TPMCafe
« Leadership, Organization, and Strategy in the California Farm Worker Movement | Home | Our meeting with Hamas »

Even gas comes through the tunnels

user-pic

weissgastunnelsmall1.jpg

This is one of the tunnels going to Egypt from Gaza. You're looking down the shaft on the Gaza side, about 25 meters to the bottom. People say there are hundreds of tunnels and if you walk around Rafah, the border town in the Gaza Strip, you can see scores of tents and shacks that enclose the work of the tunnels. If Israel wanted to destroy the tunnels, it could.

Why, there is even gas coming through the tunnels. Here is a photo I took of the gas pipes; see the two four-inch black pipes in the middle ground?

weissgastunnel2.jpg

The last time I was at the tunnels and looked down at the men working, I thought of the underground railroad. The people in Gaza live in bondage. The historical causes of this are complex, and we can talk about that when I get home, but the simple condition now is Bondage under Israel, with the complicity of the U.S., Egypt and even parts of Europe.

The actual fact of bondage is inarguable. No one will tell you any different, not the highest government official or the boys toiling in the tunnels. Hardly anyone in Gaza can get out; and the mass of people are being starved of a whole life, of dreams, dignity, education. The tunnels are the safety valve. If they were shut down, the situation would become so completely shocking that international condemnation would be overwhelming.


**
Read Mondoweiss here.


14 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Bondage? You make ethnoreligious oppression sound so kinky.

user-pic

What seems a mindset that the world bears nothing but enmity toward Israel has become a vast separation wall shutting Israel off from the rest of the world. The Jewish state is determined to do what it sees as in its best interest, its global image be damned.

This is the genesis, I think, of every monster - setting itself above ground-level social mechanism, basic morality. That's the real danger Israel faces: Of becoming what it has always pursued its people - forever, at least in the mind's eye. Israel is contemptuous of any appeals for its put-upon chattel, yet at the same time, it pleads constant danger of annihilation, that it's in relentless need of rescue.

At some point, regardless of our most deeply held beliefs, all humanity is part of one community, sharing, if you will, a covenant with one another. Israel has reached its crisis point, at which it can no longer act solely on its own will, and at the same time squeeze the world for pity from shame.


user-pic

National Solipsism?

user-pic

Good. Very good.

user-pic

Goodness Curt, what are you talking about? It's the Palestinians that are shut off from the rest of the world, not Israel. There isn't a single country that has supported the anti-semites' demands that Israel be sanctioned. Not one. Only those countries that have been doing so since 1948, and those are just poor Arab countries where the people don't have any say in what the government does. And there isn't a single country that doesn't support the blockade of Gaza, including other Arab Muslim countries such as Egypt.

You people are living in a fantasy. Israel is doing very well, maintains good relations with most of the world, and is stronger than ever. While the Palestinians starve. BradtheDad is right. People have entirely stopped caring about the Palestinians. They feel sorry for them, but everyone realizes that their problems are entirely of their own making. People have other things to worry about. Obama is making noises in an effort to distract the Muslim world's attention from America's war crimes and genocide in Iraq, but it's just talk. He knows perfectly well that supporting the Palestinians would be political suicide.

Politicians like Obama are horse-traders. They may talk nice, but if you want them to do something, you have to give them something in return. And the Palestinians don't have anything at all to offer. They have no money, no support, no allies, no nothing. So they're entirely out of options at this point. Better relations with the Muslim world? Nope, Iraq and Afghanistan have made that impossible for some decades to come. All they can offer is recognition of and peace with Israel, and they foolishly won't do that. So they're done.

user-pic

Philip writes, "If Israel wanted to destroy the tunnels, it could." But his final sentence explains why it cannot: "If they were shut down, the situation would become so completely shocking that international condemnation would be overwhelming."
The Israeli blockade is already a worldwide PR disaster. Tempting as it might be to let the Gazans starve and freeze to death, even Bibi knows Israel cannot afford the cost.
The greater the pressure on the Palestinians (whether in Gaza or the West Bank) the louder the international clamor for a peace deal becomes.
Time to really start negotiating.

user-pic

I think I speak for many when I say that I really don't give a rat's ass about how the people of Gaza are living in bondage. I feel sorry for the plight of children there, as they have no control over their fate. But the rest of the population is a different matter. Israel no longer has any interest in Gaza with the exception of preventing attacks on its people. The people of Gaza - the poor innocent victims of Philip Weiss's imagination - have consistently supported the armed terror campaigns of Hamas and Islamic Jihad. They had a historic opportunity after the Israeli withdrawal in 2005 to build instead of destroy. They actually had American Jews invest in new Gaza businesses. They squandered everything, so that Gaza is now nothing more than an a penal colony run by vicious gangsters. Does anyone doubt for a second that if Israel (and isn't it curious that it is only Israel that gets blamed for the state of siege Gaza is under) lifted the blockade of Gaza that attacks on Israel would begin immediately? Is anyone seriously in doubt on that question?

It's touching that Mr. Weiss's heart bleeds for poor Gazans. If it bled as much for Israeli victims of Gaza terrorism, then perhaps I'd feel differently about him. Sure there are innocent victims in Gaza, and one feels sorry for them the way one feels sorry for any innocent victim. But in terms of priority claims on my conscience, the people of Gaza rank pretty low.

user-pic

When are you going to get it through your thick skull that the situation in Gaza is a direct result of deliberate policies of both the Israeli AND the US governments? Is that reality too complex for you to grasp? Or is it simply impossible for you to set aside your proud prejudices in order to acknowledge the truth?


You're damn right that American Jews invested in Gaza and they were led by the most honorable one of them all, James Wolfenson who contributed $500,000.

Thanks for reminding me; it caused me to search for this old interview in Haaretz in which he sadly lays out what happened to the post-disengagement Gaza.

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/884018.html

Here's a short version; after Sharon fell into a coma, the Olmert govt and the bushies led by Elliot Abrams conspired to completely undo all the agreements made in regards to sustainable economic development for Gaza and shut Wolfenson out.

Sharon and Wolfenson had developed a warm working partnership.

In another post-disengagement account of the reality on the ground in Gaza published by the rightwing World Net Daily, the truth is exposed by non other than the settlers who were displaced:

JERUSALEM – After months of intense negotiations recently culminating in a deal allowing for the transfer of Gaza's high-tech Jewish greenhouses to the Palestinians, several former Jewish residents who briefly returned to their farms told WND they were shocked to find most of their produce has died because Israel turned off the water in the area.

"I couldn't believe it. Almost all of my crops are dead, and the rest is dying," Anita Tucker, one of the pioneer farmers of Jewish Gaza told WND. "I hope the Palestinians aren't expecting fresh produce. ... A fortune in crops is now all gone."

The greenhouse deal, reached just days before the Gaza evacuation, sold the area hot houses for about $14 million to the Economic Cooperation Foundation, an international fund which in turn will transfer the structures to the Palestinians.

The foundation consists mostly of private capital, including a personal $500,000 donation by James Wolfensohn, the former World Bank president who is a special Middle East envoy for the "quartet" of the U.S., the United Nations, the European Union and Russia.

About one-quarter of Gaza's Jewish greenhouses were previously dismantled and moved to new communities in Israel by their owners. The foundation deal reportedly covers the majority of the remaining hothouses.

The first payment to the former farmers of Jewish Gaza was transferred this weekend to a committee working on their behalf. A final payment will be made later this month, a member of the greenhouse negotiating team told WND.

PalTrade, a Palestinian company set up to export products from the greenhouses after they are transferred, has signed its first shipping contract for the produce slated to be grown there.

But several Jewish Gaza refugees who were allowed to briefly return to their hothouses said most of the produce currently inside is now dead.

Tucker, who owns large structures, said her hothouses were set to be watered by automatic irrigation systems.

"The sprinkler systems didn't work because Israel stupidly turned off the water after the Gaza withdrawal," said Tucker. "All my work, down the drain."


A former resident of Jewish Gaza's Ganei Tal farming
community who asked his name be withheld said, "Most of the greenhouses in Ganei Tal are dried up. This better not effect our payment because it's not our fault Israel turned off the water."
http://www.wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=46011

Come on Brad. Let's see you blame all of this shit on Hamas.

user-pic

"Come on Brad. Let's see you blame all of this shit on Hamas."

While maybe not all blame can be put on Hamas - surely some of it should... Actively engaging and supporting in terror attacks in Israel will not bring the Israelis to fight for the rights of Palestinians. It will just make them indifferent and even hateful. In fact you will often hear even with "moderate" Israelis: Why should we provide water or anything to Hamas, who is responsible for the murder of hundreds of Israelis and consistently harasses and terrorizes the civilian population....

The plight of the innocents in Gaza gets drowned in Israel because the gangsters of Hamas have taken over and have set a policy that will only hurt the Palestinians more. If anyone expects Israelis to care about whether the greenhouses built by settlers continues to recieve water they should encourage not only Israelis to open there eyes but Palestinians too - show them that, while there actions may be justified and right (i dont necesarily think they are but understand some do), they are not always smart and will lead to just more pain, hunger, death.

user-pic

It might help you to preempt writing a silly post by actually noting the dates and timelines of the article I linked to. Completely ignoring little thingies like reality don't help your "case".

Next thing you know, you will be blaming the Nabka on a Hamas that had yet to come into existance.

user-pic

let me help you with the timeline....for those that dont know: the very night israel left gaza 30 kassams were fired...and just about every day and night after that until a temp lull in dec 2008. More so the Gazans physically destroyed the hot houses. Whether or not one crop was lost due to lack of water does not excuse their total destruction....

this destruction was a 100% gazan, planned and executed

Facebook

Good. Very good.kameralı sohbet

Facebook

This information is very useful! Thanks!
Best regards, Katya, CEO of windows hyper v, openfiler iscsi windows

Facebook

Si vous etes interesses par le dossier, ou desirez en savoir plus, contactez-moi par mail, et je vous mettrai en contact.
Best regards,Jane, CEO of high availability clustering

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address