TPMCafe
« Burg's Past and Future | Home | In Obama's Election, Hope for Israel's Future »

To Bring Peace to Others, You Must First Bring it to Yourself

user-pic


It is with great honor that I join the conversation set forth here on TPMCafe by Avraham Burg. The Holocaust is Over: Let us rise from the Ashes is a courageous book that calls out for the healing of a people. For if one cannot be at peace with themselves how on earth can they be at peace with anyone else.

I learned about the struggles in the Middle East some twenty years ago while I was an intern in the office of Senator Edward M. Kennedy. As a budding national security scholar, I asked the good Senator why the US did not work closer with the Russians to contain nuclear weapons. His answer was not about nuclear weapons but Jewish emigration.

I went home confused for I had no idea what one had to do with the other. That day I began to study the Middle East. I learned more than I could have imagined about victims, racism, ignorance and violence. All of which is no stranger to anyone in Israel or in its neighboring states.

As a curious student, I eventually visited Israel and the occupied territories. I have to say that it was one of the hardest trips I've ever made. It was not only difficult to see how poorly so many people on each side of the conflict were being treated; it was tremendously difficult to witness Israelites internal treatment of each other. I figured out in a very short time that much of the internal unrest was due to the remnants of the Holocaust. It had a devastating and lasting grip on a people.

During my trip, I, like many others, visited Yad Vashem. A group of us gathered while my Jewish friends explained the burning flame. I still cry as I feel their anguish. Greif was evident as I toured the country, met the people and struggled to understand the overreaching politics of fear.

In my work today, I continue to study and teach about a world that so desperately holds on to war. Throughout my travels I see the trauma, the rage, those who cannot or will not let go of the wrongs they have done or the wrongs that have been done to them. It is immeasurably complicated to move on.

Despite this, I do agree with Burg that there is a train leaving the station. As he puts it, people everywhere are discussing "how best to depart from the miseries caused by the political regimes of the 20th century and toward an open, pluralistic society which contains the contemporary 'other.'" Within this, the 'other[s]' are also rising up to get on that train and be a part of the larger global society.

In his book, I believe with a heavy heart that Burg found the reason why Israel seems to be ignoring the train. It remains instead on a track caught in the middle; in between the Holocaust and, as he puts it, "shoahization."

In writing this book, Burg knew that he "would touch so much pain," "that he must be careful." The reaction to his work serves as confirmation. One may think due to such a response that he is unaccompanied in the wilderness. This, however, is not true.

There are many out there who see and who work tirelessly together so that violence and war no longer plague this region. In the words of Yitzhak Rabin, "Israel is no longer a people that dwells alone, and has to join the global journey toward peace, reconciliation and international cooperation." So if Israel is going to 'dwell' with others, first and foremost the Palestinians and other surrounding Arab nations, it must begin by learning to dwell with itself. Israel must start by listening to the advice of Burg -- The Holocaust is Over: We must Rise from the Ashes -- thereby allowing itself to heal and join those boarding that train to a more peaceful future.


8 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Good comments and well said. Thank you.

Can you expound on what Kennedy said to you?

user-pic

Yes that Kennedy comment jumped out at me also. Does this really mean that someone as respected as Kennedy was placing the Jewish emigration issue above issues of nuclear war? Up to that time, no people behind the Iron country were free to travel, and while that was used in Western propaganda to embarrass the Russians, it did not stop us from trying to back away from the threat of nuclear war with them. Does this mean there was a Jewish exception? We now know that Israel,and the neocon clique in Jackson's office, were pushing this issue the hardest because of the need for immigrants to counter the Arab demographic threat.

Most certainly, it would be interesting to get more detail on Kennedy's statement.

user-pic

Its not that simple, syvanen. Hundreds of thousands of Soviet Jews escaped the USSR largely because of Jackson's admirable persistence on the issue of Jewish emigration. I know Americans who spent years as refuseniks, and who to this day worship Jackson's memory. To say that the only reason for Israel to pursue the issue of Jewish emigration is to counter Arab demographic thread, is about the same as to say that Americans revolted against the British just because their taxes have been too high.

However wrong Israel might be on any number of issues, Jews all over the world know that if for any reason any Jew anywhere in the world will face danger because (s)he is a Jew, they shall have a place to flee - that is the founding premise of Israel, which hopefully will be in force for as long as there will be reasons for Jews to fear for their lives and their communities anywhere in the world.

US hasn't always been such a place in the past, and might not be such a place in the future. Not all Jews in America might appreciate Israel as the last refuge for any Jew now, but we never know what the future holds. Surely Jews from Ethiopia, Chechnya, Uzbekistan, Yugoslavia could tell American Jews a thing or two about that.

P.S. All that said, I don't see any reason whatsoever to keep the Jackson-Wanick amendment alive for Russia (as I understand it still is). Anyone knows why?

user-pic

The shtetl is dead! Long live the Shoah!

user-pic

The shtetl is dead because it was killed by the Shoah. Please stop embarrassing yourself.

user-pic

Give it up, anatol -- epanalepsis is just not your bag.

user-pic

And so very fortunate for Israel -- and for Judaism -- is it.

user-pic

Excuse me? The Shoah was very fortunate for Israel and for Judaism?

TPMCafe baristas, please take note - the woman has a serious overdose of caffeine. Me, I'm not going to touch this steaming pile.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Kyle Krahel-Frolander



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address