TPMCafe
« Crying Wolf -- The Same Old Song | Home | Let's Make PPIP Fun! »

ISRAEL AT 61; A HEGELIAN NOTION

user-pic

Tonight, Israel celebrates its 61st Independence Day. As usual, the country's commentators are offering mixed reviews, filled with angst and back-patting, celebration and worry. But, today I had the privilege of an unexpected 'Yom Hatzmaut' commemoration of my own, as an Israeli friend of mine was honored by Survivor Corps, an NGO that works with people who have been hit by land mines, torture, war and genocide.

My heroic friend, Nomika Tzion, lives in an urban kibbutz that she helped create, in the rocket-ravaged poor city of Sderot, just three miles or so from the Gaza border.

Yet, unlike many others who live in Sderot or in Israel proper, Nomika's response to the violence has never been to blame the other, to seek revenge or to desire war. She has always sought out a peaceful alternative and during the worst days of the recent war in Gaza, she also sought out partners--in Gaza--to work together toward peace. That's how she met Dr. Izzeldin Abuelaish, a Palestinian obstetrician and gynecologist who works in one of Israel's top hospitals, but who lives in a refugee camp in Gaza.

During the war in Gaza, Dr. Abuelaish lost 3 of his 8 children and a niece, killed by Israeli fire. One of his remaining children was seriously injured. Still, he too, seeks only peace. He is a well-known and respected doctor in Israel (and a less well-known fact-there are a significant number of Palestinian doctors working in top Israeli hospitals, both Palestinians who live inside the Green Line and are Israeli citizens or some, like Dr. Abuelaish, living in Gaza or the West Bank).

In addition to receiving this joint award, they will go anywhere and speak to anyone about a future with two states living in peace.

Nomika comes from stellar Zionist stock. Her grandfather was Yaacov Hazan, a storied and pivotal socialist Zionist who helped found the left wing kibbutz movement. He would not recognize the country he helped settle; nor would he recognize his granddaughter's kibbutz as the type of kibbutz he originated.

Nomika lives on Migvan, an urban kibbutz that exists as a small neighborhood of single family homes, beautifully designed, on a street in the town of Sderot. The kibbutz members pool everything; they run one of the top non-profits in Israel, doing grassroots organizing and teaching empowerment to the inhabitants of southern Israel. And they intentionally live in a poor community, a border community, to be part of the community there, not separate from it. All of them could choose to live elsewhere, away from the kassams, but they don't. They stay in Sderot, with their secured rooms and live with the same danger as others. Nomika herself had a rocket fall on her house. When I visited her, I saw the damage done to a roof across the yard from her.

In her talk today, when she received the award, she had this to say about Israel's independence. I can think of no better message for Israel's Independence Day. Echoing the Hegelian notion of master-slave, we are who we enslave and our freedom comes from freeing those we hold captive, she said:

"At this very moment Israel is celebrating its 61st Independence Day. I always feel proud and privileged to be living in my own country. I always feel distressed while a few miles away from my home more than 1.5 million people are captured in the largest prison in the world, fighting for their survival. Our independence will never be complete until our Palestinian neighbors are able to celebrate their own freedom...

"You and me, [she said to Dr. Abuelaish] are the symbols of this insane ongoing conflict. It is therefore our civil responsibility to speak out clearly and loudly -sometimes against the mainstream-sometimes against our friends who look for another round of revenge, not as victims, but as proud civilians, who have gotten so very tired of hurting each other. It is our obligation to make our leaders talk, to compel them to tell us, for a change, a different story."



11 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Thank you for sharing this Jo-Ann.

user-pic

Israel needs more people liker her.

user-pic

Nomika Tzion sounds like a wonderful person!

user-pic

There is hope as long as people like her, and him, can remain not only compassionate but hopeful. I don't think I could.

user-pic

The power of these dedicated and humane examples is largely lost if fanatics and terrorists in the Mideast -working together, though on opposite sides, to continually renew hate and violence- are not confronted and their defacto veto power over the peace process removed. The U.S. has taken a solid position against Palestinian terrorism. It is time for it to do so against the West Bank settler-terrorists as well. This means speaking out precisely and unrelentingly against the large majority of the U.S. Congress that has been indirectly but effectively aiding and abetting these settlers.

user-pic

I watched a commemoration of the Holocaust on C-SPAN the other day and now I read your column mentioning Israel's 61st Independence Day. Your column mentions two people, Nomika Tzion and
Dr. Izzeldin Abuelaish. Which brought to mind...

Allow me to take you back 65 years ago this Saturday, May 2, 1945 and two different people, an American soldier and a Jewish woman newly liberated from the Woebblin concentration camp at Ludwigslust, Germany.

As the soldier was leaving the camp which was now under the control of another unit, he passed an elderly woman prisoner at the gate. She had her hands clasped in prayer and was nodding her head up and down, much like most other prisoners there at liberation.

As the soldier passed the woman he reached into his pocket and took out the orange he swiped off the front seat of an American supply truck parked inside the camp, and he handed it to the woman.
It was the last thing he did inside that camp before walking through the gate to continue the war, which, unknown to the soldier, would last only 6 more days.

The soldier's wife told him that was at least one nice story that came out of that war, and she started a ritual in giving sliced oranges to their children, grandchildren and now great grandchildren whenever they come to visit.

Two people in the Middle East and two people in Ludwigslust.

Now and then that soldier wonders whatever happened to that woman at the gate.


user-pic
Our independence will never be complete until our Palestinian neighbors are able to celebrate their own freedom...

Words to remember and live by, even here in America. Middle class Americans will never have true freedom until those who are relegated to the "less desirable" parts of town also have freedom from poor jobs, aggressive salesmen of Payday Loans, tote-the-note car loans, overpriced subprime mortgages lack of adequate health care and rotten education for the children.

That's the kind of freedom that counts, but it for damned sure isn't what the Conservatives mean by "Freedom."

What is stopping the conservatives from enjoying their "freedom?" Fear that someone will come and take it away from them. That fear won't go away until they start sharing some of the things they demand a monopoly on.

user-pic

my favorite quote for today:

If people base their identity on identifying with authority, freedom causes anxiety. They must then conceal the victim in themselves by resorting to violence against others. Arno Gruen
user-pic

Richhard,

whoever said that spoke a lot of truth.

user-pic

Thanks John for that vignette - and Richard ... apt on this 61st anniversary of the establishment of a state intended to provide a Jewish homeland .. a place that my grandparents in Poland only dreamt of during the pogroms and their life in the shtetl ... 61 years on and what has been achieved .. an underground store of nuclear weapons that will one day wipe out the world ... that's what WMD are designed for ... killing and contamination on a global scale ... but that is not what Zionism was ... only what it has become ... a byword for kreplach and killing ... tanks and missiles ... matzah and mayhem ... strutting arrogant soldiers who have no conception of the sanctity of life or the terrible stupidity of oppression and torture. That is not Zionism. Zionism was freedom and life and love and children ... not this darkness that wakes one in the night with the screaming silent images of the dead and dying. This is not Zionism.


user-pic

bluecanary,


today, Saturday, is the 65th Anniversary of my handing that woman the orange. It seems like only yesterday.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Versha Sharma



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address