TPMCafe
« World writes open letter to McCain | Home | Maybe It Should Be Obama-Clinton After All »

McCain: The Foam on the Surge

user-pic

The Columbus Dispatch has an interview with John McCain yesterday, in the course of which he doubled down on his bet that the only thing he has to say is smear itself:

I will repeat my statement again, that [Obama] would rather lose a war than lose a campaign. Because anyone who fails to acknowledge that the surge has worked, who has consistently opposed it, consistently never sat down and had a briefing with General Petraeus, our commander there, would rather lose a war than a political campaign.

Credit where credit is due: The reporters pressed the point. (Next week, will anyone remember that McCain has in an instant turned half of America into surrender monkeys?) Still, too many reporters remain entranced by what they take to be the incontrovertible success of the surge, viz. Katy Couric, premising a line of questions to Obama on a claim of success that she did not question. ("You raised a lot of eyebrows on this trip saying even knowing what you know now, you still would not have supported the surge. People may be scratching their heads and saying, 'Why?') Even the Dispatch reporters, stuck in the lastest news and too hasty for memory to catch up, failed to put it to McCain that he crowed about the great promise of "rogue-state rollback" and American troops are still fighting more than five years on. That's "history."

In the meantime, McCain uttered uncontested drivel:

I know how to win wars. I know how to win them.

How does he know? Which war did he win? Vietnam? Personal courage didn't win it. Nothing did.

Finally, one of the Dispatchers said:

Q: I wanted to know how we pay for it.

A: We pay for it by a great sacrifice on the part of Americans.

Next unasked question awaiting another interviewer in another town: Senator, Given the size of her fortune and the tax-cut benefits that have accrued to the tiny percentage of Americans in her tax bracket, how much of a sacrifice has your wife made?


6 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I know how to win wars. I know how to win them.

It's simple, Todd -- you win by beating the other side. Everyone knows that, except the latte-and-arugula Democrat base.

user-pic

Damn! If only I'd been reared on arugula and latte rather than spinach and root beer, I'd have known that.

When you define one word ("win") with a near-synonym ("by beating the other guy") you are not doing a lot.

It sidesteps the murky and Phyrric area where many wars go -- nowhere. But the wars still go there.

user-pic

Personal courage didn't win it. Nothing did.

Actual, something did win the war. I believe it was called North Vietnam.

user-pic

It all depends on what the definition of the word "win" is.

McCain keeps saying "we're winning the war in Iraq". Well, he could have said that about Vietnam in 1971. "The Surge is working", well, he could have said that about the influx of troops into Vietnam in the late 60s.

How is McCain saying "We're winning the war in Iraq" any different than if Hitler said, on
D-Day, 'we're winning the war in France'?

user-pic

Obama indicated that the surge combined with the Sunni Awakening had produced better results than he had anticipated. But after saying that, he said that if he had known that he would still have opposed the surge.

Why did he say that? Does he judge the cost of the surge to outweigh the benefits in some way (what way?) or is he simply unable to ever admit having made an error in judgment?

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Kyle Krahel-Frolander



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address