TPMCafe
« Restoring America's Moral Credibility | Home | Greetings TPMCafe Denizens! »

Straight Talk From Sen. Johnny-Come-Lately

user-pic

In an inexplicable move yesterday, Sen. John McCain suspended his campaign for president and announced he would not participate in tomorrow's presidential debate, citing the lack of progress in Washington on the proposed Wall Street bailout plan.

The move is inexplicable for a number of reasons, the first of which is that a mere ten days ago, Sen. McCain pronounced the fundamentals of our economy "strong." Now, such a fundamental misdiagnosis of the state of our economy should not come as a surprise. Last December, Sen. McCain told the Boston Globe "The issue of economics is not something I've understood as well as I should. [But] I've got Greenspan's book ... and I stayed at a Holiday Inn last night."

So Johnny has come lately to the economic crisis. And now he feels compelled to rush to Washington to solve it - and incidentally cast his first vote in the Senate since April. Where has he been? And what is his plan?

There is a plan being debated vociferously in the House and Senate this week, a plan proposed by Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson to relieve Wall Street firms of $700 billion worth of bad assets by purchasing the debts with taxpayer money.

You would be excused for getting whiplash trying to follow McCain's position on the economy and the plan to save it. He has minimized the economic crisis. He made the bold, irrelevant recommendation that Securities and Exchange Commission chair Christopher Cox be fired, a veritable non sequitur universally disregarded. He has issued scathing criticisms of the Paulson plan. He has not said how he would vote on it.

If he has a plan of his own, he is keeping it a secret.

Here are two interpretations. By kicking up dust and making a fuss, Sen. McCain is distracting us from the fact that he does not understand the nature of the crisis. But he understands its political magnitude enough to think it's worth trying to flee from the campaign under cover of its gravity. Really, who believes that we should do anything so frivolous as hold a debate under current circumstances? How about a moment of silence?

Perhaps more to the point, he is distracting us from the fact that his miserable performance in the face of the crisis thus far has pushed him so far down in the polls that he now trails by almost double digits.

You can run for president, but you can't hide.

The second interpretation is more sinister, but just as plausible.

When the United States enjoyed a budget surplus and the economy was robust, then-Sen. (and more recently economic advisor to McCain) Phil Gramm, said that if the Democrats presided over such a large and growing surplus, they would be the majority party in the United States for fifty years. For Gramm, Bush, McCain and company, the surplus was like a cancer, something to be rid of, and quickly. Dick Cheney set the course of GOP fiscal policy, announcing that "deficits don't matter."

Maybe they didn't matter that much when Cheney said that and the national debt was only $5.5 trillion. Do they matter now, when the Paulson plan includes a provision for an increase in the debt limit to $11.3 trillion?

Now, perhaps, you can see the urgency. The crisis is serious and must and will be addressed in due course. Most people in Congress are of the view that the Paulson plan to spend $700 billion - deficit spending, of course - is a dead letter because it includes no taxpayer protection. Take from the taxpayer and give to Wall Street? Even if Paulson were making a halfway decent case for it in Congress, the proposition is not a winner.

The thought at the outset had been: Put a plan on the table. Arrogate extraordinary and exclusive powers for the Treasury Secretary. Permit no judicial review of his actions. Provide almost no details at all regarding implementation - no joke: the proposal submitted to Congress is three pages long.

It didn't work. Congress wasn't cowed. The administration brought Cheney in to lobby the recalcitrant GOP. They put the president on TV to address the nation, underscoring the urgency of the situation. And they got John McCain to reinforce the sense of urgency by suspending his campaign and calling off the presidential debate. Hysterical?

If it works, if the Paulson plan is passed, the United States will be saddled with twice the largest deficit in history. It will take years to work that off. Most importantly, it will utterly prevent the next president from pursuing his agenda. Health care? Forget it. Middle-class tax cuts? Please. Money for education, investment in alternative energy sources, safe roads and bridges? Don't make me laugh.

But it's not a laughing matter. Fortunately, most members of Congress see right through the gambit and will ensure that taxpayers are protected and the budget isn't busted, even if Mr. Straight Talk is.


19 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

A man of action doesn't necessarily have to understand the complexities of policy to govern successfully.

Do you think Mussolini knew how to drive a locomotive? And yet, the "trains ran on time."

You see, it's a matter of the creative spark, the deployment of the will to power.

McCain announces the need for agreement and the need is satisfied -- agreement is reached. Q.E.D.

user-pic

McCain has gotten a lot wrong about a lot of things and knows that he is a sitting duck in a debate. And he knows Obama will make him look like the fool he is. McCain is afraid to debate Obama. If I was McCain I wouldn't want to debate Obama either. And not because of Obama. But because of the things that I have to offer as responses in a debate of this nature. Comparatively speaking, Obama is armed to the teeth and McCain has squat.

user-pic


Barney Frank; "Who was that masked man that rode in here and solved these financial problems inside of 24 hours?"

Mitch McConnell: 'Why, that was "Maverick" John McCain!.'

Orrin Hatch cues "Maverick" theme to start playing in background

HI HOOOOO PALIN AWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY

user-pic


There is no doubt, the war "hero" is afraid of Obama. It is run and hide McCain now.

user-pic

Meanwhile, I'm still a citizen, a voter, and I need some information to be either of those things responsibly. What I still lack is a clear comparative analysis of what the probably consequences are of:
Handing a trillion dollars of borrowed money to a few selected corporations.
Taxpayer investment in those same selected corporations, using the same trillion dollars from the same source.
Taking another 3 months to study the issue, looking for the best course of action.
Allowing those selected corporations to go belly up, while at the same time, stiffening the anti-trust laws so we will never again have any corporation so important that they can't be allowed to fail.

If I ever get this information I will form some strong opinions, other than my current one: it's time to put impeachment on the table.

user-pic

Hop, thanks for a comment that's more than simply pithy.

Can't remember the last time I heard so much uninformative talk on a subject from people (interviewers, interview-ees, etc.) who obviously know so little about their topic.

I know this, when someone is trying to sell you something you don't understand, you don't counter their offer. If it seems important enough, you need to get them to help you understand what the hell they are talking about.

If after a good faith effort you still can't understand, chances are they are trying to take advantage of you.

user-pic

hoppy,

"In what is by far the largest bank failure in U.S. history, federal regulators seized Washington Mutual Inc. and struck a deal to sell the bulk of its operations to J.P. Morgan Chase & Co."

I wonder why this isn't the template for the rest of the bailout.


Wow, you couldn't be more wrong in saying that "McCain is afraid to debate Obama." Did you know that earlier this summer, Senator McCain offered to pay Senator Obama's plane ticket so that they could debate in some small town-hall meeting across the country and see what the people of the America (and not the moderators) wanted to know their views on. To this proposition, Senator Obama repeatedly declined.

Perhaps Senator McCain doesn't know everything about the economy. So what! Senator Obama doesn't know jack crap about fighting a war. Lets get to the real issue here. Did you know that both Obama and McCain are acting members of the US Senate? Did you know that this is the "biggest financial crisis that we have seen since the Great Depression"(quoted from Obama)? Why in the world would Senators want to decide the financial welfare of our nation and children for generations to come over a political debate!?! That's what you're really asking right?

We need to hear both of them speak (unfiltered) ....straight from the "horse's mouth" or should say, "straight from the Moose's Lodge"

user-pic

Nope. It is time to face reality. Your war "hero' is a coward. He can't face a real man.

user-pic

Behold! For shooter242 and OldSarg have brought forth a child. Let all the world rejoice.

user-pic

zeno

HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA :-)

What's becoming increasingly clear about John McCain is that he is a) out of touch, but b) self-important and therefore c) extremely dangerous. He is like a crotchety old patriarch who charges into a family fight that he doesn't understand and imposes a solution that is completely irrelevant -- just to prove to himself that he still matters. The challenge for the rest of us is simply, how do we keep this guy out of the room?

There's a lot of great humor being generated on the web these days that I think can drive home the point more effectively than the best reasoned essay. For painting the guy as out-of-touch with everyday folk, I liked this harry-and-louise take-off especially:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NrEZdLsS7Eo

But there's tons of good stuff out there. Find it and circulate it! Send it to your republican cousins!

user-pic

Of course McCain is dangerous. Cowards can act extremely dangerously trying to impress others that they are really courageous. Especially when they are ordering others to actually do the real fighting.

user-pic

I love this line from your post-

Last December, Sen. McCain told the Boston Globe "The issue of economics is not something I've understood as well as I should. [But] I've got Greenspan's book ... and I stayed at a Holiday Inn last night."

If only he said the Holiday Inn line....

But seriously, some of his previous quotes on the economy are just...I am speechless. From the Boston Globe:

"I'm going to be honest: I know a lot less about economics than I do about military and foreign policy issues. I still need to be educated," McCain told the Wall Street Journal in late November.
*
In December he said, "The issue of economics is not something I've understood as well as I should," as the Globe reported on its "Political Intelligence" blog at the time.
*
On at least one occasion, McCain has raised the matter himself. On Nov. 10, while traveling through New Hampshire on his Straight Talk Express bus, McCain was asked what he would seek in a vice presidential candidate if nominated. After mentioning the ability of a potential running mate to replace the president, McCain said, "You also look for people who maybe have talents you don't, or experience or knowledge you don't, as well."----"What are those qualities that you don't - that you wouldn't mind complementing?" asked David Brooks, a columnist for The New York Times. McCain paused. "Uh, maybe I shouldn't say this, but, somebody who's really well grounded in economics," he said. "I think I understand the fundamentals, I talk to people all the time on economics - it's obviously a vital part of America's future," McCain continued. "But I know there are some people who have literally immersed themselves on issues of economics, how Congress works on it, the tax code, that sort of thing. I would look for that kind of talent not in a vice president but in close advisers."
*
"They are complicated," McCain said of economic issues, "and I freely admit I am not an economist."

http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2008/01/26/mccain_tested_on_economy/

I feel so much better that he is rushing to D.C. to fix this mess he knows nothing about. I have to go now. I need to ask my beautician to perform my brain surgery.

user-pic

By his own admission he had not bothered to read the latest, all two-and-a-half pages, rendition of the bail-out before joining the president etal yesterday to 'solve' the crisis. Any comment in this regard would be redundant at this point.

What's becoming increasingly clear about John McCain is that he is a) out of touch, but b) self-important and therefore c) extremely dangerous. He is like a crotchety old patriarch who charges into a family ORDER Anabolic Steroids Buy
Discreet - CLICK HERE!
fight that he doesn't understand and imposes a solution that is completely irrelevant -- just to prove to himself that he still matters.

regards

user-pic

c) extremely dangerous.

Of course McCain is extremely dangerouse. That is what happens when we put a coward in a position of power. Cowards always try to overcompensate, especially when others have to go out a fight their battles.

user-pic

c) extremely dangerous.

Of course McCain is extremely dangerouse. That is what happens when we put a coward in a position of power. Cowards always try to overcompensate, especially when others have to go out a fight their battles.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Kyle Krahel-Frolander



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address