TPMCafe
« A Very Bad Story --The Big Sort | Home | Six Questions About Sorting »

Little Boxes Make Us Stupid

user-pic


In my adult life, I have lived in parts of the U.S. that might be considered on the far ends of the diversity continuum. When people imagine a lack of diversity, it is easy to think of the northern suburbs of Dallas, TX or Plano, TX or Texas A&M. These places have a lot in common with Agrestic, the fictional setting for the Showtime series Weeds. When people imagine a diverse community, it is easy to think of the San Francisco area or of New York or even South Austin - all areas that fit the "cultural creative" arch-type to a tee.

I must say that I've learned & unlearned a lot about diversity over the last 30 years. As a white male, diversity is not a theoretical issue or even something to be sensitive to. It is the air I breathe, that I inhale, it is the seats at MY table that I spread across. Building & maintaining an echo chamber of people like me takes planning & hard work - it is vigilant work to foster homophily, the mortal enemy of diversity. But the truth that I found on both ends of the continuum is captured in this simple statement from Global Voices Online founder Ethan Zuckerman:

Homophily makes you stupid.

The truth of that axiom we learned as kids - "birds of a feather flock together" - is that this flocking makes it hard for people from around the world to relate constructively, to even understand what some one else's life might be like. The little boxes lampooned by Malvina Reynolds are not limited to the suburbs nowadays - we seem to have figured out how to have gated communities for faith orientation, political affiliation, even sexual orientation. The way we have sorted - and fight to protect this sorting - is the functional definition for the origin of the word stupid:

literally "struck senseless," from stupere "be stunned, amazed, confounded,"


A few months ago on a Friday evening, we had a groups of folks over to our home for a potluck, that staple of gathering and eating. We laughed a bunch, shared some stories, even found ideas & people we could meet in and plenty other ideas that did not overlap.

For me, the evening's conversation & plotting were drenched in hope & love. One piece of our discussion has eaten at me - maybe it was the wonderful gumbo. We discussed the reality that there are red churches & blue churches, red issues & blue issues, even red ways to follow Jesus and blue ways. Bishop's insights helped me to understand a bit more of how this has happened, how our drive for affluence & comfort have created echo chambers. We ended our potluck by plotting some conversations after an upcoming event, time to reach for social bridge building, even mess up the ordered sorts we rule our lives with.


18 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

It'll only make you stupid if you decide to join a flock of stupid people. I'm pretty sure that hanging out with accomplished literary talents, philosophers, artists and scientists will actually make you smarter.

user-pic

Out here in Lake Woebegone, we're all above average.

Facebook

Thanks for your patience and sorry for the inconvenience!

Best regards, Mary, CEO of youtube download

Facebook

This is a smart blog. I mean it. You have so much knowledge about this issue, and so much passion. You also know how to make people rally behind it, obviously from the responses. Youve got a design here thats not too flashy, but makes a statement as big as what youre saying. Great job,children health indeed.

Selecting your in-group based on intelligence alone makes you less likely to survive politically, socially, or biologically.

user-pic

That's not the argument I'm answering. He says it makes you dumber. I'm just pointing out that if you hang out with smart people you won't get dumber as a result.

Sorry for being so aggressive.

All the same even a "smart" group of acquaintances is limited. Chemists hang out with chemists and contractors hang out with contractors. There is often limited cross pollenization.

user-pic

Whoops, didn't mean to snap at you! You are making a good point.

Dude, I have to notice the PKDism of your handle - am I wrong?

Specialised political capital cities are therefore a bad idea.

user-pic

Who is Bishop? What did Bishop say?

user-pic

Borges had a remark about epigones of the wise who were inexhaustibly interested by the idea that everyone is the same, or that they are different.

Levi-Strauss, at the end of his career, admitted this: by dint of travel and study, he had come to prefer tribal dwellers to Frenchmen. But he had also come to recognize that that would never be the norm. Cultural groups are entitled to prefer themselves, their own members, to others. This preference is not prejudice, if prejudice as such is supposed to be something bad. "Homophily" is a constructed concept without currency as such; we're not going to start using that term as an opposite to the "diversity" we are uncritically encouraged to limn. But taking it to mean no more than "liking what is like you", associating this with stupidity is no more than cretinous.

Facebook

religious sect may degenerate into a political faction,' wrote James Madison, but the new American nation would nevertheless be protected against the ungovernable combination of religious fervor and political power as long as the Constitution prohibited the federal government from establishing any particular creed as preeminent.
Egitim | Chat

Facebook

Madison believed that we should have separation of church and state throughout the land, federal and local. There was a fascinating moment during the congressional debate over what became the First Amendment. How could the beloved First Amendment be harmful to religion? Huntington feared that it would overturn or interfere with Connecticut’s approach, which was to have state-supported religion.
Chat | Chat

Facebook

Are you good until this issue thanks admin.
Chat | chat

Facebook

This information is very useful! Thanks!
Best regards, Katya, CEO of hyper v virtual network, 2008 iscsi

Facebook

Si vous etes interesses par le dossier, ou desirez en savoir plus, contactez-moi par mail, et je vous mettrai en contact.
Best regards,Jane, CEO of sql high availability

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address