TPMCafe
« Barak Bearing Gifts | Home | Export Emergency »

Al-Safa, June 27, 2009

user-pic

This, from my friend David Shulman, an activist in the Israeli-Palestinian peace group Ta'ayush, who has written widely about acts of witness in the South Hebron hills--including in this blog:

While Prime Minister Netanyahu scoffs at Ahmedinajad's beatings of peaceful demonstrators, here is what happened yesterday, in broad daylight, at the village of al-Safa, inside occupied Palestinian territory. I am reporting the testimony of Dr. Amiel Vardi, and many other supporting testimonies. There is graphic photographic documentation, including a live video clip, which can be seen here. The pictures seen here are part of a series that can be viewed at this Flickr site.

Further photographic evidence will become available within the next day or two. (Israel has so far not resorted to blocking internet sites.) What Amiel reports is incontrovertible.

The activists arrived in the morning at al-Safa to accompany Palestinian farmers to their fields, since it is nearly impossible for these farmers to work their land without the physical protection of Israelis: violent settlers from nearby Bat 'Ayin invariably attack the farmers and chase them away. This time, however, the army and Border Police were waiting, in force--dozens of soldiers (the Border Police are part of the army), including two Brigade Commanders. As usual, they declared the area a Closed Military Zone.

But they also immediately arrested the activists and then attacked several of them brutally with fists, rifle butts, and other weapons. They rammed their heads repeatedly against the sides of the military jeeps (you can see this clearly on the Walla video). They severely beat the detainees while the latter were hand-cuffed and defenseless. Even worse, they continued to beat them while transporting them to the police station--stopping the jeeps on the way and attacking their helpless prisoners with clubs. One Palestinian activist, Yusuf Abu-Maria, suffered a broken leg. An Israeli activist, Sahar, had her armed savagely twisted, though fortunately not broken. Many were injured.

Incidentally, while this was going on, settlers from Bat 'Ayin set fire to Palestinian olive trees only a few hundred yards away; but of course the soldiers saw no reason to interfere.

This was not random violence. It's the kind of thing that is directed routinely at Palestinian detainees, but this is perhaps the first time Israeli activists have been assaulted so brutally. The sense is that the Border Policemen were acting under direct, premeditated orders. The two Brigade Commanders--the senior officer in this zone, commander of the Etzion Brigade, and the commander of the Kfir Brigade-- stood there overseeing the assault. Perhaps they had their orders from above. Internal Security in Israel is now under the direct control of the proto-Fascist party of Lieberman, the Foreign Minister.

Let no one claim that such things happen only in places like Iran but never in Israel. Let no one claim that Israel is an enlightened, free country, the very opposite of places like Iran. Let no one claim that the Israeli army is incapable of inhuman cruelty inflicted on innocent victims, whether they are Palestinian civilians or Israelis demonstrating peacefully against the occupation. Already now, as I write, the system Israel has put in place in the occupied territories is barbaric, in every sense of the word. Unless there is massive international pressure and effective protest, that system is not about to go away. Indeed, in the meantime, things are getting worse, on the ground, day by day.


17 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Thank you sincerely for bearing witness (electronically), bringing forth the evidence, and speaking out, Professor.

It depresses me when people say Obama is not going to do anything about this kind of thing since no one ever has before. He's the first President ever who has understood that something fundamental has to be done about the substance here (though Bush I and Carter were more committed than others), and that it is not just the President's job to get along with Jerusalem while occasionally making fair-sounding statements that he doesn't believe in while hoping for Jewish support in whatever next U.S. election.

I firmly believe Obama will do something about it. I believe he is the transcendent figure he appears to be. If he is not, we're all in trouble as the sides can't do this on their own: Bibi can't cave to pressure if there is no pressure (there was none by Bush II upon Sharon, for example). And it will be another generation before we see a serious approach to this. By then, nukes may be flying around so we probably can't wait that long.

user-pic

Is it correct to say that what you describe is OK with the people who live in that country ?

I mean OK in the sense that most people ignore it or are in favor of it or would not do anything to stop it.

If so, what can an American president do about it ? We cannot force people in other countries to change their beliefs and practices. This is going to go on for a good long while. The peace movement in that country seems tiny and ineffectual - a fringe movement.

Meanwhile any moral stature that country ever had is gone forever.

The Americans will continue to pay for whatever they do - that subsidy will not be discussed much less reduced. People in democracies have to subsidize lots of things they wish not to subsidize.

And so : the situation is disgusting, it is forever, it is unsolvable,it is boring. Most Americans do not want to head anything about it.

Anyone care to bet ? Ten years from now - no peace, no deal, no improvement.

user-pic

What an American president can do, if it is OK with the people in a given country?

Israel is a small country, extremelly dependent on her access to markets in most developed countries, EU and USA. Even a whiff of trade sanctions has a big potential to alter popularity of certain policies (especially that in large part, it is apathy rather than active support).

The only defense that Israel has is that we support it as "sharing our values", and we would not support any sanctions. But if they DO NOT share our values?

By the way, does it mean that this particular outrage is the personal responsibility of Ehud Barak?

user-pic

Bernard - I have been witnessing these kind of activities by soldiers and settlers for a couple decades. Every day I visited with my settler relatives, I saw something which turned my stomach. A year ago while visiting my niece in Kiryat Arba, I withnessed a teenage settler with a gun force the father of a Palestinian family walking with his family (a wife and 4 young children) to the ground with the rifle pointed at his head. He then made the man walk on his arms and legs and bark like a dog. The humiliation was more than I could bear. The Israeli soldiers sat in their jeep smoking and laughing at the spectacle. I went up to the soldiers and asked them why they allowed this to happen and they told me - nobody got hurt and besides we have to show "them" who's boss.

A point I have repeatedly made here on TPM is the occupation is causing Israeli Jews to darken their souls. There is a callousness in Jews that extends not only to Palestinians but also to fellow Jews. I first started visiting Israel in 1956 and have been there more than 70 times since. I have seen this evolution from a "all for one and one for all" attitude to the deep divisions that affect Israeli society today. The religious versus the secular division is far greater today. In the old days it was "live and let live" between these two factions. Now there is a deep and genuine hostility. Political differences are at the point where fellow Jews are described in words formerly used only for arabs. In the 50's, 60's and 70's the term self-hating Jew would never be used - now it's common.

Growing up I was always facinated by the loud boisterous arguments Israelis had about politics. But once the discussion was done, drinks and hugs were shared by all. All too often today, one sees hatred in the eyes of those who have these kind of political arguments.

I do not know what the future holds for Israel but every fabric of my being tells me it won't be good without an end to the occupation and a peace agreement with the Palestinians. Another 40 years of occupation will rend Israeli society at it's very core to our people's ultimate sorrow.

user-pic

Powerful, always.

If Lieberman becomes PM, you might be the one who is on your knees barking. Sadism bleeds into everything.

user-pic

what we are seeing is a master-slave mentality.

the masters have the illusion of freedom and happiness, but it is only an illusion. any one, absolutely without exception, who exhibits this type of behavior has a soul that is drowning in suffering. no matter how much they smile, no matter how big their bank account is, no matter how high their position in society is, they are shriveled and emaciated prisoners in the dark dungeon of their soul dreaming that they are free and happy in the sun. yet there is always door out of that prison and that door is always wide open but the blinded souls refuse to walk through it. that door is the door of compassion.

user-pic

the settlers = IDF = the settlers

both are carrying out the policy of the israeli government. only a fool thinks otherwise.

user-pic

Just as corporations own the US Congress, the Israeli lobbyists, AIPAC and others, seem to own what is left of Congress. Otherwise our country would long ago have required Israel to become civilized as a prerequisite to continuing to receive aid from us. It won't happen in my lifetime.

user-pic

I'm sorry Hoppy but I think your comment is over the top. Israel is at least as "civilized" as America, regardless my stream of criticism of their actions. A country which did what we did in Iraq is no more civilized than Israel. I am at least as critical of America as I am of Israel and I know from reading your commentary over the past few years, that in your heart you feel the same way.

user-pic

Touche'

However, I have never considered the actions of the Bush administration to be "American" actions. That is my rationalization.

Also, I don't think the issue is whether Israel or the US is the most civilized. The treatment by Israel of Palestinians is fully as bad as the treatment of African Americans in the US up until a few years ago. We are slowly, ever so slowly, moving towards much more civilized action towards our minorities, but is Israel doing so with their treatment of Palestinians? My impression is that the answer is no, and quite the contrary.

user-pic

You say: "A country which did what we did in Iraq is no more civilized than Israel."

It was worse. It was a war to take over the assets of another nation. (See Naomi Klein's "The Shock Doctrine.")

All war is theft. And the Iraq War Crime is a Madoff-sized heist.

user-pic

Israel is sliding backwards when it comes to "civilized" behavior. A state that cannot or will not impose the rule of law upon it's own violent citizens is not even close to being as "civilized" as America.

Nor would the authorized representatives of the State be allowed to behave in the manner that is SOP for the IDF in the OT.

user-pic

I believe the word we're looking for is "ethnic cleansing".

user-pic

The grandchildren of today's Israelis will pay a steep price for what is being done today.

user-pic

Actually, all our grandchildren will pay a steep price by our unwillingness to confront reality today. Reality can't be ignored forever. The longer we wait, the harder it will bite.

But some people don't care because they'll already be dead. Let the future solve its own problems.

Facebook

This information is very useful! Thanks!
Best regards, Katya, CEO of hyper v download, xsan iscsi

Facebook

Si vous etes interesses par le dossier, ou desirez en savoir plus, contactez-moi par mail, et je vous mettrai en contact.
Best regards,Jane, CEO of high availability architecture

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address