Week of November 2, 2008 - November 8, 2008
Rahm Emanuel: Nobody Puts That Baby In a Corner
My previous statement on this subject is being vindicated by Jeff Goldberg, the New Yorker writer, a close Emanuel buddy. Read it.
I know plenty of you don't like Goldberg either. But he's pretty progressive on Israel and, I guess because he served in the Israeli army, has no problem telling Israel what it should do i.e. end the occupation.
Bottom line. Rahm Emanuel is going to be the White House enforcer. Forget about his father!
Debating Who Obama Picks is Relevant to What His Administration Will Do
I've been saying for some time that the day after Obama's election, all sorts of policy and personality battles would unfold around him.
This is happening as predicted, and the tension, backbiting, and jostling for position is fraying the nerves of many who are highest on the list of candidates Obama is considering for senior positions throughout the government.
Stop Trashing Palin
This McCain orchestrated trashing of Sarah Palin is sickening.
Her campaign was horrible. She knows nothing about he issues. She was, almost surely, the worst VP candidate in history.
Summers at Treasury: What Would We Tell the Children?
Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers' name is consistently placed prominently on the list of candidates to be President Obama's Treasury Secretary. This is rather striking since the policies he promoted as Treasury Secretary and in his subsequent writings led to the economic disaster that we now face.
As Treasury Secretary, Summers embraced the high dollar policy promoted by his predecessor Robert Rubin. While it offered short-term benefits in the form of cheap imports and lower inflation, the high dollar also produced a large and growing trade deficit. Just like tax cuts that cause unsustainable budget deficits, the high dollar policy of the Clinton years was unsustainable over the long-run.
Barack Obama Should Wrap Up Israel-Palestinian Deal In '09
The Jewish vote went 78 percent for Barack Obama. It is now safe to say that, after 80 years of consistently voting Democratic for President, the Jewish vote is no less predictable than the African-American vote or the vote of union households.
Accordingly, the scare tactics that worked so well against Obama during the Democratic primaries flopped in the general election. The Republican Jewish Coalition, which wasted gazillions on race-mongering, might as well close shop. If a relatively moderate Republican nominee cannot break above 22 percent after six months of lying e-mails alleging that the Democrat is a Middle Eastern terrorist, it is safe to say that the Jewish Republican ship will never come in.
Doing the Numbers
I know this is motley foolish, that no matter what business journalists imply, the "market" is not some big mind, responding to events with the wisdom of crowds. But the election debates have habituated me to watching lines on graphs as leaders talk; and MSNBC carried a real time, side-screen report on the Dow as Obama responded to questions.
In the earlier, and vaguer, parts of his news conference, the Dow dropped from about plus 130 for the day to under 100. As soon as he spoke forcefully about creating new jobs, in ways Paul Krugman laid out this morning, and for all the obvious reasons, the numbers began to climb steadily, and finished above 200. Let's just say some investors--not just value investors with deep pockets like Warren Buffet, but quick traders, too--understand this economy has only one hope. And Obama was shrewd to keep it alive with, of all people, fiscal hawks like Paul Volcker standing behind him.
An Appreciation
When we have a moment to reflect in the coming days on this week's election, we might pause to consider and appreciate what the people living among the farms and cornfields of Indiana, in the old textile towns of North Carolina, and in the hollows of West Virginia said when they stood and voted this week. What they said, whatever else they have have thought or felt, was that we have overcome.
If this is true, such a statement comes closer than anything else can to fulfilling the ancient hopes of our nation's founders, when they sought, in establishing our republic, to form a more perfect union.
Here Comes the Sun
If you watch the video, you readily see that we could be in much worse trouble. At any rate, both of these can be true at the same time:
1. Public opinion is mired in center-right ideology.
2. President O can lead the nation to progressive policies.
Big Victories in the States as Well
Yeah, that Obama thing was pretty cool (I watched the returns the Obama campaign office in Harlem, which had to be one of the most inspiring places to be), but it's worth noting that the victory extended far down ticket to state races.
To some extent the victories at the state level were more limited because Dems had already made big gains in 2006 and 2007, with Iowa, Colorado, New Hampshire and chambers in Virginia and Indiana having gone "blue" in anticipation of Obama's wins -- with North Carolina Dems demonstrating increasingly progressive leadership by its Blue local leadership over the last few years. This had given those voters a chance to see and understand what progressive leadership was really about--and overcoming many of the caricatures of the rightwing.
Krauthammer Weeps Over "Valiant" Mc Cain
This time I'm really, really not going to mention how Krauthammer bellowed ast the rabbi on Yom Kippur. That is getting OLD.
But today, our boy is kind of sad. He writes about John McCain. "Before our old soldier fades away, it is worth acknowledging that McCain ran a valiant race against impossible odds. He will be -- he should be -- remembered as the most worthy presidential nominee ever to be denied the prize.."
Rahm Emanuel Is No Likudnik
Before the netroots starts attacking Emanuel as an AIPAC stooge, Likudnik, or whatever, let me weigh in.
It's not true. His father is an Israeli and was active in the Irgun, the terrorist group founded by Menachem Begin which famously bombed Jerusalem's King David Hotel.
I don't know what the old man's politics on Israel are today (not all Irgunists were rightwingers). I suspect that, if he was still a rightwinger, he would not have produced a bunch of liberal kids. (Rahm's brother, the Jeremy Piven one, writes often on HuffPo and is a total Hollywood liberal).
Dancing in the Streets
The last time Americans danced and cheered in the streets was in 1945, when the nation finally defeated its enemies in the Second World War. I have no memories of those exuberant days. But I'm an historian and I've seen plenty of pictures and read many descriptions of the joy and happiness that swept over the country.
Obama's stunning victory is the first time in 63 years that Americans once again danced and cheered in the street. Here on the Left Coast, thousands of Berkeley students danced in the city, wildly cheering his victory. In Oakland's Jack London Square and in San Francisco's Castro District, tens of thousands more gathered for joyous street parties, dancing in the street. It was a bittersweet victory because of the success of those who sought to ban same-sex marriage. That day, too, will come. Of this I'm sure.
Party of Palin?
A subsidiary theme within the flood of commentary on the Obama victory is the fate of the Republican Party. In an article on Monday entitled "The Republican Rump," Paul Krugman suggested that "the Republican rump, the party that's left after the election, will be the party that attends Sarah Palin's rallies, where crowds chant "Vote McCain, not Hussein!" It will be the party of Saxby Chambliss, the senator from Georgia, who, observing large-scale early voting by African-Americans, warns his supporters that "the other folks are voting." It will be the party that harbors menacing fantasies about Barack Obama's Marxist -- or was that Islamic? -- roots."
Let's hope it doesn't play out that way.
The Election of the First Black President Owes A Lot to George W. Bush (In a Good Way)
Would America have elected Barack Obama if white Americans had not gotten accustomed to seeing (in succession) two African-American Secretaries of State? I don't think so. Before Bush, African-Americans were appointed to some good posts but not to our #1 foreign policy job. Two African Americans (one with a pretty odd first name) served as America's face to the world. That eased Obama's way. It is not Tiger Woods in whose footsteps Obama is walking -- it's Rice and Powell.
The Next Treasury Secretary: What's Their Track Record?
It would be a really bad start to his administration if President Obama picked a Treasury Secretary who shares a substantial part of the blame for the bubble economy and the financial crisis. It will not be easy to pick up the pieces and get the economy back on its feet, but we would be going in the wrong direction to put one of the people responsible for getting us in this mess in the top economic position in the Obama administration.
Sheila Bair, the current head of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, can boast of clean hands. Unlike other contenders, she never obstructed regulation of the $60 trillion credit default swap market. Nor did she push to maintain the over-valued dollar that gave us an $800 billion trade deficit. Unlike many others dealing with the fallout from the housing crash, she has noticed that people are losing their homes and has made preventing this a top priority.
Bad news in Washington: the pro sports teams
The hockey team has the best player in the world, and still is mighty disappointing.
The football team was manhandled by the Steelers. The general manager drafted three receivers to beef up the catching capability and none of them can play. The Steelers stacked the line and stifled the offense.
The baseball team did everyone a favor by not drawing audiences. And their stadium is really ugly.
Grant Park
Betsy and I were there. We were bowled over by the meaning of the event, much more than we thought we would be. We are quite confident Barack will be a great President, since he has just run the single best Presidential campaign in the history of our country.
Reading The Pictures
Coincident with the launch of the Obama administration, one thing I'm hoping for is a greater progressive ownership in and of the "visual public sphere."
The Content of His Character
I confess a certain impatience, on this poignant day, with all the earnest talk about how America achieved something remarkable yesterday by electing our first African-American president, as if the choice has been about race all along. I do not mean to diminish an historic first, like electing a Catholic in 1960; I, too, choked-up when John Lewis spoke. But relief today is not about Americans choosing an obviously black man over a white man, which proves we can come to terms with our past. It is about our choosing an obviously brilliant, reciprocal man over a thick, cynical one--a man who articulates a coherent vision of global commonwealth over someone advancing vague, military patriotism--which proves we can come to terms with our future.
Time For Israel To Mend Fences With President-Elect Obama
I hope sane Israelis understand how damaging it is to Israel to be identified in today's New York Times as being one of three nations on the planet that clearly preferred McCain to Obama.
During the campaign I would have denied that was the case because some American Jews might have been moved by this information to support McCain. (In the end 78% voted for Obama). But I knew it was true as did everyone who knows anything about Israel. And it was not only the right in Israel that was pro-McCain. It was pretty much across the board, EXCEPT for the pro-peace left. (see this rundown)
Making Hope Real: Beyond the Politics of Immediate Gratification
As an American and a citizen of the world, I was thrilled by Barack Obama's victory in yesterday's election. But even as we savor his historic victory (our historic victory), it's not too soon to start thinking about how to transform the inspiration of the moment into the new policies we desperately need. This was a key theme of Obama's speech last night, and it's worth taking him up on it by beginning a thoughtful conversation about the future of the country.
In the area that I specialize in -- foreign policy -- change is hard. Disentangling from Iraq, finding a more practical course in Afghanistan, crafting coordinated international approaches to curbing climate change and reviving the global economy, making good on Obama's pledge to seek a world free of nuclear weapons -- these challenges will not be resolved in a day, a month, a year, or, in some cases, a decade or more. But we have a chance to get started in the right direction for the first time in this century -- if we can get beyond the politics of immediate gratification.
A Memo to President-Elect Obama from America's New Veterans
Congratulations to President-elect Obama. Both he and Senator McCain are outstanding patriots, and hey, each ran a tough campaign. Now that the race is finally over, it's time to bring America together, and get to work. And there is no shortage of challenges ahead. As one vet at IAVA put it, "The new guy is going to be busier than a one-legged man in an ass-kicking contest."
The new guy is definitely going to need the right people around him. One of the most important decisions the President will make regarding veterans is his choice of VA Secretary. President-elect Obama has the option of keeping Secretary Peake, who is new to the job and has already shown himself to be considerably more adept than his predecessor. Another shake-up could possibly slow things down, however.
Remember LBJ, Mr. President: Go For It All The First Year
Lyndon Johnson understood that the honeymoon would be short. After the largest landslide in history -- with the biggest Democratic Congressional majorities ever -- he acted as if he had a year to get his Great Society enacted.
"You've got to give it all you can, that first year," he told an aide. "Doesn't matter what kind of a majority you come in with. You've got just one year when they treat you right, and before they start worrying about themselves."
What Just Happened

Isn't this strange. Maybe you have to be old to appreciate it. Fasten your seatbelts, now the fun begins.
The Burdens of History, Reconciliation, and Fatality
Amid the euphoria last night in Chicago, one network's cameras zoomed in on an elderly black man who simply stood there weeping. Jesse Jackson wept quietly that way, too. So did I.
Everything in Barack Obama's bearing and speech showed he understood what we were feeling. Last night he shouldered the burdens of history and fatality with a gravitas and, I thought, a sadness reminiscent of Lincoln's.
The Best Night Of Our Lives
Other than those personal rites of passage -- and I've had some wonderful ones -- this was the best night of my life.
I have two grandchildren, twins born in February. The first President they will ever know is an African-American. We won't have to teach them about equality and the stupidity of prejudice. We won't have to tell them, as white liberals tend to tell their kids, that they are "just as good as us" because they will know it. After all, the President is black. They won't tear up, as I did, the first time they see the word "President" under a photo of a black man or gaze in wonder at our beautiful African-American "First Family."
Force Majeure
Conceding, McCain paid tribute to African-Americans, and honored Obama for--having defeated him.
Everyone is calling him gracious--on MSNBC, Keith Olbermann and Rep. John Lewis, for example. I suppose he was. What he couldn't bring himself to do: compliment Obama for the way he conducted himself; for any of his talents; for any ideas; for his character.
Beneath the velvet, it was faint praise. A bitter night for Sen. McCain, to be sure.
Is This The Night "They Drove Old Dixie Down?"
To give birth to a new one, for all its people.
We will know once Virginia comes in and Obama actually carries he capital of the confederacy.
I only wish Dr. King and LBJ were here to see what is happening. And Malcolm who, at the end of his life, came to the understanding that America could be capable of even of this.
President Obama's Path to Greatness: Health Care As Stimulus
President Obama will have a historic opportunity to establish himself as a truly great president in his first days in office. He can take advantage of the current economic crisis to announce plans to jump start national health care insurance. Extending health care insurance can be an effective stimulus that will provide an immediate boost to the economy.
More importantly, it will provide the same access to health care that people in other wealthy countries have long taken for granted. For this accomplishment, President Obama will rank alongside Presidents Roosevelt and Lincoln as one of the nation's truly great presidents.
A Pox on "The Poll of Polls"

Enough already with these "poll of polls". CNN does it, RealClearPolitics does it, and so does Pollster. And so too will a lot of other imitators do the same thing in the next election cycle, if we just let it all slide by right now. Not on my watch. This morning, to take a conspicuous example on my home front, brought news from Pollster.com that Ohio was now back in the tossup column, based on the averaging of the latest polls, apples and oranges alike.
FOX/Rasmussen's robotic, digitally-recorded poll had Ohio as a dead heat with both McCain and Obama at 49% each. The reputable Quinnipiac Poll showed Obama up 50% to 43%. Reuters/Zogby's numbers from their online, interactive poll looked "too close to call", with Obama leading by just two points (49-47). SurveyUSA's robo-poll also had it too close to call (Obama by 48-46). But the University of Cincinnati's Ohio Poll--one with a great record of accuracy (not just because I work there...see it for yourself) had Obama leading by six points (52-46). And last, but not least, among the apples and oranges in the "poll of polls" this morning were the numbers provided by Strategic Vision--which as Mark rightly noted today, is a Republican affiliated firm-- telling us that McCain was up by 2% (48-46) in a race to close to call.
Can there be any doubt that this is the world's election?
Peruvian shamans check in. I won't spoil this by saying whom they prefer.
Election Day
Years from now, when we've (hopefully) had time to reflect on the good and bad done by the Obama Administration, I'll be able to tell my son Arlo that he helped usher in a new era of politics.
I'll tell him the story of how his parents took him to the polls on Newkirk Avenue in Brooklyn, and all around them were the faces of America: elderly Jewish holdouts from an earlier era of Flatbush, recent immigrants from Pakistan and Bangladesh, African Americans, West Indians, and, of course, white folks like me and Nicole who were attracted by the low apartment prices and easy community of our neighborhood.
Four Years Later
It is hard to imagine now that four years ago George Bush was reelected in the midst of a climate of fear and suspicion. Democrats were on the defensive, the long term relevancy of their party being questioned by the media. Today's election may render the Republicans a minority party, completely out of tune with the mood of the country. What happened?
The easy answer would be to say "Iraq and Lehman Bros.". Those two tragedies expose the fallacy of the neoconservative philosophy of preemptive war and radical deregulation. But I would argue for two different phrases--"Bottom-up and Broadband". In 2004 Democrats were overpowered by two forces: the Republican Top Down money/organizing machine and the power of right wing talk radio. There were many states that will vote Democratic today (Montana, Virginia, North Carolina, Indiana) that in 2004 had neither organization or media that reflected a Democratic message.
Indicted AIPACer Gets Job With Hatemonger Daniel Pipes
JTA reports that Steve Rosen, former Director of Policy at AIPAC, has landed a job with Daniel Pipes, whose careeer has gone from various teaching gigs to fulltime anti-Obama and anti-Muslim hate-mongering. Rosen is under federal indictment for espionage.
I'll spare comment on Rosen with whom I worked during my AIPAC days (1982-1986) and who has always struck me as Washington's spookiest character. I will say that in 1984, when he was supporting Reagan and I was gung-ho for Mondale,he told me, "You and I are not that far apart. You'll be surprised to know that my parents were Stalinists."
Thoughts Upon Casting My 6:00 am Vote
Polling places in New York City open at 6:00 am, and when I arrived at mine at 5:45 a.m. at least 600 people were on line, stretching from the school door near East 33rd Street and Third Avenue back to the end of the block on Second Avenue, and then down the avenue to 32nd Street. By the time I left after casting my vote, at 6:45 or so, it had grown light out, and there were at least another 600 people waiting on line.
The Civil War ("War Between The States") Ends Tonight
It's no secret to TPMCafe readers that I believe that -- in addition to all his other qualities that make Barack Obama the best Democratic nominee in the party's history -- Obama's racial background is of incredible significance. My wife, a public school teacher and counselor, reports that, for months now, she has seen the inspirational effect on African-American children (especially the boys). But she also notes the excitement among kids in general, telling me about one white kindergarten kid with Down syndrome, who hardly talks, but when he happened to see the young tall slender gym fair-complexioned gym teacher, started shouting "OBAMA." Nothing else, just the name. And then a big smile.
Those Prop 8 Ads
Some time early Monday Google Adsense starting running a Pro Proposition 8 ad on TPM. For those of you who aren't familiar with it, Prop 8 is a ballot initiative in California which would ban same-sex marriages. We assume it's only running in California, for obvious reasons.
Here's what it looked like for those who don't live in California.
Now, we've gotten a lot of emails about this. So I wanted to explain publicly why the ad is running.
The Wrong Kind of Choice
Thousands of volunteers across the country are preparing for today's historic election. Here in Wisconsin, field workers are preparing to give rides and make reminder phone calls to voters while lawyers throughout the state are reviewing election laws, preparing to take the day off from work to make sure that every vote gets counted. But reports from Florida and Virginia that voters have had to wait for up to eight hours in order to vote are provoking concern and outrage that perhaps even the best organized campaign in American history won't be able to make sure that all of its supporters see the inside of a voting booth. Who are the most likely to be unable to wait for hours before casting their ballots? Voters with employers who don't see the value of their employees making their voices heard. Voters who might actually want to elect political representatives who would fight for universal health care and higher minimum wage laws: voters who aren't rich.
Greg Palast and RFK, Jr. on How The Election Could Be Stolen
I'm posting this whole (I don't have a link)not because I think it is going to happen, but because it might. We need to be prepared.
By Gregory Palast:
It's November 5 and the nation is in shock. Media blame it on the "Bradley effect": Americans supposedly turned into Klansmen inside the voting booth, and Barack Obama turned up with 6 million votes less than calculated from the exit polls. Florida came in for McCain and so did Indiana. Colorado, despite the Democrats' Rocky Mountain high after the Denver convention, stayed surprisingly Red. New Mexico, a state where Anglos are a minority, went McCain by 300 votes, as did Virginia.That's the nightmare. Here's the cold reality.
Too Radical, Too Risky
That's the punchline of a Minister of Hate ad run by something called GOPTrust just now--on MSNBC, during Olbermann's show.
James Fallows same the same ad a few hours ago on MSNBC in California. He saw it several times. I saw it in New York. So some Republican outfit, on election night, is throwing money away on Keith Olbermann fans in the safest states in the universe.
McCain's Real America: Having Fun Over Obama's Grandmother's Death
Can you imagine this on our side: enjoying the death of say McCain's mother or Palin's grandmother and speculating that it was timed for election eve?
Inconceivable. That is because liberals just don't think that way. And a few of these rightwingers don't either. But the majority clearly does.
The Closer
I do not pretend to have done nearly as much as I intended to, but this is New Hampshire--arguably, a battleground state, where McCain is still admired--and my Boston-based daughter and I have just come back from canvassing a couple of dozen of my neighbors for the Obama campaign. I think it is safe to say that one fear many of us have had is misplaced: that the lopsided polls would engender a kind of complacency, and people who might otherwise have turned out for Obama's ticket would stay home, expecting to take a free ride on others.
Even people in their 90s greeted us with the moral equivalent of a high-five. Nobody asked for help to the polls, or needed to know where they were voting. The last time I sensed anything like this level of enthusiasm for an election was when Pierre Trudeau swept into office in Canada in 1968.
Astroturf Online
At cjr.org, Renee Feltz, citing research by John Kelly, pinpoints a key difference between the Obama and McCain campaigns' use of the Internet. Turns out there really is a difference in spirit--between a lateral, interactive approach and a top-down one. Guess which is which.
You guessed it:
Barack Obama's campaign reaches out to activist bloggers in order to communicate with and mobilize campaign volunteers and feed them into its online social networking site, MyBarackObama.com. In contrast, John McCain's campaign takes a top-down approach, using blogs--many of which it helped incubate--as an echo chamber for channeling mostly anti-Obama attacks into the mainstream media, in order to create an impression of grassroots online support.
Jews Big for Obama While Unrepresentative "Conference of Presidents" Hijacked by Republican Party
Greg Sargent shares this repulsive mailer the Republican Jewish Coalition is putting out in Ohio. Disgusting stuff. And totally racist.
But, hey, it's the Republican Jewish Coalition and these mailers are in keeping with the McCain/Palin campaign. If McCain/Palin was not running a racist campaign, neither would the RJC. They are a partisan organization and don''t pretend to be anything else.
Not Bloody Likely!

On Sunday, John McCain held his last "town hall meeting" in Peterborough, New Hampshire, hoping for a miracle to propel him to victory both in that state and in the country. But, as Eliza Doolittle's father says in "My Fair Lady" (Pygmalion), "Not Bloody Likely!"
McCain's campaign staff pointed to victories by the Arizona senator in the 2000 and 2008 New Hampshire Republican primaries as evidence that Granite State voters like their candidate. And they pointed with hope to the last pre-election polls in January's New Hampshire Democratic primary, which showed Barack Obama with an average nine-point lead, only to lose to Hillary Clinton by two points less than two days later. McCain's campaign suggests all is not lost, and that there could be another such last-minute swing in New Hampshire, and in the country as a whole.
Republicans to Chrysler/GM Workers: Drop Dead
For auto workers the Bush cavalry is on the way, except they are years too late. The latest shoe to drop is George Bush's rejection of a potential merger between GM and Chrysler. Coincidentally the merger is said to be a threat to many workers in Ohio and Michigan, since it could mean the closure of plants in those states.
Ought the Federal government keep its nose out of the declining U.S. auto industry? Will the new program for fuel efficient vehicles be sufficient? I'd say no to both.
Open Thread: Predictions
Welcome to election eve, Caférs. We've discussed, chatted, debated, and berated. Now we want your predictions on the following:
Presidential Elections:
-Margin in the popular vote
-Electoral college number
Senate Elections:
-Final seat total in the senate, final seat total in the house
So, for example, Obama/McCain wins by x% in the popular, and gets xyz electoral college votes. Democrats/Republicans win x number of seats in the senate, and the house.
We want to know what you're thinking. Join us.
Predictions and questions
Barack Obama's percentage of the popular vote will not be very close to his percentage of the electoral college vote. Although he will win both, why is it good for democracy if the two percentages diverge?
Although Democrats have widened the battleground in a wholly admirable manner, this election will be the third in a row to raise the question of the wisdom of the electoral college in modern America.
When an election precedes the census by only two years, the deviation between the electoral college and popular vote result is potentially the greatest.
Where Is The First Brigade?

It is a pleasure to be part of a discussion with commentators so very sophisticated about these issues. As a layperson I still have many questions and probably not enough time to have them addressed given our time limit, but I do want to take this chance to put them out there to you all. As exciting as it is to consider the various scenarios presented for change, and as persuasive as the proposals are, I am not sure how the same constraints --in terms of the power of the defense industry not only to lobby for their own agenda, whether or not it is ours, but to affect decision-making itself--will not apply this time around.
And, perhaps more importantly, while I have all of your ears here in cyberspace, I turn the question over to you: where is the First Brigade? Many of you are plugged into information and have access to influential people not available to the Americans across the country who have been asking me about this. You could also let us know: what is their mission here? Why did Northcom's stated version of their mission change once questions were asked, from 'crowd control' to 'helping communities affected by weapons of mass destruction?' What information led to that change in mission? Are any other troops going to be deployed here or is this it? And why is the First Brigade here to duplicate tasks that are already covered by the National Guard and various emergency services?

















