TPMCafe
« The Man on the Comment Thread | Home | "Don't Know Much About History" »

Rep. Peter King Says Health Care Crisis Is Not "A Rabid-Type Issue" While 84 Year Old Ed Koch Says He's Done With Obama

user-pic

Rep. Peter King (R-NY) told MSNBC today that there is no need to rush on health care reform.

The health care system, he said, "may not be perfect....But it's not the rabid-type issue that had to be solved by August 1 of this year, the way President Obama was saying."

And he's right. Health care reform is not a rabid-type issue. In fact, there are no rabid type issues. Rabies, in general, is attached to no issue -- left or right.

So why is Peter King have rabies on his mind. I'll tell you why. It's because his party's activists are acting as if they are rabid. He watches these violent, screaming haters on television or the web and thinks, "Jeez, these people are rabid." So later, when he's discussing the issue, he employs the term that is at the tip of his tongue. He's thinks rabid rightwing crazies. He says, "rabid-type issue."

Of course, King has had his own rabid moments.

Here he is criticizing the media for covering the death of Michael Jackson who he calls "a low life." Of course, one doesn't have to admire Jackson or think he was an upstanding citizen. But what can you call a Congressman who, unasked, takes to the airwaves to denounce a pop star who has just died.

Believe me, Peter King, did not condemn Sinatra as a low-life, despite his mob ties.

No, he denounces Jackson for rather obvious reasons. That attack appeals to his base. Why? You figure it out. So what's the right word? Rabid? Or rancid?

Whatever, it does not apply to the health reform issue.

It applies to those stirring up hate against this President, tapping into the ugliest strains in American life and doing it with utter disregard for this country and its people. Maybe it's time to bring back the term "un-American." I always thought it was a stupid phrase and wondered what it meant. Now I know,

***

Check out this column by forrmer New York mayor, Ed Koch. Koch supported Obama in the general and was quite helpful in Florida. But here he breaks with the President because he fears that under Obama's plan he might not get millions of dollars of care in his old age.

"I know from personal experience. I have been told that the cost of my hospital care, including the services of 20 doctors and 72 nurses and medical technicians over a six-week period, may ultimately cost a million dollars. My private insurance policy is paid for by my law firm, Bryan Cave LLP, and because I still work full-time, that insurance policy is my primary one, not Medicare, even though I am 84 years old. Will that continue to be the case under any law signed by Obama? Or will I be denied the right to spend my own money and that of my law firm for such unlimited coverage?"

I don't know the answer to Koch's question and it's a legitimate one. But Koch, at 84, should be ashamed to say that he'd perpetuate a status quo in which millions of young people and kids get no care to avoid making any sacrifice of his own (i.e., paying more out of pocket).

We Americans are supposed to be a generous people. I wonder.


7 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Sure, it's not urgent. What's another 20 years?

user-pic

Koch's comment shows just how selfish many Americans really are. "The system is workin fine for me, so hands off!"

user-pic

Americans were generous. Think WWII and its aftermath. But that all began to change in the '60s and many of today's adults are by and large selfish and cramped in their thinking. I have hopes for the younger generation, but there aren't enough people over 30 who can see beyond their own circumstances.

user-pic

RE: Koch, at 84, should be ashamed to say that he'd perpetuate a status quo in which millions of young people and kids get no care to avoid making any sacrifice of his own (i.e., paying more out of pocket).

MY COMMENT: I once admired Ed Koch, but when he became an apologist for "Pastor" John Hagee I lost all respect for him!

SEE: "Why McCain Should Have Stood by Hagee", By Ed Koch, 06/03/08

Senator John McCain was wrong to reject the endorsement of Texas evangelist Rev. John Hagee.

Several years ago Rev. Hagee delivered a sermon that was caught on tape in which he preached, "Then God sent a hunter. A hunter is someone with a gun, and he forces you. Hitler was a hunter. How did it happen? Because God allowed it to happen. Why did it happen? Because God said, 'My top priority for the Jewish people is to get them to come back to the land of Israel."

Anyone hearing the tape would conclude that Hagee is hostile to the Jews, but nothing could be further from the truth. He and his congregants are among Israel's strongest supporters. For religious reasons, they want Israel to rule supreme over all of the lands that made up the ancient Jewish kingdoms of Israel and Judea....

ENTIRE ARTICLE - http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2008/06/why_mccain_should_have_stood_b.html

user-pic

By the way, if Koch is full time lawyer, bringing down some significant bucks, is he collecting social security also? He was a big bag of crap when he was Mayor of New York and he is now an older bigger bad of crap.

user-pic

How could he be so misinformed. Of course, none of these plans before Congress would invalidate private health insurance. Even in Europe, individuals can buy private insurance to supplement the national health plans. About 10% of Germans do so. This has resulted in a two tier system but one that most seem to be satisfied with.

The old fool should be reassured -- his top tier coverage would not be threatened in any way.

user-pic

MJ, you say Koch's question is a legitimate one. It is not.
Before you pontificate publicly on what you fear MIGHT be in a particular piece of legislation, you have a responsibility to inform yourself as to the facts. Koch doesn't even try:
"The president, I believe, has said that there will be no restrictions on private insurance coverage. ... So, where lies the truth? I don't know."
Some advice, Ed: Find out what's actually in the text of the bills, then get back to us.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address