TPMCafe
« Kennedy's Quick Win for Social Security | Home | Questions for Senator Grassley »

Two Lions: When Ted Kennedy Privately Honored Yitzhak Rabin

user-pic

It is a small part of his great legacy but it should not go unmentioned that Ted Kennedy was one of the few senators who rarely, if ever, yielded to the pressure to join the Israel-is-always-right caucus. The mindless jingoism of his colleagues was not his way (nor is it John Kerry's) and when he addressed the Israeli-Palestinian issue, he was compassionate and even-handed. He was not your standard "liberal on everything but Israel" type.

Professor Leonard Fein from Boston (of Americans for Peace Now) -- who has spent a lifetime struggling for Middle East peace -- offers this beautiful remembrance of Ted Kennedy today. He describes a small incident in Kennedy's long life but one that tells us a lot about the man.

"On the morning of the day before the funeral of Yitzhak Rabin, Senator Ted Kennedy called the White House to inquire if it was appropriate to bring to the burial some earth from Arlington National Cemetery. The answer was essentially a shrug: Who knows? Unadvised, the senator carried a shopping bag onto the plane, filled with earth he had himself dug the afternoon before from the graves of his two murdered brothers. And at Mount Herzl in Jerusalem, after waiting for the crowd and the cameras to disperse, he dropped to his hands and knees, and gently placed that earth on the grave of the murdered prime minister.

No spin, no photo op; a man unreasonably familiar with bidding farewell to slain heroes, a man in mourning, quietly making tangible a miserable connection."

Miserable it is. But how much more miserable it would be if we never had these heroes at all?


15 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

That's very moving. Thanks for sharing it.

user-pic

Surely something the vitriolic Right-wing will forget to mention when savaging the reputation of this great leader.

user-pic

Lovely anecdote, very typical. Can just imagine the Murdoch press, Rush and that gang all demonizing him vs. the truth of a story like this one.

user-pic

:)

user-pic

Another reminder that the Senate seems to be a far less *human* place than it used to be...

user-pic

You do know that Jesse Helms used to be in the Senate.....

user-pic

I had never heard that story. Thank you for sharing that with us. It really moved me.

user-pic

Ditto!

user-pic

What a truly beautiful story.

user-pic

Ted Kennedy was one of the few senators who rarely, if ever, yielded to the pressure to join the Israel-is-always-right caucus.

From his first year in the Senate, 1962, until his last votes, Kennedy was a stalwart Israel supporter. It is likely in this, too, he was living the values of his older brother. “Israel will endure and flourish,” John F. Kennedy once said. “It can neither be broken by adversity nor demoralized by success. It carries the shield of democracy and it honors the sword of freedom.”

According to one tally, Ted Kennedy voted 100 percent in concert with positions taken by Aipac, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee. Tom Dine, who served as Aipac’s executive director from 1980-93, was a defense and foreign policy advisor to Kennedy.

In the run-up to his tough 1994 Senate campaign against Mitt Romney, Kennedy accumulated some $45,000 from pro-Israel political action committees over the years, according to former Aipac legislative director Doug Bloomfield, “and presumably a lot more from individual pro-Israel donors, considering his long record of support for U.S. taxpayer aid for Israel.”

The relationship was mutually beneficial—either a testament to Kennedy’s bedrock values or his astute political instincts. Take the Carter race.
In the 1980 presidential race, writes Jeffrey S. Helmreich, “polls indicated that Carter would beat Kennedy in the New York Democratic primary by a margin of 54 to 28 percent. But on March 1, Carter’s UN Ambassador, Donald F. McHenry, voted for a viciously anti-Israel resolution in the UN Security Council condemning Israeli settlement activity in Jerusalem. Three weeks later, Kennedy beat Carter in New York by 59 percent to 41 percent.”

In a statement following Kennedy’s death, Israeli Prime Miniiter Benjamin Netanyahu said, “(Senator) Kennedy has been a friend for 30 years, a great American patriot, a great champion of a better world, a great friend of Israel. He will be sorely missed.”

It is also worth noting that in a major policy address on the eve of the second Iraq War, Kennedy challenged the wisdom of attacking Iraq when Iran’s nuclear weapons program posed a greater risk to the world and to Israel.
“Iran has had closer ties to terrorism than Iraq,” he said on Sept, 26, 2002. “Iran has a nuclear weapons development program, and it already has a missile that can reach Israel.”
But such support alone was not enough to win the hearts of Jews who opposed Kennedy’s stalwart liberal positions, or those who remained suspicious his character.

“Rarely in America has a more unworthy person been accorded such deep respect as is regularly heaped upon Kennedy,” wrote Dr. Mendy Granchow, past president of the Orthodox Union, yesterday.

http://www.jewishjournal.com/bloggish/item/ted_kennedy_israel_and_the_jews_20090826/

user-pic

“Iran has had closer ties to terrorism than Iraq,” he said on Sept, 26, 2002. “Iran has a nuclear weapons development program, and it already has a missile that can reach Israel.”

Israel did not agitate for the attack on Iraq. Sharon was agnostic and did cooperate with US up to a point in regards to military assets and exaggerated WMD (bio/chem & missiles) intelligence estimates for American consumers. For whatever reasons, the Israelis refused to cobble up linkages between Saddam to AQ.

Given that Kennedy's statement about Iran of 9/2002 perfectly echoed the sentiments of the Israeli government @ the time, the institutional belief in the Iranian "exisential threat" to Israel mythology embedded in our political superstructure is truly bi-partisan. Israelis had stopped worrying about Iraq and Saddam long ago; their focus shifted to Iran ca. 1993.

Let's hope that Obama doesn't think that attacking Iran would be a "smart war".

user-pic

FWIW, here is the "viciously anti-Israel" resolution McHenry voted for, mistakenly according to subsequent apologies from the Carter administration, and which apparently caused such an uproar during the New York primary:

http://domino.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0a2a053971ccb56885256cef0073c6d4/5aa254a1c8f8b1cb852560e50075d7d5

The resolution calls on Israel to stop building settlements in Jerusalem and the occupied territories, and to dismantle its existing settlements. There is, in fact, nothing vicious about the resolution at all. It is filled with common sense.

Perhaps the key paragraph is this one:

5. Determines that all measures taken by Israel to change the physical character, demographic composition, institutional structure or status of the Palestinian and other Arab territories occupied since 1967, including Jerusalem, or any part thereof, have no legal validity and that Israel's policy and practices of settling parts of its population and new immigrants in those territories constitute a flagrant violation of the Fourth Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War and also constitute a serious obstruction to achieving a comprehensive, just and lasting peace in the Middle East;

Here the authors of the resolution took a "vicious" stand for international law, and against colonialism and the acquisition of territory by force.

The population of the Israeli colonies in the occupied territories was in 1980 only about 1/20th of what it is today, and so the settlement issue was much more tractable. If people like Kennedy had managed to avoid playing domestic politics with the Israeli colonization of Palestine back in 1980, perhaps we would have found a way out of that mess by now, and prevented three more decades of violence.

Perhaps emboldened by their success in influencing the US presidential race and administration, Israel passed the Jerusalem Law in July, 1980, declaring Jerusalem, "complete and united", the capital of Israel.

Kennedy has a long record of progressive legislative accomplishments that needs no repeating, but he was as much in the tank for Israel as anyone.

user-pic

From an Arab commenter on Helena Cobban's Syria vs Maliki et al thread, another memory about the youthful Ted Kennedy relayed to the author in 1987:

A special commitment to Senator Ted Kennedy

Under the shock of the bad news - the death of the world figure Senator Ted Kennedy - I must apologise to Helena for breaking the rules to her blog and say something about him may be a new information to the most readers.

In 1987 I attended a conference presented by an Algerian ex-diplomat named M'hamed Yazid was held at KASR ATHAKAFA ( CULURAL CASTLE )in Algiers.

He said about this great pesonality when he was a student in the mid-1950's in France and visited Algeria during his holidays and saw the the Agerian people how are suffering from french colony. When he returned back to the USA he explained the Algerian national cause to his brother sentor John Kennedy at that time and when the latter became a President he gave a great support to the Algerian independence.

I still remember M'hamed yazid made an appeal to the Algerian leaders to invite him and acknowloge his contribution to the Algerian national cause.Unfortunately, the Algeiran naive dipolomacy turned its back to the people who loved this country.
for tis reason, I feel sad and upset, sad because the world lost a great personatity and upset because my government didn't make her duty to this kind of personalities.

Hafid

Posted by Abdelhafid Dib at August 26, 2009 05:27 PM


user-pic

Support for Israel has become almost a necessity in American politics and I'm sure if you check the record closely, Teddy was guilty of it (albeit to a lesser degree) like most politicians. But, I do get your point that he did not wear it on his sleeve, or visably trade on the association like so many politicians.

user-pic

Hey MJ, Haaretz is quoting this blog:

When the late Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, who died on Tuesday, came to Israel in 1995 to attend the funeral of assassinated prime minister Yitzhak Rabin, he had brought with him earth from the graves of his brothers, Sen. Robert F. Kennedy and President John F. Kennedy, who were killed the same way as Rabin.

Prof. Leonard Fine, who revealed the gesture on the Talking Points Memo blog, said that "after waiting for the crowd and the cameras to disperse, he dropped to his hands and knees, and gently placed that earth on the grave of the murdered prime minister. No spin. No photo op."

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1110799.html

They screwed up the attribution for some reason. Sloppy.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

November 16-20

http://orbooks.com/files/going-rouge-small.jpg

Coming Soon



November 30-December 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address