TPMCafe
« Obama's Iran man is still pictured on site calling for sanctions on Iran | Home | Why Not Love the PSI? »

Health Insurance Coop

user-pic

Moderate Democrats, perhaps cowed by Limbaugh's "socialized medicine" trope seem to be backing away from the public plan option. Their substitute is a non profit insurance cooperative.

"I am inclined, and I think the committee is inclined, toward a co-op," Mr. Baucus said. "It's not going to be public, we won't call it public, but it will be tough enough to keep insurance companies' feet to the fire."

This is a really dumb idea. You are going to start from scratch a whole new bureaucracy to handle potentially millions of customers, instead of letting the government which already has the systems in place (thanks to Medicare) service these customers? A start up coop is doomed to fail, which is probably the point.


18 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

And, despite what Baucus says, they WILL call it a "public" option and when it fails we will be denied another bite at the apple for at least a generation.

user-pic

Yep...I agree with destor. It is being set up to fail and of course the tag "public" will be attached to it, and endlessly repeated and reported as such on the TV news, seeing that is what the goal is.

Then we will get to hear "See we told you it wouldn't work, leave private enterprise alone!!!"

user-pic

I don't want a synonym for a public health care option. I want a public health care option.

user-pic

I guess that's what you get when you elect Rush Limbaugh President and leader of the Democratic Party. We did do that didn't we? I mean why else would he be dictating policy to Boss Baucus?

user-pic

If I understand correctly, these co-ops are just purchasing organizations. You'd still be buying your insurance from an insurance company. The co-ops would give you access to group rates and would give small businesses and individuals some of the same bargaining power that large companies now have. But other than that, I'm not sure I see the advantage. Also, one suspects the co-ops would have a higher number of very sick people in them than employer-sponsored plans typically do, which means insurance companies will not be willing to reduce the rates they charge to these co-ops all that much.


user-pic

Re: the government ... already has the systems in place (thanks to Medicare)

The public plan would not simply be Medicare for younger people, so the government would have to set up another system (and hire a lot of people) to put one into effect. It would need its own software, and pretty much everything else built from the bottom up too. This is not an argument in favor of coops (which would also need their own build up) but it is a correction to the idea that a public plan would simply be "Medicare for all".

user-pic

Republicans don’t trust Americans.

Republicans don’t trust us Americans to make the right decision if we are given the option to choose to spend our money on a public health insurance option Vs private insurance. They claim that if given the choice the American people will choose the public option and this will lead to all sorts of evil such as rationing of health care and bureaucrats making life and death decisions.

This from the party who in regards to corporate & financial regulation and taxes on the rich and powerful, has said, “We trust the American people” to make the best decisions of what to do with their money. I suppose, in reality, the Republicans only trust the corporations, rich and powerful to make good decisions (such as tanking our economy). But when it comes to individual choice the Republicans just don’t trust us Americans.

To all the Republicans out there who don’t trust American individuals to make the right decision if given the public insurance option I ask that you trust us to make good decisions. What’s the worst that could happen? We choose public insurance and it doesn’t work out, then we have to change our minds and buy back into private insurance. What’s the best that could happen? We each save thousands a year on our health insurance.

user-pic

First of all thanks a lot for the great and informative article. I have just been searching for some information about the health insurance and accidentally i have noticed this post. I see that there is a great discussion about this subject and reading all people's thoughts I have found many new and useful ideas about this insurance. It is really great that you have created the ability for us to express our own opinions. Thanks a lot for the informative entry one more time and keep up publishing these great posts in the future too. Regards, Brad Taylor from online payday loans website

user-pic

I think the insurance field is a great money maker for a few individuals who are already bringing home the profits. You don't have to be a genius to figure out that the auto insurance sector for example is a huge business. I mean look at how many cars are out there and how the auto parts prices are going up year by year...

user-pic

I think we should take care of our health as much as possible and don't rely on health insurance (at least not until 50 or around). Most of our health problems come from eating either really bad or too much. We all like junkfood and some of us really over do it. A really good way to improve your health and quality of life is to take an Appetite Suppressant which will lower the ammount of food you eat on a daily basis. Many people have tried this and have come to the conclusion that it's a really easy (yet efficient) way to improve their weightloss and life in general.

Facebook

Yes, I agree with it. It is being set up to fail and of course the tag "public" will be attached to it, and eternally frequent and reported as such on the TV news, seeing that what the aim is.
Quick cash loans | Faxless Loans

Facebook

This information is very useful! Thanks!
Best regards, Katya, CEO of windows 2008 hyper v, iscsi target 3.2

Facebook

The co-ops would give you access to group rates and would give small businesses and individuals some of the same bargaining power that large companies now have. But other than that, I'm not sure I see the advantage.
Short term loans | payday loans no faxing

Facebook

I was browsing the car insurance ireland website when I found your article here. The only good thing about this idea is the non-profit health insurance organization. That would surely put things on the right track.

Facebook

Si vous etes interesses par le dossier, ou desirez en savoir plus, contactez-moi par mail, et je vous mettrai en contact.
Best regards,Jane, CEO of sql server high availability

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address