,000 people are losing their homes every month through foreclosure. Tens of millions of people who had expected a comfortable retirement just saw most of their wealth disappear with the collapse of the housing bubble. State and local governments are being forced to lay off school teachers and fire fighters under the pressure of enormous budget deficits.
But not everyone is suffering. Thanks to the bailout programs put in place last fall, most of the country's major banks are back on their feet. In fact, in the most recent quarter, bank profits hit a new record high as a share of all corporate profits.
And the banks are sharing their wealth. Many of their top executives and high performers will be getting bonuses this year worth millions of dollars, in some cases the bonuses will be in the tens of millions.
In the meantime, in elite Washington circles people are busy making plans for a national sales tax so that the government can limit the fiscal damage caused by the bankers' recession. A sales tax is of course very regressive since low and moderate-income people typically spend the vast majority of their income, while our banker friends will more likely to be able to save some of their income or spend it in other countries where they will not be paying this new sales tax.
To summarize: the bankers wrecked the economy with their greed, ran off with taxpayer dollars in a massive bailout, and now plan to raise taxes for the rest of us. If that picture doesn't sound quite right, then go to Chicago.
This is a case where the divisions are not left-right, but of the elite against everyone else. When Congress was debating the TARP bank bailout last fall, members of Congress were hearing calls from people across the political spectrum who were outraged that their tax dollars were going to the banks that had wrecked the economy. A higher percentage of Republicans than Democrats ended up voting against this bankers' piñata.
The policies that will rein in the banks: reform of the Federal Reserve Board to make it democratically accountable, a tax on financial speculation to pay for the bankers' mess, and restrictions on the bank abuses of consumers that caused the carnage have support from people on both the left and right.
A bill that would require the Fed to disclose what it did with more than $2 trillion in loans to banks and other financial institutions was originally co-sponsored by Ron Paul and Alan Grayson, one of the most conservative and one of the most progressive members of Congress. Due to public pressure, it now has more than 270 co-sponsors.
This is exactly the sort of alliance that gets the elite worried. Reining in the power of the financial industry will be a long hard fought war, but it is one that must be fought. President and Nobel peace prize winner Barack Obama may not have been able to bring the Olympics to Chicago, but everyone who wants to retake our country from the banks can bring their backside there on October 25th.

















We definitely need everyone else to organize against the elites. I would actually argue, though, that the definition of the left is such organization, so it's not true to say that it transcends the left-right axis. It's just that this leftist position happens to appeal to an overwhelming majority of the public.
We need to separate social leftism from economic leftism like what you're advocating here. Social issues really do divide the population, so for example blue states are definitely more socially liberal than red states, but on economic issues the primary division is not geographic but rich vs. poor.
October 12, 2009 10:22 AM | Reply | Permalink
I'll be there, if ---
You can get me an Embassy Suite for $97.50 a night.
October 12, 2009 10:38 AM | Reply | Permalink
Standard single rates start at $199.00
Seniors $189.00
No trip to Chicago for you.
October 12, 2009 1:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
Oh I wouldn't be too concerned about any protest in Chicago. I'm sure the Bankers have greased the appropriate palms in city hall to make SURE the local cops keep every thing under control.
C
October 12, 2009 10:56 AM | Reply | Permalink
Most of them are Cubs fans. Can't hit a thing.
Let's go! ;O)
October 12, 2009 11:27 AM | Reply | Permalink
Shhh..Sleepin...you'll rouse Lisb with that comment. ;-)
C
October 12, 2009 12:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
I heard that...
October 12, 2009 12:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
White Sox Rule!
October 12, 2009 12:42 PM | Reply | Permalink
Now I suppose you'll write an article about the Cubs filing for Chapter 11.
Just wait 'til next year!
-- ARG
October 12, 2009 4:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
Gentlemen! The police are not here to create disorder. The police are here to preserve disorder!
October 13, 2009 12:42 PM | Reply | Permalink
I am disappointed that Dean Baker has no better ideas and/or means to affect financial policy than to bring people (to do what?) in Chicago.
He forgets that we were losing in Viet Nam and our casualties were 58,000 by the end of it. This situation is not analogous.
For the last 8 months or so we have heard that the banks HAD to be saved, since they are the underpinning of the financial system. The smaller banks that were allegedly not complicit in the mortgage scams are the ones that are failing now. Surely we cannot let them fail.
October 12, 2009 11:30 AM | Reply | Permalink
You're right, Ruth, this situation is not analogous to Vietnam, where we only lost 58,000 over several years of war. The conflation of financial and political power in America costs at least that many lives every year.
For example - in just one small part of our financial industry - health insurance - more than 44,000 lives are lost annually due to the lack of it. (You'll argue that health insurance companies are not banks, I know. Neither is AIG, right?)
And in the end, this really is about saving smaller banks. Once upon a time, banks were responsible citizens of their communities. Then NCNB and BOA and others ate them alive. Re-regulation should move us toward healthier banks at the local level, less concentration at the top.
And yes, large numbers of citizens do get the attention of the elite when they band together. I can't imagine a more appropriate venue for this than Chicago.
October 12, 2009 11:40 AM | Reply | Permalink