TPMCafe
« Very few | Home | Message for Obama and Dems: The Country Cannot afford Another President Who Lies »

As Treasury Sows, So Shall It Reap

user-pic

Once the Treasury bailed out Bear Stearns with government guarantees, the next buyer of a major US financial institution might expect similar help. Barclay's was the last likely buyer of Lehman Brothers. Earlier today, it announced that without the US taxpayers putting their money on the line, Barclay's isn't interested in buying.

We can debate whether the government should have bailed out Bear Stearns, but surely the current mess tells us one thing we should not have done: Bail out Bear Stearns and then return to business-as-usual. So long as the only tool the government seems to have to halt this crisis is a bailout, then we are in trouble. More bailouts will be needed, and, at some point, even the American taxpayer can't handle it.

Bailouts will not put a stop to the underlying problem: we can't find a bottom in the housing market. Until that happens, the value of financial instruments based on those mortgage obligations will keep falling, and the worldwide market will keep sliding toward collapse.

Worse yet, so long as the government uses bailouts, the financial institutions have an incentive to sit on the sidelines in dealing with homeowners. There's less reason for them to take their hits for bad mortgage investments if they believe that the government may bail them out.

What will it take to put a bottom in the housing market? We have a lot of evidence now that the foreclosure approach isn't going to do it, and the voluntary rewrite-the-mortgage approach won't either. Instead, we need a serious program to write down mortgages to an affordable level, and sort out which families can afford to stay in the homes and which families need to move out. That was the Durbin/Miller proposal to change the bankruptcy laws, but the mortgage industry shut down the idea. So far no one has another idea that would accomplish the same end. Without a plan to deal with bad mortgages more efficiently and to sort out who can afford houses and who cannot, we can't find the bottom on the market and get this crisis behind us.

Bailouts--without serious changes designed to deal with the problem that are causing the collapse--won't work. I hope the Treasury and the Federal Reserve won't give in. If they do, they will reap the bitter harvest of an ever-worsening financial crisis.

It is time to plant different seeds.


14 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I'm a psychologist. I can't really add to your comment. But thanks. I'm all for reality-testing.

I thought it was the market's job to sort out who stays and who gets the boot; pay your mortgage or out you go. If that doesn't work then the owner of the mortgage can always negociate with the mortgagee. Who better understands his financial condition? Get the politicians involved and you'll see corruption on a monumental scale; favoritism, nepotism, bribery, whatever.


That's the standard line, anyway. What am I missing?

Hey OTY: Good to see you...

"you'll see corruption on a monumental scale"...

I think the new corruption can't be worse than what got us here. Namely, the politicians got involved by deregulating the finance industry, and turning a blind eye to the predatory lending & stoking of "house lust" that caused this FUBAR fiasco.

I think Prof. Warren is suggesting finding a soft landing for the mortgage crash by finding the solution through the perspective of the consumers, and not the lenders.

And I like it.

After all, consumer confidence is shattered. Consumers actually drive the US economy, and if you destroy/demoralize them with crushing debt, we've destroyed our economic engine.

Trust in markets is shattered. I believe we're fighting to restore nothing less than the "Full Faith & Credit of the US Government." Trust can be restored if -- for once -- Government sides with Barney Smith instead of SmithBarney.

@ Wade Boggs


If she can find a soft landing, I'd sure like to see the details. God knows we need it.

Maybe Liz is still up and can give more details... (Lord knows I'm no lawyer...)

The Debt Market/Bubble caused this problem, not the Housing Market/Bubble.

If I understand her correctly, she's saying we should call a time-out, and put a debt forgiveness plan in place. ie - Everyone in distressed contracts agrees their house is worth $50,000 less now, so the mortgage will be recalibrated to that new price as of x date. (Maybe I'm way off, but that's how I see this post...)

I'm just so intriqued by this idea. Like L. Warren and Dave Ramsey and others, I see consumer debt as the poison pill threatening to dismantle our economy. I envision that one day, government will have to through out contract law (when it comes to the bear trap Credit Card contracts at least) and rule against CC Companies in favor of the American public. Massive Debt forgiveness. Sacrificing the CC Companies and Predatory Lenders in favor of the common good / public / consumer / the Republic.

I also hope Obama ties the mortgage crisis to his tax cut plan. This chart is the best explanation I've seen: http://chartjunk.karmanaut.com/taxplans/

To my mind, he should say:

""""The debate is over. There are bigger tax cuts for the Middle Class under my plan. Hands down. Slam dunk. My plan is exactly what this economy needs: A stabilized middle class making stable mortgage payments again. Even Greenspan agrees:

"Greenspan: America Can't Afford McCain's Tax Plan... "I'm Not In Favor Of Financing Tax Cuts With Borrowed Money".""""

user-pic

But a bailout is what we'll probably see:

Lehman: more socialising the losses of the rich

Saving Lehman would avoid massive problems for Wall St's other banks, and thus it would be appropriate to get them to contribute the (much smaller) amounts that would allow for an orderly closing down of Lehman.
The problem is, of course, that each has an incentive to put up as little money as possible, as long as others put something. And none want to help the buyer of the good bits to get a good deal at their expense. But of course, no buyer has any reason to do any deal and put any money on the table unless it makes sense for it to do so.
A classic "freerider" problem, which can only be solved if there is an outside force to coordinate contributions and, if necessary, impose them. This is the function that the Treasury and the Fed can play.
But - they are themselves against the wall: if no solution is found before the markets open on Monday (and that's only a few hours away in Asia now), then there is a good chance of a total financial meltdown, something that the Treasury is desperate to avoid.

http://www.eurotrib.com/?op=displaystory;sid=2008/9/14/13725/4238

Not that they need much provocation, but the term "total financial meltdown" tends to resonate throughout the peak oil doomer community:

Life After the Oil Crash: We're at Impact

We now have multiple large banks fighting for their lives and a 10 day disruption in gasoline supplies coming out of the Gulf Coast, both on the heels of the government nationalizing $5 trillion in mortgages and the Big Three automakers all letting it be known that they're going to need government bailouts as well. And that's before we even get to the crisis in Georgia over the BTC pipeline, the war in Nigeria MEND declared, or the rapidly collapsing climate.

http://www.lifeaftertheoilcrash.net/BreakingNews.html

This is unfortunate, but it should serve as a wake up call to all American investors. If you want to protect your money, you need to diversify and invest at least some of it overseas. These are hard times for American investing firms. I personally use offshore bank accounts and they have helped me with diversification and asset protection. If you want to read more on why offshore investing is smarter, feel free to visit my website.

Best,
Frank Miller
http://www.theoffshorebankaccount.com

JDSalinger: Phil Gramm probably loves your website. Unlike the Republicans, I still care about America, so I'll invest here and pay my taxes here. Thanks, but no thanks.

Instead, we need a serious program to write down mortgages to an affordable level, and sort out which families can afford to stay in the homes and which families need to move out.
We already have a serious program to determine who should stay and who should go. Foreclosure. Why aren't you cheering on the bankruptcy of Lehman?
user-pic

airgun177,
So you're in favor of foreclosure. To drive down the value of neighbors' homes? To punish the unrighteous? It's easy to tell that you're paid by the post, not the word. And you are my b.... .
Cheers,
z2v

user-pic

Both offensiveto you and shooter242 rightly point out that left to its own devices, the market and the law of contracts (mortgage foreclosures) will act to find us a bottom in the housing market. And I agree.

Unfortunately, Bush, Paulson, Bernanke and Geithner don't and have done everything they could think of to interfere with the market. From the time of the first Fed Funds rate cut to the Bear Stearns bailout on to the establishment of Bernanke's "facilities" up to the recent take-over of Freddie and Fannie, the men with the power have been bailing like crazy.

So you two --

Since "bailing" is the word of the day, should we be bailing out the banks and securitized loan investors or making them take their haircuts and directing our attention to helping homeowners.

I don't think the question -- "Which side are you on, boys" -- can be avoided.

user-pic

Ellen,
o2u is a person, disagreeing, but getting better. airgun177 is a sock puppet with multiple Atwater descendants inserting their paws.

Your comments are reasonable, but maybe more than the addressees deserve.
z2v

user-pic

It is the Republicans that are believers in Socialized Business.
Let them pay not taxes when they are outrageously profitable,
but bail them out when they are in distress.

Keep business alive but let human being die could be the mantra of the Republicans!

We now know the Republicans are the Socialists, but only for the Rich.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »



Book Club Calendar


Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Kyle Krahel-Frolander



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address