« The Unbearable Whiteness of the RNC | Home | From Straight Talk Express to Schmidting »

Is the McCain-Media Love Affair Souring?

user-pic

As Cliff's book, The Real McCain, amply demonstrates, the reality of John McCain's person and career is somewhat different from the carefully constructed persona that has been presented through the media for the last fifteen years or so. The question of the moment is whether now, with only two months until election day, there is a change afoot in the long love affair that is John McCain's relationship with the press.

It appears that the McCain campaign is falling back on that old Republican standby, whining about the media. McCain's campaign manager, Steve Schmidt, is blasting the press for asking tough questions about McCain's running mate, whom virtually no one had heard of just a week ago. When Campbell Brown of CNN grilled a McCain spokesperson about Sarah Palin's qualifications, the McCain campaign responded by canceling an interview McCain had scheduled with Larry King, no doubt with flared nostrils and a loud "Harumph!" As a parent of small children, I am well familiar with this kind of behavior.

Joe Klein wrote today, "Those of us who have criticized the candidate--and especially those of us who enjoyed good relations with McCain in the past--have been subject to off-the-record browbeating and attempted bullying all year. But things have gotten much worse in recent days." The McCain campaign would appear to be playing a dangerous game. McCain didn't bring a lot of advantages to this race, but one thing he could count on was the affection of the press. He has benefited greatly from that affection thus far (a Lexis-Nexis search on "McCain AND maverick" just for yesterday - a single day - yields 217 hits). But I doubt that the benefit McCain gets from posing as a victimized underdog will outweigh the cost of biting the hands that have fed him for so long.

There's no doubt, though, that complaints about the media are what the Republican faithful want to hear. Even last night's video tribute to Ronald Reagan included the line, "The media despised him." Anyone who was alive during the 1980s could only laugh at that one (read Mark Hertsgaard's classic book On Bended Knee for details). But the accusation of media bias has been written into the conservative DNA. Back when the Republican base didn't have much use for McCain, they used to complaint about him being the media's favorite politician. Now that he's their standard-bearer, they can't help but complain that the media aren't being fair to him.

Working the refs does work, but it comes at a cost. One of the things that always differentiated McCain from other politicians in reporters' eyes was that he treated them with respect, even love. He acted as though he valued what they do and wanted to be their friend. This was in stark contrast to most politicians, who treat reporters like the enemy, or at the very least like some kind of dangerous animal around whom one doesn't want to make any sudden moves. But once you start questioning their motives and telling them that they're unprofessional, they might start thinking you're not their friend after all.


8 Comments

| Leave a comment

declaring war on the media like this may be far more significant than his VP choice. I didn't think it would happen in an all-out declaration like this, but it will be a very interesting ride from here on out.

user-pic

Look Republicans are good at the blame game but they'll never point the finger at themselves. I guess they're just stunned that Palin isn't being accorded the same free pass treatment McCain got for so long.

user-pic

McCain needs all the help he can get, and attacking the media is always a plus, but he risks having some take their lips off his ass.

All the MSM has to do id stop showing up at their media events. Mind over matter = the media doesn't mind because why McCain says doesn't matter. But they're yoo chicken to do something so bold.

All the MSM has to do id stop showing up at their media events. Mind over matter = the media doesn't mind because why McCain says doesn't matter. But they're yoo chicken to do something so bold.

All the MSM has to do id stop showing up at their media events. Mind over matter = the media doesn't mind because why McCain says doesn't matter. But they're yoo chicken to do something so bold.

Snidely McCain is who the American people are about to see over these next 56 days or so, and could be the President of the United States if enough Republican Christian Zombie's go to the polls. But, I think it was a young Alabama man, who said last week during a phone call to C-Span's daily call-in show Washington Journal, "It's time to get back to the right kind of war's, and more religion." ~

user-pic

I’m glad that the media aren’t showing such affection for McCain anymore. I also find it interesting that some people are finally standing up to the media and insisting that they do their jobs. I think it is great that contributors to Talking Points Memo Café have developed the Sudden Citizens' Action Against Media Distortion (SCAAMD). Another blog states the following: “Nothing is more frustrating than reading a news article, or watching a pundit on television, and finding that the truth is being distorted right before your eyes. Maddening as hell, isn't it? Media distortions will continue to be allowed as long as no one fights back with the truth.” (http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/blogs/lisb/2008/10/scaamd---calling-all-watchdogs.php).

A different blog states that the group plans to send a mission statement to Dan Rather which states: “To develop or encourage the development of tools to facilitate immediate, large-scale citizen action against media distortions, lies and propaganda, and to create a viral campaign to inspire people to speak out.” (http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/07/scaamdthe-media-isnt-going-to.php). Hopefully sending this to a top journalist will allow the idea to be disseminated across the nation so that more and more people can take action to keep the media in line.

I feel like this election in particular has drawn opinion from many journalists. Most of the opinions I have seen have actually been against the choice of Sarah Palin as the Republican vice presidential candidate. An example of this was Dermot Cole in the Fairbanks Daily News-Miner (http://newsminer.com/news/2008/aug/29/palin-unqualified-serve-vice-president). It is not the job of journalists to state their opinions of the candidates. Rather, they should strive to cover all candidates equally and remain unbiased.

It is reassuring for me to hear that people are creating groups like SCAAMD to hold journalists accountable. As the group says in this blog, the media isn’t going to do a better job unless they are pushed to do so. I believe that if enough people stand up to the bias, distortion and lies that sometimes emerge, the media will be forced to reform their ways.

Leave a comment

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


January 5-9

Book Cover

January 12-16

Book Cover

January 19-23

Book Cover

January 26-30

Book Cover

February 2-6

Book Cover

February 9-13

The Great Depression

February 16-20

Tear Down This Myth

February 23-27

Demagogue

March 16-20

Engaging The Muslim World




Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Claire Wilcox



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address