TPMCafe
« Obama Gets an "A" on Health Care; Needs Improvement on Banks | Home | Bobby Jindal »

Obama's Masterful Speech

user-pic

The sight of this new President before all of assmbled official Washington is, in its way, as extraordinary as the other standout moments of this past half year: Denver in Mile High; election night in Grant Park; the DC Inaugural. All of those showed Obama directly amidst throngs of the American people, yet even here, amidst the new official Washington, he speaks to -- and for -- the citizenry. Repeatedly in this speech, Obama presented himself as fighting for a people of goodness and resolve -- for a better, shared future for all Americans. This is a very effective way for him to marginalize political enemies and call elites as well as regular citizens to greater personal and social responsibility.

Several impressions:

--Obama spoke more quickly and firmly than usual. Confidence in the face of massive challenge was his message, and I think it worked, allowing him to reframe his themes of resolve in the face of crisis, and determination to lay foundations for a stronger national future. The language of patriotic responsibility, love of nation, and service to nation allows him to speak for and with all of us. The challenge to Congress to take responsibility was also clear. To get beyond short-term and petty considerations. He called out irresponsible elites, too, to give voice to populist anger. He "gets it."

--A lot of policy ground was covered, but Obama's speech did not seem wonky. The best policy news, from my perspective, was the announcement that he is moving forward with health care reform this year. His framing for this new round of a too-oft-repeated and too oft-failed struggle is brilliant: "Cost" is the fault he invokes, allowing him to point at once to the burden on the economy and the burden on people. This is quite different from the traditional Democratic rhetoric of expanding coverage to the uninusured, yet it includes that goal and marries it to the larger challenge of economic renewal and innovation.

-- In such marked contrast to the timid triangulation of Clinton, Obama offers a strong, positive statement of the role of U.S. government in national development, past and for the future. Government does not "substitute" for business or individual action, but it is an essential "catalyst." Regulation has to be there to make markets "healthy." Obama invokes examples across the sweep of our history to illustrate and motivate the new round of federal government initiatives he now promises to lead -- and he names the major challenges that require major federal investments: in health care, energy, and education.

-- Obama managed to invoke the need for greater fiscal responsibiliy in a manner helps to motivate major social reforms (health care as a way to contain costs as well as support American wellbeing) and in a manner that makes it harder for Republicans to fight higher taxes on the wealthy. This is politically brilliant. So what if reducing the deficit by half by 2012 is a pipedream -- all Presidents make that same promise (half the deficit reduced ty the end of their first term!), but HOW they frame this task is what matters. Obama is doing it in a way that supports reforms and social investments and higher taxes on the well-to-do.

-- Overall, I am in awe of how effectively Obama combined human empathy with a projection of authority, and patriotic Americanism with a realistic assessment of where we really stand in a competitive world. How often have we heard any major U.S. politician repeatedly suggest in a speech that America is, or is in risk of, falling behind other named countries in key realms (renewable energy production, education, retooling major industries)? Obama did that several times tonight -- to help explain why he wants us to spur ourselves to greater investments and efforts. But he did it without making us seem pitiable or weak, in the context of an appeal to pull together and shape a better future. Remarkable.


8 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Yes, Obama provided motivation for his policy goals without sounding overly negative about our shortcomings. Seems to me he did very well walking that fine line between realism and optimism.

I thought it was a remarkable speech.

I think his pacing had a lot to do with the fact that he knew the speech was going to run long. He seemed impatient with the applause! Funny, though, it didn't feel to me like a long speech.

-- ARG

user-pic

And how nice was it to see the newest Cabinet member in the chamber? What a day for Labor Secretary Hilda Solis.

user-pic

It was breathtaking...the man is a master

user-pic

Ummm, were you conscious during the Clinton administration? This speech sounded very Clintonesque.

Obama: "not because I believe in bigger government, I don't"

Clinton in 1996: "The era of big government is over."

Using the Republican hatred of "big government" and adopting it in your own rhetoric is pretty much the *definition* of triangulation.

user-pic

Non-wonky for sure: he's still pushing "clean coal"; however, there is not such thing as clean coal. The problem is there's no place to put the CO2 after it's been captured. This shows he has been captured by the coal industry. He also has surrounded himself with the same neoliberals who deregulated us into this financial mess during the Clinton administration. How is he going to escape that?

user-pic

pokerbum,

Non-wonky for sure: he's still pushing "clean coal"; however, there is not such thing as clean coal.

No indeed. Meanwhile, I remain optimistic that it was merely a gratuitous political nod to the folks downstate that once upon a time helped make Barack Obama the junior Senator from Illinois, and when push comes to shove science will prevail.

user-pic

I think the speech was good too. Obama projected strength, which people look for in a leader in times of crisis, and (like W) sometimes find it where it doesn't exist. Obama was blunt, but followed Bill Clinton's advice to be upbeat, without sounding pollyanna-ish. I would have liked at least an extra paragraph or two explaining about where he is going in the banking crisis (given that a lack of specifics has been a problem), but those will no doubt be coming out of his Administration.

It was staged to be like an unscheduled State of the Union address and it worked -- I think it was effective and polls will show it to have been so.

The snarling forces of retrenchment, including copperheadism at the astroturf roots, however, remain unabated as of now.

user-pic

Perhaps it's one of those "you had to be there" deals. But I just can't listen to any more speeches, lectures or sermons. Smoke, mirrors and pancake makeup is what we see on TV. It remains merely propaganda (framing. marketing, Lakoff lingo) whether it's our guy or theirs if, and this is important, if we just applaud without using the speech as a jumping off point for a real conversation about what needs to be done and how.

What do we remember about FDR most? Fireside chats or his reforms? We can actually see what FDR accomplished when we see our parents living in some dignity on Social Security. We can now feel what the gutting of the Glass-Steagall Act can do to us. Yes, the fireside chats were comforting and made us feel some sense of unity, but they had bold policies behind them whose effects we can directly see and feel today.

But that's just me. What I need is some big bold move like taking over Citigroup or pushing straight for a universal healthcare plan as a show of good faith to those who have born the brunt of this foolish experiment with empire and repackaged feudalism. Close down 109 or more of our 761 military bases. Frog march some of the banksters off to jail. How about fixing New Orleans?

Speeches serve some purpose, but if they are followed by that strange elfin looking creature Geithner mumbling about stress tests, I am not yet ready to get all fuzzy or awestruck over how much niftier Washington looks than it did two months ago.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Versha Sharma



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address